Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 December 2004 · European Council

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference following the December 2004 European Council meeting in Brussels, summarizing key decisions on EU enlargement and other conclusions.
Main themes
Turkey's EU accession negotiations, EU enlargement, Romania and Bulgaria accession, Croatia negotiations, EU financial perspectives, fight against terrorism, Barcelona Process and Mediterranean policy, EU-Latin America strategic alliance, EU-MERCOSUR negotiations, European values and democracy
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,947
85th percentile
Sentences
128
74th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
15.9
83rd percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

128 sentences in 58 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. As you know, we have held a European Council that has been dense and intense in work; a European Council, without a doubt, that will go down in history as the European Council that opens the doors to Turkey's integration into the European Union.

The European Union has decided today to formally initiate the negotiations process with Turkey, a process that will begin on October 3, 2005, and which is contemplated and designed with a common goal: Turkey's integration into the European Union. Undoubtedly, with this decision and in the confidence and desire that the negotiation process, with all the requirements that a negotiation process entails, culminates in Turkey's integration into the European Union, we would be facing a moment of great relevance for what the European Union project represents.

The European Union was born for peace, economic integration, and the defense of values that give us identity: democracy, human rights, and the rule of law. The European Union has grown throughout its history, and as it has grown, it has extended the values of the market economy, social cohesion, the rule of law, and human rights. Today we take a very important step, not only because the European Union opens a path for growth in relation to a very relevant area of the world, but also because it extends its values by opening the integration process.

Likewise, as you know, the Council has given the green light to the process that has been followed regarding the negotiations with Romania and Bulgaria. For 2005, therefore, the signing of the accession of these two countries is already planned. Finally, regarding the enlargement process of the European Union, the Council has also given the green light to the start of the negotiation process with Croatia.

On behalf of the Government of Spain, on behalf of our country, I would like to welcome both the process of starting negotiations with Turkey, as well as the imminent signing of the incorporation of Romania and Bulgaria, and the negotiation process with Croatia.

Alongside this, the European Council in its conclusions has addressed various aspects of great interest to the Union and of great interest to our country. First, a Conclusion regarding the Financial Perspectives, a Conclusion that allows for the initiation of the negotiation and dialogue process on the Financial Perspectives that must begin from 2007. I want to emphasize that in these Conclusions a modification has been introduced, agreed upon by various countries, including Spain, which makes it clear that the new financial framework must have the necessary means to respond effectively and equitably to future challenges, including, of course, those arising from disparities in the level of development in the enlarged Union; disparities that must therefore be addressed equitably, as we have defended and our country has defended.

Today, obviously, was not the time to negotiate figures, but to organize the debates. The report of the Presidency and the Conclusions of the Council have achieved this objective and correspond to our proposals. From the next Presidency, the process of concrete negotiation with specific figures and deadlines will begin.

In addition, the Council has included Conclusions regarding the fight against terrorism, representing a thorough analysis and a commitment from the European Union to establish the fight against terrorism and the cooperation of all the countries that comprise it, as well as the Union's own policy, as one of its major objectives. Therefore, the Conclusions establish that in the first half of 2005 the Union will approve a global action plan against terrorism, the principles of which are included in the Conclusions and, of course, essentially respond to the needs that the Government of Spain and the various political forces in our country have been raising.

Moreover, I want to highlight that the Conclusions of the European Council include two aspects that are of great importance to our country and to our foreign policy; specifically, a reference to the Barcelona Process, a Barcelona Process that underpins the neighborhood policy in the Mediterranean and has an important meeting in 2005, a meeting to relaunch everything that the Barcelona Process meant and to give it new momentum and to the dialogue and Euro-Mediterranean cooperation.

Finally, the Conclusions of the European Council also reflect the commitment of the European Union to consolidate the bi-regional strategic alliance with Latin America and the Caribbean. Likewise, they establish that the will of the European Union is to continue advancing towards concluding the negotiations between the European Union and MERCOSUR.

Thus, the most relevant points of the Council's conclusions. In short, the European Union has decided today to expand; the European Union has decided to extend the values, the principles, of a model of coexistence; the European Union has decided today, once again, to lead all cooperation in the fight against terrorism; the Council has decided today to establish reasonable bases for the negotiation of the Financial Perspectives with the principle of equity essential for Spain, and, likewise, the European Union has reaffirmed today its will, in the international order, for what that represents that multilateral vision, that projection of dialogue with the Mediterranean, which I just referred to, and that dimension of dialogue with Latin America and the Caribbean.

Additionally, as you know, the European Council has held a meeting with the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Annan. In that meeting, the vast majority of the Council members have given their express support and great backing to the work he is doing at the head of the United Nations, support that has been summarized by the President of the Council himself, and the commitment to intense work, permanent respect, and support for the great objectives of the United Nations for maintaining security in the world and for achieving the Millennium Goals.

Q.- I would like to ask you if you had time to defend your vision on the fight against international terrorism in the meeting, as it was a long meeting very focused on Turkey.

As a second point, in any case, despite the fact that Turkey has softened the conditions a bit, what is clear is that it raises in a certain way the possibility of having a, let’s say, second-class association with Turkey. I wonder if you are not afraid that the more reluctant countries to Turkey's entry could take advantage of this clause to later, when there is a referendum on Turkey's entry, say to their public opinions "better that we opt for that." That is, what is initiated today could one day be truncated.

President.- As I said, what begins today with Turkey is a process of historic scope that must fulfill a series of stages, but I can assure you that the will expressed today by the Council and already yesterday at dinner, the will expressed by Turkey is that the objective is integration. Undoubtedly, in the negotiation process there will be important and difficult tasks ahead to resolve; but the objective is integration and I believe there is no element that allows us to speak of another issue at this time, nor of any alternative or any model. The objective is integration and, of course, Spain will contribute to the task that from this moment essentially corresponds to the Commission so that this objective can be fulfilled.

In the international fight against terrorism, we have established, as I indicated a moment ago, an action program that must be presented in the first half of 2005. You can already imagine that there has not been a debate around these Conclusions on terrorism that could or would allow for celebration due to the intense development that the Council has had in relation, especially, to Turkey.

Q.- I understand that in these times when the issue of ratification of the Constitution is being raised, this matter is not addressed directly, but do you consider it normal that, in the perspective of Turkey's accession, the European Union maintains the institutional structure that has been agreed upon for the Constitution or do you think it necessary, within an indeterminate time frame, to face the reality of renewing that framework again?

President.- It has been a very short time since we renewed the institutional framework with the European Constitution and it is a framework designed for the medium-term future. It is a framework that, in my opinion, will allow for a broader European Union, even than the one we have today and, therefore, I believe it is not necessary to open a reflection today on what could be a future institutional framework, in this case, that we would be talking about a very long term.

Q.- I wanted to ask you regarding the paragraph related to the future of financial policy. You said that there is great satisfaction on the part of Spain, equity is included, and solidarity is included; but there is a fundamental principle for Spain, which is the gradual exit of funds, which is not mentioned here. You had breakfast this morning with Schröder and President Chirac. Does this mean that this is a topic that still needs to mature or does it mean that there are few prospects for achieving that?

A second question I wanted to ask you is regarding the appointment of Mr. Peces Barba as High Commissioner for Victims. You know that the leader of the PP, Mariano Rajoy, has rejected this appointment, because he said it should have been made with a meeting of the Anti-Terrorism Pact, which has not been convened, and they are asking for it to be restarted. What is your response?

President.- Regarding the first question, I imagine you are referring to the principle of equity which is, as I said, essential when addressing the Financial Perspectives. Undoubtedly, the principle of gradualism will be a principle that Spain defends and will defend. And I can assure you that we already have a segment of the path made in dialogue with various countries of the European Union, countries that are undoubtedly of great importance when it comes to defining the Financial Perspectives from 2007. The intense, concrete negotiation of numbers will develop in the next semester and I believe we need to have sufficient calm to address that issue.

Regarding the other issue you raised, I will say two things about it. First, administrative decisions, appointments, positions, in the area of the national Government are the competence of the national Government and in no case does the Anti-Terrorism Pact establish that this is part of what represents the letter and spirit of the agreement. I can say clearly that I know it very well, because I was the person who proposed it at the time.

I want to tell the Popular Party, which has been supporting that appointment for twenty-four hours and which has been very well received by the Association of Victims, that this is a person, I believe, of great importance, of great trajectory, and, regarding the issue we are discussing, to reflect and support the task that the High Commissioner for Victims of Terrorism will carry out.

Q.- We understand that you had a meeting with your Polish counterpart. I would like to know the content of your conversation with him, if you agreed with him on the paragraph of the Financial Perspectives in the Conclusions and if he reproached you for your --allow me to qualify it this way-- snub from last week.

President.- I must tell you that we did indeed have a meeting with the Polish delegation, with the Prime Minister, which was a cordial meeting and in which we addressed some issues of this Council, logically, such as the topic of the Financial Perspectives. We talked about it, as well as what will be the next visit and bilateral meeting that I will have in Poland in early February.

I can tell you that he made absolutely no comment regarding that. I have read, it is true, some comments or some evaluations in recent days and, frankly, I cannot share them under any circumstances, nor can I accept what represents some expression that I have also heard and read.

Relations with Poland are very good, today, yesterday, the day before yesterday, and since we have been at the head of the national Government. Just look at what the circumstances are that this very good relationship has had a certain contrast in recent days, because Poland supported yesterday the candidacy of Zaragoza in Paris. It would be very difficult to think that a country with which one is in a bad relationship supports the candidacy of another country. Anyone who knows a little about the functioning of diplomatic relations will understand this perfectly.

Q.- President, I would like to ask you about Gibraltar, which is a matter that arose yesterday in the Spanish panorama and is of utmost importance. The PP has suggested that the new strategy towards Gibraltar, which was announced yesterday by Spain and the United Kingdom jointly, could be illegal because it does not have the support or agreement of the Spanish Parliament. I would like to know what you think about this and also what you think of the criticisms that claim that Spain has thrown overboard a historical claim of 300 years in five minutes.

President.- Regarding Gibraltar, I want to make a few things clear. The Government of Spain, as is evident, maintains its claim to sovereignty, which is a non-negotiable issue, an essential principle; secondly, the Government of Spain has opened a dialogue process with Great Britain and with the local authorities of Gibraltar, a dialogue process that, as is well known, was at a standstill after the process led by the Popular Party Government. By the way, during that process, the Socialist Party, in opposition until March 2004, was continuously supportive, and when that process reached a dead end, the Socialist Party remained silent out of a principle of basic responsibility, essential in such a sensitive issue of foreign policy for Spain.

Now the Government is initiating a dialogue process, it is starting, and before even seeing a result or an assessment to address a problem that, as we know, has been pending for three hundred years, we have heard all the disqualifications from the Popular Party and the opposition. But time makes things clear and puts everyone in their place.

The Popular Party said that our policy towards Cuba was a policy in which we were alone, and now the European Union has ratified the new policy towards Cuba. The Popular Party has been saying that we have lost friends and influence in foreign policy, and we have just had proof with facts — with facts, not opinions — that is a great success in obtaining the majority support of fifty-seven countries for the candidacy of the International Exhibition in the city of Zaragoza. I simply want to emphasize that: time puts things in their place and everyone in their place.

Regarding Gibraltar, the Popular Party must do what the opposition in Spain has always done: exercise what affects Gibraltar with responsibility and support a state policy.

Q.- Mr. President, today Turkey has open doors to Europe, and we will see if it can enter, if we can get it to enter; but what has so far hindered that integration, or at least the approach we open in negotiations with Turkey — we have seen with Croatia how quickly it was told yes — and what will continue to be a hindrance for Turkey, we fear, will be the religious character, Islam. Does Islam still separate Europe so much from other countries? You spoke of dialogue of civilizations, of alliance. Do you believe that the alliance of civilizations that the Spanish Government proposes, that you propose, could and should go through Europe?

President.- Europe is a model of coexistence and freedom; it is a secular model; it is a model of pluralism in politics, religion, culture, and nationality, and today much more with the dimension that the European Union has acquired. It is a hallmark of Europe.

Europe is more than a geographical framework; Europe is a model of coexistence and a model of coexistence that has developed not only the traditional principles of democracy, the rule of law, economic freedom, and social cohesion, but something that today is even more important for the international order: it has developed the principles of dialogue, cooperation, the search for peace, and understanding between cultures, peoples, and civilizations. We have just seen this in this Council.

Europe not only encompasses a vast geographical area of what we know as the European Continent, but it also projects itself in its relationship towards the Mediterranean, in its cooperation towards Latin America, and in its transatlantic dimension. Certainly, as a model for addressing international relations and the progress of peoples, I believe it is an enormously satisfactory model.

That is respect for all religions, respect for religious freedom and worship, for all, and, at the same time, as a logical consequence of that respect, that no religion can impose itself, that no religion can have a character that represents the entirety of a citizenship. Religious freedom, democratic freedom, political freedom, and pluralism are essential values.

Q.- Returning to the issue of Gibraltar, I would like you to clarify how Gibraltar's veto power will function in this new situation, if that veto power will refer, as some versions say, only to administrative matters or also to sovereignty issues.

Secondly, regarding IZAR, I would like to know how the new situation has been after some obstacles were raised here in Brussels regarding the agreement signed in Spain.

President.- Regarding the first question, I have already explained that what affects sovereignty is a non-negotiable principle for the Government of Spain and that this is a dialogue that takes place with Great Britain.

In the dialogue process and what affects Gibraltar, there are various issues, not only sovereignty, being this the most important, the fundamental one, but there are issues that affect people and the situation in the area.

Up to this point, we had lived a dialogue around Gibraltar in which there was dialogue between two Governments: Great Britain and Spain. We believe it is important to include people in that dialogue and, in this case, to include the people who live in Gibraltar, and for that reason, they are incorporated into that dialogue.

It is a new way of seeing things, a way that complements what has been the normal dialogue process, and I simply ask, as is logical, that the citizens and the political forces, especially the Popular Party, have a little calm, because the dialogue has not yet started.

Regarding the question about IZAR, the first thing I have to say is that I am pleased with the agreement reached yesterday between the unions of the public shipyards, of IZAR, and the Government. It is an agreement that will fully respect the principles and legal requirements of the European Union. This morning the Economic Vice President has already spoken with the relevant Commissioner on the matter, and I have full confidence that the agreement will have all its effectiveness.

But it is also good to remember that time puts things in their place, because we have heard during these weeks the Popular Party saying that commitments were not being fulfilled. I said there would be an agreement with the unions in IZAR, I said that no workplaces would be closed, and I said that no worker would be left to fend for themselves. That is what the agreement signed yesterday contemplates.

Q.- President, a couple of clarifications on two already discussed issues. Regarding the issue of the Financial Perspectives, the topic of gradualness is not included in this principle, which Spain raised. I do not know if there has been any problem on the part of any country for it to be included here. And specifically also, when you referred to the relationships that are going well with some important countries, I suppose you are referring to France and Germany. Do you mean that France and Germany already accept that there will be that gradualness in the Financial Perspectives?

Regarding the issue of Gibraltar, until now, let’s say, in the other negotiations, it was moving, according to the Brussels Process, in parallel in cooperation and sovereignty. Here it seems that there is more emphasis on cooperation, but will it take long for Spain to raise the sovereignty issues? That is, will it be a year or two years, or is it a matter of months?

President.- The agreement has just been born, the new path has just been born, and I do not emphasize the 300 years of the past, but the eight years of the Popular Party Government, where, in the end, I insist — and I do not doubt their commendable desire to reach a solution on the Gibraltar issue — the result was a dead end, nothing new, everything continued the same.

This Government, eight months in, begins a dialogue phase, a new path, a new strategy. I do not think it is too much to ask for patience, prudence, and a sense of state from the Popular Party regarding Gibraltar.

Financial Perspectives. Spain wanted the word, the concept, of "equity" to appear essentially in this Conclusion today. That is what appears, and indeed, we are talking with many Governments of the European Union about what will be an immediate, concrete negotiation regarding the Financial Perspectives.

As you know, I held a meeting this morning with President Chirac and Chancellor Schröder, and in addition to discussing the European Council, we talked about the Financial Perspectives and also about some other issues of international politics, about which I can inform you at this moment, because we have agreed to hold a Summit next year in Paris between the Governments of France, Germany, Russia, and Spain. Therefore, we have addressed a series of issues, and certainly, also the Financial Perspectives, which we have already been discussing and which will logically require a broad process of dialogue and negotiation.

Q.- Returning to the issue of IZAR, in the conversation that the Vice President had with Commissioner Kroes, she identified three problems: one, that there is no date for the closure of Fene and San Fernando; another, that the liquidation of Sestao is not closed, and she says that the commitments agreed upon are not being fulfilled. Has the Government agreed with Brussels on these two measures?

President.- I believe that is information prior to the conversation that the Economic Vice President had. I reiterate that I have full confidence that the agreement reached yesterday between IZAR and the unions is an agreement that complies with the prescriptions and regulations of the European Union, and that this agreement will have effectiveness and will be effective, beyond the nuances, which will not have any other scope than the technical scope, in the process of confirmation with the European Union.

Q.- A clarification. What is the purpose of the Summit with Russia? Why has the decision been made to convene this Summit?

President.- It is a Summit that arises from my last visit to Russia. At the initiative of President Chirac, it has been deemed appropriate, to foster the good understanding between France, Germany, and Spain, to have a direct dialogue with President Putin, therefore with Russia, about the international situation, about Russia's relationship with the European Union, and about other issues that will undoubtedly arise on the agenda of that meeting.

Q.- Will it be only next year, or will it be institutionalized in some way?

President.- No. For now, next year.

Thank you very much.