Press conference of the President of the Government and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 October 2006 · Press conference following the bilateral meeting between the President of the Government of Spain and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy · Palacio de La Moncloa, Spain

Context
Zapatero held a joint press conference with Italian PM Romano Prodi at the Palacio de La Moncloa on 15 October 2006, ahead of the informal EU Summit in Lahti.
Main themes
Spain-Italy bilateral relations, European Union integration, immigration policy, Mediterranean cooperation, economic and trade relations, FRONTEX and border control, European welfare economy, Africa-Europe development, EU foreign policy, Lahti European Council summit
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,273
88th percentile
Sentences
176
86th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

176 sentences in 69 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. First of all, I want to thank Romano Prodi for being here in Spain, at the Palacio de La Moncloa. You know that Romano Prodi is an old friend of Spain and, as a former President of the European Commission, he knows our country very well and the challenges that both Governments share; Governments of two pro-European countries, linked by a bond as powerful as the vision of the south, the Mediterranean vision, and that we have, consequently, many common issues to address.

These issues have been the subject of the dialogue we had this morning, which also served to prepare for the bilateral Summit that we will have here, in our country, specifically in the Balearic Islands, in January, which have mainly affected the moment and the future of the European Union, immigration policy, and issues related to the bilateral sphere, especially our economic relations.

I want to remind you that there is a shared commitment on the part of both progressive Governments to boost the European Union, to boost our economic relations and our trade exchanges. I will recall that Italy is the third largest economy from which Spain imports and also the third to which we export; moreover, three million Spanish tourists visit us each year and already more than one and a half million Spaniards spend their holidays in Italy.

As you know, our companies are growing and have interests outside our borders. Italy is one of the most competitive countries in the world. It also has significant investments in our country and we want that bridge of communication, of trade relations and investments to grow, to increase.

Around the European Union, we have a coincidence on the three objectives that lie ahead. First, the European Union must lead the functioning of the European welfare economy, making our economies strong, competitive, innovative, generating employment and ensuring social cohesion.

Secondly, the European Union must play an active role in the world because, to a large extent, the welfare, security, and trust of all Europeans depend on what happens outside our borders; first and foremost, with the issue of migratory movements, with immigration.

Immigration, we have fully agreed, is a European issue. The best proof is that Italy and Spain experience it in a similar dimension, as do other countries; but perhaps a good example is Italy and Spain. It is a European issue and, therefore, it must have a common response from the European Union. That is the process we are in and, without a doubt, Italy and Spain will expedite, intensify, the effort to ensure that immigration is, above all, a European issue.

It is fundamentally a European issue because it concerns the economic relationship and the development relationship of two continents: the European continent and the African continent; that is why it has a foundation of a European nature. And it must be a European issue because, as Europe has demonstrated, whenever it has the political determination to do things united, the results are much more positive for all citizens on any issue. Whenever we act united in foreign policy, as for example in Lebanon, things go well.

Therefore, it is essential that there is unity, determination, and assumption regarding immigration on the part of the European Union. That will be the message we put on the table this week, at the informal Summit in Lahti, at the European Council, and it will be the shared commitment.

I want to take this opportunity to thank Romano Prodi and the Italian Government for their effective, material collaboration in the project and in the resources that FRONTEX has made available to our country, especially in controlling the Canary Islands' coasts, which, as you know, have been subject to strong migratory pressure.

In short, Spain and Italy currently have the responsibility, as pro-European countries, to make Europe function and advance more united every day. That is the security of our progress and the security of our welfare. And on the bilateral level, we have a clearly positive expectation, as Mediterranean countries, to take a joint look at the Mediterranean in the line of cooperation, dialogue, and seeking fruits related to cohesion and the balance of expectations and possibilities between the North and the South.

A useful, very positive meeting, therefore. And, of course, I reiterate my gratitude to Romano Prodi for our ability to share principles and objectives of two countries that are, of course, fundamental in the context of the European Union.

Mr. Prodi.- I want to sincerely thank the Spanish Prime Minister for the warm and friendly welcome he has extended, just as our dialogue has been cordial and friendly. Truly, these are two countries that have common objectives and that are carrying out a common strategy. Today we have begun to work on the common strategy and the common objectives have already been largely explained by the President of the Government.

I add that regarding the issue of immigration as a European fact, I repeat, it is a European problem and, as such, we will begin to talk about it at the Summit this week and then, operationally, in December, it is also about cooperating among ourselves in all cases where it is necessary. We must, in fact, begin to demonstrate that this is a problem for our entire continent, because immigrants arrive in all our countries. And we must present it to Africa in a united way, that is, help the African Union to collectively address this problem, because it cannot be resolved from country to country. Therefore, we need a series of initiatives, also in Africa, to help this process, to organize it, and to make it coherent with our objectives.

It is clear, immigration is not a temporary or casual fact; it is a systematic phenomenon of our society. Therefore, we must face it with all the necessary cooperation.

We have also talked about a common Mediterranean policy. For me, this is a matter of great importance. I am very pleased that we have shared this.

Moreover, I have often emphasized the great importance of Asian development that is changing and transforming the world. In this area, we might seem like competitors. In part, we are also, as our ports can be considered competitors; but, above all, we have common interests.

The Mediterranean has not yet reached the role, the function, the weight, that it must have; therefore, the interests of Spain and Italy are common interests. In this way, we will work because this is a problem of strategic repositioning in the context of the European continent.

This refers to the discourse of common European commitment and on this we have had no problems. We will prepare for the Summit in which we will emphasize and recall the plus that the common European policy provides us. The President Rodríguez Zapatero has already said that when we work together, as has happened in Lebanon, we have results. It is clear that this should make us think about our unity also in the future development of policy in the Middle East and, above all, in thinking together about a greater European role in the world.

We are center-left Governments, with a strong social commitment, with a strong commitment to balance in the redistribution of income in our countries, and we have exchanged, also in this area, experiences and also results of our common work.

I have personally welcomed with great satisfaction the continuation and progress of negotiations with ETA for peace, which is fundamental for the future development of the country, peace that also favors the international context, for this sense of belonging to a single reality in which these problems can be resolved with a spirit of cooperation. We advocate that this can continue and that the progress made so far can be consolidated and become definitive.

This has been our dialogue that will end in concrete initiatives in the near future.

We have also addressed bilateral issues and issues that are also evidently in the press; for example, Autostrade-Abertis. We have talked not only about the very important issues at the international level but also about economic issues that currently affect the countries. I have reiterated that the Autostrade-Abertis issue does not minimally affect our relations. There is no, by far, the idea of discrimination. It is not an Italian-Spanish problem, but an Italian-Italian problem.

We will also move forward on these issues in the future and we will be able to address them with absolute openness and cooperation.

We have also obviously addressed all the issues related to energy, which is another chapter in which both countries are experiencing strategic changes and movements; but, above all, they have the great problem of energy autonomy for the future. This will be addressed, of course, in a few days, three or four days, at the Summit we will have in Finland and we will arrive at this Summit with a common position so as not to be overwhelmed by suppliers on whom we depend completely and not with an isolated strategy.

Q.- I wanted to ask President Prodi. You said that you have talked about the situation of the center-left Governments and the measures being taken. Has there been an exchange of advice also regarding some important issues? I refer to the labor market issue, which is a topic that is also being addressed in Spain.

Mr. Prodi.- It is true. We have exchanged, I repeat, not advice but experiences, which are even more important than advice. He has informed me about the type of agreements reached with the unions in recent times, about twenty agreements on specific problems, and I have presented the strategy that we have with the budget law. Naturally, we also start from very different positions. From an economic point of view, there is a notable, strong surplus in Spain's accounts, while in Italy there is a need for adjustment. But the experiences reach a common point: that is, without concertation, our two countries will not achieve the changes we want for the modernization of the economy and politics in our countries. That is, different situations, common methodology, and common objective.

Q.- I wanted to ask you about immigration and the joint initiative that you want to present in Lahti. I would like to know what the keys to that joint initiative are, whether there is any novel proposal or if it will simply be limited to insisting again on the message that this is a problem for the entire European Union and must be addressed collectively. I would also like to know if it is confirmed that France will join this initiative that you are going to present.

To President Rodríguez Zapatero, I would like to ask about this rejection that you say you have or would have to enter the G-8. I would like to know if you think it is an excessively neoliberal club or if you believe it is necessary for it to be expanded to four or five more countries and become a G-13 or G-14.

Mr. Prodi.- I will respond to the first part, regarding the issue of immigration. We have no intention of making only general proposals. There is a problem of resources that we need to put together to work in collaboration with the African Union and with the countries from which immigrants come. It is clear that we need to work to coordinate the regulation of migratory flows, regulated flows that can and should not be obstructed, but regulated, and a joint effort against irregular and clandestine flows.

We have also addressed the fact that on many of these issues there is still no common European competence. Justice and Home Affairs are still the competence of each State, so in the problems that affect immigration we should work to make them a competence at the European level; therefore, strengthen the operational, administrative, and financial capacity of the Agency for the Control of External Borders, commonly known as FRONTEX, and strengthen cooperation among all for the external border control.

We also have the objective, and this was initially a French proposal, shared by all, to create training or labor analysis structures in the countries from which immigrants come to be able to know the demand and supply of those countries.

This is not a separate task. The letter to the President of the European Commission was signed by Italy, Spain, France, Greece, Turkey, Cyprus, and Slovenia. So, we already have seven countries that have taken a common initiative to bring it to the European Summit. It is clear that there are some points, such as the pooling of competences regarding migrations, that require a reform of the decision-making process of the European Union and that cannot be done in the short term, but there are other aspects that can be addressed in the short term.

President.- Regarding the two questions you raised, first of all, the European Union and immigration policy must have three perspectives, which are the objectives we will bring to the Lahti Summit and, of course, to the Council in December: first, cooperation of the European Union with the countries of origin and transit of immigration, and cooperation at different levels: cooperation in development aid; cooperation in channeling investments, through the financial instruments that the European Union can mobilize, and cooperation in what represents the proper channeling of migratory flows. This will require resources and organization.

Therefore, the first idea is cooperation, because we debate a lot about whether to regularize here or not to regularize, when what we should be doing is being in the debate and prioritizing that so many human beings who are in despair have minimal expectations of regularizing their lives. Surely, if we put much more effort and much more political action into regularizing the expectations of many citizens, we would not have debates that, sometimes, I sincerely believe do not put our model of coexistence in the best light.

Second, border control. The European Commission must hold all countries accountable in a common task of border control, both in terms of the control of the borders of those countries that have the most direct accessibility, as well as in cooperation for the control of the borders of those countries of origin and transit.

And, thirdly, obviously, resources, financial and budgetary availability for immigration matters in all the areas I have just mentioned.

Regarding the G-8 question, I believe that experience should serve us, and I think that each President should learn from the experiences that have come before. I remember that there was a President, the previous President, who set the goal of entering the G-8. He announced it with great fanfare, and then I don't know if there was frustration on someone's part; but, certainly, I think we should be cautious in a matter like this. I reject nothing; I simply say that at this moment it is not part of the Government's priority objectives, because things, if they are to happen, will happen naturally.

I have, of course, a great deal of respect for what the G-8 represents, although we are already among the top eight from the perspective of economic strength and economic creation in the world, in the international order.

Q.- Mr. Prodi said yesterday in "El País" that Europe has serious problems in the energy sector. What problems do you foresee? Do you think they will be resolved with larger and cross-border companies? And how do you foresee cooperation between Italy and Spain on the matter, for example, that international mergers can now also take place in a very strategic sector?

Mr. Prodi.- Let us distinguish the problems. From a general point of view, it is clear that an alternative and diversified energy policy is necessary; but Europe has an extraordinary problem: if it does not have a common energy policy, it will be crushed by suppliers. We already have an increasing dependence on natural gas, inevitable, for ecological reasons and for a thousand other issues. It is not just a matter of price; it is also a matter of supply security. Each country individually has no possibility of escaping this trap.

As President of the European Commission, I proposed a Euro-Russian Summit on these problems three times. Once it was the Russians, another time the Europeans… I never managed to have a common policy that Europe absolutely must have, and it must also have it regarding alternative energies.

The effort being made is an increasing effort, and Spain is a good example in this field, but it is not a sufficient effort for the future. The energy problem will become increasingly dramatic, and let us not forget last winter.

This is in reference to the European issue. Regarding our bilateral relations, we have intense relations in the energy field, more Spain in Italy than Italy in Spain. This is a sign of coincidence, but also of market openness. We welcomed Endesa; if you ask me if I am German, I am not; that is another problem, and the investments have been large investments, of high quality, in the Italian energy system. It is true that, if you want my opinion, in the case of absolute freedom of choice for the protagonists, I would wish for a much closer, much stronger relationship between Italian companies and Spanish companies, not for a theoretical reason, but because there is a true common interest in supply and also in the strategy to lower costs or actions in third markets, which is very important.

I believe in synergy spaces, but it is not politics that should do it; it is the companies that need to find them.

President.- In this regard, we have three or four challenges ahead in energy policy. One is of a general nature, affecting the world, the growing demand and a supply that must guarantee this demand, especially for the European Union. Therefore, the first major problem: supply guarantee.

Second, we have a problem of electrical interconnection in the European Union; certainly, it affects Spain in a very singular way.

Third, we have a problem arising from the inequality of size and regulations of our energy companies. There are some countries, like Spain, that have the entire private sector and others that have a large public sector participation. Different regulations make it difficult to have a common energy policy in the European Union in a world where the trend is for energy companies to become larger and more powerful to competitively address the supply and demand problems we have.

Finally, but not least, we have the problem of a serious dependence, especially in some countries like Spain, on hydrocarbons. Therefore, the great challenge we have from the perspective of our innovative capacity, to maintain respect for what should be sustainable growth, is to make a much greater effort for renewable energies, for alternative energies, which will undoubtedly come from efforts in research, development, and innovation.

These are, nothing more and nothing less, than the four major problems that will only have a better solution in the short and medium term if Europe acts more united. Once again, this is the recipe; although we know that this is a matter that will entail enormous difficulties for that common policy in all four aspects I have just mentioned. But we need it. Europe must do it. Each country must commit to having that common policy because it will benefit our economies, our citizens, and sustainable development.

Q.- I would like more information about the Autostrade-Abertis operation. What are the advances? Can a bet be made on whether this marriage will happen by the end of the year or not?

From the perspective of energy, I would like to know if ENEL will have a free hand in Spain or not.

Mr. Prodi.- Details about what we have not said are very difficult to provide. As for a bet, as you said, the problem is not a closure regarding Spain, absolutely. So, from the perspective of what concerns Abertis, the traffic light is green.

President.- We are facing a matter that primarily affects companies. Governments must facilitate, help, channel, and we must respect what the process of companies is. If you ask me, as President of the Government of Spain, I obviously wish that an investment from Spanish companies culminates well with a country like Italy, always within the principle of cooperation and doing things with the appropriate understanding.

Regarding the Italian energy companies in our country, I believe that as long as things are done well, this is a country, as it has shown, that is open to cooperation in all areas and also in the energy field.

That is my position, but we are in the realm of companies. You know that we always move in a balance here, which is sometimes not easy, because the Government always has something to say regarding the regulatory framework or a series of circumstances, although the initiative and the consummation of those initiatives have a fundamentally business dimension. But anything that progresses in Spanish investments in Italy and Italian investments in Spain seems positive to me.

Q.- It seems that you have talked about the peace process here in Spain. I would like to know if the Government is expecting a statement from the terrorist group ETA in the coming weeks announcing its definitive cessation and also if, in any case, something can be negotiated with the terrorist group in view of the situation with "kale borroka."

If I may, given that you do not seem to have a candidate for the Mayor of Madrid yet, I would like to know if you would be willing for your Vice President to be the candidate.

President.- Regarding the first point, we are in a peace process, a process that effectively began with the permanent ceasefire of the ETA group, which has lasted a little over six months, after forty years of terrorist violence. Therefore, let us allow the process to follow its rhythms and take the necessary time to address a matter of this magnitude.

You know that the Government does not wait or stop waiting; the Government works only with three principles: the end of violence, of all violence, and any manifestation of violence is not positive for the peace process; the second principle, legality through which the entire peace process must flow; and, thirdly, agreement, dialogue, because we understand that this will be the best way for coexistence in Euskadi to overcome what has represented the horror of violence.

From there, surely there will not be news every day; it is very difficult for there to be news every day. Let us give time to time. The important thing is that the process flows, and from my point of view, with respect to all the opinions that may exist, from my point of view the process is flowing.

This is neither the place nor the time to talk about the Madrid candidacy. I will tell you that, when the time comes, which in any case you know must be before November 18, we will announce it closer to that date, because the proposal must be supported by the colleagues from Madrid, and we will do things well. We will do things better than we did in the last week.

Mr. Prodi.- I saw a cartoon in a Spanish newspaper, and I can assure you that I am not a candidate for Mayor of Madrid.

Q.- I had a question for Prime Minister Romano Prodi. Regarding Autostrade and Abertis, I would like to ask at this moment what is preventing the merger from being approved and what concessions or conditions would Italy like to see for it to be approved. Is it a matter of keeping the headquarters of the new company in Italy and having more Italian executives, or that the construction company ACS lowers its participation? And I would just add one last question: will you meet today or have you already met with the President of Abertis or other executives from Abertis?

Mr. Prodi.- The problem being discussed here is not the conditions of the merger, as these are established by the companies. It is the relationship of the concession to the Autostrade company and the respect of the conditions in such particular cases as a network of highways. But that has nothing to do with the conditions of the merger, which are established between the two companies.

I was not expected to meet with Abertis today. I will not do so, but, obviously, there is no problem in having a meeting; but at this moment we prefer that the matter be between the companies. From a political point of view, there is no problem.

As I said earlier to the President of the Government, in the case of BNL, after a long period in which Italy has had a certain policy, we are absolutely open, and it is the market that decides. It has decided towards a French company, but there has been neither the slightest desire nor the slightest Italian action to prevent BNL from going to a Spanish company. Let this be absolutely clear.

The relationships of reciprocal investments are good, and at this moment it is Spain that is investing in Italy, and at other times it was Italy that invested in Spain. But in the long term, the relationships are good, and, for the reasons we have heard before, in my opinion, in many sectors we would like to have more intense relationships for our common interest.

President.- Thank you very much.