Press conference of the President of the Government during the signing ceremony of the Treaty for a European Constitution.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

28 October 2004 · Signing ceremony of the Treaty for a European Constitution · Rome, Italy

Context
Zapatero held a press conference in Rome on October 28, 2004, following the signing ceremony of the Treaty establishing a European Constitution, announcing a Spanish referendum for February 20, 2005.
Main themes
Treaty establishing a European Constitution, Spanish referendum on EU Constitution, European political unity, Spain's commitment to European integration, constitutional reform in Spain, peace and social cohesion, multilateralism and human rights, democratic legitimacy, public debate and civic engagement, Barroso Commission crisis, Rocco Buttiglione controversy
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,439
81st percentile
Sentences
119
71st percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.45
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

119 sentences in 53 paragraphs

President.- Good morning and thank you very much for your presence at this press conference.

The signing today in Rome of the Treaty of the European Constitution represents the first major step on the path to building the political unity of our continent. The Constitution lays the foundations for what can be a great power oriented towards peace, social and territorial cohesion, multilateralism, cooperation, and the defense of human rights and international legality.

Moreover, it is a powerful instrument that establishes common rules of the game for all European citizens and also guarantees that the great achievements made so far by Europe, from democratic and social strengthening to economic development, will be projected into the future.

Our country, Spain, which arrived late to democratic constitution and European construction, now has the opportunity to demonstrate that it is unequivocally and overwhelmingly with Europe. I firmly believe that the European Constitution exceeds, due to its capital importance, the political class and concerns all citizens. Therefore, the Government will call, with prior authorization from Parliament, a referendum to be held on February 20 so that Spaniards can express, through the exercise of their vote, their approval or disapproval of the European constitutional text.

This means that Spain will be the first country to ratify the European Constitution by referendum; that is to say, our vote will have a continental dimension and will influence public opinion in another twenty-four countries. Now Europe is watching us. We will be a reference and an example, but I am convinced that Spaniards will send a clear message of Europeanism by placing ourselves at the forefront of European construction.

Q.- Mr. President, regarding what you mentioned about Spain being at the forefront of defending the European Constitution and the referendum on the 20th, just yesterday the President of the Council of State in Spain said that the Government should probably consult the Constitutional Court about a possible specific incompatibility between the Spanish Constitution and the European one. I would like to know if there could be anything to this and, if so, whether there is any kind of problem in reaching that referendum on the 20th.

President.- No, not at all. This will not interfere in any way with what the referendum represents, and what I must say is that the electoral program and the investiture program precisely contemplate the incorporation of the European Constitution into the Spanish constitutional text as one of the elements of constitutional reform. But, I insist, there will be no interference in the referendum, beyond the fact that we will have to carry out a reform of the Constitution, to which I express my support.

Q.- Mr. President, 70 percent of Spaniards state, according to surveys, that they know the European Constitution, but 56 percent of that 70 percent claim they have no idea what it is about. So, why this rush from the Spanish Government to call the referendum, to be the first country? Is it because it benefits us that Spaniards do not know what it is about so that it can actually be approved or not? What interest is there in that?

Second question, will there be an opportunity here in Rome for you to speak with Mr. Barroso or with any of his colleagues to see how this open institutional crisis in Strasbourg can be resolved? Will you specifically ask him to withdraw Rocco Buttiglione from Silvio Berlusconi?

President.- The Government's interest is to do its homework quickly; the homework that a country like Spain, which could not be present at the birth of the European project because it was a country without freedoms at the time and after being a country that arrived late to a democratic Constitution because we had a regime without freedoms, now that we enjoy a regime of freedoms and democracy, and now that we have a clear and unequivocal Europeanist will, let us demonstrate to all of Europe that we are committed to that commitment and that project with the utmost willingness and that we will fulfill our duties quickly.

I want to say that the Government will especially call on society so that, from now until February 20, we have a broad informative debate about what the European constitutional text represents, about its content and also about what it represents in historical terms. The Government's greatest interest is that the European Constitution is known and debated in every university, in every workplace, in all social spheres, in trade union organizations, business organizations... in short, in all that is a social fabric like the one our country has, increasingly strengthened.

I have just said that this is not just a matter for political leaders, for governments; this is a Constitution for citizens, it is a Constitution for society, it is a Constitution for rights, it is a Constitution for social cohesion, and it is a Constitution for peace. That is what we will debate from now until February 20, and I am convinced that there will be increasing involvement in that debate.

Regarding the situation of the European Commission, I have already expressed my deep respect for the will and attitude of the European Parliament. The European Parliament represents European citizens and, therefore, democratically expresses a position.

Secondly, I believe it is necessary for the situation to be resolved as soon as possible, I believe it is necessary for the situation to be resolved with flexibility, and I believe it is necessary for the situation to be resolved between the President of the Commission, especially Mr. Durao Barroso, and the European Parliament, and that governments have the task of contributing and supporting constructively; but this is a situation that must be resolved between the President of the Commission and the Parliament.

I am confident that, by introducing and proposing the necessary changes—there is a clearly expressed tacit will from the European Parliament—we will have a Commission in a few weeks.

Q.- Mr. President, some European political leaders have publicly stated that if any country in this long process of two years of ratification fails to ratify or rejects it, either through Parliament or by referendum, that country should consider leaving the European Union. What is your opinion on this?

President.- My opinion is that we now have ahead of us a process in which we must demonstrate European tension, European nerve, confidence in Europe, and therefore seek the ratification of all countries in the Union. Obviously, it is not the best way to speculate on what the non-ratification by any country would represent.

We must strive for citizens and parliaments to ratify this Constitution, and I believe that it is the obligation of all governments that have signed and supported this European Constitution to put all their effort, all their conviction, and all their trust in European citizens. I am sure that if governments convey to society a well-oriented debate and a historical explanation of what this Constitution represents, European citizens, who have a will for Europe and a will for the future, will give a majority backing to this text.

Q.- Mr. President, it is not clear to me whether the Government will submit the study of the European Constitution to the Constitutional Court to see if there is any kind of incompatibility with the Spanish Constitution.

Secondly, I would like to know if you consider it appropriate that just at the moment when the Government is embarking on issues of utmost interest to Spaniards, such as the Budgets, the ratification of the European Constitution, and the debate on the model of the State, prominent members of your party are raising the need to pardon a person who has been convicted of embezzlement.

I would also like to know if you do not think that all these people should say everything they know about that case so that Spaniards can consider it definitively closed.

President.- This last question goes a bit beyond the Europeanist scope, as is evident, but I will gladly answer it.

I will tell you that the Government is carrying out its investiture program. Yesterday we had a very important Conference of Presidents, which I had committed to in Parliament as the highest expression of a willingness to govern Spain with dialogue and cooperation with all Autonomous Communities. We have also had the total debate on the Budgets this week, which have initially received the majority confidence of Parliament and express many commitments from the Investiture Debate, and today we are in a very important day, certainly for Europe, but for me personally very important, because I had also committed to Spaniards to be an actor capable of promoting a European Constitution, and we have taken that action and today we have a European Constitution.

From there, I have already expressed myself on some occasions quite clearly. There are people who have requested, exercising a right, a pardon, and certainly the Government has nothing more to add than that the pardon will be processed like all pardons and will be resolved in due course with the same criteria as all pardons known to the Council of Ministers.

Q.- Mr. President, you are going to start this week some contacts with Mr. Rajoy and other political leaders to talk to them about their involvement in the debate on the referendum of the Constitution. I wanted to ask you if you trust in Mr. Rajoy's support and, above all, if you trust in the Europeanism or support for the Constitution from the voting base of the Popular Party, because it will be fundamental to increase participation in this referendum and, therefore, the success of the referendum.

On the other hand, I wanted to ask you what message you can send to the nationalist forces that are reluctant to approve the Treaty.

President.- I believe that at some point I have expressed that the Popular Party and Mr. Rajoy have expressed their support for the European Constitution, and I have no doubt about that position. Therefore, I have confidence in the position that Mr. Rajoy has expressed on behalf of the Popular Party. From there, my opinion is that there is a more favorable position every day from some nationalist forces, which I find to be a positive trait.

Beyond all that, this is a referendum in which, regardless of political forces, there must be a great citizen debate, a social debate, about what represents nothing more and nothing less than a project for a European Constitution. But it is evident that I have confidence in the word expressed by political leaders regarding their position for the referendum.

Please allow me, but I do not want to, by omission, seem to be not answering a question that was previously asked of me and that I have now realized I omitted. I must say that the Government will decide in due course on the possible consultation to the Constitutional Court, but I can already tell you that the report from the Council of State, as is logical, is a very important element in the decision when it comes to adopting it.

Q.- I return to the issue of Strasbourg. What happened this week in the European Parliament has been presented univocally as a kind of good result for democracy and for the strengthening of European institutions. However, some of the people who have said this have also acknowledged, as the President of the Eurochamber, Josep Borrell, has said, that the hearing procedure is what it is, but it leaves much to be desired. I wanted to ask you if you believe that changes should be introduced in this procedure to establish either limitations on its scope of use or procedural changes.

President.- The ratification procedure for the President of the Commission and the Commission itself is surely improvable, but I believe that today it is not the central issue that should concern us. Today the central issue is that the President of the Commission must have a Commission backed by Parliament, and for that, he must introduce modifications and earn the trust of Parliament.

From what has happened, I believe we must make an assessment of democratic normality. It is an example of the democratic functioning of the European Union and, therefore, when something produces the consequence of seeing and verifying that it functions democratically, the reading cannot be negative. Like any peak moment, democratically, it is a moment that has tension, that has risks; but democracy is, precisely, conforming a majority will, and I believe that it will be achieved.

Q.- I wanted to insist a bit on this issue of the Commission. You spoke with Durao Barroso on Wednesday, I believe; but I suppose that today, as the Twenty-Five are here for the signing of the Constitution, which is a very important historic act, I say that at some point they might take the opportunity to talk about the situation in the Commission. Do you have any mini-meeting or mini-gathering planned?

If I may, I wanted to ask you, in light of Yasser Arafat's health, what does the Spanish Government think may happen now in the Middle East with the possible or probable disappearance of Yasser Arafat, at least from the political leadership of Palestine?

President.- Regarding the second point, I can only express my wish for the recovery of Yaser Arafat today. I believe that in this situation, it is the logical thing to do, and any political assessment at this moment is unnecessary.

Secondly, it is quite likely that today we will have dialogue and some kind of informal meeting about what this moment represents in the birth of the new Commission; a birth that is certainly complicated, but that does not prevent it from having a full development and a life full of successes. Yes, it is quite probable that meetings will take place and, of course, dialogue around the situation, although, I insist, I believe that what Governments should fundamentally do is to support constructively and let the European institutions, in this case the Commission and Parliament, be the main actors, the main protagonists, in solving the issue we have at hand.

Q.- A moment ago, you expressed your confidence that with some changes we could have a European Commission within a few weeks. Are you referring to changes in portfolios among the twenty-five already designated individuals or to changes in candidates from some countries?

President.- I believe that the last question requires me to be very cautious. I think there should be changes and nothing more, because I believe it is not good at this moment to introduce, we could say, noise into the situation. It is in the hands of the President of the Commission, Mr. Durao Barroso, who has had the support of the Council, who has had my support and who has my support, and, logically, the situation calls for changes. The desirable changes are, obviously, those that open the door to the support of the European Parliament, and I believe that in that context, President Durao Barroso will have the support of all the Prime Ministers and Presidents who make up the Council.

Q.- Regarding languages, I believe your Government has received two identical translations from two statutorily different languages. I would like you to confirm this and to comment on whether you do not consider it a somewhat bizarre situation or how you will explain this somewhat bizarre situation in Europe.

President.- I will simply say that the translations of the European Constitution have already been completed, that I will personally deliver them to the General Secretariat of the Council at our next meeting, and that this is a matter, for the purposes of the controversy we had, resolved.

Q.- The solution that Mr. Barroso is seeking requires, in a way, a position from you as Heads of Government. I would like to know if the change in portfolios that the Parliament expects from the perspective of Spain is a broad or small change, because here each Government has a candidate for Commissioner and the Spanish candidate is Mr. Almunia, and I would like to know, although it may be difficult to talk about the host, if you expect a gesture in this case from Mr. Silvio Berlusconi.

President.- I believe the situation is very clear regarding where the problem has arisen when the Parliament has expressed its dissatisfaction with the content of certain statements made by a Commissioner. I believe the circumstance is perfectly clear and confined to one person. I think that is where the reflection for changes should begin; but, I insist, I will not state whether there should be one, two, three, four, or five changes and who should assume the main responsibility for facilitating those changes. I believe Durao Barroso will know how to do it.

Q.- I wanted a couple of clarifications on previous questions. The first is whether you are going to ask Mr. Rajoy to actively campaign for the yes in the referendum, specifically, the Popular Party.

Also, regarding the Vera case, I wanted to know if you, aside from what the Government decides, have been personally bothered by Mr. González's attitude, if you have spoken with him these days, and also if you have spoken with Mr. Rodríguez Ibarra, who said he was going to tell you everything he knew.

President.- I have said it many times: exercising a right does not offend anyone. All Spaniards have the right to petition for a pardon, all of them, and from that perspective, it has not caused me any discomfort or unease at all. From there, I can say that I have not had the opportunity these days to speak with Felipe González. It was about ten days ago that I last spoke with him.

As for Mr. Rajoy, I have already expressed myself. Mr. Rajoy has already said that he will support the Constitution in the referendum, and the program of the Popular Party also included holding a referendum. It is not that I am going to ask him to campaign; I will tell him that the Government is at his disposal for whatever he wants to carry out regarding the referendum and that we think it is positive that he keeps his word, as I am convinced he will.

Q.- Yesterday, the gala dinner of the twenty-five Presidents with Mr. Berlusconi was suspended. Was it due to the lack of interest from the twenty-five Presidents, as is published today?

President.- I have no reference in that direction. I believe it is more related to the difficulty of the agendas that many of us have to make these meetings, these Summits, last several days. That is, I believe, the real situation at the core.

Q.- Forgive me for insisting on the issue of the Commission. You speak of the need for some change. Do you lean towards, or would you defend, an exclusion, or a substitution, or an exchange of portfolios?

President.- The one who will give the green light is the European Parliament, not the Council. Therefore, the one who has to express what produces sufficient satisfaction to give the green light to the Commission is the European Parliament. Let us be respectful. I believe it is our responsibility as Prime Ministers to be constructive and supportive. Mr. Durao Barroso is, of course, fully entitled to request our support, because it stems from our trust, and to request whatever he deems appropriate to unblock the situation. I, for my part, will collaborate in that direction from what is already known, because I have expressed many times my profound disagreement with the statements made by the Italian Commissioner candidate at the time.

Q.- Do you think you will have the support of the Church in the referendum? That is, in the first months of your Government, you did a lot of things that the Church did not like very much; so, what will happen now?

President.- I am not the one to speak on behalf of what the Catholic Church will do in Spain. I believe, moreover, that this reflection is well understood. But I am convinced, because it is an element I have dialogued about, that what the Catholic Church represents is profoundly pro-European and has always had a favorable attitude towards what the European Constitution represents. Beyond whether it achieved its ultimate objectives regarding the definition in the preamble, it has always maintained a supportive attitude towards what Europe and the European Constitution project mean. But God forbid that I attempt to express myself in this act on behalf of what the Catholic Church will do.

Thank you very much.