Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

7 February 2006 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from opposition leader Rajoy on labor precariousness and the Catalan Statute agreement during a February 2006 control session.
Main themes
Job insecurity and employment quality, labor market reform, social dialogue, Statute of Catalonia negotiations, collective bargaining, workplace safety, gender equality, immigration integration, fiscal policy, autonomy and regional competencies, solidarity in financing
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,757
72nd percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
15.2
77th percentile
Syntax
3.45
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 47%46%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Geopolitical 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

82 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Mr. President, not only is job insecurity not being reduced, but it has increased over the past few months. We have agreed with you in the opposition to reject an economic model based on precariousness, based on low fiscal and environmental costs. On the contrary, we have also agreed during the Investiture to improve the quality of employment, because we were convinced that it affected not only the economic model but also profoundly impacted the social model: it affected the future of youth, it affected gender equality, it affected the integration of immigration, and it also affected what we can call the dignity of all, the dignity of having a job that does not cause such high workplace accidents.

However, we are seeing how the Government, far from defending the quality of employment at the negotiation table, increasingly defends cost-cutting and the flexibilization of layoffs. That is the majority position, as expressed today by the Vice President of the Government.

In that sense, what we ask of you, what we demand from the Government, is that it resumes its commitment to the quality of employment; that at the negotiation table it be active in reaching an agreement, to unfreeze the situation, and that, on the other hand, the Government achieves that during this Legislature, democracy also enters the companies. In short, Mr. President, just as in other matters, we request and demand that you personally assume the leadership of a strong commitment in social and labor matters.

President.- I reiterate that the objective is shared, and you have not refuted that the path is the right one. I can assure you that the Government seeks an agreement with the essential aim of turning precariousness into stability, and for that, as you can easily understand, it is necessary to unite the legitimate interests of employers and unions. We are working towards that. I reiterate, I believe that the objective will be achieved, and from there, we will make assessments.

But I want to remind you that in the process of social dialogue in less than two years, there have been twelve agreements between the Government, employers, and unions. Never in the last twenty-five years, in such a short period, have there been so many agreements on matters of dependency, pension increases, the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, yesterday on Training, very soon on equality, and I hope also on social protection and the labor market.

It will be a success of a policy to advance socially and labor-wise through dialogue between employers, unions, and the Government, looking at the interests especially of the most vulnerable and of workers who are in a precarious situation.

Response to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, in September 2005, you and Mr. Mas told us that you had reached an agreement on the Statute of Catalonia; four months later, in January 2006, you and Mr. Mas told us that you had reached another agreement on the Statute of Catalonia. I am not going to delve into the evident lack of seriousness that this implies or what it has of mocking the people, but I must ask you what agreement you reached, because the only thing we know is what the Convergència i Unió website says, which I do not know what value it has, or what a national newspaper's website says that you handed to us in a meeting held some time ago among the spokespersons. And we also know that Mr. Mas has said that "we will achieve our objectives by leaps or by stages."

Since you spoke to us about an agreement that you wanted to be stable for at least a generation, we would like to know if you truly reached an agreement, as you told us, and if that agreement is stable for a generation.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I appreciate the question, regardless of how original it may be. I want to tell you that I find it strange that you do not know or are not interested in the content of the agreement that Convergència i Unió, Iniciativa per Catalunya, and the Socialist Party of Catalonia have reached with the majority of the Socialist Group, with the majority of this Chamber, because from the very first moment they have been qualifying and disqualifying it. Therefore, I am surprised how they can qualify or disqualify something they claim not to know in its contents.

But beyond that, I will tell you that the agreement meets the objectives set for promoting autonomy and statutory reform for this legislature, for Catalonia and for other Autonomous Communities, based on an increase in competencies to improve the management of public services before citizens and based on a modernization of what the reform of the financing model should be, which incorporates greater responsibility to the Autonomous Communities, and therefore greater possibilities based on their management, while maintaining solidarity as a key element of the financing system.

Moreover, the agreement innovates formulas for bilateral relations between, in this case, the Generalitat and the State, which will benefit the management of the competencies of both Administrations, because we will advance in promoting cooperation.

Of course, all parliamentary processing will take place, with the debate, in which I hope you will participate constructively, as is your usual style, in what represents the search for broad consensus for the Statute of Catalonia and for all Statutes that may be processed in this Legislature or the next, which is the Government's desire, and I would like it to be the desire of your Group as well, at least on some occasions.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I will tell you what I know: you and Mr. Mas have agreed twice, they have agreed on two different things. They have not told us, today they have not told us either, and the only thing we know is what two contradictory websites say.

I will give you an example that occurred yesterday and that is really revealing of what is happening in Spain at this moment. You two have reached an agreement --you have told us so-- on the financing of the Autonomous Communities. Mr. Homs, from Convergència i Unió, has said that this means for Catalonia, in one year, 5.128 billion euros; Mr. Maragall, 3 billion; the Convergència website, 4.310 billion; Mr. Durán, who knows; yesterday Mr. Solbes, in the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy, only said that this agreement does not bind him, because that is an agreement between parties and that he is not to blame for the fact that the Secretary General of the PSOE lives in La Moncloa, and Mr. Sevilla said that the financing agreement had nothing to do with what you had agreed with Mr. Mas.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, whom should we believe? You, Convergència i Unió, the websites, or Mr. Solbes? I have it clear: I do not believe you. I lost confidence in you a long time ago. Others will be able to verify it in the coming dates.

What I do tell you is that what you are doing on this issue and on the issue of ETA is a disgrace, for which I hope you will soon regret.

President.- Look, Mr. Rajoy, I have not lost confidence in you, because trust is the basis of respect in democracy, and I have a lot of respect for you because ten million citizens voted for you and eleven million for the Socialist Party.

I want to tell you that you were aware and an architect of a new financing model in...

Response to the question posed by Mr. Joan Puigcercós, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Puigcercós.- Does the President of the Government consider that the agreement reached in Moncloa regarding the Catalan Statute, specifically regarding the financing aspect, will be a good solution to the problem faced by the most vulnerable sectors today in Catalonia?

President.- As Mr. Puigcercós well knows, this country has been able to build a Welfare State with important social benefits that, fortunately, have only one horizon, to improve, and that have been improving very intensely in the last two years, with the action of the Government and with the parliamentary support that the action of the Government receives, throughout the territory, for all citizens of this country.

To give you an example regarding the Autonomous Community you are interested in, which is Catalonia, I will tell you that the Welfare State has not only maintained its financing but has improved; for example, with 550 million euros more for additional financing for Health that this Government promoted; for example, with 270,000 pensioners on minimum pensions in Catalonia who have had an increase double the average of pensions; for example, with the 67 million euros that Catalonia has received for the social integration of immigrants in education and social policy; or, for example, with the increase, as a result of the new Housing Plan, which goes from 392 million for housing in Catalonia to 855 million.

We are improving the Welfare State throughout the country and in Catalonia. The objective of the reform of the financing model will undoubtedly be for the Autonomous Communities to have sufficient resources to guarantee and improve the Welfare State in Catalonia and throughout Spain. I am convinced that you are also motivated by this being the case throughout the territory and in all Autonomous Communities, and that it be under a principle of solidarity, because that corresponds to a progressive force like the one you represent.

Mr. Puigcercós.- Do not doubt it, in line with what Mr. Llamazares said, pushing towards the left and pushing towards solidarity: pensions and the immigration fund. Remember that it was a proposal from our Parliamentary Group.

But the reality is that in Catalonia, a work of more than two years has been established to create a Statute, and it had an essence and a backbone, which was financing. This financing had to largely remedy the fiscal deficit that Catalonia carries, a fiscal deficit that weighs on the most vulnerable sectors of Catalan society, the "zapateros" and the "rodríguezes" of Catalonia as well, who today have problems finding public daycare; the teachers in Catalonia in public schools, who have problems coping with the impact they have received, the influx of new immigrant-origin population, and the waiting lists in Catalan hospitals, unmatched in other Communities. We sincerely believe that this proposal does not solve it.

This is a proposal that we believe is more of the same, as Mr. Piqué said, and some of the proposals or reactions from the Popular Party are out of place.

Mr. Piqué, the "torero" of last year, presented a model that far exceeded the current agreed model. It perfectly responds to a strategy of weariness from the Popular Party, but they know that they have no reason. Mr. Rodríguez Ibarra said it; he was satisfied because the model did not solve the problems, in this case, that it seemed to pose the Parliament of Catalonia. It is more of the same.

We will continue working in the working group, in the Commission, and in the Senate with a constructive and positive sense to reach an agreement. We sincerely believe that the financing of Catalonia must improve in the Statute to reduce the fiscal deficit and to guarantee equal opportunities for all.

But in reality, in our opinion --and the figures are eloquent-- there are sectors in Catalonia, among the workers of Catalonia, regardless of their language, regardless of where they were born but who are Catalans, because Catalan identity is a right, and we recognize it as a left-wing and Catalan party, that we sincerely believe are not well treated.

We will work, I repeat, to ensure that this Statute and its financing improve the living conditions of the workers of Catalonia.

President.- I believe that at this point we have enough experience to know that in the evolution of reforms in autonomous financing, all have tended towards two factors: one, to improve the financing of the Autonomous Communities, and that improvement is largely dependent on the growth capacity of the Autonomous Community itself and on the factors that have been introduced in the reform.

You know that the Government, and the majority that supports it, believes that there are new factors, such as immigration, that must be an important reference in that financing reform. And this Group will always be...

Response to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran i Lleida.- Mr. President, aware that we have publicly expressed, both Mr. Mas and I, that this is the Statute for our generation, I would like to ask you a question, convinced that the Statute has its constitutional channel in the Constitutional Commission.

We are concerned about inflation for two reasons: because it affects the competitiveness of our companies and because it affects the purchasing power of citizens. We closed the year with 3.7 percent when the forecast was 2 percent; we have the highest inflation in Europe, surpassed only by two recently incorporated countries, and that affects, I insist, the competitiveness of our companies and also affects the purchasing capacity of millions of workers who do not have revision clauses, of many workers who do not have a collective agreement, and of about two and a half million self-employed workers.

What do you and the Government plan to do, especially when you are also raising the rates of electricity, gas, or butane, to contain the negative effects on citizens and on the productive economy of our country regarding inflation?

President.- Mr. Durán, the Government shares your Group's concern about the rise in inflation that has occurred in recent months, particularly in January. It is true that it is the only element of the macroeconomic framework that presents worrying aspects, given that we have a growth of 3.5 percent in 2005; we have created nearly a million jobs in 2005, and we have, for the first time in history, a fiscal surplus in 2005 of more than 1 percent of GDP. Surplus and fiscal rigor must undoubtedly yield results in the medium term for controlling inflation.

As you know very well, in 2005 the price of oil increased by 40 percent, and you also know, as we do, the energy dependence that our country has. You also know that there have been related factors that have affected agriculture and have caused an evident impact on certain food prices.

Even so, I can announce to you, Mr. Durán i Lleida, that the Government is studying new measures, such as the one that the Minister of Industry made public yesterday, to promote further liberalization in the energy sector, which will involve various aspects that the Government will agree upon and announce in the coming weeks.

But beyond that, I must tell you that the Government has estimates according to which inflation will moderate throughout the year and will improve substantially.

Mr. Duran i Lleida.- I remember that similar expressions about moderation were also used by the Vice President of Economy in the presentation of the 2005 Budgets, not 2006, and they not only did not moderate, but actually increased.

I urge the President of the Government to undertake a real tax reform that can truly imply a reduction in the tax burden on our companies; that you do not increase the prices of water, gas, electricity, or basic services; that you can promote a reduced VAT for these basic products and that, at the same time, you can create a professional diesel that is cheaper for the transport sector, for agriculture, for fishing… in short, that can positively impact citizens.

President.- I have just announced that the economic Vice President is studying various measures to address what has been the rise in inflation, and some of them may align with what you have previously pointed out. But I believe it is fair to recognize, even based on the forecasts that may have existed for the year 2005 in the presentation of the Budgets for that exercise, for the past exercise, how the evolution of oil prices has been, which, evidently, was not predictable.

But even so, we share your concern, and of course, the Government will adopt various initiatives in the coming weeks to improve inflation and prices in our country, and not harm the competitiveness and economic growth of the Spanish economy.