Press conference by the President of the Government following the European Council
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero held a press conference following the European Council summit in Brussels on 10 March 2011, reporting on discussions about Libya, Mediterranean transitions, and Eurozone stability.
- Main themes
- Eurozone financial stability, Libya crisis and Gaddafi regime, Mediterranean region democratisation, European Council decisions, Arab Spring transitions, Tunisia and Egypt democratic processes, Morocco constitutional reform, Japan earthquake and tsunami, European Stability Mechanism, Greece loan terms, EU solidarity and humanitarian aid
- Duration
- ~25 min
- Words
- 2,967
- Sentences
- 132
- Readability
- 42
- Grade
- 12.9
- Syntax
- 2.92
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
132 sentences in 39 paragraphs
President of the Government . Good evening. Before discussing the two important meetings that have taken place today in Brussels, of the European Council to tackle this situation of the countries in the Mediterranean Region, and the Summit of the Eurogroup, I would like to mention Japan, the people of Japan, to express, in the name of the Government and people of Spain, our condolences and our empathy in light of this terrible earthquake and subsequent tsunami which have all the signs of having caused a major human catastrophe and destruction on a mass scale. We have already conveyed to Japan our willingness to provide whatever support it may deem useful, in the same way as the European Union has today.
This morning, as you are aware, we have held a long work session in which the European Council has fundamentally analysed the situation in Libya, in particular, and the situation in the countries on the edge of the Mediterranean, in general.
Firstly, the European Council has sought to express its solidarity with the Libyan people regarding the victims in this country. It has resolutely urged Gaddafi and his regime to stop the attacks on the civilian population, and to put an end once and for all to this journey to nowhere orchestrated by the Libyan regime, which is senseless, without a future and without a way out; it can only lead to pain and destruction.
Gaddafi, as the European Council has asserted today, has lost his political legitimacy, and hence, the EU Council has agreed to back any possible options, beyond political pressure and humanitarian aid, to protect the citizens of Libya; options which, as the case may be, should rely on the appropriate international legal framework and the support of the region, as is textually stated in its Resolutions.
Moreover, as you are aware, the European Council has decided to convene a joint Summit of the Arab League, the African Union and the European Union to analyse the situation in more depth, assess joint measures and, of course, join forces in favour of a swift resolution to the situation of Gaddafi and, in general, of the evolution of the countries in the Mediterranean Region.
I would also like to highlight the express support that the European Council has given to the processes underway in Tunisia and Egypt. I have had the opportunity of informing my European colleagues of my impressions, after my visit to Tunisia. I am convinced that the democratic transition in Tunisia has a positive future and I am convinced that the support of the whole European Union is essential, both regarding the process in Tunisia and in Egypt.
Finally, the European Council, upon a proposal from France and Spain, has welcomed the announcement of constitutional reform made by the King of Morocco; a constitutional reform that represents a step in the right direction and that represents progress in a process of democratisation which we undoubtedly wish to see in Morocco, in the same way as for the other countries in the region.
I will now report on the afternoon's session, the "brief" afternoon session that we have held with the leaders of the Eurozone.
Our meeting has taken place at a key moment. You are aware that in this first half-year of 2011, we have resolved to agree on and set in motion all of the elements of the response strategy to guarantee the economic and financial stability of the Eurozone. The European Councils of December and February established a 'roadmap', and today we have taken another step in this direction, which will be definitively defined in the coming European Council on 24 and 25 March.
We have again adopted agreements today with determination and with a clear and unequivocal message to all the economic agents, to business leaders, to citizens and to investors regarding the strength, soundness and the determination for the stability of this common project that is the Euro.
Firstly, since we reached the agreements in a specific manner, we have guaranteed the capacity for financing, both of the current temporary mechanism, known as the Financial Facility, and of the Permanent Stability Mechanism that will come into operation as of 2014. We have agreed, to that end, to provide such guarantees as are necessary to make effective the 440 billion euros in the case of the Facility, and we have ratified the decision adopted by the Ministers of Finance on 14 February to contribute 500 billion euros to the future Permanent Mechanism.
Moreover, we have given more flexibility to these mechanisms and to the terms for granting aid to those States that have sought financing. Specifically as regards Greece - although it has not strictly resorted to the financing mechanism, it has had, as you are aware, a programme of support and it has received a loan - as a result of the efforts and commitments that it has acquired in the Council, there will be a reduction of 100 base points in the interest rates for loans that have been granted to Greece to improve the sustainability of its debt, and an extension to the term of the loan from five years to seven and a half years.
Furthermore, as you are aware, this meeting of the leaders of the Eurogroup, as well as tackling the part related to the Financial Facility and the Permanent Mechanism to guarantee the stability of the Eurozone, has tackled and agreed the so-called Competitiveness Pact; a pact that strives for greater convergence between Eurozone countries, convergence through the coordination of economic policies to guarantee that the Monetary Union is more integrated and more competitive.
In the coming European Council, the Eurozone countries, together with those countries that, although not part of the Eurozone, wish to join the Competitiveness Pact, will assume specific commitments on economic reforms in the four areas contained in the Pact: competitiveness, employment, the sustainability of public finances and the strengthening of financial stability. This commitment to reform will last for one year; for the coming twelve-month period.
I should stress that the Competitiveness Pact is not a declaration of intent, it is not the Lisbon Treaty. It is a political commitment to take further steps in areas where powers are mainly national, but which overlap with the competitiveness of the Eurozone as a whole.
It will thus be an on-going exercise demanding the competitiveness of the economies of the Eurozone. Commitment and progress made will be revised on an annual basis, and of course new commitments may be incorporated.
I should also stress that for these commitments to be undertaken, the involvement of social stakeholders is vitally important in the opinion of the Spanish Government. This is the path that the Government of Spain is going to take in undertaking the reforms of the Competitiveness Pact. Due to the importance of the content of the Pact and the matters it tackles - competitiveness and employment - it is essential that they participate in the dialogue process and the social agreement; and furthermore, that efforts are stepped up, at a European level, on social dialogue to carry out the Competitiveness Pact.
These are the essential aspects. I have summarised them as far as possible, given the time that it is, and, on a reciprocal basis I hope that your questions are also brief.
Q . I wanted to ask you about Libya and the position of Spain. You have said, if I am not mistaken, that the Council has decided to back all possible actions to protect the civilian population within the appropriate legal framework. You have not referred to a UN resolution whereby, as far I understand, from what you have said on other occasions, such a resolution is essential for Spain. Could you confirm that for me.
President of the Government . That is the legal basis. The legal basis for any type of intervention under International Public Law is a resolution of the United Nations Security Council.
Q . Can we consider that this is essential for Spain? President of the Government. Absolutely.
Q . I would also like to know why some countries still do not consider the National Council for the Transition of Libya as an elected delegate and representative of the Government of Libya, such as France for example. What are they waiting for?
I would also like to know when the Arab League is going to meet with the European Union and if the wait will be long given what is unfolding in Libya.
President of the Government . As regards the first question, I believe that the UN resolution speaks about political delegates, which they are, which they will be and which have been recognised. The recognition of the representation of a country or of a Government is quite a different matter. That will need developing, and consequently, will need to be looked at more cautiously.
Yes, this has been the subject of debate. It is true that a form of representation has very recently emerged which can be considered as a political delegate; but it seems prudent, in the opinion of the vast majority of the European Council, to wait and take the steps necessary to see what the alternative formation is of what is currently a regime that is committing absolutely intolerable acts that are going from bad to worse.
In relation to the Summit, I imagine that no date has currently being set. It is the Council's wish to hold it as soon as possible. It may take place in the coming days or weeks, or somewhere in-between, because we consider it fundamental that the effectiveness of any action is closely related to the capacity to share our reflections, assessment and decision-making as far as possible with the Arab League and the African Union.
Q . In a letter, you have asked for wages and productivity to be aligned. It seems that the trade unions have felt somewhat under pressure, and hence I wanted to know if you could specify the role that you believe inflation should play in this alignment and whether you are going to present the reform on collective bargaining in the coming Summit on 24 March.
A second question. I wanted to know if you could specify the degree of flexibility of the Euro Fund, the options that have finally prevailed and whether the countries that benefit from this flexibility and are eligible for the Fund have to commit to extraordinary levels of austerity.
President of the Government . As regards the first issue, there is a currently a negotiation process on collective bargaining underway between business leaders and trade unions. We hope an agreement is reached. This would be extraordinarily positive.
Collective bargaining in Spain needs to be reformed; there have been practically no reforms in the last few decades and, from the information available, both business leaders and trade unions are showing maximum interest in the matter. Of course, collective bargaining is one of the most important ingredients of the Competitiveness Pact regarding how to adapt salaries to economic conditions.
As regards indexing salaries to inflation and the role of productivity in setting salaries, there are many formulas. It is very 'reductionist' to speak about salaries and productivity, or salaries and inflation. Some countries only calculate the evolution of salaries by employing a part of the prices, rather than all prices to determine the country's inflation. And the formulas for incorporating productivity are also variable. In fact, productivity is already partly taken into consideration under our collective bargaining system.
Hence, the debate, as almost always happens, is enriched by the models we already know, something the business leaders and trade unions in Spain know better than anyone. I am convinced that a balanced agreement can be reached, which favours both productivity and the competitiveness of the economy, because this is key to our future.
I repeat that this is of course a fundamental element. Flexibility. There are two key aspects: I have already described one of them, the effective capacity of the Fund, whereby all countries are going to have to increase the guarantees of the provisional Fund; and secondly, the Fund will be allowed to acquire debt on the primary markets with certain requirements and under certain conditions. In other words, there are two major areas of flexibility.
Q . I wanted to ask you, aside from the reforms already announced and approved, and aside from collective bargaining, whether the application of the Competitiveness Pact in Spain may require new measures or new initiatives on the part of the Government, for example, to control the deficit or the debt.
President of the Government . We are going to make an in-depth assessment. It is likely that new initiatives will be implemented.
As regards fiscal sustainability, as you are aware, you have heard me talk, on certain occasions, about the possibility of strengthening the Budgetary Stability Act. This is an important matter. You are aware that there were various positions, various initiatives, for the Pact to determine that this be carried out at a constitutional level. It has finally be left more open; open to the legislation of each country. Nor is there a strict formula. Each country, within the framework of its sovereignty, as you would expect, can take steps to amend its legislation to strengthen the commitments to strict compliance with its deficit within its fiscal framework; within the framework of the Pact. This is one of the options which we will of course assess and which we will discuss with the other political forces.
A good part of the reforms deriving from the Competitiveness Pact are underway: those relating to employment, those relating to financial sustainability, to the financial sector, and there are those relating to fiscal sustainability. There are matters relating to Research, Development and Innovation which also need to be assessed. And, of course, everything relating to competitiveness basically falls under collective bargaining and the job market.
In short, a good part of the reforms that make up the Competitiveness Pact are underway, but there will probably be more to come and, of course, these will be specified in the European Council on 24 March.
Q . A couple of questions, both related to Libya. The first is regarding the ambiguity of the legal basis, which is not defined either at a European level or at the level of the alliance. All the countries, in both camps, talk about the legal basis without any explicit reference, which could be given, should it so wish, by the United Nations Security Council. In fact, President Sarkozy today said that if there is no UN Resolution but the countries in the vicinity - thinking about the Arab League - so request, an intervention may take place. In Hungary, the Ministers for Foreign Affairs, and in their name, the Rotating President, the Hungarian Minister for Foreign Affairs, has said that Europe is waiting for the Arab League to call on us to intervene without the need for the opinion or backing of the United Nations. Would Spain intervene, in this case, without the say-so from the United Nations Security Council? My second question on Libya. Since it is a question of isolating the regime economically speaking, and Spain is one of its gas customers, is Spain prepared to do without Libyan gas to economically strangle Gaddafi? President of the Government. As regards the first question, I attended the meeting of the European Council with the maximum interest regarding everything that affects this part of the debate on the situation in Libya and the possibilities of action or intervention. The interpretation of anyone who was present leads to the fact that the legal basis for any intervention is a resolution of the United Nations. That is my conclusion. Secondly, it is also my position. That is why the United Nations Security Council exists and we know from experience that other frameworks, other initiatives, if they do not have the support of the United Nations, are extremely weak. But I would add something else: the European Union, the Arab League, the African Union and the international community have a great capacity for political and economic pressure to put an end to the regime that is committing the acts that it is committing; it has this capacity. And, of course, economic pressure and all the measures and sanctions that have already been applied - in Spain as well, as you would expect - are having their sought-after effects on the regime. Have no doubt about that. And there will be more effects. As I have said on other occasions, Spain and all European countries have adopted emphatic decisions at an economic level, and regarding sanctions. We will take them to their bitter end and this will have an effect. It is already having an effect. Q. We don't need to do without gas? President of the Government. It is not a question of whether we do without gas or not. This is also an issue, of course, we need to make adjustments, as do all countries, when imposing sanctions: there are many direct sanctions, which are the most effective and those which most clearly economically damage the Libyan regime. Allow me not to be more explicit, for obvious reasons. Q. Will the terms and conditions for reducing interest rates for Greece also be applied to Ireland? President of the Government. Only for Greece. P. Only for Greece. But for Ireland hasn't there been…? President of the Government. Ireland hasn't signed the agreement proposed, which was related to the coordination of fiscal policy - and we know what we are talking about: above all, about the imposition on company profits and Corporation Tax - and hence, no reduction will be applied. Thank you very much.