Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

19 October 2006 · Informal European Council · Lahti, Finland

Context
Zapatero addressed press following the informal European Council in Lahti, Finland on October 19, 2006, reporting on discussions of immigration, energy, and innovation.
Main themes
European Union immigration policy, FRONTEX border control, energy policy, innovation, EU common policy, cooperation with African countries, irregular immigration management, demographic change, EU enlargement and consensus, integration and diversity
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,672
83rd percentile
Sentences
119
71st percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
15.2
78th percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
1.93
5th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

119 sentences in 52 paragraphs

President.- Thank you very much for attending this briefing. I want to report on what has been the development of this informal European Council here in the city of Lahti, Finland, which, as you know, had three essential topics for discussion and idea contribution: immigration, energy, and innovation, perhaps three of the most important issues facing the entire European Union.

I will start with immigration. As you know, the Finnish Presidency tasked me at the time with preparing an introductory report to analyze the evolution of the migratory phenomenon and the European Union's policy in response to this crucial challenge.

As you are well aware, for approximately a year now, since the Hampton Court Summit, the global strategy on immigration has been the note we have sought to promote so that the European Union and European institutions adopt a progressively stronger common policy and a global strategy.

The debate we had today highlighted some points of high interest. First of all, we are facing a structural phenomenon, immigration, in the European Union, in a continent with an aging population, a high level of development, and which undoubtedly needs and will need immigrants, but those it needs and will need must come in an orderly and legal manner. Ultimately, behind the phenomenon of immigration, we not only have a challenge of inequality between a developed continent like Europe and a continent in a situation of great fragility from an economic and social perspective, like Africa, but we also have a challenge to govern citizenship, to manage a whole process of integration, diversity, and demographic change in our societies.

The first objective I conveyed today in the informal meeting of the European Council was to take a step forward so that the European Union has an increasingly common policy on immigration. In the past year, steps have been taken, but many remain to be taken; there is still much work ahead. Why does the European Union need to take more responsibility for the migratory phenomenon every day? For a very obvious reason: because the borders are common, the labor market is common, and consequently, common responses are required from the European Union.

Today's debate will serve for the European Council in December to approve a communication from the Commission regarding new measures to address the three major elements we face regarding the migratory phenomenon, which are cooperation, control, and integration.

As you know, in recent months we have promoted various initiatives related to control and cooperation; border control with the implementation, still in its early stages, of FRONTEX through the bilateral collaboration of various States. Certainly, today as a first point, we have decisively supported, together with other countries, the strengthening of the budget and resources of FRONTEX. For this, there must be a commitment from the States, a commitment that must be driven by the Commission itself, but in which, logically, each State must provide resources for the management of maritime borders.

In addition, we have proposed a new cross-information system for border control; a database, a system that advances through a database on the control of irregular immigrants, and a common policy that creates European information offices in third countries with a dual objective: to disrupt the strategy of the mafias and to inform about the real and legal job opportunities. The goal is ambitious but essential. Those who wish to come to Europe to work must knock on the door and enter in an orderly manner; they cannot come in any way, without more, and disorderly.

I want to emphasize that in the debate there were several interventions, essentially from the countries that jointly signed a letter for this European Council, from Portugal, France, Italy, Greece, and Malta; interventions that all supported the set of initiatives I proposed today to the European Council and that, without a doubt, will allow us to have, formally and effectively, in December, after the Commission's communication, new initiatives that contribute to both the aspect related to border control and cooperation with the countries of origin and transit, particularly with Africa and especially with sub-Saharan Africa.

I want to say that there has been a common interest and an absolute consensus among the Twenty-Five, of course from the Commission and also from the European Parliament, because José Borrell had an extraordinary intervention, highlighting on behalf of the European Parliament that the phenomenon of immigration requires as soon as possible an effective, in-depth involvement of all European institutions and support from the Twenty-Five to advance in a common European policy on immigration. And he provided a very detailed review of what these last seven years have been since the Tampere Summit in this area, the need to recover much lost time regarding immigration, and the necessity that the will to create common policies is the only path that will allow us to strengthen the means, instruments, legislation, cooperation, development, and dialogue with Africa, which is essential.

As I mentioned, the Council has addressed two other issues: technological innovation and energy policy. Regarding technological innovation, since the so-called Lisbon Strategy, there has been a desire to turn the European Union into a laboratory of innovation and to make this area of progress a benchmark that leads to economic growth based on technological effort, the promotion of talent, and the capacity to innovate.

As you know, Spain is committed to this effort. Today, three specific issues were analyzed in the context of the idea debate, as is appropriate in an informal Council. Specifically, the willingness that the Commission has expressed to advance on the already well-known project of the community patent, with the aim of reducing costs and being able to promote innovation; also the creation of a European Technology Institute, which has received a boost from the entire Council: a European Technology Institute so that the best researchers can yield the best results in innovation and a European Technology Institute to serve as a motor, a leader, a tractor for the entire research that the countries of the Union, the Twenty-Five, are carrying out.

Energy challenge. As you know, we are going to hold a meeting with President Putin in which this matter will occupy a prominent place; but beyond the meeting with President Putin and the relationship between the European Union and Russia, I wanted to emphasize that there has also been a clear, decisive willingness, already expressed in some other European Council, regarding the imperative need for two objectives from the common European policy in the field of energy.

The first of these is to strengthen the guarantee and, therefore, provide more security in energy supply. Here, Russia, but also Algeria, has occupied a preferred place. As a consequence of what Russia and Algeria or some other country, like Norway, represent in energy supply and as an absolutely essential consequence for the Iberian Peninsula, the need to advance much more rapidly in electrical interconnections has been highlighted.

Therefore, the first issue is security of supply, guarantees, balance, interconnection, and the second issue, perhaps as important or more than the first: the challenge that our energy in the short, medium, and long term is increasingly renewable and clean energy. If there is one thing that is directly related to the productive process and the energy we use at the moment, it is that the challenges of climate change are accelerating. This is evidenced by the best studies, the most advanced research from the scientific world.

And, as the risk of the climate challenge accelerates, the responsibility that governments and the European Union have is decisive to accelerate an increasingly environmentally friendly energy policy, with the risks of climate change, and therefore much more active in promoting renewable energies and energy efficiency, where, by the way, there are countries within the European Union that are yielding very favorable and positive data and results.

In short, immigration, energy, and innovation all require not only good ideas, good proposals, and good studies, as in the case of climate change; they all require, above all, European will, common will, and Europeanist will. And I hope that this Council, which I believe has had a fairly positive development, can translate into concrete initiatives and joint action programs in the December Council.

Q.- I am going to ask you about a topic that is not exactly the Council, although it is European, and that is your opinion on the support that the European People's Party expressed yesterday for the position of the People's Party in the so-called peace process. So, I wanted to know how you assess that support, the prospects it opens for the vote on Wednesday, and if you even think that the time has come to try to reach a consensus on a resolution with the PP, to change the proposal that is already on the table or, even in the extreme, to withdraw it.

And a small addition is on the topic of immigration: has the proposal from Mr. Mas to introduce a points card for immigrants been taken into account or discussed in any way?

President.- No. To that, I must say clearly no, and I also believe that in no case would it be...

Regarding the first question, I want to say that I have, of course, respect for the positions of the different Parliamentary Groups in the European Parliament. I want to express my position, and my position is one of maximum availability for there to be an agreement in the European Parliament. This has been the disposition of the Socialist Group, because I believe it would be positive, and certainly, the peace process, the more agreements it has, the better for its development. The less it is used in partisan contention, the better, and from that perspective, it would be very positive for us to leave the peace process alone, to let it proceed naturally, which will be, as I have said many times, long and will require a lot of work from us.

Q.- I understand that you also proposed a review of Maritime Humanitarian Law. I would like you to explain a little more about this proposal.

And returning to the topic of Mr. Artur Mas's proposal, I wanted to know if you essentially share what he proposes, that access for immigrants to social services and residency facilities should be conditioned, in some way, on their effort to adapt or knowledge of languages.

President.- I learned about the proposal today, and therefore, I cannot make a thorough analysis. What I have seen in the initial messages I do not like, I do not like it at all. I believe that is not the way.

Regarding the first, one of the proposals is to study everything related to the regulation of International Law concerning the sea to see if there is any possibility of facilitating or improving what are, on the one hand, humanitarian requirements and, on the other, the necessary control that States must carry out at their borders. But it is a proposal for study by the European institutions, which logically must have a clear reference and leadership in this.

Q.- President, you have spoken about the support that Spain has received, of course, from the eight countries on the Mediterranean shore that made the joint letter; but I would like to know how you have perceived the attitude of other Heads of State or Government from countries further away from the Mediterranean regarding the problem that Spain has, specifically, with the Canary Islands.

President.- I want to emphasize that there are several countries that have a problem similar to that of Spain regarding the Canary Islands. I believe it was the Greek Prime Minister who spoke of 25,000 attempts at illegal entry so far this year in his country. Consequently, there is a clear awareness among the twenty-five countries, a special sensitivity in all southern or Mediterranean countries, and at this moment, from my point of view, a clear political will on the part of the Parliament, I will speak for the order of the will I have seen, of the Commission, and of course, the Council for Europe to reinforce means, measures, and initiatives towards Africa and, of course, to push all Member States to provide those absolutely necessary means for the institutions of the Union itself.

Q.- I have two questions. The first relates to the Summit, and the second does not. Many of us have the impression that the European Union, in addition to paying the high bill, in cash, to Russia, buys gas from this country in exchange for silence. I would like to know if anyone at dinner will remind Mr. Putin that human rights exist even in Russia, that laughing at a violator is committing a crime, and that, ultimately, the lives of journalists should also be valued in the Russian social stock market.

On the other hand, it has nothing to do with the Summit. It has been three years, I believe, since the start of the war in Iraq, two and a half years since the decision to withdraw troops, and in the meantime, the country is as it is; that is to say, only the gravediggers have guaranteed stable work in that country. On the other hand, Italy and the United Kingdom have already set a deadline for their military presence in Iraq, and even President Bush and his military commanders acknowledge that the situation is unsustainable and are already comparing it to Vietnam. What is your analysis, and do you believe that the International Community, what we call the International Community, should continue to look the other way regarding Iraq?

President.- Regarding the first question, I can confirm that in the meeting we are about to have with President Putin, we will talk about energy, but we will also talk about democracy, human rights, and freedom of the press, without a doubt. This has been a will expressed overwhelmingly by the members of the European Council and with a specific mandate to the President of the Council, the Prime Minister of Finland, and certainly also to the President of the Commission, José Manuel Barroso, to act in that direction.

Regarding Iraq, like many political leaders and millions of citizens, I want to express my deep concern about the situation in Iraq. According to the latest information, there have been 600,000 deaths since the military intervention began, a hundred deaths every day. I am not surprised that practically all countries and all leaders are talking about a profound change in strategy. I am not surprised at all, and surely many people will not be surprised that I am not surprised, after the positions I have defended on this matter.

Q.- I wanted to know if your political calculations lead us to say that we can count on the possible opening of the party table starting at the beginning of the year or, at least, once the methodology is established, which seems to be what is currently being discussed, there will be a first preparatory meeting to start working next year.

President.- The peace process and the political future of the Basque Country, I have said on many occasions, require prudence, time, and not anticipating events. Certainly, regarding political dialogue, as is known, the position of the Government and my position is that it is absolutely essential that we advance in what represents the basic objective of Spanish society and Basque society, which is the end of violence, the final point of ETA. That is the priority direction in which we are going to work.

Q.- I wanted to know if in your speech you have evoked the issue of unaccompanied minor immigrants. What do you expect from the European Union, what could the European Union do on this issue? I also wanted to know if any of the European partners have told you whether they will finally provide more resources to the FRONTEX operation that continues in Africa and the Canary Islands, and until when it can be extended?

President.- Yes, we have referred to the issue of minors. I believe that the European Union must become aware of the scope of what this represents; by the way, another Southern country has also referred to this issue in its speech, and we are convinced that the European Union will establish means that represent cooperation and solidarity with countries, like Spain, mainly Spain, that have to attend, as is obligatory and logical, to the arrival of unaccompanied minor immigrants.

There has been some country that has already expressed specifically, not publicly in the meeting, but privately, the willingness to provide, to make available, resources for the strengthening of FRONTEX. I want to tell you that the will of the Government of Spain is that FRONTEX, of course, remains for as long as possible with the horizon of working in a scenario where we have a permanent coastal surveillance system at maritime borders.

Q.- I wanted to insist a little on a previous question. What is your opinion on Mr. Putin's statements regarding envying the Israeli President accused of rape, considering that you will be sitting down to dinner with him tonight as a privileged partner?

President.- I have hardly had the opportunity to know about that... It was just now, when I entered, that I was given a comment, but I cannot believe that this could be the case, just like that.

Q.- I wanted to ask you, within the peace process, if you trust that Batasuna will take the necessary steps for its legalization.

President.- I understand that the peace process is a matter of great significance, but I reiterate and ask you to be patient.

The principles are established, and the channels for things to go well are known: the principle of legality, the rule of law, dialogue, and agreement. Those are the four principles, and we will be walking the path; surely, at times, with more ease; at others, with less; some, more quickly; others, more slowly. But there is time. Peace deserves time, calm, and prudence. After almost forty years of violence, it is logical that we give ourselves time for the final result to be a positive result, the one we all expect, the one we all desire.

Q.- I wanted to insist on this matter just to ask you if you maintain that philosophy you had at the beginning that first, peace, and then, politics, or do you believe that both paths can be walked in parallel, now seeing how progress has been made in these months.

And a second question, insisting on a previous question. I wanted to know if you have planned or thought of any strategy to communicate to the International Community or to European leaders to address the situation in Iraq, and if you think it is advisable for all the forces that are there to leave Iraq now.

President.- Regarding the first question, first, peace and then politics, among other things, because for me there is only politics without violence. The other is not politics. Politics and peace go hand in hand. And on more than one occasion, I have also said that the end of violence has no political price, but that politics can contribute to the end of violence. Ultimately, the Government has been carrying out a whole political initiative to try to fulfill the first duty that a Government has, which is that in its country, people are not killed for political reasons.

That there be no violence, that terror does not exist, the duty to preserve the life, security, and freedom of citizens; that is a whole political option and a whole political decision.

Regarding Iraq, we have seen that there have been reflections in recent times, in recent days, about what should be done. Certainly, it should correspond to the United Nations Security Council, in its case, to take initiatives. What I want to express clearly is that things have gone wrong, wrong for the International Community, wrong for the citizens of Iraq, and wrong for the Middle East, and I believe that the strategy must be changed as quickly as possible. Surely, in this, the vast majority of the International Community will agree.

Q.- I would like to return to the topic of energy. You have mentioned that the Council's intention is to bet on a future of clean and renewable energies. I would like you to analyze this a bit and how it is understood if the relationship with Russia is particularly strengthened, considering that the energy produced by Russia, which Russia sells, is polluting energy: gas and oil.

And a second question on this topic: if there has been time or will there be time to develop what I understand is the intention that the Presidency had to definitively address the opening of the discussion on nuclear energy in Europe.

President.- Regarding nuclear energy, there has not been time, that is the truth. There has been some comment, but very collateral, and therefore, we have not gone in-depth on that issue.

Regarding the first question, it is evident that the bet, at least in the terms in which I have expressed myself and some other Prime Minister and Head of State, is for clean, renewable, alternative energies if we want, to the extent that we can from the point of view of the capacity that each country has to promote that type of energy. To the extent that we can gain space, we will reduce space for energy from hydrocarbons; but, in the meantime, and decades will pass, as everyone knows, we need for our development, for our model of life, energy from hydrocarbons.

Now, as with everything, it will depend a lot on the political will and the effort that is wanted to be put in favor of alternative energy. Certainly, Spain will put it in. It has very clear ideas on this matter, moreover, in a country where we have a high energy dependence directly linked to hydrocarbons.

Thank you very much.