Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 March 2005 · Press conference after the meeting of the European Council

Context
Zapatero held a press conference following the Spring European Council meeting in Brussels on March 22, 2005, reporting on key EU economic agreements.
Main themes
Stability Pact reform, Lisbon Strategy review, economic growth and employment, EU competitiveness, European social model, Services Directive, Financial Perspectives, Spain-Greece bilateral relations, illegal immigration and coastal surveillance, biodiversity and environment, technological innovation, entrepreneurial spirit
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,801
84th percentile
Sentences
133
76th percentile
Readability
41
37th percentile
Grade
14.5
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.24
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

133 sentences in 62 paragraphs

President.- Good morning and thank you for attending this press conference, which aims to inform you about the Council we held this afternoon and this morning. It has been a Council of consensus, a Council of agreement, and a Council to boost the economies of the European Union.

As you know, the most relevant news has undoubtedly been the agreement reached regarding the reform of the Stability Pact. Both the Stability Pact and the review of the Lisbon Strategy lay, from my point of view, new foundations for a future economic policy for the European Union.

From now on, the Stability Pact will be more adapted to economic circumstances and, at the same time, will respect the classic reference values: 3 percent for public deficit and 60 percent for public debt; criteria that have very evidently helped to consolidate public finances in Europe. Furthermore, the Pact places special emphasis on growth, in line with the objective of revitalizing the Lisbon Strategy.

In short, the Pact has been endowed with greater flexibility and rationality, and there is an awareness of the need for governments to take advantage of good times to save in anticipation of worse times.

The other major aspect addressed in this Spring Council has been the review of the Lisbon Strategy. This Strategy has received significant impetus by focusing on the fundamental objectives: growth and employment. Only with more and better employment will Europe achieve its goal of becoming the most competitive economy in the world, a goal set by Lisbon; with greater social cohesion and, at the same time, with greater environmental balance.

I would like to highlight several aspects that Spain has defended and that I consider very positive in this push for the Lisbon Strategy: first, the role of productivity has been emphasized as a guarantor of social cohesion and sustainable development; second, there is an awareness that for Europe to advance, it is a priority to close the technological gap between countries; and third, the importance of fostering entrepreneurial spirit, research, development, and technological innovation has been underscored.

Finally, in environmental matters, we should congratulate ourselves on the recognition given to the importance of biodiversity in Europe. It is worth remembering that Spain has 25 percent of the European spaces that must be protected to preserve this biodiversity.

Regarding the so-called Services Directive, the European Council has reiterated that it is necessary to implement the internal market for services without jeopardizing the European social model. In the Council's view, of which the President of the Commission is a part, the current wording of the Directive does not fully meet these requirements. Therefore, we must continue the effort until we achieve the necessary consensus around the Directive.

I would also like to inform you that this morning I held a meeting with the Prime Minister of Greece, Costas Karamanlis, in which we addressed bilateral and European issues of common interest: on the one hand, we analyzed the negotiations on the Financial Perspectives, in which we share common positions; and we also studied the possibility of making a joint proposal for the creation of a European rapid response unit for coastal surveillance, which would primarily operate in the Mediterranean, to protect community coasts against illegal immigration and transnational crime.

In short, I want to give a very positive assessment of the European Council. The degree of agreement and the willingness to boost growth and employment, from the perspective of the different states, complemented by the action of the European Union, opens up an expectation, from my point of view, of revitalizing the need for an economy like the European one, which must gain ground in competitiveness and must gain ground in its capacity to create jobs and maintain its pillars, its social model.

Q.- I know that the Financial Perspectives were not on the agenda for this Council, but was there any discussion about it, apart from that bilateral meeting with Mr. Karamanlis? In some way, because everything in the Union is linked, could the approval of the reform of the Stability Pact ease Germany's stance, make the atmosphere more accommodating, and make it more understanding towards the demands of the southern countries, like Spain?

And a curiosity, just a more relaxed question. What happened to your finger?

President.- My passion for basketball. I can answer that quickly.

Secondly, I will say, regarding the Financial Perspectives, that indeed, it was not on the agenda of this Council. I do believe that a reflection can be made, which is quite evident: there is a climate of broad consensus at this moment in the European Union, within the Council. The consensus around the reform of the Stability Pact is a good sign for addressing the set of pending issues we have (of a socioeconomic, budgetary nature, and of boosting economic action by the European Union) with a climate and an expectation of consensus.

Certainly, that is my perception, and Spain, of course, has a negotiation and a matter of great significance and great interest in the Financial Perspectives.

I do not want to insist again, but I am also optimistic in this area.

Q.- The German Minister Hans Eichel, in an interview with "Associated Press," said yesterday that he insists on the 1 percent spending limit; that no more can be allowed, despite the changes to the Pact. Do you think that his boss, Chancellor Schröder, could be more understanding towards Spain?

President.- I believe we have not yet started what is the in-depth negotiation phase on the Financial Perspectives, and we will not have, let’s say, as a reference one statement or another regarding what the final outcome may be.

I affirm and reiterate the agreement on the Stability Pact. The consensus reached is a good sign, a positive sign, for addressing, although they are different issues, what the Financial Perspectives represent.

Q.- Mr. President, a collateral question regarding the Summit, if you allow me. Today is the deadline for the Bank of Italy to make a preliminary or precautionary statement regarding BBVA's intention to buy Banca Nazionale del Lavoro. I wanted to know if the Spanish Administration has had any contacts with the Italian side to, let’s say, overcome any potential obstacles or political concerns in Italy.

And, more generally, I wanted to know your opinion on the integration of the financial sector in Europe and whether you believe that in a monetary union, such as the eurozone, there are reasons to invoke national interest to halt operations like this.

President.- What exists are reasons for the logic and nature of the market, economic rationality, and the expectations of various financial entities to function. We must be respectful of how the market operates and respectful of a possible operation of the nature you just asked me about.

Q.- Returning to the Financial Perspectives, what has been discussed in the Council is the orientation of aid, and this may be of considerable interest to Spain. With a financial ceiling, part of the aid that will be lost in the next financial period could be recovered. What can you tell me about this? What do you plan to do and what programs do you intend to present to take advantage of, for example, funds for research, etc.?

President.- I believe there is a very clear line from the Spanish Government regarding the analysis, both of the key to growth for competitiveness and regarding the analysis of the Financial Perspectives or, in other words, the cohesion policy. This key lies in the need to strengthen our technological capital. This means research, development, innovation, the education system, or human capital.

That is where we have placed emphasis regarding the review of the Lisbon Strategy, which, as you know, will have a reform program, a program in each country, a reform program that must be presented in the autumn, which must have a national coordinator for each country, and I can advance that in Spain the coordinator, who will lead the entire implementation of Lisbon, is the Director of the Economic Office of the Presidency of the Government, Secretary of State Miguel Sebastián.

Exactly the same applies to the Financial Perspectives. Cohesion, from the Spanish perspective, in the European Union -- and cohesion is a path, a means, for more development, more well-being, and more equality -- must fundamentally focus on strengthening our technological system, our technological capital, our research system; on strengthening our researchers and, of course, on the capacity to undertake that derives from those better circumstances for research. That is where we will focus our efforts regarding the Financial Perspectives.

Q.- Regarding the Stability Pact, the new rules provide that countries with high growth potential and low debt, which I believe is the case for Spain, can waive the medium-term budgetary balance objective and go up to a 1 percent deficit. So, I wanted to know if Spain is going to increase public investment in R&D, education, etc., and go up to a 1 percent deficit.

President.- The Government of Spain has as a fundamental principle of its fiscal policy and economic policy the budgetary stability; moreover, I believe it is a right of citizens. You know my insistence that a political project must have as its fundamental reference the idea of rights, and I believe it is a right of citizens that public administrations do not spend more than they earn and that they manage every euro, every public euro, with the utmost rigor. That is a right of citizens and, furthermore, it is very good for the economy.

I can assure you that the Government of Spain is trying, and will succeed, in maintaining the objective of budgetary balance. As you know, it depends on the cycle; there may be moments of surplus or moments of deficit. Surplus moments are meant for saving and having a margin in the face of more complicated economic times.

With the growth rate that the Spanish economy has and with the good management of the financial administration being carried out by the Ministry of Economy and Finance, we have the possibility -- we have already made an effort this year -- for the budget for the following year, for the 2006 budget, to make a significant increase in public spending efforts in the areas of Research, Development, and Innovation. Without a doubt, it will be the most relevant increase in spending that we will contemplate for the 2006 Budget, which will be rigorous and strict regarding the principle of budgetary stability and the principle of strict compliance with the Stability Pact.

Q.- If I may, I would like to ask you a question about the current political situation in Spain. I wanted to know if you are in a position to deny the doubts that are currently being raised in our country regarding the relationship between a socialist militant from Oviedo and someone now detained for the 11-M. It has even been said by the popular spokesperson, Mr. Zaplana, that to whom this alleged member of the CNI, this socialist militant who may possibly be a member of the CNI, reported; to whom did he report, to the Government or to the PSOE? You were the Secretary General of the PSOE, you still are; are you in a position to deny that the Socialist Party knew nothing, was not informed of the plans regarding the 11-M?

President.- Many speculations have been made in recent months regarding the attack or tragedy of March 11. All of them have collapsed. What remains is the pain, the tragedy, of 192 victims who died and many injured, which had a great impact on Spanish society. That is what remains.

The responsibility and task of the Government, in which I am logically very directly involved, is to improve our security to prevent an attack of the magnitude represented by the March 11 attack. This means reinforcing all the instruments of our security, our State Security Forces and Corps, our Intelligence Services, and everything that the State has to prevent attacks.

I want to reiterate, and I have made this explicit on more than one occasion -- I did so in my appearance before the March 11 Investigation Commission -- that just over a year later there is extensive and abundant information about that tragedy and that we know that the responsible authors are linked to what is known as radical Islamist terrorism. We know that, thanks to the actions of the Police, the Civil Guard, and Justice, there is a very significant number of those charged and a very significant number of detainees. We know that the Police and Justice continue to work to complete all the details of the action and the responsible parties.

Therefore, we can have full confidence in the actions of the institutions of the Rule of Law regarding the responsibility and determination of all the implications of the March 11 terrorist attack.

And we also know, although perhaps we should try to overcome this, that some political leaders find it difficult to accept the trauma of the electoral result of March 14. But, well, I will apply all my patience to this task.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to return to the topics of this Council. A very specific question as well, and I would like you to be very specific in your response. Can Spain expect to counteract the loss of Cohesion Funds and Structural Funds with new money coming from here, from Brussels, in exchange for projects to invest in R&D? Is this where the hope of many Spanish regions lies, who are waiting for this?

President.- Yes. I have just reiterated that, in light of the Financial Perspectives, the Government of Spain will place the greatest emphasis possible on what represents the effort of aid in the areas of Research, Development, Innovation, and technological capital and education, with a particular support -- which appears, by the way, in the review of the Lisbon Strategy that we have just approved -- for everything that represents the European Research Area.

Of course, we know that there is a report from the Commission and we know that there is a statistical effect as a consequence of the enlargement. Of course, the Government of Spain will work to ensure that the reduction is as minimal as possible and that the reduction is a progressive one, even understanding the different position that, from an economic and data perspective, our country has once the enlargement has taken place and been completed.

But, I insist, we will have, surely in the coming weeks and months, plenty of opportunities to talk in detail about the negotiation process of the Financial Perspectives.

Q.- I would like to know if today or yesterday you had the opportunity to discuss with your European colleagues your participation in the Arab League Assembly yesterday and also if you have any data or at least some sense of how your speech was received by the Arab countries.

President.- I had the opportunity to comment, precisely yesterday, when I arrived, that I came from the meeting of the League of Arab States. I will not evaluate my speech; I simply want to reiterate two ideas that I consider fundamental.

The first of these is that it is of great strategic importance for the European Union, for Spain, and for the international order that the Arab world increases its process of modernization, the emergence of the rule of law, democracies, and the guarantee of freedoms -- freedom is the best brake on intolerance and radicalism, as I stated yesterday -- and that, of course, this is done from the perspective of political cooperation, from the perspective of dialogue, and from the perspective of calling for a space of understanding that, in my view, must be a proposal like the Alliance of Civilizations.

I believe there are many signs that can generate concern among cultures, among religions; concern that leads to division, to confrontation. And at this beginning of the 21st century, we have the opportunity to prevent walls from being built in one way or another, like those that were built in the 20th century. The only way to avoid walls between cultures, peoples, civilizations, is dialogue, respect, cooperation, and assistance; and, undoubtedly, it is also the best antidote to strengthen the shared security that the Arab countries logically desire, that Europe desires, and that the Western community desires.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to know if the Spanish Government agrees that one of the fathers of the doctrine of preventive attack could take the reins of the World Bank.

President.- They are different areas, right?, the area of economic policy, where I still believe, if the Economic Vice President does not correct me, that the doctrine of preventive attack is not found, from what can be the doctrine in terms of foreign policy. The Government of Spain, like all the Governments of the European Union, has taken note of the candidacy. There will be contact with the candidate to know his proposals, and Spain will be in consensus with the countries of the European Union regarding this candidacy.

Q.- Mr. President, about ten days ago you met, without cameras as well, with the Cuban Foreign Minister, Felipe Pérez Roque. Cuba is asking the European Union not to support the United States in the Human Rights Commission in Geneva and, at the same time, has increased the harassment of the families of dissidents in Cuba. Was this the response you expected after meeting with Minister Pérez Roque and after the gestures Spain has made in relation to the European Union? I wanted to know if you feel a bit disappointed.

Then, why do you refuse to convene the Anti-Terrorism Pact, as the main opposition party is asking you to do?

President.- Regarding the first question, I have expressed on many occasions the policy that I believe should be maintained with Cuba, which is a policy of demand, but of dialogue.

I must confess that I am surprised by some of the things I have read recently after having met with the Cuban Foreign Minister. I am surprised that they come from some places, because I believe there was a lengthy process of meetings of the previous Government and the previous Prime Minister, not with the Foreign Minister, but with Fidel Castro himself. Therefore, I think it would be reasonable to ask for a bit of prudence.

Demand and dialogue, and I believe that the efforts that the Government of Spain is making in this area require prudence, on one hand, and calm. That is what I refer to.

Secondly, the Anti-Terrorism Pact, regarding whose philosophy I believe I can be authorized to recall some of its elements -- I say "can be authorized" because I proposed that Anti-Terrorism Pact and I am glad that some who initially disqualified it now give it high value -- has as its essential objective to create a common anti-terrorism policy, to create a loyal anti-terrorism policy, to create an anti-terrorism policy where party discrepancies do not exist and are not publicly transferred. This is the philosophy, because that makes us stronger to end terrorism.

I want to simply invoke one piece of data: if anyone can recover or remember if in my responsibility as leader of the opposition at any time I criticized or suspected the anti-terrorism policy that the government of Mr. Aznar was carrying out. I did the opposite, because I believe that is good for Spain: to support at all times the policy of fighting against terrorism. I simply want to make that reflection, which will be the same, logically, that I will make if there is an opportunity at some point in the parliamentary sphere.

And of course there will be future meetings of the Anti-Terrorism Pact; future meetings where the Government will inform about the effectiveness that it is carrying out, thanks to the State Security Forces and Corps, in the fight against terrorism.

I remember that on the same day that the Popular Party publicly demanded, gave credence to certain information, and maintained a critical attitude towards the Government, that same day the collaboration of the Spanish and French police led to the arrest of three alleged members of ETA.

Those are the facts. First fact, during four years of opposition I supported, I never criticized or insinuated, but only collaborated, giving full support to the policy to end terrorism. Obviously, now citizens will be able to judge the behaviors of some and others in this stage that, I emphasize, has also been characterized by a clear effectiveness in the fight against terrorism, the merit of which belongs to the State Security Forces and Corps and, where appropriate, to Justice.

Q.- I wanted to revisit a previous question to see if you can provide more detail regarding the socialist militant Fernando Huarte. I wanted to know if you knew if he was a collaborator of the CNI and if, through him, you had information about the 11-M attacks.

President.- I believe I have expressed myself clearly after having lived through various pieces of information in recent months. All of them have been conjectures, conjectures that have collapsed. I still have my recent appearance before the Investigation Commission in mind and I will not enter into any conjecture. I will do my job, which is to reinforce the security of Spaniards in the prevention of terrorist attacks, and to collaborate, as the Government permanently collaborates, with Justice and with the State Security Forces and Corps so that all, absolutely all, those responsible for the tragedy of 11-M pay dearly with the full weight of the Law. And I reiterate: I have the utmost confidence in the work that the Justice Administration is doing and I hope that one day some will calm down, which would be very convenient for everyone.

Q.- I would like to know why Spain, in this case, is not alongside France, Germany, and Sweden in defending changes to that Directive. Is there nothing that concerns you, specifically? And if you are concerned about something, what points should be changed in that Directive?

President.- Your question represents an assumption of what Spain's position is. I have just said that we understand that it is necessary to reform this Directive to reach a broad consensus, because we believe it is convenient to maintain the social model, and I can also add something: it is also necessary to see the perspective and consider the compatibility with what should be the services of general interest that have also characterized and characterize many of our societies.

Therefore, reform of the Directive, as it stands, in search of the broadest consensus where, logically, the social agents should be included.

Thank you very much.