Press conference by the President of the Government following the European Council meeting
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed a press conference following the June 2011 European Council meeting, reporting on decisions regarding Greece's debt crisis and EU economic strategy.
- Main themes
- Greek debt crisis, Eurozone stability, European Council economic strategy, EU economic governance, Spanish fiscal consolidation, austerity and privatisation measures, EU financial stress tests, Eurozone stability instruments, EU foreign policy, Schengen Agreement
- Duration
- ~32 min
- Words
- 3,891
- Sentences
- 154
- Readability
- 43
- Grade
- 13.5
- Syntax
- 3.13
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
154 sentences in 50 paragraphs
President of the Government .
Good afternoon.
This European Council meeting was used to tackle two important economic issues and other matters regarding EU foreign policy and the policy stemming from the Schengen Agreement. As regards economic issues, which are obviously extremely important given the context in which this meeting was held, the first to be tackled was the situation in Greece, the Greek debt situation, and the second to be tackled was the process of analysis, of response, to the economic crisis that had been adopted at the European Council meeting held in March. Both Greece and the analysis of the economic situation are based on the same commitment: a resounding and firm commitment to the twenty-seven countries of the European Union to do everything necessary to guarantee the stability of the Eurozone.
On the issue of Greece, the Council has agreed that the stability of Greece is key to the entire Eurozone. Furthermore, the Council recognised the considerable efforts being made by the Greek Government and that are being made (and must continue to be made) by the Greek people at this time. We are convinced that the Greek Parliament will make an announcement next week regarding the new programme of austerity measures and privatisations that has been designed in agreement with the European Commission, the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund. Hence, and given the extreme importance of this programme and that decision from the Greek Parliament, the twenty-seven leaders of the Council are strongly calling for all the political efforts being made by Greece to be supported. Therefore, we call on the Greek opposition to act responsibly. Backing for the programme by the Greek Parliament will enable the fifth tranche of the first financial aid package to Greece to be paid out at the start of July, which will in turn enable Greece to meet the payments it is due to make in July and August, as well as move on to the second aid package to Greece. It is true to say that the situation in Greece is one of difficulty, of great difficulty, but the Greek society, the European authorities and each one of the countries that make up the Eurozone are demonstrating noteworthy strength and, what is most important and essential, a strength of unity and solidarity in favour of the European project.
As regards the assessment of the strategy to combat the economic crisis, I will briefly remind you that that strategy is made up of four fundamental aspects. Firstly, a strengthening of economic governance by means of a far-reaching legislative package that is aimed at strengthening fiscal discipline, avoiding excessive macroeconomic imbalances, which that we hope the European Parliament will approve as soon as possible. Secondly, the assessment of the twenty-seven National Reform Programmes and the Stability Programmes that, within the framework of the so-called European Semester, all EU Member States have sent to Brussels in April. These Programmes include more than one hundred economic policy actions for the next twelve months in the Euro-Plus Pact. The European Council's assessment of the Programme of Reforms being applied by Spain, which has already been released, is broadly-speaking positive given that it states that a response is being provided to the medium-term challenges posed by the Spanish economy. For example, regarding Spanish fiscal policy, the European Council believes that Spain's path towards fiscal consolidation is adequate and that it will enable the levels of public debt to be stabilised at a level that is considerably lower than the European average and urges, as is to be expected, that all public administration services endeavour to meet targets.
The third aspect in the strategy to combat the economic crisis relates to the stress tests aimed at guaranteeing transparency and solvency for European financial entities. Hence, the Council highlighted the importance to be had by the publication of their results by the new European Banking Authority at the start of July and for the test to apply highly rigorous criteria. Fourthly, the Council welcomed the progress made by the Economic and Financial Affairs Ministers in meeting the mandate of the Council regarding the Eurozone Stability Instruments, both the temporary instrument and the permanent instrument, which we have discussed and debated over the last few months on many occasions.
Those are the two main issues concerning economic policy. Firstly, Greece - the commitment to support Greece, a call for responsibility from all political forces in Greece, for them to approve the programme and for Greece to gain access to the resources it needs to repay its debts. That commitment is essential for the Eurozone and, of course, the European leaders, Europe, will continue to seek stability and support from all countries in the Eurozone with absolute conviction. Secondly, we took another step forward today in defining more integrated and more coordinated European economic policy in our search for greater stability, greater risk prevention and a response to the crisis.
Regarding the matter of immigration, asylum and the Schengen Agreement, which as you know was another of the important topics at this European Council meeting, we discussed various issues. A proposal was made to strengthen the system of supervising the control of external borders and the establishment of a safeguard mechanism for action in exceptional circumstances. Similarly, the European Council approved the Regulations governing the European External Border Agency, strengthening its ability to act and its operational and personnel resources. I would like to remind you and point out that the European immigration policy continues to be a fundamental pillar for European integration in Spain's opinion, with significance that goes far beyond that of control issues and implies fostering greater cooperation with the countries of origin and transit, and the total integration of immigrants into our societies. With Spain's complete support, of course, the European Council highlighted the need to preserve the fundamental right to free movement of people throughout the European Union and, more specifically, within the Schengen Area. Under no circumstances may the exceptional safeguard mechanism that we approved today and that must now be developed by the Commission be used to arbitrarily restrict that liberty as its objective is limited to guaranteeing effectiveness in the control of external borders under exception circumstances involving the uncontrolled movement of people.
I will briefly mention Croatia. The Council has welcomed the forthcoming conclusion of adhesion talks with Croatia and has set a deadline for signing the Adhesion Treaty before the end of the year.
On the matter of foreign and southern neighbourliness policy: today we concluded the work to revise the European neighbourliness policy that, as you know, is a core part of EU action to construct an even stronger partnership between the South and North Mediterranean regions. Besides the generally positive development in other Arab countries such as Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco and Jordan, we also discussed the Middle East Peace Process and the initiative from the High Representative to call a meeting of the Quartet to enable direct talks between Palestinians and Israelis to be resumed. At the same time, we also continued our constant discussion on the situation in Libya, reaffirming the principles contained in the United Nations Resolution to protect the country's population and to make every effort, without taking a step backwards, to attain change for the political system in Syria - a change towards a democratic regime. The same aspiration is called for in Syria, whose regime the European Council once again called upon to cease its repression of protests - something that achieves nothing except detracting from its legitimacy to rule on a daily basis - and to undertake sound and necessary reforms of a constitutional and political nature that would also be aimed at attaining change.
Finally, as you are aware and has been widely publicised, I would like to express my satisfaction, my great satisfaction, regarding the candidature of a Spaniard and member of the Government and direct collaborator, Bernardino León, for that new and extremely important figure of Special Envoy for the Southern Mediterranean and the Transition Processes. The European Union has a lot at stake in the Southern Mediterranean. The European Union has a great duty to decisively contribute towards a conclusion of the transition processes in the Southern Mediterranean that leads to democratic regimes, regimes of liberty and, of course, regimes with strong ties to the European Union. I believe that our candidate is a magnificent candidate, an excellent candidate, with great knowledge of the region, of EU foreign policy and who will decisively contribute to that resolute objective of the European Union. Furthermore, I think he is the best candidate and you will see that over the coming days.
Q .
On the issue of Greece, I would like to know whether the appeal to the opposition is a desire from the Twenty-Seven [EU Member States] or is a condition sine qua non of the support from the Greek opposition to the new austerity plans for the Eurozone to provide those twelve billion euros and the second rescue plan. On the issue of Schengen, Spain had previously been opposed to any changes to the Treaty. Do you accept this exceptional mechanism you were talking about a few moments ago? And on a key domestic issue, how do you view the fact that Bildu is leading the Provincial Council of Guipuzcoa and the City Council of San Sebastián?
President of the Government .
It is not a condition sine qua non but rather an appeal made by the European Council to all the political forces in Greece and particularly the main opposition party. It is very serious. It means that the European Council and the European leaders are taking note of the current and future attitude of the Greek Parliament. However, I must insist that it is not a condition sine qua non. The stability of Greece and the ability of Greece to face up to its responsibilities and the commitment to solidarity and responsibility with the Eurozone are, undoubtedly, the criteria that guide and have always guided the Council and the European leaders.
On the Schengen issue, you will be aware that the agreement reached today supposes an exceptional limitation when faced with special circumstances. Express reference is made to the fact that, under no circumstances may this procedure, which, I repeat, must be further specified or developed by the Commission, affect the rights to free movement of the members that make up the Schengen Area. In fact, there were several speeches during the Council debate regarding the limitation that should be imposed whilst excluding specific reference to illegal immigration, for example. That position, which was shared by myself and the Swedish Prime Minister to be precise, was taken into consideration. Of course, we must be thinking about exceptional circumstances that generate… We have already seen some, and this must be organised and rationalised. That is what the Council wants, without limiting what is an essential, basic, pillar of the European project - the free movement of its people. We hope that the Commission comes up with a good project for those exceptional circumstances, but our position today, with the text as it stands, is one of acceptance.
On this issue of Bildu, I am not at all pleased that the group is governing the City Council of San Sebastián and the Provincial Council of Guipuzcoa but I must remember two things: one, that it will have to follow the Law, all aspects of the Law; and, two, that it does not hold a majority. That fact is of significance when reflecting on the political forces to be found in both institutions.
Q .
Mr President of the Government, I would like to ask you about something you have not mentioned. Following the announcement made yesterday by President Obama, how and when will the withdrawal of Spanish troops from Afghanistan take place? Also, the State of the Nation is just around the corner. This will be the last, for the time being at least, that you face as President of the Government. I would like to know what you expect from this debate and, above all, from the leader of the opposition who, it would seem, is going to reveal certain aspects of the programme with which he will present himself at the upcoming general elections in March or November. Finally, if you'll allow me, can you give us any details about the Special Envoy for the Arab Spring Process? I would like to know where the process stands, when he would start his job, when the new position might be approved and whether he is still the only candidate to have put himself forward.
President of the Government .
Afghanistan, first of all. Yes, the Government of Spain has a withdrawal plan that will basically play out as follows: first half of 2012, about 10% of all troops; first half of 2013, up to 40% of the troops we have in Afghanistan; and, in 2014, a complete withdrawal. That would be the plan, bearing in mind how the situation develops of course, but the plan is relatively advanced in those terms.
On the State of the Nation debate: that's right, this will be my last State of the Nation debate. I don't know what you meant to say with "for the time being", but it is my last State of the Nation debate. I will say that no-one will be surprised to hear that the analysis and basic content of my speech will focus on the economic situation, financial stability, the stability of our debt and the reforms we have under way, and on making and calling, once again, for an effort for collective responsibility from the autonomous regions, the local councils, the political forces and the social stakeholders (business leaders and trade unions) to carry out the task, the difficult task, as everyone already knows, of economic recovery and, above all, returning ourselves to a situation of sustained employment. Basically, that will be the content of the debate.
As regards the Secretary-General of the Presidency of the Government and soon Special Envoy for the Southern Mediterranean, I believe that the matter will become clear over the coming days. You will hear news soon enough. There must be a legal process and I'm sure some of you know more than me about the bureaucracy in Brussels. So, I think things will be confirmed in the coming days, but it will happen.
Q .
Is no-one opposed?
President of the Government . No, absolutely not. Quite the opposite.
I must say that this doesn't happen all too often but the unanimous support for Bernardino León is quite exceptional. It should be a cause for pride in Spain that we are capable of having diplomats, diplomatic politicians or political diplomats, who enjoy such prestige and recognition. And, if you will allow me, it is also something that gives me great pride.
Q .
I have two questions, Mr President of the Government. Firstly, if the Greek Parliament votes against the plan from the EU and the IMF next week, will Spain defend another different option other than that of allowing Greece to default? Secondly, regarding the second rescue plan for Greece, there are already several banks or a part of the European banking system that has indicated its willingness to participate in the "roll over". Even though the Spanish banks hold a very small stake, what has been the first reaction from their negotiations?
President of the Government .
We are focused on the hypothesis that the Greek Parliament will back the plan and, therefore, we are working on that hypothesis. The data would indicate that, with Prime Minister Papandreou having won confidence, support for the plan from the Greek Parliament will follow. I also think that it would be rather inappropriate to venture a hypothesis regarding what would happen if that were not the case. I am convinced that the Greek Parliament will back the plan next week.
In terms of those entities that have some sort of position or other with Greece (in fact, as you know, the First Vice-President has already had some contact), there is a good feeling but, as you yourself said, exposure to the Greek debt is very low in terms of what affects our country and, therefore, will not pose any great problems for our entities. As a result, from that perspective, we can remain calm.
Q .
Mr President of the Government, from this European Council an express appeal has emerged, as you have called it, to the Greek opposition for it to support the reforms being implemented by its Government. Even though the situations are different, I would like to know whether you believe that the Spanish Partido Popular should feel itself the target of that message in some way and support the reforms being implemented by your Government. That on the one hand. Secondly, the Partido Popular failed to support the collective bargaining reform two days ago. I would like to know, in the event that you had not pushed that reform through, which you believe to be highly important, whether you would have felt forced to bring the general elections forward.
President of the Government .
First of all, perhaps not so blatantly obvious as has happened recently with Greece in terms of that appeal to the opposition to support the reforms, but the European Council has made other appeals during this process of serious sovereign debt crises. More specifically, I remember Portugal very clearly. And I must remind you that the Commission and the Council, the Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund called for a commitment from the two leading parties to back the plan ahead of the election process.
The reflection is clear: in a crisis situation, and there is a situation of crisis being experienced by many Eurozone countries, some in a situation of extreme crisis such as Ireland, Portugal and Greece, which have been forced to resort to external aid (aid provided by Spain, for example, and all other Eurozone countries), the stronger the crisis, the stronger the responsibility weighing down on all political forces; the greater the difficulties, and those being difficulties that are objectively global and far-reaching, and which can only unsustainably be attributed to the action of one particular Government or another, the greater must be the supporting attitude. Just like other great issues we have experienced over the last thirty years, the issue of Spain overcoming this serious economic crisis, of guaranteeing its financial stability and recovering the strength of its economy is an issue for the whole country. It is above and beyond colour and political symbology. It is a central, substantial and all-encompassing issue.
Yes, I would have liked the Partido Popular to have supported the reforms, some of which are difficult, costly. I said, I think it was in May 2010, that I was going to do certain things, whatever the cost, but that they were essential for the country. Everyone is entitled to interpret their own responsibility to their country and I would have liked to see the Partido Popular and Mariano Rajoy assume those responsibilities and not simply resort to the easy task of voting against and saying the responsibility lies with the Government. I have thought recently that, at this difficult stage of tackling the economic challenges, many Governments and, of course, I include my own Government among them, are working amid an excessive lack of trust from the markets and the logical discontent of the people. We are working on that path in some countries, such as ours, with very little commitment from the opposition. But that is the way things are and it must be accepted.
What would have happened? There is no point thinking like that but I must tell you one thing: I was always convinced that the Royal Decree-Law was going to be approved. That was the case because, as you can imagine, I had already been talking with the leader of the Basque Nationalist Party in particular for several days, several weeks even, beforehand over and above the standard negotiations that must take place for any parliamentary process. But my position was one of confidence and, for that reason, I did not consider what I should do if what didn't happen were to happen and what I didn't want to happen, of course.
Q .
Two questions, Mr President of the Government, on Libya. I would like to know whether you have discussed the Italian proposal for a ceasefire to create a humanitarian corridor and what Spain thinks about this proposal.
And my second question is about the Schengen issue. Between now and when the Commission presents its proposal, will there be any discussion about whether this safeguard clause may be activated by the Member States or will have to be activated, as the European Commission wants, by Brussels? I would like to know whether Spain wants the Commission to have power over when to close borders.
President of the Government .
I think we will have to wait until September, which is when the Commission intends to present the text; but it can be deduced from the Council mandate that it must be a process in which there is agreement between the affected countries, albeit with leadership from the Commission. That would be the most appropriate solution.
On the issue of Libya, the Italian Prime Minister has indeed emphasised the serious humanitarian situation. He did not propose a humanitarian corridor but did emphasise the serious humanitarian situation that exists on some borders as a result of the situation in Libya. And what he basically did was to ask the Commission to become more involved in this serious humanitarian problem, to which, as can be expected, all the European institutions must make a commitment.
Q .
On the Schengen issue, Mr President of the Government. Even though the specific reference to illegal immigration has been removed, it is obvious that there were exceptional circumstances in Italy and that France was calling for this reform on those grounds. Why are you accepting that? And, secondly, do you not fear that what has been approved today could one day be applied to Spain?
President of the Government .
No, because there is an aspect of reasonableness in the proposal and that is to say what happens in a situation involving the displacement of people… I believe that the debate on legal or illegal immigration, for the purposes at hand, is a little useless because it relates to categories we apply in situations of normality. What happens when there is a migratory displacement of people following a large catastrophe? Think of any kind of catastrophe you want: the result of terrorist action, the result of war or a pandemic. Let's imagine. They are very exceptional circumstances and circumstances that, due to their exceptional nature, can reasonably demand exceptional responses to what is the Schengen framework. That said, it must be the case that we have complete guarantees, agreement with complete guarantees, and it must not affect the free movement of people within the Schengen Area. I think that is something that can be supported because it respects the spirit, the text and the principle fundamentals of free movement and the principle behind the Schengen Agreement.
Thank you.