Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the Council of Ministers.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

9 February 2006 · Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the Council of Ministers

Context
Zapatero held a press conference after a Council of Ministers meeting in February 2006, outlining legislative priorities and anti-terrorism policy at the start of the parliamentary session.
Main themes
Anti-terrorism policy and ETA peace process, legislative calendar and planned bills, Social Security Reserve Fund allocation, cabinet appointments, rule of law and judicial independence, social rights and equality legislation, modernization of public administration, government accountability and press transparency
Duration
~56 min
95th percentile
Words
6,725
95th percentile
Sentences
218
91st percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
14.9
75th percentile
Syntax
3.36
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

218 sentences in 99 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. As you know, I had committed to you and to public opinion to hold an open press conference at the end of each session period. More specifically, it was at the end of each session period, and it is true that in this case we will do it at the beginning, in the week that the parliamentary session begins, to maintain that commitment and also because I believe it can be, above all, very useful for all of you.

Allow me, since today is Friday and, therefore, we have held a Cabinet meeting, before I provide a general assessment on two aspects that I want to highlight in this appearance, one related to anti-terrorism policy and the other related to the legislative calendar of government initiatives for this session period, to refer to two specific agreements that the Cabinet has made today. As you already know, you will have the rest of the decisions available in the usual Reference that the First Deputy Prime Minister normally explains so adequately, as you well know.

The first agreement is that the Cabinet has appointed Francisco Vázquez, Mayor of A Coruña and President of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities, as Ambassador to the Holy See, a person with a long public career and a history of service to the interests of citizens and the interests of the country. We are convinced that he will be an Ambassador dedicated to improving relations between the Vatican State and the Government of Spain, and ultimately the Spanish State.

The second agreement adopted today by the Cabinet is a new additional allocation to the Social Security Reserve Fund amounting to 3.7 billion euros, which will mean that the Social Security Reserve Fund reaches 31.207 billion euros. This is an enormously important figure that reaffirms the good state of our public Social Security system, which, as you well know, is the cornerstone of the protection system for citizens in our country.

I was saying that, beyond these two specific agreements from the Cabinet, I wanted to make two general considerations. The first refers to the calendar of Bills that the Government will send to the Chambers in this session period, which express the high degree of objectives, fulfillment of commitments, and the political agenda of the Government on issues of great social and institutional importance. I would assert that this will be a session period characterized by historic social laws and by a process of modernization of the functioning of institutions and public services in our country.

I will now refer to the twenty-eight laws, twenty-eight Bills, that the Government will approve in this session period:

These are the twenty-eight Bills that highlight the ambitious agenda of the Government for this session period and a very important step in qualitative and quantitative terms in fulfilling the electoral program and also the investiture program. Social laws that will incorporate new citizenship rights, that will improve equality, and modernizing laws in specific areas and, very particularly, in a broad field of what is the functioning of the Public Administration, its adaptation, and its updating also for public employees.

I was saying that I wanted to make a general consideration about anti-terrorism policy, especially because we have had a very tense debate on this matter in recent days; a debate that, in my opinion, should have a profound reorientation in favor of the very objectives of all Spaniards, which are to combat and see the end of terrorism, and, secondly, in favor of the effective functioning of our Rule of Law.

In recent days, I have heard many analyses and many comments about the optimism of the Prime Minister regarding what we could call a peace process or the end of the violence that has caused so much harm to this country for decades, especially to many people and their families. Believe me, this is not about optimism or pessimism. It is a conviction, a conviction that stems from an idea that serves for life in general, and for politics and coexistence in particular: you reap what you sow, and this Government sows the hope of ending violence to reap that great collective hope, which will undoubtedly, if we succeed, be the fruit of all Spanish society.

Secondly, in recent days, the main opposition party has sought to make accusations regarding what the strict application of the Law represents by those who constitutionally have that competence, judges and prosecutors, in relation to the compliance with sentences by members of ETA.

Today, Spaniards know, after the forceful, clarifying, and unquestionable response we have heard, not only from the Minister of the Interior and the Minister of Justice yesterday in a clear and precise manner, but also from what members of the Prosecutor's Office and members of the Judicial Career have made explicit, that to say that there is the slightest indication or political action in the process of applying the Law is an unsustainable, unacceptable, and intolerable lie.

The Law, the Penal Code of 1973, has been applied, from a jurisprudential criterion, always in the same way, as has been proven; with criteria of the Rule of Law, whose results may produce greater or lesser conformity, but which are always the same, with this Government and with previous ones. Therefore, I cannot understand how one can have the audacity not to respect the truth on such an evident and sensitive issue.

From here, I want to make a call to the main opposition party, the Popular Party, to recover the sense of responsibility that has historically characterized all political forces since the democratic transition in the fight against terrorism.

It is true that all the Governments that have existed, all of them, have had the loyal support, understanding, and help of the opposition in the fight against terrorism and in the search for the end of violence. I would like to be able to say one day, as Prime Minister, to all Spaniards that I too have had the help and support of the opposition, when all citizens know very well, and all political parties know, and those who have had government responsibilities know, that this is a difficult struggle; that it has required firmness, commitment, shared citizen and social mobilization; that the pain and horror we have felt for decades is a pain and horror shared by all; that the collective effort to defeat, combat, and end violence has been collective because at stake is nothing less than freedom, life, and full democracy in the functioning of our society; that it has achieved brilliant conquests since the democratic transition to here in all areas and that it has known how to sustain, with the best principles, the fight against terrorism and what it represented as a threat to people.

I believe it is my duty as Prime Minister to make this call to responsibility, and, if you allow me, I feel with all moral authority, because I too was in the opposition for four years and during those four years I fully supported the Government in the fight against terrorism. I did not criticize even once, I never asked for explanations. I backed, encouraged, congratulated, contributed to advancing the end of violence and, of course, to providing security and tranquility to the entire Spanish society regarding what the principles and functioning of the Rule of Law mean.

This is what I wanted to say to you.

Q.- In line with what you have just said and the analogy you used, I wanted to ask you if you can guarantee that there is no management, let’s say, to cultivate what you mentioned regarding the peace process; that there is no known or consented management by the Government to reach that point.

Secondly, given that publicly what Spaniards know is that there is no change on the part of what we could call the ETA environment and that there are still bombs being placed and extortions against businessmen, can you guarantee or explain to us where the optimism or hope lies in that peace process?

On a completely different topic, do you support the criticisms of the Minister of Defense towards Pasqual Maragall?

President.- I have said it before: I have a conviction, a conviction, that the process of violence that has caused so much harm to Spanish society has a limited time. That conviction stems, above all, from the strength that Spanish society has had; it stems from objective facts, such as the absence of fatal attacks for more than two long years; it stems from the perception that the Government has regarding the maximum desire and commitment for peace and the end of violence that exists in the vast majority of Basque society, and it also stems, evidently, from information that the Government possesses; information that, in its own responsibility, as it cannot be otherwise, is to be managed with prudence and discretion, as has always been the case in the democratic trajectory.

The only thing that has unfortunately changed, having objectively better expectations regarding the possibility of seeing the end of violence, the only thing that has changed, I repeat, is the attitude of the opposition, when it has had from day one the offer to share, as we shared during all these past years and especially in the last legislature, what represents a collective effort from all.

Because, you see, if I am talking about a conviction that we may be at a moment, perhaps the best in many years, to see the beginning of the end, that is due to everyone, to everyone. I believe it is neither in the way of behaving in the opposition nor now, as Prime Minister, to downplay anyone's merits and that it must also be in the responsibility of the Government, as is logical, and as it has always been managed -- I could provide many quotes here -- to have the prudence and the obligation of prudence that must characterize in this matter, very especially, the Government; not only in this matter but also in some others.

To the other question, I believe it is known that in our party, and also in the Government, there is a wide margin for freedom of opinion. The only thing I want to say about this is that the Socialist Party and the Government have made a special effort to ensure that the reform of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia goes ahead with the maximum possible support, in the terms that I have committed on many occasions to the Spaniards regarding compliance with the Constitution, because I understand that reforms of Statutes of Autonomy are a positive process for the management of public affairs in relation to citizens and that in the context of that process a reform of the financing model will also be positive, which guarantees more responsibility and solidarity in the overall functioning of the Welfare State and public services.

Therefore, freedom of opinion and, of course, the objective of ensuring that the Statute goes ahead in those terms, because it will be very positive.

Q.- President, I will return to the topic of ETA. Do you think the criticisms are justified? Everyone can understand that the information the Government has should be managed with prudence and discretion, but are we not at a moment where it is possible that the Government is not providing information to the main opposition party, which they are certainly demanding? If we have reached a limit where some cross the line and others make those accusations, has that moment arrived where it is impossible to see a meeting between the Prime Minister and the main opposition leader?

President.- I just want to make a clarification to the question. I believe that the Government and the Socialist Party, before, when it was in opposition, and now, when it is in Government, have never launched an offensive attack against the Popular Party, whether governing or being in opposition, in relation to the fight against ETA terrorism. We have never done so because we feel responsible, in opposition or in Government, for the defense of the values that unite us: freedom, life, and democracy. They are absolutely above any Government, any electoral process, or any party label. They are at the very heart of the Constitution and democracy, and that is why they belong to everyone. It is a heart that we all must make beat strongly every day.

I thought it was appropriate to make that clarification.

In the meetings I have had with Mr. Rajoy, we have talked about anti-terrorism policy, and I have conveyed to him the analysis of the situation that the Government has. Obviously, he is the one who manages the information I have transferred to him, and I will always respect what he says, because it is his. It is information, logically, that remains between the Prime Minister and the main opposition leader.

And I will tell you: of course, it is my objective to meet again with Mr. Rajoy to talk especially about anti-terrorism policy and the situation we may have in the future. It will be at the right moment.

Q.- Will it be when there is some news in the peace process that the moment to meet with Mr. Rajoy will be?

In any case, a question on this same topic: does the current attitude of the Popular Party put these peace expectations at risk, or is the process sufficiently protected to prevent this from being a threat?

And the last one. As I believe you have left a previous question unanswered, or you have left it hanging, I simply wanted to know if, in your opinion, Mr. Maragall has been a source of problems for the Government and if you support him running again as a candidate for the Generalitat.

President.- As you know, there is a standard response regarding candidates: when the time comes, when it is appropriate, and by the bodies that are thus provided for in the party's Statutes.

I believe that Pasqual Maragall has been a fundamental driver of the project to reform the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, as President of the Generalitat, in a clear manner. That will be an asset in his political work. But it is evident that some of the statements he has made at some point I do not fully endorse. I imagine that this will also be part of the own logic and what represents the democratic debate.

What historically represents the possibility of a peace process responds to such deep reasons that it will not be altered by any political situation that may arise in the debate among the major parties. That is my conviction. Does the Government wish to see the support of the main opposition party? Undoubtedly. Does the Government deserve it? Undoubtedly, because the balance is very clear. Therefore, as I said before, if that process ends up in a good place, it will be a merit of all.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to know if you consider that we are already in a peace process, because you speak of it reaching a good port.

Secondly, in the conversations you have had with Mr. Mariano Rajoy, has he conveyed that conviction you have just spoken about, or has he also conveyed part of that information that, for prudence, you do not inform us about?

President.- I have conveyed the conviction. A conviction is composed of many elements (political analysis, social analysis, analysis of what has been happening) and of a part of information that corresponds to the interlocutor. Obviously, establishing a principle of trust on a topic like this...

I have very clearly etched in my memory the first thing I said to Mr. Aznar when I was elected leader of the opposition and came here, to Moncloa, in my first meeting with him, just a few days after the congress. The first thing I said, as I sat down, after the courtesy congratulations, was: "President, I want you to know one thing: nothing would make me happier as a political leader than to see the end of terrorism with you as President of the Government and me as leader of the opposition. Therefore, you have my total support in this task, unconditionally." That was the first thing I said to Mr. Aznar.

From there, it is absolutely reasonable that the main opposition party wants to have all the information, but the information must start from a basic principle of trust, and that principle of trust must be demonstrated. The opposite has been demonstrated, particularly in this last week, after seeing the speech that was made when decisions were being made in the realm of the Supreme Court prosecutors and, in their case, the Supreme Court judges regarding the compliance of sentences by terrorists; decisions in which the Government does not intervene at all and decisions that are exactly the same as always in the entire democratic process.

It is not that there is no principle of trust, nor a favorable attitude towards trust; it is that there is something very serious: there is a distrust based on falsehoods on a very serious issue. And I have to tell the Spaniards. It is my duty.

We are in circumstances that allow me to have the conviction that it can, it can, begin the beginning of the end; but that will depend on many factors. I have said it: it will be a long, difficult, and hard task. Obviously, the main element has been the capacity and strength of the institutions, of the democratic system; but there are more desires than ever and conditions that perhaps have never occurred.

Q.- Mr. President, in that lack of trust that you say you find in the dialogue with the Popular Party, do you not have the impression that both you and this Government may have some part of the responsibility, since in the realm of negotiation or the peace process regarding the agreement that was already in the Congress of Deputies for a mandate, when the circumstances for negotiation arose, the Popular Party did not join that and there was, let’s say, a beginning of a rupture? In the process of the Catalan Statute, the Popular Party has also been sidelined, and both you and other members of the Government have boasted of the solitude of the Popular Party.

Regarding what has happened in recent days concerning the release, it has also coincided with other news such as, for example, the dismissal at this moment of Prosecutor Fungairiño or the fact that the Prosecutor's Office did not act --a judge did-- when the Batasuna assembly took place.

A series of circumstances have occurred in which it seems that, both on the part of the opposition, but perhaps also on the part of the Government, that disagreement and isolation of the Popular Party have facilitated this distance, and perhaps that has been the reason why you do not provide them with the information that you say you have not given completely because you do not trust them. How do you assess that situation?

President.- The problem is that facts are stubborn, but it is in the memory of all Spaniards that from the very first moment this Government began its journey, the Popular Party has made anti-terrorist policy a central theme of criticism and opposition. Not now, two years later, no, no; from the beginning of the legislature. It does not matter what moment is sought, the decision or the circumstance that may arise.

The best proof is that there have been countless parliamentary initiatives for control from the very first day of Mr. Rajoy himself, when it was something unprecedented in the parliamentary life of the country; to oppose, to demand control and political responsibility regarding the fight against terrorism. Unprecedented and, moreover, they had it agreed upon in the signing of the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism.

That pact, which I proposed at the time, was to put in writing and sign --everyone can perfectly understand that when I proposed it, I did so in my capacity as leader of the opposition--, to say to the Government and to the Spaniards "I put my signature here, I put it here, before all the people, because I will not oppose the anti-terrorist policy. Not only will I not oppose, but I will help, support, and commit myself in easy and difficult moments." That was my commitment in the first State of the Nation Debate as leader of the opposition, and I fulfilled it to the letter.

Others have decided on a completely different political strategy. Allow me to say two things: it will not harm the expectations of ending the violence; secondly, it will undoubtedly provoke a process of self-criticism and reflection in the Popular Party. That is my opinion.

From there, all the circumstances that one wishes can be poured: that a State Attorney General is appointed, or a Prosecutor of the National Court is replaced, or it is the process of deciding "yes" or "no," whether the Communist Party of the Basque Lands should be challenged… Everything. Sometimes, information that has been proven to be falsehoods about penitentiary policy and the treatment received by members of the terrorist group ETA, and the culmination, the culmination of the falsehoods, is what we have experienced in recent days regarding the compliance of sentences by terrorists.

I simply want to say that and I want to remember something else. I want to remember that this is being done by a party in opposition that negotiated with ETA with the understanding, backing, and support of all political forces and the expectation of Spanish society; a party that was then presided over by Mr. Aznar, President of the Government, and who said things like the following: "if the terrorists decide to lay down their arms, I will know how to be generous"; "I am willing to take the necessary initiatives if we see that it could be understood or positive steps could be taken for this situation of cessation of violence to lead to a definitive peace process"; "with violence, no political advantage is achieved, but I am willing to be generous, if necessary, to be understanding, if that helps to end terrorism. That is what everyone must understand. It is not an easy path." In this, I agree with Mr. Aznar.

"You must take into account," said Mr. Aznar, "that penitentiary policy is part of anti-terrorist policy, and penitentiary policy must serve the end of the recovery, if possible, of individuals previously linked to terrorism." And he answered the following question: "Should we start thinking about the possibility that the ETA members do not serve their sentences in full?" "The law will always be complied with, but the spirit must be open and generous." This was not said by the President of the Government José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero; it was said by the President of the Government, now former President, Mr. Aznar.

And now, in what is the strict compliance with the law regarding the sentences of terrorists, some of whom have a horrendous number of crimes that provoke the greatest indignation in all of us regarding the facts and the consequences of those terrorist acts, we have had to hear what we have had to hear.

Therefore, I believe, I insist, with all moral authority, and I believe it is my political duty as President of the Government, to make an appeal to responsibility, knowing the history we have traveled and what we have ahead, which, I reiterate, will not be easy or short in time.

Q.- I do not know if the Government is aware of the Catalan families, some with deaf-mute children, who cannot enroll their children in Spanish, as recommended by doctors, who advise that children be enrolled in the same language as their families. There are families that are even moving to Alicante, and this was reported in the media, such as the weekly "Alba" or the newspaper "El País." Does the Government plan to take any measures to facilitate these families enrolling their children in Spanish?

President.- The Government has recently adopted an initiative, which is a historical demand of the deaf-mute community, which is the institutional recognition of sign language, which will obligate the Administrations and will facilitate, of course, the process of communication, understanding, development, and personal autonomy of this community. Do not doubt that, regarding equality of rights, especially for those individuals who, due to their physical circumstances, may have more difficulty, the Government is willing to remove all necessary obstacles, all of them.

Q.- I wanted to ask you if, in the event that your conviction materializes, you would consider the model carried out by Mr. Aznar's Government a good model, that is, for Government representatives to meet directly with ETA leaders.

On another matter, regarding the appointment of Mr. Vázquez as Ambassador to the Vatican, is the fact of appointing one of the few socialist leaders who openly declares himself Catholic an intention to smooth over rough edges or to improve relations with the Vatican after the recent problems that have occurred?

President.- If I were to answer "no" to this second question, it would probably not be very credible. Obviously, the decision was influenced, first by the personality of Paco Vázquez, Francisco Vázquez, and, of course, also by his convictions, yes. I believe that is a fairly objective element that can facilitate the relationship, the communication, which is the desire, I insist, of the Government.

Regarding the first question, I believe that prudence obliges me. There is no possibility of talking about a model if that conviction, that hope that I cultivate of seeing the beginning of the end, were to occur. In any case, I can assure you that, if that happens, the Government will take its time to take any step, which in any case will be, logically, in the terms approved by Parliament.

Q.- President, allow me to convey three economic concerns, some of which are related to the legislative calendar you have previously outlined.

First, the overvaluation of housing prices detected by the Bank of Spain, also by the European Central Bank and by various national and international organizations.

Secondly, does the President see a risk that a sharp correction in the stock markets could occur, considering that the IBEX is already reaching levels close to 1,500 points?

Finally, is the Government concerned about the appeal that ENDESA has filed with the Supreme Court against the takeover bid? On Sunday, you had a lunch --a controversial lunch, by the way-- with a group of Catalan businessmen, and I wanted to know if you have detected this concern among them.

President.- Regarding the economic situation, I will tell you that the Government has confidence in the evolution of the economic situation in our country, and this is reflected in the most relevant data from the macroeconomic framework. We are finishing 2005 with a growth of 3.5 percent; we have finished 2005 with a surplus above 1 percent of the GDP of all Public Administrations, which is the first time in the history of our country; and we have practically finished the year creating one million new jobs.

We must take into account the evolution of inflation, which, as I have explained, is closely related to the 40 percent increase in oil prices in 2005 and also to the natural conditions we have faced that have affected agriculture and the prices of some foods. However, the expectation for 2006 is a positive expectation for economic growth, positive for job creation, and also positive in terms of fiscal rigor and public accounts.

I do not understand why the lunch was controversial. For me, it was a cordial lunch, where we talked about the evolution of the economy, the evolution of the situation in Research, Development, and Innovation in our country, tax reforms, and also the political situation in Catalonia and Spain, something I do regularly with businesspeople and with groups and representatives from the most diverse social spheres, as is my obligation.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to know if you consider it appropriate for Mr. Carod Rovira to return to the Catalan Government at some point.

Regarding your own Government, do you plan to make any reshuffle in the Government soon, perhaps due to the upcoming regional elections?

President.- No, I do not have any changes planned in the Government.

Regarding the Government of Catalonia, I believe we must be very respectful of those who have that area of competence, which is the person who presides over it, and therefore, I will not make any assessment. But I believe that President Maragall knows perfectly well what the Government of Catalonia needs and the possibilities it may have in that horizon. But I think respect is fundamental.

Q.- I wanted to ask you about the information being released today by Cadena COPE, which is based on official documents to which they have had access and which contradict the official version given by Minister Bono regarding the accident of two helicopters in Afghanistan. These documents record the testimony of the military from the second aircraft, who speak of gunfire, when Minister Bono completely ruled out the hypothesis of an attack. They also compare the missions in Iraq and Afghanistan.

I also wanted to ask if you would be willing to appear, as requested by the Popular Party, in Congress to explain why this information has been concealed.

President.- The Minister of Defense has conveyed the technical report on the "Cougar" accident that cost the lives of seventeen compatriots in Afghanistan; the mandatory report according to the legal framework, which is prepared by a team of experts and technicians, is not done by Mr. Bono. It is a country that operates with rules. That is the official report.

From there, any other testimony—by the way, at this moment I do not know what information any broadcaster may have provided—will have to have the minimum support to give it credibility. And I believe that the Minister of Defense is always willing to appear, always. And we hope to see what the Popular Party does because, I insist, I do not have information at this moment.

Q.- I would like to know if, due to the current relations between the Government and the Popular Party, you rule out the possibility of the planned constitutional reform in this legislature or, in any case, if the comprehensive reform proposed by the Government is not possible, whether a partial reform is possible in aspects such as the succession to the Crown.

President.- I do not want to rule anything out, because it would be good if the reform of the aspects of the constitutional text that we have explained many times could be carried out, especially the reform that affects the Senate, which is a Chamber that can and should play a much more relevant and integrative role as a Chamber of territorial representation.

The Government, logically, is eager for dialogue and an agreement regarding the reform of the Constitution in all aspects, including the one I mentioned regarding the succession to the Crown. We will try. They will tell me that I am optimistic. I am always optimistic, even in this. In this, it is commendable, but I will maintain it.

Q.- I wanted to return to the issue of terrorism, but from another perspective. A sector of the Associations of Victims of Terrorism maintains a critical attitude towards the Government's anti-terrorist policy or in this context regarding a hypothesis of a peace process. I wanted to ask you what analysis you make of this situation, first, and whether the Government will take any initiative regarding the different Associations of Victims.

A second question, regarding CiU and Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya, there is a situation where both parties are in the realm of possible allies of the Government, but in different situations, following the agreement you reached with Mas. So, what attitude will you adopt towards these two parties? If you were faced with the possibility of choosing one or the other as a preferred ally, which one would you choose?

President.- I will start with the second question. We should be clear that one thing is the reform of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, which the Government and the Socialist Party wish to have the maximum consensus, that is, to receive the greatest support from the political forces in the Parliament of Catalonia, and hopefully also the greatest backing from the political forces represented in the Congress of Deputies and the Senate, and another is what the Government of Catalonia represents and the relationship that exists with groups in the Chamber that support or have an open attitude to contribute to the governance of the country.

These are two things that have their own trajectory, and we should insist on the idea that a Statute of Autonomy, this Statute of Autonomy, this reform of the Statute of Autonomy, will be for many years, for many, and the Government of Catalonia has a period until the voters speak, because it is from there that it can be formed.

Consequently, I believe that no political force should approach the Statute and the entire final rectification process in which we are, thinking about the upcoming elections or thinking that it will be an action or a result of a label or a political force; no. The new Statute of Catalonia will be the result, above all, of the set of political forces and, especially, of the citizens of Catalonia, because they are called to express themselves in a referendum.

At the level of the Congress of Deputies, regarding the governance of the country, the Socialist Party has had an open attitude towards collaboration with all Parliamentary Groups. It is true and understandable that you cannot ask the main opposition party to collaborate in governance, because the logic is Government-opposition, and the logic there has a different territory. But we have had an open relationship with everyone, and we have agreements that are being renewed, constructed, and shaped with the majority of Parliamentary Groups. We started directly with those who supported the investiture, and those political groups have my full recognition and gratitude, and we have progressively opened the spectrum, as was very evident in the voting of the General State Budgets for the year 2006.

We will continue like this, because the Government, attending to the composition of the Chamber, believes it has a wide margin, a wide availability, in agreement with different Parliamentary Groups, although, as is known, Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya and Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya have had a singular relationship from the beginning, as have other groups in the Chamber.

Like all Spaniards, I have a deep sense of recognition towards the victims of terrorism. Therefore, I will always respect all their opinions, even if they are critical and harsh towards the Government. They will always be heard, always be valued, and always be taken into account.

As you know, I have met with all the associations representing the victims of terrorism. I had an intense day explaining my policy and my commitment to them, the commitment that they would have all the information and that they would be considered in a very special way, if we have a process, as it has already been coined, called peace; if it occurs. They know this directly.

And I will add: we have sought during this time of Government to improve the attention, the relationship, and the High Commissioner for Victims of Terrorism is doing so. He has made a broad catalog of new proposals and reforms that improve the aid and assistance to the victims of terrorism. And I have just reiterated that we will send to Congress a Bill for the reform, modification, of Solidarity with the Victims of Terrorism.

I will add finally, because it has also been a subject of controversy, that I feel deeply proud to have been invited, and for that reason I accepted the Honorary Committee, to the Congress of the Victims of Terrorism. They will always have, to the extent of our reach as rulers and of our reach as people, as human beings, all our closeness, all our understanding, all our help, and all our explanation. I know that they deserve it, and I know that the Spanish people wish it.

Q.- I would like to know what hope you have or on what you base—there must be some basis because, if not, you would not raise it—the idea that the Popular Party will change its attitude in this area; that is, what do you think it depends on? Do you see it feasible? Does this tense atmosphere generate relative frustration for you halfway through the legislature, when one of your goals was to change political life in Spain, and it seems that the climate does not respond to that?

Then, in a completely different area, is there any progress on labor market reform? It does not seem that there is an agreement. I would like to know if the Government is currently considering legislating without it.

President.- I will start with the last one. It is progressing, being very cautious, because we are dealing with a matter, logically, of great significance and where economic and social agents, employers, and unions, it is normal that in the face of a decision on a labor market reform that they must agree with the Government, are very cautious and careful when incorporating changes. But it is progressing.

Regarding the attitude of the PP, it is clear: I believe, and I say it as I feel it, that it is not that the President of the Government would like it; I believe that changing the attitude regarding the fight against terrorism would be welcomed by the vast majority of Spaniards. This does not mean diminishing the firmness, the strength, and the energy that a good democracy demands from the opposition. But, honestly, there is a historical convention in our democracy and a well-established democratic flow, which falls within the deepest values of our coexistence, of not making that opposition nor using it in political contention.

Of course, I appeal to responsibility. I insist, I hope there will be self-criticism in that direction.

The fact that some politicians or some political leaders try to create tension does not mean that there is tension. Fortunately, Spanish society flows with an impressive democratic and civic strength; fortunately. At the right moment, I will analyze why some political leaders seem to have the temptation to elevate, to overact, and to provoke an effect, yes, in what is the political debate, of a tone of certain exaggeration in the tension.

Q.- I was reviewing the twenty-eight Bills for this session and I did not see, at first glance, any that referred to foreign policy. In this sense, I wanted to know if, just as the Government intends to smooth relations with the Vatican with the appointment of a new Ambassador, in this case Mr. Vázquez, will there be any gesture or any kind of similar shift in another direction regarding the United States?

President.- Believe me, I do not have the perception that we need to make any shift or any change in our relationship with the United States, because the relationship is fluid. They know the discrepancies we have had, and there is a discrepancy, let’s say, from the outset, that has to do with the Iraq war, with the presence of Spanish troops in the Iraq war, and that is a decision and a situation that must be assimilated by both parties. In my opinion, it should be overcome, because it is the exercise of political coherence, of commitments, and of the will of the citizens, and a country like the United States and an Administration like that of a country like the United States must respect that.

From there, we work, I can assure you, with considerable intensity on many issues that certainly have positive effects for the relationship in the economic sphere, in the area of security, in the fight against terrorism, of course, and in many other areas.

Thank you very much.