Speech by the President of the Government before the Parliamentary Investigation Commission on the March 11, 2004 Attacks

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

12 December 2004 · Parliamentary Investigation Commission on the March 11, 2004 Attacks

Context
Zapatero testified before Spain's Parliamentary Investigation Commission on December 12, 2004, addressing the March 11, 2004 Madrid train bombings that killed 192 people.
Main themes
March 11 2004 Madrid bombings, victims and remembrance, Spanish resilience and courage, rejection of terrorism, political accountability, counterterrorism policy, national unity, democratic values, public response and solidarity, attribution of meaning to terrorist acts
Duration
~45 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,371
92nd percentile
Sentences
204
89th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 42%40%
  • Institutional 31%29%
  • Social 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Economic 1%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

204 sentences in 81 paragraphs

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen of the Parliament,

Allow me to begin my speech with a remembrance of Eva Belén Abad Quijada, 30 years old, of Spanish nationality and residing in Coslada; also for Csaba Zsigovski, 26 years old, born in Romania and residing in Madrid. They are the first and the last on the alphabetical list of the 192 people who lost their lives in the monstrous attack that our country suffered nine months and two days ago. My thoughts extend to all of them.

There are 141 Spaniards from all corners of our country and 51 foreigners up to that point, whose only connection to their murderers was their will, on that fateful day, to live as they had until then: with the hope of realizing the project of life, of hope, of happiness, in which each of them was engaged.

It has been said that people remain alive as long as someone remembers them. I ask everyone to keep their memory alive.

None of those people voluntarily gave their lives. They died without knowing why. They, the victims, did not give meaning to their death, and we must not attribute meaning to that which has none. It was their life that had meaning for them and for those who loved them, not their death. Their deaths are an impossible-to-forget mutilation, a wound that will accompany us all as long as the memory of this time reaches our children. Those who took their lives and health offered a useless sacrifice and, moreover, sacrificed something that was not theirs. Everything was useless, absurd, and pointless. That is why it hurts so much.

The Spaniards have known this for a long time. We have been suffering the same pain for more than thirty years; from other hands, but the same pain. Thirty years confirming after each death, after each attack, that it makes no sense, that it serves no purpose other than to kill, to destroy. Thirty years of terrorism have taught us all. To us, who suffer it, they have taught us to resist, to not yield, to fight; and to those who provoke it, they have also taught something: that it is useless. They already know that.

There are those who have attributed one meaning or another to the actions of the terrorists. It is evident that the terrorists give a meaning, however insane it may be, to their actions. But the terrorists struck in the most sterile country on earth for their ambitions, against the citizens of the world most vaccinated against their methods. Of course, their bombs had an effect, on flesh and steel, not on our freedom, not on our spirit.

Knowing our people, it is inconceivable that anyone could imagine that Spanish citizens would yield to the supposed intentions of the terrorists. It is possible that in other latitudes, poorly informed public opinions may believe such a thing; but it is impossible that, in good faith, a Spaniard could hold those arguments.

It is brutal, it is unacceptable, to add to the humiliation of having been mocked in our security, to the pain of the deaths, of not having been able to prevent the murder of our fellow citizens, our family and friends, to add to all that the infamy of labeling a brave people as cowards.

How is it possible that some continue to assert that our country, ours, Spain, yielded, did what the terrorists wanted? When have we, the Spaniards, submitted to terrorist violence? Can anyone tell me? I cannot recall a single case in my memory. Who has gone with the tale of our cowardice and our docility to the rulers and public opinions of other countries?

Ladies and gentlemen,

The reaction of our compatriots from the very moment of the March 11 attack has formed a gallery of unforgettable heroic scenes. There is the reaction of the passengers who emerged unscathed and hurried to assist their unknown neighbors instead of fleeing in terror; there is the reaction of police, paramedics, firefighters; there is the astonishing coordinated response of the municipal, regional, and central administrations; there is, above all, the generous reaction of citizens who, from Madrid and from all corners of Spain, contributed their blood and breath to the victims and their families; there is the compassionate and close reaction of the Royal House.

The Spaniards did not cower. On the contrary, they rushed to the aid of the victims. But they also did not bend: thirty hours after the massacre, millions and millions took to the streets in the broadest and most forceful demonstration of courage that any country has ever witnessed. They came out to say "no to terrorism." Even then, the Spaniards did not cower.

The Spaniards do not yield to panic; they take to the streets to assist the victims, they take to the streets to confront terror, and they take to the streets to renew their support for democracy. I was on the street on March 12 like eleven million other Spaniards, like many of Your Lordships, and I saw no fear. No one was afraid. There was pain, indignation; but no fear.

Throughout these months, the most varied versions of what happened have been sustained. Among them, there is one that is unacceptable: that which describes a Spanish people cowed in the face of terrorism. That description is simply indecent.

The Spaniards have been enduring the claw of terror for a long time. During this time, it has claimed the lives of children, soldiers, housewives, teachers, politicians, law enforcement officers. Terror has struck our homeland from North to South and from East to West and has spared no age or profession. And we have stood firm against it. Moreover, after such a brutal attack, not a single case of xenophobia was recorded, not one.

Can a more serene and secure citizenry be found in the world? Stronger? More reflective and restrained? That is the Spain whose Government I am honored to preside over.

It is difficult to contain the pride of belonging to this people. We have faced so many difficulties in our lived history, in the history that the living generations retain in their memory: the Civil War, the Dictatorship, poverty, exile and emigration, terrorism. Nothing has been easy and yet, despite all the hardships, we have built together a country from which its citizens do not leave, but to which citizens from other countries come to live, to prosper, to seek freedom and well-being. The same ones, just like those who died on March 11 in those trains.

No, it is not easy to contain the pride of belonging to a country that has given in this ordeal an example of civility, citizenship, and solidarity. That is why I want to assert here, as President of the Government, as a representative of all citizens, that the example we Spaniards set endures in the memory of all; that no one can now, after months, come to distort History, to offend us with slanders and insinuations.

Now, after honoring the memory of the dead and the dignity of the living, I am ready to do what I came here to do, that is, to fully collaborate in the purpose that inspires this Commission, a purpose that is twofold: first, that the truth, the whole truth, about March 11 is known; and second, as a consequence of the first, to contribute with that truth and the lessons learned from it to prevent, as far as humanly possible, that events like this happen again. That is why I publicly expressed my support for facilitating my appearance before this Commission, and that is why I requested the Socialist Parliamentary Group to support it.

We seek, ladies and gentlemen, the truth of the facts. That is what matters here, not the truth of opinions, but the truth of the facts. There are as many opinions as there are factions or people; but there is one truth, and that is the important one, the only one capable of providing comfort to the victims and light to the future.

I want to begin by stating that all my political activity, before and after the last general elections, has been inspired by a fixed idea: the fight against terrorism must be the absolute priority of all government action in Spain. This is demanded by the profound respect for the victims of terrorism, this is demanded by the defense of democracy, this is demanded by the survival of our system of coexistence, this is demanded by the commitment to the freedoms and rights of citizens, and this is demanded by the strength of the Rule of Law.

Faithful to that idea, I proposed, from my position as leader of the opposition, a Pact for Freedom and against Terrorism in which we could recognize ourselves and agree as democrats. It was a Pact that we managed to have the then Government accept, sign, and implement, and it has functioned well over the last four years. In the twelve meetings that have been held so far, we have managed to agree between the two major national parties to maintain a common strategy against terrorism, in favor of the victims and in guarantee of collective freedoms.

Under its auspices, we have agreed on police strategies, legal reforms, measures to support the victims, initiatives to isolate the violent, and efforts to strengthen international cooperation. Also under its auspices, we have largely managed to remove terrorism from the realm of partisan debate as an expression of our common commitment to prevent anyone from attempting to extract political gains, directly or indirectly, from the activities of terrorist groups.

I insist: I believe it has worked well; I believe that those of us who have signed it can feel legitimately and democratically satisfied; I believe, in short, that the Pact for Freedom and against Terrorism has been one of the best examples of democratic commitment to the freedom of Spaniards. That is why, from the investiture speech, I guaranteed my loyalty and commitment to the letter and spirit of that Pact. I have been advocating and fulfilling it since then with the same conviction as when I proposed it from the opposition.

This led me to preside over the Monitoring Commission of the Pact, which I convened immediately after the formation of my Government; the first time, by the way, that a President of the Government has taken such an initiative. This has also led me to promote the appearance of the Government before the Commission of Official Secrets of Congress in order to integrate the political forces that, at the time, decided not to join the Pact but share with the Socialist Party and the Popular Party our democratic commitment against terrorism into the reception of information and the design of new strategies.

That has been the guide of my behavior in relation to the fight against terrorism before and after March 11. Now I have new responsibilities; fundamentally, to guarantee the security of citizens and ensure their peaceful enjoyment of their freedoms and rights.

It is true that no one can guarantee the end of the terrorist threat; but I have made it my main obligation to put into play all the means at my disposal to prevent the possibility of attacks like those our people have suffered from happening again.

Preventing, however, requires knowing and therefore requires knowing the truth of everything that has affected us throughout our recent history, because only the truth gives us the possibility to choose the instruments we equip ourselves with for our collective survival.

That is the objective of the investigation that has been carried out since the very moment of the attacks and, of course, from the moment my Government took office. It is undoubtedly the objective of this Investigation Commission, which seeks, as could not be otherwise in the Congress of Deputies, the truth. And it is, of course, the objective of the investigation that the Administration of Justice and the State Security Forces and Corps are diligently, tenaciously, dedicatedly, professionally, and with prudent silence, carrying out.

It is, without a doubt, their obligation. The one they assume every day out of their profound and convinced sense of State. They do not need anyone to stir their zeal. They know that they are the main instrument and guarantee for the security and freedom of citizens, and I know that all their members are proud to carry out that essential mission for all on a daily basis.

But, although it is an obligation they fulfill out of vocation and with sacrifice, I want to make clear in this initial intervention the support they have from the Government. All of us, and also the Government, have placed in their hands the search for the explanation of what happened, the attribution of administrative and criminal responsibilities, the arrest of the guilty, and their corresponding condemnation, and the Government is satisfied with the work they are doing, which I will summarize briefly.

In these nine months, the National Court is maintaining two ongoing investigations in which thousands and thousands of pages are already accumulating, along which I am sure we will soon learn facts and responsibilities that will allow us to know exactly what happened. Justice, then, is investigating and, by the way, in the resolutions we know so far, it determines that the preparation, authorship, and responsibility for the March 11 attacks correspond exclusively to radical Islamist international terrorism.

In recent months, the State Security Forces and Corps have made more than 70 arrests linked to the March 11 attacks and 42 more related to new threats from international terrorism; they have controlled, analyzed, and studied more than 25,000 pieces of evidence and effects; they have conducted more than 80 on-site inspections; they have analyzed more than 1,300 fingerprints; they have obtained more than 80 genetic profiles of those under investigation; and more than 100 reports have been sent to the Judicial Authority. The State Security Forces and Corps are doing a great job. The State Security Forces and Corps are investigating, and, by the way, from the investigations they have conducted to date, it is deduced that the preparation, authorship, and responsibility for the March 11 attacks correspond exclusively to radical Islamist international terrorism.

During this time, the prison authorities have closely monitored inmates linked to terrorist organizations. Since 1998, they have intercepted more than 220,000 letters, monitored more than 40,000 recordings of conversations, and transcribed more than 8,000 documents. In recent months, they have issued more than thirty reports on the relationships maintained by the more than one hundred Islamist inmates with others from different terrorist organizations. The prison authorities, therefore, are investigating and, by the way, from their investigations to date, they deduce that there is no relevant relationship regarding the preparation, authorship, and responsibility for the March 11 attacks between inmates linked to radical Islamist international terrorism and the terrorist organization ETA.

In recent months, the National Intelligence Center and the Information Services of the Police and the Civil Guard have multiplied their contacts and collaboration with equivalent services from other countries, particularly those that, for obvious reasons, may be in a position to provide useful information for clarifying the facts and for the arrest of the guilty. These contacts are yielding results that you all know about, and in recent days we have had sufficient evidence of the support that our partners, friends, and allies are providing us. The National Intelligence Center, the General Information Commissioner, and the Civil Guard Information Service are, therefore, investigating. And, by the way, the contacts maintained to date certify that the preparation, authorship, and responsibility for the March 11 attacks correspond exclusively to radical Islamist international terrorism.

I want to especially thank, in this regard, because I believe it is of particular importance for citizens to know this fact, the collaboration and help, enormously useful and constant, that the security services of Morocco are providing us. If from September 11, 2001, to March 11, 2004, they had provided 165 reports related to the terrorist threat in Spain, since March 11, 2004, they have satisfied 118 requests for information, provided 231 reports on individuals involved in the Madrid attacks and in the financing of the Madrid attacks, and identified 280 Moroccan phones and 363 Spanish phones identified as contacted by individuals related to the March attacks.

In short, those responsible for conducting this investigation are doing so effectively. They are doing it during the final period of the previous Government and since my Government took office. For their work throughout that period, I am proud and satisfied. They are doing well, aside from a few exceptions. They are doing well to the satisfaction of the Government and, I am convinced, to the satisfaction of Your Lordships. They are also doing so without neglecting or disregarding effective prevention against other terrorist movements. The successive blows that ETA has suffered in recent months confirm, with the strength of facts, what I am telling you.

I wish to and can offer Your Lordships a first certain and secure conclusion from all the investigations carried out by all the institutions of the Spanish State and by all the investigative services of all the States that cooperate with Spain in the fight against terrorism: the sole and exclusive responsibility for the March 11 attack lies with Islamist terrorism:

The March 11 attack was conceived, planned, and carried out by the same murderous terrorism that conceived, planned, and carried out the attacks of September 11, 2001, in the United States, which cost more than three thousand lives;

the same murderous terrorism of the attack on October 12, 2002, in Bali (Indonesia), which cost 180 lives;

the same as the attack on May 16, 2003, against the House of Spain in Casablanca (Morocco), which claimed 28 lives;

the same that orchestrated the attack on November 15, 2003, in Istanbul (Turkey), which cost 32 lives.

The attack that struck all Spaniards on March 11, 2004, and claimed the lives of 192 human beings was the work of Islamist terrorism. The police and judges will determine the names and surnames of all those who participated in that massacre, but we already know that all of them belonged to the networks of Islamist terrorism.

This is the truth of the facts, not the expression of an opinion.

While the responsibility for what happened was being diligently investigated, the Government has been adopting a set of decisions and initiatives aimed at correcting the deficiencies that the data from the investigation demonstrate in the means and procedures available to the State Security Forces and Corps and the rest of the State services.

These are actions to correct any lack of protection against the threat of Islamist terrorism. They are initiatives all aimed at improving the defense capacity of our democratic system. They are intended to prevent or, at least, hinder the action on our soil of an international terrorism that had already shown its capacity to generate horror, pain, and destruction in many parts of the world; a terrorism for which, however, no specific alert mechanisms had been foreseen in Spain.

We have begun by increasing the personal and material resources of the State Security Forces and Corps for the fight against international terrorism. In this same year that is ending, we have increased the number of members of the National Police Corps by 150 and another 150 from the Civil Guard assigned to anti-terrorist services, and we have incorporated 40 new interpreters into their service. A similar effort, which has led to an increase of nearly 150 people assigned to this activity, has taken place at the National Intelligence Center. Similar advances are planned for the 2005 fiscal year, to which will be added the necessary measures so that, throughout that year, more than 1,600 Civil Guard agents are trained in prevention and response to nuclear, radiological, biological, and chemical threats.

On the other hand, I want to highlight that the Council of Ministers held on May 28, 2004, agreed to create the National Anti-Terrorist Coordination Center. It is the first serious step taken to address the lack of coordination among the State Security Forces and Corps, one of the elements that at times may have undermined the effectiveness of their actions. The National Center will integrate, therefore, members of the National Police Corps, the Civil Guard, and the National Intelligence Center. What are its missions? To alert about terrorist threats, to jointly analyze and assess the information acquired, and to coordinate operational information.

Its coordination activity will see its effectiveness increased with the decision made on May 7 by the Executive Committee of the Unified Anti-Terrorist Command to proceed with the creation and management of a common police database accessible to the State Security Forces and Corps. That common database, incredible as it may seem, Your Lordships, did not exist.

The same purpose is pursued by the decision to activate the Commission for Monitoring Terrorism Financing Activities, created by the Law of May 21, 2003. Convened only twice prior to March 11, it has already held two meetings after that date. It is just the first symptom of the new impetus we will give to the control of money laundering because, Your Lordships, the fight against terrorism requires controlling and destroying the means and resources it uses to carry out its actions.

If anything has been revealed by the investigation conducted to date, it has been the need to strengthen the current legislation on explosives, both regarding the control of their use and consumption, and regarding the criminal sanctioning of their trafficking and consumption when they endanger the life and physical integrity of individuals.

If regarding the first point, by Order of July 21, regulations have been established for the content and maintenance of a register book that ensures the control of the sales, use, and storage of explosives, the drafting of the Project for the revision of the Penal Code will be carried out in one of the first sessions of the Council of Ministers, after the Government has been informed by the Minister of Justice about the status of that Bill to amend the Penal Code in this area.

It will not be the only relevant legislative reform. I want to announce before you the Government's intention to address during this legislature the reform of the Organic Law of State Security Forces and Corps to adapt it to current times, to increase its operability to ensure its coordination, and to improve the legal and economic regime of its members.

The third axis of our program to combat international terrorism is international collaboration. It is a path whose spectacular results the Spanish people know and appreciate from friendly countries. It has yielded excellent results over the years in the fight against ETA. We see them practically every week, and I assure you and announce that we will continue to see them.

Now, in addition to collaboration in the fight against ETA, we have added the fight against international terrorism; fundamentally, that of radical Islamist origin. The Spanish people must know that in this fight we are not alone. We are not condemned to suffer the solitude we endured for many years in the fight against ETA.

Against international terrorism, we are all potential victims, and therefore, we must all contribute the means and cooperation necessary to defend ourselves against them. France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Sweden, the United States, Morocco, and, in recent hours, Italy are daily honoring this collective commitment. To all of them, therefore, our gratitude, a gratitude that also takes the form of the information that, reciprocally and constantly, we provide them for their specific and collective security.

In this line, the multiple contacts that the Minister of the Interior has been maintaining since we took over the Government are inscribed.

This attitude also responds to the agenda that I systematically incorporate into the international meetings of a multilateral or bilateral nature that I have been holding. These are contacts in which I reiterate the universal dimension of the threat; the need to harmonize legislation, actions, and police procedures and means; the exclusive recourse to legality and the instruments of the rule of law, and the inescapable, determined, profound commitment to the victims.

To all of them, I convey the painful Spanish experience, I require collaboration from all to discover and punish those responsible for March 11, and I offer all our information, our knowledge, our resources.

Here, then, is a second conclusion that I offer to Your Lordships and to all Spaniards: our country is today more and better protected against Islamist terrorism; greater awareness of the threat, which was clearly underestimated; greater human resources; greater technical means; meticulous control of explosives; more police coordination and more and better international cooperation. It is, again, a truth based on data, figures, and facts.

Your Lordships know that the pillars of the fight against terrorism are improving the means of the State Security Forces, international collaboration, and the unity of all democrats. Allow me now to refer to this last point.

The final and essential instrument in the fight against terrorism is the unity of free citizens, of political parties and forces, of social organizations, and of all institutions.

We know from experience that the beginning of the end of ETA, although it is not yet closed, occurred on the day when citizens took to the streets by the millions to demonstrate against terror and the parties understood that we could not betray that outcry. The day we became aware of our strength and lost the collective fear, that day we began to win our battle.

The Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism is, today, the best expression of that unity. I know that there are those who have not signed it, but they fully share its aversion to terror as an instrument of political domination. To them, I extend my recognition for their courage and democratic commitment.

This movement of unity, of collective commitment, must find a channel for its expression when establishing a great agreement among us to defend ourselves against the new international terrorism that has so cruelly wounded us.

I want to announce before this Commission that the Government is willing to support, promote, and subscribe to a great Agreement, a great Pact against Terrorism that is advocated by the political forces with parliamentary representation. They have, we all have, sufficient experience to do so: all the pacts against terrorism have emerged from the political forces and parties.

It is now a matter of reaching a Pact in which we all integrate to, with that strength, offer it as a model, as a Spanish contribution, to the International Community, because international terrorism constitutes a threat that particularly looms over open, tolerant, and increasingly multicultural societies; but it threatens global security and peaceful understanding between civilizations.

It is necessary to clearly delineate Islam from the terrorism of Al Qaeda, individuals and groups related to that terrorist structure or inspired by its leaders. Likewise, it is necessary not to confuse the causes of that international terrorism with the pretexts claimed by those who practice it. Nothing justifies terrorism, and its existence is solely the responsibility of the terrorists themselves and those who support them.

The prevention and fight against international terrorism require, as I have already said, the removal of the anti-terrorist policy from partisan debate and its consideration as a State policy. It is the demand of the citizens, it is the obligation of the parliamentary forces. A coherent, firm, and consistent government policy; an effective police response; well-equipped and nationally and internationally coordinated intelligence services; an adequate legal framework; the involvement of civil society; the adoption of social integration programs for Muslim immigrants and their families; the collaboration of the media and the continuous demand by the powers of the State for democratic principles and values.

But, in the face of such a widely transnationalized phenomenon, the response cannot be effective if it is not international. It is a project on which I intend to involve the entire European Union, because all of it, and not just us, must feel affected. I will do so, by the way, immediately: at the European Council next Friday.

The objective of this State Agreement should be none other, Ladies and Gentlemen, than to defend peace and democracy by supporting a policy against international terrorism; an objective in which I know we all agree and to which we must subordinate the specific disagreements we may find in its formulation. It is an objective that much better secures our future in peace and is an objective worth pursuing.

Thus, I offer you a third conclusion: I propose to all democratic political and social forces a State Pact against international terrorism that serves as a catalyst and model for the International Community. We have suffered like few others the claw of terror and we are well positioned to incite international resistance against it.

I have so far referred to the investigation of the March 11 attack perpetrated by international terrorism of a radical Islamist type; to the improvement of protection against that type of terrorism and to the need to broaden the citizen support base for the anti-terrorist struggle both within and outside our borders. These are the same axes of the anti-terrorist struggle in which my Government is engaged as I outlined in my investiture speech; but I have left for last one that I consider crucial, which has been the first and main concern of the Government in these months: the care of the victims of the March 11 attacks.

I do not want to elaborate on details, because I attribute this attention to a collective moral obligation. It suffices for me to say that we have tried to recognize the victims with the honors they deserve; that permanent contact with the victims' associations has been fostered; that we have been attentive to the families of the 192 deceased and the more than 1,400 injured; that fifty million euros have been allocated for this fiscal year to cover the compensations to which they are entitled under our laws; that extraordinary pensions are being recognized; that 130 nationalities have been recognized for injured or families of deceased foreigners and nearly 900 residence permits have been recognized under the same conditions; and that the provisions contained in our regulations have been rigorously executed.

Here, to conclude, is a fourth and final conclusion: the Government has sought to provide care to the victims of Islamist terrorism, just as it seeks to provide it to the victims of ETA terrorism.

I said at the beginning of my speech that the actions of terrorists are senseless and therefore it is a futile endeavor to try to unravel it. Our fight against terror does have meaning, it does possess sense.

The Spanish people did not recently discover the ruthless face of terror. We have known it well for more than thirty years. No Spanish Government has knelt before terror and none will. Each blow has reaffirmed us in our values. The memory of the victims gives meaning to our resistance against terror and doubles the value of our freedom.

It is against this country, against this people, against these citizens, that those who attacked on March 11 acted. The hands were different than before, the explosives were different; but we know well the violence they unleash, we know what those explosives did to the metal of the trains, what they did to the bodies of the people they carried, what they have done to the hearts of their families. And we also know that stronger than bodies, than the steel of the trains, than the concrete of the buildings, is our spirit of freedom, the freedom of the Spanish people.

My obsession, Ladies and Gentlemen, is to put in place the means so that a tragedy like the one we experienced nine months ago in Spain does not happen again. I have only one imperative as urgent as protecting the lives of Spaniards: defending our freedom and our democratic framework of coexistence.

Thank you very much.