Press conference by the President of the Government and the Prime Minister of Poland following the Spain-Poland Summit (extracts)
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed a joint press conference with Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk at Moncloa Palace, Madrid, following the Spain-Poland Summit on March 9, 2011.
- Main themes
- Competitiveness Pact for the Eurozone, Arab Spring and democratic change in North Africa, Libya crisis, Spain-Poland bilateral relations, European Union cohesion policy, Morocco constitutional reform, Eastern Partnership, euro area economic stability, employment and fiscal sustainability, Poland's role in the EU
- Duration
- ~35 min
- Words
- 4,163
- Sentences
- 169
- Readability
- 46
- Grade
- 12.7
- Syntax
- 3.10
- Vocabulary
- 2.05
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
169 sentences in 66 paragraphs
President of the Government . Good afternoon. Firstly, I would like to express by satisfaction regarding the organisation of this Spain-Poland Summit and regarding the presence here, in Madrid, at Moncloa Palace, of the Prime Minister of Poland, Donald, my friend Donald. The main purpose of this summit is to analyse and exchange opinions on three fundamental issues: firstly, the Summit of Eurogroup leaders tomorrow; secondly, the European Council tomorrow in Brussels to discuss two important topics - the Competitiveness Pact for the Eurozone (which may be extended to all European Union countries) and the situation in the Arab countries, those around the Mediterranean and Libya in particular; and thirdly, bilateral relations between Spain and Poland.
I would like to briefly comment on each one of these issues. Firstly, the Competitiveness Pact must lead to a strengthening of the Euro, of the Euro economies, of competitiveness in the Eurozone, through a greater shared demand from all countries in the areas of employment, fiscal sustainability, the financial system and productivity. I believe an agreement will be reached tomorrow.
As you know, the Competitiveness Pact is open to all countries in the European Union and Spain's position is one that favours the incorporation of all EU countries into this Pact. That would make it stronger, more credible and would be beneficial to all concerned.
Among those EU countries that do not belong to the Euro, Poland plays a fundamental role; it is the most important country Therefore, its position gains increased importance.
Secondly, we have examined and shared a vision on the changes taking place in the Maghreb countries, in the Arab countries, and in Libya especially. We share a positive outlook on the events leading to democratic change that we are witnessing, of change in favour of States subject to Law and the Rule of Law, and the extension of fundamental rights. We congratulate the changes made in Tunisia, in Egypt and we express our concern, our great concern, for Libya.
We hope that tomorrow will bring a unanimous, solid and determined position from the European Union in support of change in Libya and, of course, of responsibility from the international community. But, above all, we want the European Union to accompany every country at the same pace, in the same direction, in regard to the process of change that is taking place in the Mediterranean; the process of change that has unique characteristics in each individual country. Each country will write its own story in this process of overall change, its own history, and we are seeing that those changes are taking place in a variety of ways: with popular uprisings, with revolutions, but also responding to circumstances with other expressions.
Yesterday, the King of Morocco announced a wide-reaching reform of the Constitution, with content that affects the Government, the Parliament and the Justice system. This is a reform that we view positively, very positively. This is definitely the right path: one of democratic reforms to broaden political representation and for it to be the Government that has ultimate executive power and responds to the will of a parliamentary majority. Therefore, Spain expresses its satisfaction with the reform proposal formulated yesterday by King Mohammed VI for Morocco.
Finally; bilateral relations. I must say that Spain and Poland are both stabilising countries for the European Union project. We are two countries that play fundamental roles in the south and east of Europe due to our geographic positions, our history, our economies and our relations with the south and east of Europe, those places where Europe has a great interest in expanding horizons, objectives and relations: to the south and to the east. Therefore, Poland and Spain each play an essential role in the direction that history has assigned them.
We have always enjoyed a very special relationship. We have always valued the extraordinary manner in which Poland looked to Spain for inspiration regarding its model for joining the European Union project; particularly regarding development through the Cohesion Funds and the EU cohesion policy - a policy that is of fundamental importance in the European Union.
The Polish Prime Minister has informed me of the goal to strengthen that partnership to the east, that Eastern Partnership. Spain is greatly interested in that idea and, of course, Poland can count on our full support.
I will end by congratulating the Prime Minister on the progress in his country, on its level of growth, on its development and its consolidation. Poland is becoming more and more attractive to companies and investors, Spanish ones included, but also to the international economy in general. It truly pleases us to see that is the case. Our bilateral relations, in terms of trade, politics and cultural exchanges, are growing as Spanish interest in Poland grows. That fact gives us particular satisfaction.
In short, this is proving to be a highly enriching Summit and this Spain-Poland, Madrid-Warsaw axis is one that enormously strengthens the major external political objectives of the European Union.
Thank you, Donald.
Donald Tusk . Many thanks, Mr. President, my friend. This is one of our successive meetings and confirms that Hispano-Polish relations remain at the highest possible level in terms of mutual trust and mutual understanding. It is very important for Poland, looking ahead to our Presidency of the European Union, and it pleases me that the priorities we have established for our Presidency have been met with your understanding and that we can count on your support and support for our work during the Presidency. It will involve the development of the internal market, common security and defence and promotion of both the eastern and southern aspects of European politics.
Today, the experiences of this region, among them the highly valuable experience of Spain in its relations with the South, but also our experience with our neighbours to the East, show us the importance of politics being governed by the same criteria with all our neighbours.
What I have heard today in Madrid has been highly positive because it would seem that we both have the same opinion regarding how to build a better future and how to help our neighbours to the south of the European Union build that better future.
Spain and Poland have adopted a cautious position because we know, both in Spain and in Poland, that the construction of international order and an order in those countries that are our neighbours to the South requires full respect for certain fundamental values. The European Union has a great task ahead to return to that frank and honest language in which we described our world of values in order to propose to our Southern and Eastern neighbours that they themselves embrace the same values.
In Libya today, we are seeing events that strongly remind us of the importance of democracy, of human rights and of public and social order, and that they are not empty words. When we forget that, we arrive at a dark place that we have already seen in many countries in this region.
Our position could be important for the entire European Union because both countries, and here I thanked the President of the, Government, Rodriguez Zapatero, have shown the European Union that the neighbourliness policy to the South and the East are not policies in direct competition. They are equally important; they complement one another and make European foreign policy something logical and coherent.
I am pleased to receive your support for our plans for our Presidency in terms of the Eastern Partnership. We spoke about our bilateral relations and I can repeat and highlight our satisfaction regarding the fact that so many Spanish investors and business leaders find work and room for their experience in our country. Roads, highways, bridges; these are the success stories shared by Poland and Spain.
The recent investments in the banking sector also tell us that our collaboration will continue to develop in that field. We have signed something that is very important to us. I refer, of course, to the agreements we have reached that will enable us to realise our intentions in the form of a cultural cooperation agreement.
We have discovered from the President of the Government that there are people in Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero's family learning Polish and that people from my own family are learning Spanish.
We are going to be able to speak in Polish and in Spanish at our future meetings. I warn you though, I have it easier. I would also like to greatly thank the declaration on the need to undertake shared action to repair economic management in Europe and also on the Competitiveness Pact that will be signed in the future.
Poland has always thought that the important decisions in the Eurozone should be decisions shared by all parties concerned. Today we now know that interested countries, such as Poland, want to participate in this Pact and will participate. I thank you for your support and for the support of Spain, and we are convinced that this is our shared interest, in the Eurozone and also in Poland.
Poland is very well prepared to meet any criteria or expectations that the participants in the Pact may have.
That understanding between our countries and our personal relationship is a guarantee that our path towards Europe, towards the Presidency and towards economic-financial success was possible and is possible thanks to this support from Spain, and also the fact that we have good examples to follow. Poland is the country most benefiting today from all the European funds, but we took our lesson from your example. You did the same before us. We are also learning from the mistakes of those who came before us and that is how we have been able to achieve such a high record of efficiency regarding the way in which those funds are being used, thanks again greatly to your experience.
I am convinced that the Polish Presidency, also thanks to our bilateral collaboration, will by very fruitful and positive for everyone. I thank you again for all your support.
Q . Prime Minister Rodríguez Zapatero said that there will be a declaration from the Summit in Brussels, the adoption of a firm position, from the European Union regarding the Maghreb countries. What is the Polish position? We already know how important mass migrations are. Is that also something that was discussed during your meeting?
Given the possibility of the European Union allocating funds to the Maghreb, to the countries to the South that have to tackle the problem of mass migrations, will that mean there will be less money for the Eastern Partnership or is that an entirely independent issue?
And I would like to know who will be the spokesman for the Polish Presidency.
President of the Government . We are working towards a clear, firm and committed political statement at the European Council regarding the democratic changes taking place in the Maghreb countries that includes, firstly, a mobilisation of humanitarian aid, something that has already begun, especially on the border with Libya, and that has produced good results but that must be maintained at the same level; secondly, strict compliance with economic sanctions on Libya and support for democratic change; and finally, a commitment to responsibility regarding the progress of events that may take place in Libya so that the regime is made aware that we will not stop until democratic change is obtained in Libya.
Of course, the change in the Mediterranean, in the Maghreb countries, has a very positive side: there will be more democracies and, where there are more democracies, there is more peace, more possibilities for people and better international relations. It will also demand greater commitment from us and possibly financial commitments. This will not come at a cost to the Eastern Partnership, which is also very important, but we cannot haggle when talking about conquering freedom, democracy and human rights. And I hope that Europe, all of us, will refrain from haggling on this point.
Mr. Tusk . I will begin by saying something that might sound rather strong, but I have my reasons. When we look back over recent years with the clear conscience of Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, we can say that neither Spain nor Poland should feel ashamed for what they have done or what they have said in terms of what has been happening recently in Libya.
It is very important for the entire European Union to believe in what we so often say: that there are less and less people living to the south of Europe who aspire to democracy, to freedom, and that Europe must clearly, and consequently free from hypocrisy, support that kind of transformation that leads to permanent change for the better in this part of the world, without deluding ourselves that it is possible from one year to the next but also without being tempted to impose our own order by force. For that reason, we must give a clear signal to those citizens to the South of Europe: that Europe will support a specific direction of change. It cannot be the case that the European Union supports a regime at the cost of peace because that can never last.
In the East of Europe, we have our own experiences and we see that a permanent order must be based on human rights and democracy. That is why we would like, without panic, to propose this direction of change both in the South and in the East.
I would like to stress that there are plenty of financial resources to help the South. Europe has, of course, accumulated resources to that end and there is no need for us to ask ourselves whether we have sufficient funds to act in this region; the question should be whether those measures will eventually be spent wisely and effectively. It can be seen today already, that wise action such as in Moldova for example, where the European Union is spending money wisely, is an example of what can be achieved and the good effects to be obtained. We also know how to distinguish the differences between Libya and Tunisia, we can see where the money works better and we know where more preparation and more effectiveness are needed.
I also shared something with the President of the Government that is perhaps not entirely politically correct. We cannot uphold the situation in which certain regimes in North Africa transfer the resources taken, for example, from existing raw materials to private accounts, of individuals, from the elite in the regime while, on the other hand, the European Union is pumping money into that country.
If you look, there are countries in this region that have enormous funds with which to help their own people, but how much of that money ends up in private accounts in tax havens? We must give a very clear signal that help only makes sense when the beneficiaries are willing to also use their own resources to help their own countries. Our partners to the South, to the East, or anywhere else for that matter, must hear that message loud and clear.
After everything we have said to each other, Spain and Poland will tomorrow present a very similar position regarding the crisis in Libya and the events throughout the region. Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero and I believe that everything taking place in this region constitutes a sign of hope; signs of hope. We must accept these events with hope, not fear. This is not a problem for us but rather an opportunity and we have to believe that.
As regards the spokesman for our Presidency, we will decide on that tomorrow in Brussels.
Q . I have a question for you both, because President Rodríguez Zapatero has just said that the desirable result from tomorrow would be the emergence of a clear, resounding, committed and unanimous political statement on Libya; but Paris has already recognised the Libyan rebels today. I would like to know whether both the Polish and Spanish Governments would accept a statement to that effect.
(…)
President of the Government . In response to your first question, it would be advisable to specify precisely who has spoken about political recognition, who has spoken; whether it was Paris or those who were in Paris - there is a difference. From there, all European countries must act in unison and I believe that there will be an unequivocal commitment in that direction tomorrow and, of course, in terms of what is the intermediation with those who are leading the process of democratic, revolutionary change in Libya.
We are going to work towards that objective and I have no doubt that the best way we have of helping democratic change in the Mediterranean is for all of Europe to speak the same language and have the same capacity for commitment and to change certain policies that, within the framework of the Union for the Mediterranean and the Association with the Mediterranean, we have to change.
(…)
Mr. Tusk . I have just one thing to say about the National Council and the possibility of its recognition by Poland or the European Union. We have to be sure that we are supporting those who intend to instigate change in Libya and not simply to replace Gaddafi; let's speak clearly. We want to recognise those who want to create a more acceptable regime for Europe in terms of its principles and the way it acts, and not simply to ensure stability by replacing one dictator with another. We have to know what we are doing.
As it stands today, there is no reason to think that the National Council has any bad intentions but, at the same time, neither do we have sufficient information to be sure that they are anything more, that they seek something different to what was sought by Gaddafi and the current regime in Libya. We mustn't support change for the sake of change; we need to change the transition. There is a difference.
Q . You have spoken a great deal about the Competitiveness Pact and that, within this Pact, we must collaborate with the countries that don't belong to the Euro. Can you then guarantee that the meeting tomorrow is a separate case when only the Eurozone countries are meeting? When will other Eurozone countries be invited, including Poland?
President of the Government . That is an excellent question and it was also the topic of some intense debate at the last European Council.
We have to find a balance. It seems reasonable that those countries that share a common currency and that want to make a Pact on the Euro are those that hold the initiative, that draft it and sign it. It also seems reasonable that such a Pact on the Euro holds sway and has an effect on the entire European Union. There is no doubt about it. Therefore, the countries that do not belong to the Eurozone can participate and, of course, join, adhere to the Pact.
The spirit of the Pact, besides being a framework of ideas in which to work on strengthening competitiveness, is a spirit of national commitment, of self-demand and, therefore, the most important part of this Pact, the most important design aspect of this Pact, must correspond to each country in the commitments assumed by its Prime Minister or Head of State.
Therefore, if Poland decides to join the Pact, because that would be Poland's decision, which I think would be a good thing and desirable, it would be Poland itself that establishes the targets to set for improving its competitiveness. We will all then assess ourselves and each other and show our results to each other together. This type of self-imposed demands will be, in my opinion, useful. Even though the country is not included in the meeting of leaders from the Eurogroup - by the way, only two such meetings have ever been held, only two meetings of leaders from the Europe have ever been held; this is the second - we know that Poland is participating and that Poland is aware of the content of that agreement.
This comes up on more than one occasion, the Euro and the European Union, and we will have to decide on a formula. I am a supporter of the most open formula possible, a participatory one. I personally believe that I feel more comfortable, better, if the greatest number of countries possible take part in European decision-making processes.
But the Polish Prime Minister knows more about that, in light of the last European Council, because he played a very prominent role and had certain issues with certain Heads of State, which I will not recall or quote here, regarding the issue of participation by non-Euro countries in Eurogroup meetings.
Mr. Tusk . The kind words offered by President Rodríguez Zapatero not only fill us with hope but reassure us that the Pact will be a Pact open to countries outside of the Eurozone.
In order to make it blatantly clear, Poland, and I stress this fact here today, is willing to participate in the Pact and is willing not only because it is what we want but also because we would be no worse at tackling the competitiveness challenges at this time than the majority of Eurozone countries. We have already committed ourselves to assuming all the responsibilities without complications and without excessive problems. Our partners know this and that's why we have been hearing for some time now opinions saying that Poland would be a welcome country for participation in, for joining the Pact.
Q . Mr. President Rodríguez Zapatero. What will Spain have to do, once the Competitiveness Pact is approved, to comply with it? I mean, particularly in terms of wages, whether wage increases will be tied to something other than the CPI.
Also, now that the Bank of Spain has recognised that our Savings Banks need fifteen billion euros to refloat themselves, does the downgrading of Spanish debt by Moody's seem disproportionate to you?
Finally, do you think your presence detracts more than it brings to the municipal and regional elections?
President of the Government . In response to the first question, the Competitiveness Pact will be a commitment of great importance to economic and social issues in the countries planning to participate because we will demand things to be done, reforms and change, and we will set targets.
Spain will immediately present its reforms, its commitments, within the framework of the Competitiveness Pact and those reforms, those changes, must be subject to the highest degree of social dialogue and agreement possible and, of course, political agreement; political agreement that would have to be substantiated during my appearance before Parliament following the European Council and social dialogue that I am already involved in with the trade union representatives - I will also involve the president of the employers' association, of course - on the text itself of the Competitiveness Pact and what must come from it; the national commitments.
But it will be of great importance, because we are going to commit as a country, we must commit as a country, to meeting targets annually; this time with the highest level of demand. This will not be anything like Lisbon, this will be serious and, therefore, we will seek maximum social participation and maximum political agreement.
The Bank of Spain has indeed published the data regarding the requirements for returning to strong, demanding capitalisation, as established by the Royal Decree-Law approved by the Government, for the financial entities. It is a reasonable and acceptable amount: a little over fifteen billion euros. Those entities that need to capitalise themselves must now define their capitalisation plan either by turning to the markets, i.e. private capital, or, as a last resort, to the public capital mechanism through the Fund for Ordered Bank Restructuring, as we know.
That is the amount and the rigour, credibility and solvency of the Bank of Spain, proven over the course of decades, is hard to question. Entity by entity. Those who would suggest a different amount must say, entity by entity, the figure they think to be more correct. I respect all the ratings agencies, I respect them; but, as President of the Government of Spain, my trust lies with the Bank of Spain.
Finally, I would be forgiven for forgetting this question because it is one of those questions… The work we do is out there for all to see in political terms and the electorate will judge. I have been judged on more than one occasion and now I am trying to ensure my colleagues presenting themselves for election do the best they can. I will offer all my support. All support is good for a candidate, all support is good, and I will offer mine with great enthusiasm, as always.
Thank you.