Interview with the President of the Spanish government on Al Jazeera
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero spoke to Al Jazeera in October 2009 ahead of a diplomatic tour of Syria, Lebanon, and Israel, outlining Spain's peace efforts ahead of its 2010 EU Presidency.
- Main themes
- Middle East peace process, Spanish EU Presidency 2010, Spain-Arab world relations, Spain-Israel relations, Palestinian unity, Quartet Road Map, Palestinian statehood, Hamas and Palestinian Authority, Syrian-Israeli relations, European Union role in Middle East, Egypt's mediation role
- Duration
- ~23 min
- Words
- 2,783
- Sentences
- 125
- Readability
- 48
- Grade
- 12.1
- Syntax
- 3.04
- Vocabulary
- 2.01
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
125 sentences in 47 paragraphs
President - Thank you.
P - What are the objectives of your tour which is to begin in Syria, the Lebanon and Israel? President - The objectives are to contribute to this new effort to achieve peace. This contribution will be worth more when Spain holds the European Presidency as of 1 January 2010.
P - Your first stop is Syria. It is known that Spain has an excellent relationship with this country and also has a solid relationship with Israel. Will this encourage you to contribute to the peace process between both countries?
President - Spain is a country that has historically had an ability to relate to the Arab world and also to Israel. This makes us feel comfortable with all countries and gives us the ability to bring both sides closer together. In this case, we have a great relationship with Syria, we also have a good relationship with Israel and this will enable us to assess the situation of bilateral relations, as well as making a contribution.
However, the perspective of this trip is fundamentally a European perspective. Beyond the fact that Spain has a good relationship, I would like for the contribution to this process or renewed peace process to be a European contribution.
P - Before moving on to Spain's role and its forthcoming Presidency of the European Union, some people think that the Spanish presence in the Middle East has relatively reduced.
President - The fact is that we have worked and operated on many fronts in the region. To want to be in the limelight is another matter entirely. However, it is well-known that, both in matters affecting Syria, and in matters affecting Jordan and Palestine, Spain has played a key role, among other reasons, because it has a Foreign Minister who is, perhaps, the person who best knows the region, having been the European Union's representative for the Middle East, and the person who is best known to all of the players, to all of the political leaders. I believe that there is no one in the Middle East who has a diary like that of Minister Moratinos.
We are always working. The Middle Eastern task is often a discreet and prudent task, and Spain is certainly often called upon. Spain does its work and the important thing is that it bears fruit. We are now going to have a more central role due to the European Presidency.
P - It is precisely through the Spanish Presidency of the European Union that you always maintain that the European Union has a central role in the Middle East. What are your proposals for activating that role?
President - I believe that the Quartet Road Map is urgently needed; the task must be supported and reinforced in order to consolidate Palestinian unity; Israel must be involved in order to guarantee a period of calm in terms of the settlements at the beginning of the negotiations; Israel must be given the maximum security guarantees and, in my opinion, the International Community said it at the United Nations just a few weeks ago, an objective should be set for the recognition of the Palestinian State. The Palestinians should know that the International Community is going to take that step and the Palestinians must feel that this is a right that is going to be won.
As such, the Quartet must work in this direction, because this is a task for the entire International Community; security in Israel, but the advisability that it does not take new steps and, of course, Palestinian unity. These are the basic elements and, furthermore, the support of the region: Egypt plays an important role, Jordan and Syria. That is the task.
P - With regard to Palestinian unity, you have identified the need to achieve this unity. Could it be that Spain will play a role in mediating between the Palestinian factions?
President - That is a job which is basically done by Egypt and President Mubarak. We offer support, but the key role, the leadership, belongs to Egypt and we understand that it is good leadership.
P - You put forward proposed solutions to the Arab-Israeli conflict. Is the isolation of Hamas included in these proposals? President - The fact is that this is an issue that must basically be settled by the President of the Palestinian Authority, because he is the reference for the International Community.
P - But the mandate of President Abbas came to an end a year ago, whilst the government of Hamas is legitimate according to democratic rules.
President - Yes, but the next electoral horizon is currently being assessed and it seems that there are some people who were previously very enthusiastic about the elections who are now less enthusiastic about them. Let's leave the Palestinian Authority which has shown… Furthermore, I have great faith in Abu Mazen, great faith. I think that he is a sensible and calm politician and leader. Let us leave him to work on the reconciliation, beyond acronyms and electoral situations.
The Palestinian people are much more than abbreviations and much more than an electoral situation. If we are talking about a peace process that seeks to be permanent, and let's hope it can be permanent, we cannot hold on to the momentary vicissitudes of elections. We all know that there are various Palestinian forces, but all Palestinian forces should know that, in tackling a peace process, there should only be one voice and Palestinian objective.
P - In the last war against Gaza, your party's position was to totally reject aggression, which caused concern at the Embassy and for the government of Israel. Is it possible that this could have a negative affect on your role as a mediator?
President - I believe that we should hold on to our principles and that, when military action is not joint, this must be said, and said to our friends. I have always said that the best way of demonstrating trust to a country is to say what we think. If only there was a chance that Israel would feel safe in its existence as a state, its borders and, above all, in the safety of its inhabitants in order to make them see that they need to face up to the process of dialogue and the future of coexisting with Palestine differently.
However, of course Spain will never hold back when it needs to criticise or when it disagrees with military action. It has done so and will do so again due to the trust, interest and relationship that we have with Israel and its people, and our hope that they can live in peace and safety. They are things that must be understood and which, of course, we will maintain.
P - Let's change the subject and talk about Afghanistan. It is known that no army has ever been able to achieve political or military victory there. What will be the next development, from your point of view?
President - What we must think about in Afghanistan are two basic ideas: the first, if there was military intervention in its day with the presence of troops from forty countries with the backing of the United Nations and practically the entire International Community, it was to overthrow a radical Taliban regime which promoted violence and incited terror, authority and humiliation of women. We do not want the Taliban regime to return to Afghanistan, the region or the world in general. It is a manner, a way of understanding totally undesirable coexistence.
However, none of the countries with a military presence in Afghanistan considers it to be a conquest. No, this is something else. What do the countries there want? We want the conditions to enable us to leave their safety, their guarantee of coexistence and their economic development in their own hands, to exist as soon as possible, which is long overdue. This debate is open to the entire International Community, to all of the countries that are there; I repeat, forty countries, making sacrifices, and we have recently lost a Spanish soldier who died the victim of the impact of a mine on his vehicle. We must have an objective and a prospect of leaving Afghanistan. We must consider a set of milestones to fulfil.
P - When will you consider the objectives achieved?
President - I believe that we should establish this together. In other words, if I were to say a figure now, it doesn't matter whether I say five or six, to a certain extent it would be a random figure, a figure that is not based on a structured analysis. NATO has to manage it because it is NATO that manages the military action, the United States undoubtedly playing a big role. However, we should have a reasonable horizon, a reasonable initial horizon, on which we can set this objective, in other words, transfer security.
We know that the military presence generates a lot of debate and controversy in countries in the Islamic world, in the Arab world, however, we must emphasise that this presence, in addition to being a military presence, is a cooperation and development presence. Spanish cooperation is tarmacking hundreds of kilometres of road and is bringing health and education to a nation and an extremely poor country, which has suffered a lot throughout history, above which we cannot assume that there is a type of curse which means that it will always be in conflict and always have a horizon of poverty.
P - NATO is currently demanding an increase in the existing forces in Afghanistan without defining these objectives.
President - Indeed. In the last year or year and a half, the forces in Afghanistan have increased by some ten thousand soldiers and there is political consensus to assess the result of this increase. For example, Spain has decided to send a further 220 soldiers, which will mean that we have a thousand soldiers permanently stationed there. We are going to look at the result, see the result of the increase by ten thousand soldiers.
It is true that the last few months have seen greater violence and greater unrest, but it is also true that this has coincided with the electoral period and we must gain a little perspective in this respect. Until now, the governments that are there have agreed not to embark on a new period of increasing troops. I stress that we have just completed a period of increasing troops by ten thousand soldiers. Of course, reports from military leaders are considered, but we are logically facing a government decision.
P - You recently spoke of the controversy that arose concerning the presence of foreign troops in Afghanistan, but you have also increased the number of Spanish troops. Is this to restore relations with the United States?
President - Yes, but I do not consider this to be an objective or coherent analysis for one reason: because I always supported the military presence in Afghanistan. When Aznar's government decided to send troops to Afghanistan in 2001, I voted in favour and I have always been in favour. The criticism would be understandable if I had changed my position, but this has not changed. I always backed Afghanistan, the presence, the effort and the sacrifice required in terms of Spanish forces in order to guarantee a different future to that country, and I always opposed Iraq, because they are vastly different situations.
It is likely that the consistency is open to criticism, and I understand that because in politics everything is open to criticism; but I have been highly consistent at all times with my position with regard to Afghanistan and with other unrelated scenarios.
P - President, there are people who criticise you here, in Spain, on the pretext that the nature of the mission of the Spanish troops in Afghanistan has not been clarified. You say that they are humanitarian missions, but are there also military missions?
President - It is true that one of the worst things that we can do when we are involved in a public debate is to remain in a nominalist debate. Afghanistan is, from the United Nations point of view, a mission for peace and security, and this is the case, following a military intervention authorised by the Security Council in order to re-establish order in a country or restore a situation of greater stability and economic progress.
In Afghanistan we basically do three things: firstly, security, supervision and protection of people; secondly, training troops, security forces and Afghans with the aim that they can one day operate by themselves; and, thirdly, development cooperation: roads, hospitals, supplying water, cooperation... This is our mission. Since we are in an area where there are groups that do not accept this order, violent people, fanatics who place bombs, when we are attacked we logically repel the aggression, because this is why we have an army and they are soldiers. However, that is not our mission.
We perform this task; incidentally, a task that is highly valued by the people where we develop our sphere of activity and a task that is hard and difficult, because there is violence and because there is conflict. However, it has a significant humanitarian element and also involves guaranteeing security. Is it high risk? Yes, it is high risk.
P - The severe economic crisis suffered by many countries has resulted in numerous victims, including immigrants who say that there are attempts to create harsh laws against immigration in Spain.
President - Immigration is a source of wealth for Spain. In recent years, almost four million people have come from Latin America, Northern Africa and Sub-Saharan Africa to work in Spain, and for us this has been a source of wealth. We all agree to start with that immigration works best when it is legal and ordered, like anything else. Nobody likes to be illegal and no country likes there to be illegalities. This is common sense, quite reasonable.
Our government, my government, has made a big effort to ensure that the largest possible number of people working in Spain does so legally. Some time ago, we regularised seven hundred thousand people, seven hundred thousand people who were working illegally, and we regularised them, and we have engaged in consensus politics with the main countries from where immigrants emerge, be it Morocco, African countries or Latin American countries, in order to establish the quotas that the Spanish economy needed.
I perfectly understand that despair and poverty lead people to stow away in order to try and cross the Atlantic in what we call a kayak, a boat, due to the desire to survive and due to distress; but we must all understand that this is not the route to take. Of course, our legislation, to which you referred, is not going to be tightened up, as has been said.
P - However, Mr. President, there are extreme reactions such as, for example, not offering some immigrants health or education services.
President - Here in Spain, the entire population is guaranteed health care. I wouldn't know the exact figure, but there are hundreds of thousands of immigrant's children in our schools today. This is one of the countries in the world that has a universal health care guarantee, irrespective of where people come from and the colour of their skin. Curiously, as a government we receive the opposite criticism; we receive the criticism of being a government that is too open where immigration is concerned.
As such, they enjoy all of the rights and we often have the satisfaction of receiving words of recognition from the governments of the immigrants' home countries. All of the rights, all of the duties and, above all, legality. Otherwise, it is very difficult to have immigration that is positive for everybody.
P - With regard to justice, Spain has been a Pioneer in international justice and has passed a new law which reduces the competences of Spanish justice.
President - Because the effects of certain legislation were producing situations that were difficult to manage and handle, and it seemed prudent and sensible to rationalise this. In other words, when legislation causes effects… In the world and in international relations, it was being said that Spanish justice appeared to be entitled to intervene in any conflict situation in any country. This produces an effect that is difficult to explain and I believe that amending the legislation will rationalise, moderate and make the participation and intervention of Spanish justice more logical in the international order.
P - Thank you.
President - Thank you very much.