Press conference of the President of the Government, the President of the French Republic, and the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

12 September 2004 · Press conference following the meeting of the Spanish, French and German leaders on the European Constitution · La Moncloa, Spain

Context
Zapatero held a joint press conference at La Moncloa with French President Chirac and German Chancellor Schröder to promote European Constitution ratification and trilateral cooperation.
Main themes
European Constitution ratification, European integration, trilateral cooperation between Spain, France, and Germany, common foreign and security policy, EU enlargement, military cooperation, justice and interior affairs, Barcelona Process, Iraq and Afghanistan, Mediterranean dialogue, Turkey's EU candidacy
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,656
83rd percentile
Sentences
146
80th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

146 sentences in 60 paragraphs

President .- Good afternoon and thank you for your presence.

First of all, I want to thank Chancellor Schröder and President Chirac for being here at this meeting, here in La Moncloa. They represent friendly countries of Spain and countries that have contributed to the process of modernization, to the process of incorporation and strengthening of democracy in our country.

We have gathered today, in La Moncloa, the leaders of these three countries that are driving European construction: Germany, France, and Spain. We all agree on the need to fully support the ratification of the European Constitution. This is a campaign on a continental scale, not just within each country, and we wish to develop it together.

Spain wishes to be one of the first countries to approve the European Constitution in a referendum. That is why I have invited my friends Chirac and Schröder to participate in an event to promote and explain this decisive text, which will also include some representatives from other countries of the European Union. And I have also offered, as is logical, to carry out any events they deem appropriate in favor of the project represented by the Constitution of the European Union.

Spain, France, and Germany also agree, in a very particular way, to promote a common foreign and security policy, and to strengthen from now on the role of Javier Solana, the future Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Union.

We also want to reinforce our military cooperation in terms of capabilities and armaments.

Likewise, we are also addressing important matters of Interior and Justice in this meeting, and we have reached an agreement to develop the sharing of our national criminal records.

Spain, France, and Germany support the candidacies for European Union membership of Bulgaria, Romania, Croatia, and Turkey. In the case of Turkey, this country still needs to make efforts for the dialogue and integration process into the Union.

We have also addressed the situation in Iraq, in Afghanistan, in the Middle East, and in Ibero-America, and we have instructed our Ministers of Foreign Affairs, Defense, and Economy to develop these topics.

Likewise, we have agreed to give a boost to the dialogue process with the Mediterranean, through what is known as the Barcelona Process, which next year will celebrate its tenth anniversary.

This is the agenda, intense; but beyond this agenda, the meaning of this meeting is evident. You have before you three pro-Europeans; we are not the only pro-Europeans, but we are fervent pro-Europeans. It is true that this is just another meeting, but it is not just any meeting. If I had to describe in a few words the atmosphere of this encounter, I would say that old Europe is like new.

Mr. Chirac .- I believe that the Spanish President has perfectly characterized our meeting, a meeting of three countries that have a clear will to move forward in a European construction that allows for greater rooting of peace, democracy, and economic and social progress across our European territory.

We have observed that we share the same approaches; that our interests, mainly in such fundamental areas as foreign policy or domestic policy, coincide; that we have topics for reflection that arise, especially regarding the future financing of Europe, which we need to start discussing now with the best attitude, and that is what we will certainly do; that in the military field we also have very similar positions and that our will to develop the European core of defense is identical.

Therefore, on all these issues, a convergence and common will have been expressed to be strong elements of the European construction of the future, not the only ones, of course, and we have decided to mainly develop our relations with the main countries of the Union, small, medium, or large, in the same direction. But we must start, and the strengthening of the ties that allow Spain to return to the heart of decisions and European policy I believe is the best omen in that regard. We are pleased about this and I warmly thank you for your welcome to President Rodríguez Zapatero and the work we have been able to do together.

Mr. Schröder .- I do not have much to add on my part. I agree that we need a unified, strong Europe, and the Rodríguez Zapatero Government has shown that Spain wants to play a very important role, and that it will do so, in Europe. Certainly, without the Rodríguez Zapatero Government, that decision on the Constitution could not have been made, and that is something that must be said. It is something historic, a historic achievement in European history, and it is about advancing the country itself, but also all partners within Europe. That will be seen today, and not only today, but in collaboration and cooperation, in general.

The Spanish Prime Minister and Mr. Chirac have already spoken about the fundamental issues. I will not dwell on them, but I would like to say that France, Spain, and Germany are countries with a very developed industrial structure. That is to say, our countries are not only dedicated to services, which are very important, of course — and we also have common ground there for the future — but we are particularly interested in ensuring that the social structure remains intact and can be developed wherever possible. That is why we have been discussing what we could do in this regard, for example, to advance the Lisbon Process in the field of Research and Development, for instance. It is a very important topic in which we can collaborate closely.

For example, if we want to maintain our industrial capacity and performance, we must be just as good as we are now in the most important sectors, but with a view to improving so that competition does not overtake us. That means we need to increase or improve everything related to Research and Development, and, above all, what we must not allow in Europe is for the issue of the industrial capacity of our countries to become secondary, because it is always considered that the most modern is the best.

After all, there are many people in Europe who live from industrial production, and we must maintain that sector, of course, and continue to develop it. I am referring to the automobile industry, for example, and in that area the three countries have capabilities; of course, also to the chemical industry; to all that is engineering; likewise to the maritime economy, where we could collaborate much more than we have in the past; and in aeronautics as well, where, by the way, a European company is currently a leader.

Therefore, I believe these are sectors in which we can collaborate, and I think we can affirm that our meetings are held in this spirit that unites us. Moreover, our three countries are very important in Europe, and we are open to all countries that want to work with us in that same spirit joining us. This, for me, has been a result of a meeting that could not have had a better atmosphere than it has had.

Q.- I wanted to ask the same question to each of you. The former French Socialist Prime Minister, Laurent Fabius, has just spoken out in favor of "no" in the referendum on the European Constitution on the grounds that it would not be sufficiently social. What do you think of that attitude?

President .- My opinion is in favor of the European Constitution. The project of European unity is undoubtedly the most important historical achievement that civilization has experienced in the last century. Countries that decades ago turned Europe into a battlefield are capable of creating a framework for common political coexistence, elevating it to the highest level, which is to have a European Constitution. Furthermore, Europe remains the paradigm of social cohesion, and that identity of social Europe, in my opinion, is sufficiently reflected in the European Constitution. With respect to any opinion, my view is clearly in favor of the European Constitution.

Mr. Chirac .- I fully share the opinion expressed by Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero and would like to add something. For me, with the referendum, what is at stake is very simple and very clear: there is a question, and that question would be: Is the European Constitution a progress for France and for Europe, does it allow us to continue the construction and organization of an enlarged Europe, which roots peace and democracy, but also economic and social progress in its territory? That is the question, and it is a fundamental question for our future. That is why, as I have already said, the French will be consulted by referendum.

I would not want this question to be emptied of content. Every French person must express their opinion on the proposed text of the Constitution, and for my part, I will do everything possible to ensure that this campaign for this referendum is not manipulated for partisan purposes.

Mr. Schröder .- The Constitution provides a very good framework to do, within the Constitution, what I want, that is, to maintain the European social model, which is unique in the world, and to develop it further wherever possible. That can be done on the basis of the Constitution, and that is why I will always be in favor. Germany, without intending to get ahead of others, will also, of course, ratify this Constitution as soon as possible, among other things, because it provides a very good framework for maintaining and developing the social model in which I believe.

Q.- Presidents, my question relates to terrorism. I wanted to know, Mr. President, if from your point of view there are different levels of security and threat in the European Union. For example, is Spain now, after the withdrawal of troops from Iraq, safer, more protected?

If I may ask a question to the German Chancellor, when you talk about terrorism and the terrorist threat with your colleagues, do you have a sense that that threat is different, of a different degree, from one country to another in Europe; for example, that Germany and France are a little more protected or safer because they did not even participate in the war in Iraq?

Mr. Schröder .- When the horrific attacks occurred here in Madrid, when we were living and feeling with the Spanish people, with the victims, that horror, we all became aware that terrorism is a threat to everyone; without differences, for everyone. Therefore, anyone who thought they could escape that global threat of terrorism is mistaken. That has nothing to do with the fact that one can have a different opinion about Iraq than our British friends or the Government in Spain at that time.

Terrorism threatens us all, and therefore it is the common task of all to fight against it. In my opinion, there are no different degrees of threat from international terrorism, and that is why solidarity from all with all those affected is necessary.

President .- I agree with Chancellor Schröder. Terrorism is a general threat, it is a blind action and can strike anywhere in the world.

The best way to combat terrorism is international cooperation in the field of Justice, in the field of police, in the field of intelligence institutions, of intelligence services, and also in the area of what political efforts represent to prevent the so-called clash of civilizations from becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy. All those areas are essential for the fight against terrorism and, of course, the highest level of agreement in the realm of the International Community.

Q.- President Chirac referred to the financing of the European Union and said that we should be constructive, have a constructive attitude. In light of Spain's demands for a gradual exit from the Cohesion Funds, I wanted to ask President Chirac and Chancellor Schröder if they consider it acceptable or if they will accept that this gradual exit occurs, and if, on the other hand, they will in no case accept that the one percent of the European Union budget is exceeded.

Mr. Chirac .- We fully understand that the financing of the European construction of tomorrow poses problems. It is, in fact, the characteristic of all financing problems.

Naturally, one can have the ambition to spend more and more, and we understand that, because one can have great ambitions. Unfortunately, there are limits, because these expenses come from the contributions of the different Budgets, that is, from the different peoples. Therefore, one must also be reasonable.

If we take, for example, the situation of our three countries, since we are all three here, it is clear that the concerns are different, and in fact, it is one of the few issues where our concerns are different.

Germany is the largest net contributor to the European Union. It has accepted this situation; but it considers, and it cannot be reproached for wanting this, that this situation has limits, especially when we tell Germany: we are going to spend more, you are going to have to contribute more -- which already poses a great problem for the Germans--; but, in addition, just like the others, we are going to impose limits on you in terms of budgetary matters that prevent you from increasing your deficit. Therefore, pay more and maintain the same deficit. What does this mean? This means, of course, significantly reducing social spending. It is not possible, everyone can understand that. Hence comes the German approach to this issue, which we understand perfectly.

Spain says: we have benefited from solidarity -- this was the initial political contract, it was normal--; little by little our economy has developed, our incomes have increased, and we have reached the point where we can no longer benefit from this solidarity, since our average income will have exceeded the initially foreseen cap in this area. But Spain tells us: what cannot be done is a brutal break, and therefore, we wish to negotiate this matter. We understand it perfectly, it is something normal. Therefore, we will have to find solutions.

As for France, it is a medium net contributor and it also has its concerns, such as, primarily, for example, the maintenance of the commitments made by the European Union regarding the agricultural budget until the year 2013. We are very attentive, of course, to ensuring that this commitment is maintained, and this commitment implies, of course, money.

You see that we have three different approaches, and when there are three different approaches, there are two possibilities. One can come saying "this is what I want and you have to accept it." It is never a good method, it is never the way to solve problems. Arrogance or the will to disregard others always leads to failure. But that is not the spirit in which we find ourselves, none of us three, nor the spirit with which we have discussed these problems. On the contrary, each one has said "these are the problems I have to face," and the others have said: we understand the problems and we are going to seek the best solution to reach a compromise that is as satisfactory or as acceptable as possible for each one.

This is the good solution, the good recipe, and the correct method, and it is the one we have adopted, and it is why we will move forward. Of course, no one will be able to win in everything. It is evident, it is impossible; but we will continue to strengthen Europe by finding acceptable compromises for the different public opinions. This is what we think in this regard.

Mr. Schröder.- It cannot be expressed better than the French President has done, and therefore it is unnecessary to intervene now. But this implies that there is still much work ahead for us.

Q.- I wanted to know if you agreed that a more favorable situation would be created in Iraq if there were a generalized withdrawal, for example, of the countries that have troops there, or a staggered withdrawal, or some kind of withdrawal.

Mr. Chirac.- I have no reason to judge the position of one country or another. What I know is that the situation is serious and that it is not improving. I believe that together, in one way or another, we have opened a Pandora's box that we are now unable to close, which can have serious consequences.

In any case, neither side intends to change the position we took in good conscience, because we thought it was the one that best corresponded to the problem at hand.

Q.- My question is for all three of you. You mentioned that Turkey has to make certain efforts. I would like to know if this means that Turkey has to deepen rights for the Kurds if it wants to aspire to the European Union.

Mr. Schröder.- At the European Council, we have made quite a few decisions regarding this, and one of the decisions was to instruct the Commission to examine whether Turkey meets the criteria established in Copenhagen or not. Undoubtedly, Turkey has made great strides, it has progressed a lot. The European Commission will present its report, and in that report, it will be confirmed whether those advances are sufficient to begin accession negotiations.

I do not want to anticipate that report. What I can tell you is that Turkey has made great progress, and I believe that everyone recognizes that. If the Commission's report is in favor of Turkey's entry -- and I believe Turkey can be hopeful in this regard -- then I think the Council will have to decide. It will have to make a decision to start the accession negotiations soon, which will undoubtedly take a long time.

Forty years ago, Turkey was promised that if it met the political criteria, it would have a perspective for accession. Let us keep in mind that it is a country that, considering the region in which it is located, can have enormous added security value, because let us think that it can be an intermediary position between that fundamentalist Islam and Europe, and therefore it can imply a huge increase in security for Europe.

For these reasons, I believe that if the Commission's report is favorable to Turkey's entry and the proposal is made, I think the Council will decide positively.

Mr. Chirac.- I completely agree.

Q.- I would like to ask all three of you a question regarding the European Constitution. You say that you are going to commit body and soul to ensure that the Constitution is ratified and moves forward; but, in light of the difficulties in some countries, for example, in France, I would like to know if, in the event that it is not ratified in any country, you believe that a plan B should already be prepared, which would include, for example, repeating the referendum, as happened in the case of Maastricht, or would it be more appropriate to move towards a two-speed Europe, where some advance faster and others slower. I would like to know your opinion.

President.- From my point of view, European governments and European leaders must make every effort to obtain the ratification of the Constitution of the European Union. There is enough time, and there must be a very close explanatory action with citizens so that all European citizens can clearly see how it affects their concrete future, their rights, and living in an increasingly integrated political community, the Constitution of the European Union.

I believe that Europe has been able to set an example of overcoming great challenges in its integration process, and I have no doubt that it will also be able to overcome this one. Therefore, we must work on the hypothesis of plan A, that is, to see the ratification of the European Constitution.

Mr. Schröder.- I am totally in favor of plan A. It means that we have to work hard so that the European Constitution can be ratified in all countries. That is why I do not even consider the possibility of a plan B, C, or D.

Q.- The question is directed to all three of you. The British Foreign Secretary, Jack Straw, has already indicated that the United Kingdom does not feel excluded from this meeting. Although all three of you will say that this is not a directory, but at this moment in the European construction where there are suspicions that this could be the case, given the shift that the Spanish government has made in its foreign policy, is this the birth of a new directory?

A second question: are you going to systematize these meetings? When are we going to have this trilateral meeting again?

President.- From my point of view, this is a positive meeting for the European Union, as undoubtedly are those meetings held by representatives of the countries that make up the Union, especially those with a deep European vocation.

This meeting is part of a context of normality and momentum following the establishment of the European Union, and it is always possible to have other types of meetings with other types of interlocutors. On the part of the Spanish government, of course, we have the utmost interest in having further encounters and meetings, like the one we are holding today, with the government of France and with the government of Germany. It is useful for the Spanish government and for Spain, it is useful for the European Union, and I believe it is also useful for the governments and countries of Germany and France. For my part, there is availability, and I believe there is already some idea in that regard from President Chirac.

Mr. Chirac.- Of course, we do not exclude anyone, naturally.

Mr. Schröder.- Completely agree.

President.- Thank you very much.