Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the Progressive Leaders Summit.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

14 October 2004 · Progressive Leaders Summit

Context
Zapatero held a press conference in Budapest on October 14, 2004, following the Progressive Leaders Summit, reporting on multilateral discussions and bilateral meetings.
Main themes
Multilateralism and UN reform, Middle East peace process, international terrorism, bilateral meetings, Spain-South Africa relations, Spain-Hungary relations, Spain-UK relations and Gibraltar, Iraq war, EU integration, progressive leaders cooperation, U.S.-Spain diplomatic tensions
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,338
80th percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
15.3
78th percentile
Syntax
3.34
86th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

108 sentences in 48 paragraphs

President.- I will make a brief introduction of what has transpired since yesterday afternoon-evening during my first presence at what is known as the Forum of Progressive Leaders in the world.

Yesterday we had an interesting meeting in which we fundamentally addressed the issues of the Peace and Security Agenda for what represents 2005. There was a widespread agreement that we face three fundamental challenges: first, the recovery of multilateralism, the recovery of strength in the United Nations as the best way to guarantee peace and security; second, the need to urgently and decisively address the situation in the Middle East, the conflict between Israel and Palestine; and third, the decision and determination that the fight against international terrorism must be a shared struggle that unites countries rather than divides them. Essentially, these would be the three most important elements of the debate surrounding the Peace and Security Agenda in the world.

In addition to that and the content of that debate and the conclusions of the leaders' meeting, which will be made public today, I held three bilateral meetings this morning; in other words, we started work early. I had a meeting with the President of the Republic of South Africa, I had a meeting with the Hungarian Prime Minister, and I had a meeting with the British Prime Minister, Tony Blair, taking advantage of his presence at this Summit. All three had a high political interest, both in terms of the international order issues that are currently priorities, as well as from the perspective of bilateral relations between Spain and those three countries.

Regarding the meeting with the President of the Republic of South Africa, I will say that there was an exchange of opinions and a willingness for joint cooperation on various problems facing the African continent that affect the Maghreb and Equatorial Guinea, and a determined willingness to increase relations from both a political and an economic and commercial perspective between Spain and South Africa. You know that South Africa is an emerging power on the African continent, you know that it has a clear desire for influence in what represents the construction of a new international order, an increasingly multilateral order, and, of course, in that perspective we share the fundamental positions held by the Republic of South Africa.

In relation to the meeting with the Hungarian Prime Minister, who was hosting this meeting, I must emphasize, above all, that Spain's intention is to have a clear process of increasing economic and commercial relations with Hungary, with this new country of the European Union; which in the coming years will receive significant assistance from Union funds and therefore Spain wants to be present in the entire process of modernization and economic development of Hungary. In addition to that, we have agreed that an official visit by the Hungarian Prime Minister to our country can take place; as you know, the Prime Minister was elected very recently.

Furthermore, as I mentioned, I had a meeting with Tony Blair; a meeting that fundamentally focused on analyzing the international political situation, especially in all aspects affecting security, affecting Iraq, affecting the issue and the moment of the conflict between Israel and Palestine, and also on the shared willingness to hold a thorough meeting in the coming months to address bilateral issues. Among them, logically, we will talk about Gibraltar.

But I believe it is of great importance that the communication and exchange regarding the positions of British Prime Minister Tony Blair, both in relation to the process of building the European Union and to that international order which will have very important milestones in the coming months, have a strong communication capacity with what the positions of the Spanish Government represent. I believe that, therefore, the conversation has been useful, it has been fruitful, and, without a doubt, I am very satisfied in that regard.

Q.- Mr. President, yesterday we learned of statements from the U.S. Ambassador in Madrid stating that he was not present on the 12th at the reception for Hispanic Heritage because a year ago the then leader of the Spanish opposition, now the Head of Government, did not stand during the parade as the American flag passed by. Regarding that direct reference, I would like to know your assessment.

President.- I will not make an assessment of the statements of the American Ambassador and, in fact, I will not evaluate whether certain methods are the most diplomatic or not. I will not make an assessment. The only thing I want to say is that I will not change my convictions or my decisions regarding the war in Iraq. My convictions and my decisions regarding the war in Iraq are a commitment I have to the Spanish citizenry and that I will maintain.

Q.- Given that you have said you will not respond to the Ambassador's statements, I would like to know if you will ask the Spanish Ambassador in Washington to respond, in some way, to what the American Ambassador has said in Madrid.

By the way, I wanted to ask your opinion on the likely European Commissioner for Justice and Freedoms, Mr. Buttiglione. Do you think he meets the conditions to hold this position?

President.- Regarding the first point, the Spanish Ambassador in North America is a great diplomat and I am sure he will do what is expected of an Ambassador, which is to strengthen the good relations we have, beyond the profound disagreement on the issue of Iraq, and that, of course, my Government will promote with American society, with that country and with its authorities. That represents a coherent foreign policy, which we will certainly put into practice. I am fully convinced that Mr. Westendorp carries out that diplomatic task with success and brilliance in Washington. I have confirmation that this is the case.

Secondly, it is up to Parliament and the President of the Commission to express their views. No one should be surprised that certain statements I have heard from the Commissioner, I obviously do not share at all.

Q.- Mr. President, it seems that yesterday Álvaro Cuesta, a member of the Socialist Party in the 11-M Commission, said something like the attack was prepared right under the noses of the previous government. Do you think this could increase tension ahead of your appearance and that of the former President in the Commission?

President.- I think it is perfectly understandable that in everything that affects the 11-M Commission and the 11-M, I refer to what will be my appearance and my statement before the Commission, with the aim of ensuring that all the data, all the information, and all the truth that the Government possesses is known by public opinion and, of course, with the fundamental objective of conveying confidence to Spanish society: confidence in our capacity to fight against terrorism, confidence in the institutions, confidence in justice, and confidence in the proper functioning of a good rule of law that we have.

That is my objective in the 11-M Commission in my appearance, in addition to being, logically, at the disposal of Parliament, which responds, as I have said many times, to my democratic convictions.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to know if you could explain the measures the Government plans to approve today to repair the memory of the victims of Francoism and the request from the Catalan Government that is on the table to do something special regarding former President Lluis Companys.

President.- I believe that it is the task of the Vice President of the Government, who also chairs the Interministerial Commission and is the Government Spokesperson, to address that in today's press conference of the Council of Ministers. Logically, it is her task and I believe I must respect that.

Q.- Regarding dissidents in Cuba, do you consider that relations with the Cuban dissidence have deteriorated after the reception on October 12 at the Embassy and that some left the reception?

On another note, you mentioned that you spoke with Mbeki about the Maghreb. Did you ask him to maintain a different position after recognizing the Sahrawi Republic?

President.- I will start with the second point. We did indeed talk about the Sahara. I explained to him what the position of the Government of Spain is: thirty years without an agreement, thirty years without a solution regarding the Sahara; therefore, the position of the Government of Spain is: the solution is the agreement. And we agreed on something that I believe is of enormous importance: to have diplomatic cooperation between South Africa and the Government of Spain, specifically between the two Foreign Ministers, to seek and contribute to finding that solution within the framework of the United Nations that, I insist, involves a major agreement. In this, I believe there has been a very high level of understanding between the President of the Republic of South Africa and the positions I have expressed on behalf of the Spanish Government. But, indeed, it was one of the important points.

Regarding Cuba, I believe the position held by the Government of Spain is well known. It is a position of open disagreement with the policy that the regime of Fidel Castro practices regarding human rights and freedoms. This was expressed by the Spanish Ambassador in that country.

It is also known that the Government of Spain considers that the Cuban people and what is, above all, the future of the political situation in that country is not foreign to Spain or the European Union; and that, therefore, we must work within the European Union, with all the political strength of the European Union, in both directions, which is to demand profound changes from the regime of Fidel Castro and also to think about the future. This is the line maintained by the Government of Spain, which will be a line to be discussed, logically, within the European Union, and, evidently, this line is above what may be a momentary disagreement of some people from the dissidence, whom I obviously respect.

Q.- Mr. President, do you consider the attitude of the U.S. Ambassador not attending the events of October 12 to be a slight to the entire Spanish people, apart from to yourself?

Secondly, do I deduce that you link the attitudes and actions of the Ambassador with your decision to withdraw troops from Iraq?

President.- I reiterate what I have said: I will not make assessments about the Ambassador's statements. I am the President of the Government, but I also like to practice and must practice diplomacy, and I believe that is what is appropriate between friendly countries and allied countries. Therefore, it is best not to evaluate; to refer and explain, as I have done, that there is a disagreement on a fundamental position, which I will not change, regarding Iraq, because it is my conviction, my commitment to the citizenry, and I also believe that time has vindicated those of us who have maintained certain positions regarding the inconvenience of the war in Iraq.

Q.- I wanted to know if you have spoken with the British Prime Minister about the International Conference that Egypt is promoting or preparing for in a few weeks and I wanted to know if you share France's idea that at that International Conference the presence, in one way or another, of "presentable" insurgents from the insurgency should be on the table, and whether the withdrawal of all military forces occupying that country should also be on the table.

President.- I have spoken quite a bit with Tony Blair about Iraq and the situation currently being experienced in that country, about the immediate prospects and the possibility or not of holding elections in January; we have not talked about the Conference. Regarding the Conference, I refer to what I have expressed on more than one occasion: any international conference on Iraq will only succeed, from my point of view, if it is led by the United Nations, if the United Nations has clear leadership and unites the largest number of countries possible.

I believe that experience tells us that the mistakes made only have one alternative: to reinforce international legality and to strengthen the United Nations. While the United Nations does not take that leadership, I sincerely believe that we will not have a conference with positive expectations, regardless of who participates in that conference, respecting what is, logically, the position maintained by France. But I believe it must be the United Nations.

Q.- In light of this, have you considered the possibility of sending "blue helmets" if the United Nations were to lead the reconstruction process?

President.- I have expressed on more than one occasion that Spain maintains a firm position of not sending troops to Iraq. It is a commitment I have to the citizenry, it is a deep conviction, and it is pure coherence with what I think about the military intervention in Iraq.

From there, Spain is willing to put all its political, economic, and diplomatic effort, with ideas, with proposals, so that we see an Iraq, in the shortest possible time, with stability, with a perspective of democracy, and, of course, with what can represent a recovery of an international climate and international unity lost for too long as a consequence of what the intervention in that country represented.

P.- In response to the question about relations with the United States, you have briefly mentioned the American authorities, but you have not referred to the American government regarding the logical interest in maintaining good relations with the United States. I would like to know if, at this moment, you place the orientation regarding political relations with the U.S. government very much within the framework of the election results and your conviction that Kerry will win; that is, if you are directly betting on Kerry's victory.

Then I would like to ask you, aside from that, if you would like to be in Barcelona this afternoon or tonight participating in the tribute to Lluis Companys, or if you perhaps feel more comfortable being here in Hungary.

President.- Neither more comfortable nor more uncomfortable. The government will be at that tribute, and all the attitudes, statements, and gestures that the government of the nation has made regarding what they imply and represent as historical recognitions of things that happened in our country, and, unfortunately, should never have happened, in Catalonia and many other places, are well known. That is my known position.

Regarding the first question, I will tell you that the government of Spain has the United States of America as an ally, as a friend, for countless reasons: because we share many instances, many international organizations, because we have a deep agreement and many reciprocal commitments in the bilateral order, and, of course, with the authorities that in a democratic country are the government of the United States, starting with its President. But we must get used to the fact that there may be, in the development of those relations, discrepancies, and the discrepancy regarding what Iraq represents is well known.

I have not publicly expressed, although it has been commented on privately, any desire regarding the outcome of the elections. I will not do so, because I have a deep respect for democracy and for what the Americans vote in the upcoming presidential elections. I believe that respect has been maintained and will be maintained for as long as I am President of the Government, because I will not make any pronouncement or campaign in favor of any of the candidates, neither in the United States nor in any other country. Why? For a very simple reason: because I want, for what democracy represents in our country and what the Spaniards vote, the same respect that I will give to all countries. I believe that this is part of the best democratic tradition, and therefore, any other reflection is not possible.

That said, are the upcoming American presidential elections important? Without a doubt, they are very important. I believe that the best data we can have ahead of us is that all indications point to a broad participation of the American people, and that, without a doubt, is very positive.

P.- Mr. President, you have said that there will be a next contact—important, it is understood—with the United Kingdom, in which bilateral issues and also Gibraltar will be discussed. Yesterday there was another high-level contact between the Spanish Administration and the Gibraltar authorities. I wanted to know if there will be a significant change in Spain's position regarding how to conduct the relationship with the Gibraltarians in the opening of those contacts.

A second question. From what you have said, it can be inferred that the government fully supports Ambassador Carlos Alonso Zaldívar's intervention at the party and what he said, and that he said it at that moment and in that way. I would like you to reaffirm that, if possible.

Finally, regarding the topic of the Conference and the differences with Blair, what was made public yesterday about Blair's intervention—you were not there—in the preparatory conference and in the article he published, this does not quite align with the positions you have maintained regarding Europe, except in international politics because he was very brief and practically did not speak on the subject. I understand that the statement goes a bit in that direction and also practically does not talk about anything, because it does not address issues that divide those present here.

President.- I believe that some things have been discussed, but well...

P.- Ultimately, you say that there is good communication, but it gives the impression that this is not reflected in the public interventions, either yours or Blair's. I wanted to know how that is.

President.- I do not think it is necessary to dwell on... It is well known at this point that Tony Blair's position regarding what was the military intervention in Iraq and the position I have maintained and maintain are different. It is evident, and I believe that this should not surprise, nor should it cause any special concern. Fortunately, we are in the realm of freedom of analysis and the capacity to discuss in depth, as was the case last night. At one point in the discussion, I said that I had the same interest in conveying my positions to Tony Blair regarding Iraq, the same interest, and that it provoked a reflection in Tony Blair, as exactly the same interest in respecting the positions that Tony Blair has on the matter. That is what international forums are for, and that is the capacity for debate we have when it comes to coordinating policies.

Regarding Cuba, I have reiterated: our policy is one of firm and strong demands regarding what the regime of Fidel Castro represents and its attitudes; and, secondly, our policy is for the European Union to open a reflection on new initiatives regarding the future of Cuba; a reflection that, I insist, must be shared and must have maximum support within the European Union, and everyone can understand that Spain has an important role there.

Gibraltar. Indeed, it has come up in the conversation with Tony Blair, as could not be otherwise. I raised it, and it will be part of that meeting. We have always said that what the Gibraltarians think is an element that is and must be present, although, obviously, the most relevant thing is the relationship and the positions that in that dialogue we maintain between the government of Spain and the government of Great Britain.

As we know, we have lived through years, the preceding years, in which there were many expectations and very few results, if not no results at all. Now I believe it is wise to go and walk with reasonable expectations, little by little, and wait for the results before stating them so that they do not end up unfulfilled, as happened in previous years.

Thank you very much.