Press conference of the President of the Government, the Secretary-General of the United Nations, and the Prime Minister of Turkey after the conclusion of the work of the High-Level Group for the Alliance of Civilizations.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

12 November 2006 · Press conference after the conclusion of the work of the High-Level Group for the Alliance of Civilizations

Context
Zapatero, UN Secretary-General Annan, and Turkish PM Erdoğan held a press conference in November 2006 following the High-Level Group for the Alliance of Civilizations report presentation.
Main themes
Alliance of Civilizations, interfaith dialogue, follow-up implementation mechanism, religion and secularism, clash of civilizations, democratic society and religious freedom, Arab world engagement, intercultural coexistence
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,692
83rd percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

166 sentences in 57 paragraphs

P.- I would like to ask the Secretary-General if he has any mechanism or structure to implement the Alliance of Civilizations. Would he agree to preside over it?

Mr. Annan.- First of all, I would like to say that the report presented today is a report that we all must consider as our own, take ownership of, and realize that we are going to be part of its implementation to make it truly effective, so I would encourage everyone to take the report as their own and to work with us to put it into practice.

We have been discussing the creation of a follow-up mechanism, a Secretariat, and possibly also a High Representative who would work with that Secretariat and with other governments, NGOs, and other stakeholders. We have not yet decided exactly who that High Representative will be, but I believe we will be able to announce it very soon.

This is what I can say for now, and obviously, further discussion will be needed to decide who it will be. We are talking about it.

P.- I wanted to ask the Prime Minister of Turkey a question and another to President Rodríguez Zapatero. To Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero: how do you explain the absence of Arab media, as we are not seeing colleagues from Arab countries who should supposedly be the most interested in spreading this idea to their own countries?

To Mr. Erdogan, I would like to ask if he can talk to us, even if it is about Turkish domestic politics, about his plans to run for the Presidency of the Republic.

President.- You can understand that knowing the nationality and the list of accredited media is not within my specialties. I know that the Secretary-General of the Arab League is here, representing all Arab countries, and therefore, he is a good testimony to the interest that the Alliance of Civilizations has for the Arab world, for the Islamic world, for the Western world, and for anyone who wants to build, unite, and seek peace. That is the Alliance of Civilizations, and I am sure that it has great interest in all countries; of course, among Arab countries.

Mr. Annan.- I want to add that I know you have raised a question about Turkish domestic politics, and probably the Prime Minister will answer it later. In the meantime, I would suggest that you leave all such questions for the end, or if you raise them now, we will leave them for the end. First, we will address the issues related to the Alliance of Civilizations, which is the topic of this press conference, and once we have answered all the questions about the Alliance, we will address the rest of the questions within the thirty minutes we have for this press conference.

Mr. Erdogan.- If I may, I would like to say that the President of the Arab League, Mr. Amro Mousa, is here, and from the beginning of this work, the wife of the Emir of Qatar has also been present here. I am convinced that there are members of the press, and I have been able to see some. Do not worry in that regard.

P.- I wanted to ask both Heads of Government present here about the text proposed today. In this text, I see a strong defense of the role of religion and a call for understanding between religions, which is obviously always positive. My question is whether it would not also be necessary in these times to include a defense of secularism, which is a legacy of the Enlightenment and one of the hallmarks of European civilization.

President.- The text is a text for coexistence and a text for coexistence that starts from the analysis of a specific historical moment, the beginning of the 21st century, where one of the most important risk elements is the so-called clash of civilizations, which ultimately has a motive based on what a faith, a religion, or another religion represents. Hence, the analysis starts from the recognition of the religious fact, of the influence and importance of the religious fact, and of the respect and call for the encounter of what religious tolerance can represent, which, by the way, is part of a logically secular vision of what a democratic society represents.

The democratic society is, above all, freedom: religious freedom, freedom of worship, or the freedom not to believe. That is the democratic society, and the democratic thought recognizes today, at the beginning of the 21st century, that there is a religious fact that undoubtedly groups many people and that the different religious views or different creeds are one of the motives that can provoke confrontation and conflict.

Mr. Erdogan.- I agree with the response given by Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. We must also talk about another truth within the Alliance of Civilizations: we cannot speak of a separation based on whether one is secular or not. There can be secular people or secular states; however, when it comes to religion, we are still talking about atheists, and when we try to see it philosophically, we sometimes see that they have some belief. Some have said that atheism was also a religion, and some have spoken on this topic. What we want are dialogues between cultures and the union of religions.

As you know, Turkey is a democratic, secular country and a rule of law, and we cannot have any problem of this type with Spain, which is also secular.

P.- The Secretary-General has asked us to focus on the topic of the Alliance of Civilizations, but I have another question that I will also raise now, and you can answer it whenever you want. The report speaks of the impact of Western military operations in the Muslim world, and I would like to ask our guests if what they are asking for, let’s say, is an end to the American occupation in Iraq or if there is something specific they have in mind regarding how to address those issues.

My second question is for the Secretary-General and relates to the Cyprus process and when the United Nations will return to mediate a solution for Cyprus.

Mr. Annan.- I can answer first. Regarding your first question, I would like to say that when we talk about military presence in the world, we are referring to Afghanistan, Iraq, Palestine… It generates the perception in some contexts that Islam is being attacked, which in turn also generates certain reactions. When these conflicts or difficult situations can be resolved, this will have a positive impact on the work we are trying to do here in the Alliance of Civilizations and will stop generating the tensions, the conflicts, that they are currently creating, nor will those situations be exploited by those who use them for their own interests. Nevertheless, these are situations that need to be resolved.

I do not believe that the troops will remain indefinitely in these countries; there will have to come a time when there will be a withdrawal of those foreign troops. I do not think they will stay there forever, nor should they, in any case, stay there.

Regarding the issue of Cyprus, I will leave it for the end, as we have agreed.

P.- I had a question for the President of the Spanish Government and for the Secretary-General of the UN. This morning we received confirmation of an attack on Spanish troops in Afghanistan, 120 kilometers from Herat. Apparently, at this moment, there is one soldier injured. I would like you to confirm if you have more news about this attack and, in any case, to give me an assessment of the work of Spanish troops in Afghanistan.

President.- The information I have confirms that it is a minor injury, and of course, my assessment of the task of Spanish troops in Afghanistan is highly positive. You know that I was on the ground, and above all, they have a humanitarian dimension given the social conditions of civil disorganization and lack of resources that the inhabitants of Afghanistan have in that area. Therefore, alongside security, there is a very high humanitarian component, and it is evident that what is appropriate, on my part, is to recognize, support, and encourage our soldiers in Afghanistan.

P.- Is this the last meeting of the Alliance of Civilizations? Will there be any meetings from now on, or is this already the last one and there will be no more?

To Mr. Kofi Annan. You will be leaving your position very soon. Do you already have a clear idea of what your influence will be from now on in the development of this dialogue between civilizations? In the report presented by the members, what importance is given exactly to the dialogue of civilizations?

Mr. Annan.- A panel has presented a very important report today, so this phase of the work has concluded. I am sure there will be meetings, not only annual ones but many meetings on this topic in various parts of the world as we move forward, also encouraging public opinion, the academic world, and the media to educate, inform, and engage people. The media also have a responsibility, as we have pointed out, and we must also encourage people to exercise their right using the correct language, because language can pacify, but it can also incite conflict, it can do a lot of harm. We must be very careful about how language is used.

The work of the panel, therefore, has concluded with the delivery of the report, but the work of the Alliance will continue. For my part, I finish my responsibilities as Secretary-General, but this topic seems to me of such fundamental importance that I will continue to be involved. I will continue to speak when I consider it necessary and appropriate, and I hope that everyone else will as well.

P.- To Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. Yesterday you spoke to us about wanting to present some initiative within the European Union to address the problem of the Middle East conflict. I would like to know if you can give us some details about that initiative and also if you think that this initiative or dialogue should be in conjunction with the United States as well, because it was not mentioned yesterday at this time.

President.- I want to say in this regard that the situation in Palestine is a very serious situation. The report of the Alliance of Civilizations makes a very accurate diagnosis of what the conflict in the Middle East represents. It is the conflict of conflicts, it is the latent cause of many conflicts and many disagreements.

The international order, the international community, must react, and when we live in a situation of rapid aggravation, it must do so with all firmness.

Indeed, Spain is already working on an initiative. We will specify it next week; it will have its embryo in Europe, among several European countries, and, of course, seeking the initial support of the European Union. Next week we will announce the content of that initiative.

P.- A question for the Turkish Prime Minister. In the report we received, no decisive importance is given to freedom of the press. I would like to know if the Turkish Prime Minister sees his country, Turkey, as a model to follow in the Alliance of Civilizations.

And the second question is for President Rodríguez Zapatero out of curiosity. I have been following your career for quite some time, and you always talk about peace, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero: a yearning for peace, a will for peace, a desire for peace… And I have always wondered if you wish or have thought at any time about receiving the Nobel Peace Prize.

President.- Obviously not; but there is no greater obligation, greater responsibility, and greater ambition for someone with political responsibilities than to desire peace and fight for peace. It is the foundation of order, of coexistence; it is the principle of coexistence of all freedoms. Peace should always be the natural state of human coexistence. In peace, the best of man appears; in conflict, in confrontation, the worst of our coexistence appears. I believe that a political leader must always aspire for the best of human societies to emerge and prevail.

Mr. Erdogan.- Of course, I see that my country is making great strides regarding freedom of the press, but I do not know where other countries in the world stand. Since we started working, we have made great strides in terms of freedoms and freedom of expression. But this is not finished, and of course, it cannot be finished.

As has also been said today, whether freedom has limits or does not have limits is a topic that is always discussed. We understand by freedom that each person's freedom must stop at the freedom of the other and be able to use it in this way. One should not insult the beliefs or the sacred for someone when practicing freedom.

If we achieve this, we can say that Turkey has more or less reached its goal. If we still have things that we lack, we are willing to address and remedy them.

P.- To the Secretary-General. The report also states that there is polarization between Western countries and Islamic countries, and the real reason is chronic problems that do not have easy solutions. Could you tell me if the proposals have the possibility of being implemented easily?

Mr. Annan.- I believe that this depends on all of us. This report itself will not get underway on its own. We have talked about the media, we have talked about education, we have talked about working with the media and having the media help educate and inform public opinion, which means that the media also has a certain responsibility. Of course, the problems and differences will not be resolved overnight. It takes time for that process of information and education to take place; but even so, I believe it is possible to resolve it or at least improve the situation.

I think that the way the report describes the tensions that exist today is accurate. We must take action to reduce them and also understand that the actions, the acts, of small minorities or individual people cannot be used to describe a community or an entire group. But I will also say that it is important for the majority to make their voice heard, particularly when we say that it is the minorities that are acting, claiming to act on behalf of the silent majority. I think that silent majority needs to be less silent and speak up more.

Q.- A question for both Prime Ministers. I would like to ask what concrete, measurable results you expect to achieve with these initiatives.

A question for the Turkish Prime Minister. As one of the co-sponsors of this initiative, I wonder if you could explain your decision not to meet with the Pope when he comes this month.

President.- There are already tangible results regarding the Alliance of Civilizations. What is happening today and yesterday here in Istanbul is good proof that there is already an Alliance of Civilizations. There are countries, governments, and people from culture willing to combat intolerance and fanaticism with words, education, tolerance, and dialogue. To invoke peace and understanding, we are a great space that will reduce the spaces of the fanatics, and we are a great space that will reduce the temptations of those who easily resort to war, too easily.

These are the concrete results, and without a doubt, we will move in that direction. We will gain a growing global awareness in favor of tolerance and against fanaticism, and a growing global awareness in favor of the peaceful resolution of conflicts. For that task, we owe a lot to Kofi Annan; I want to emphasize that.

Mr. Erdogan.- Of course, the work done by the High-Level Group demonstrates all of this very well. We are trying to set aside extremisms and find a middle ground to unite the different cultures and beliefs on this path so that they can have real power.

Of course, we cannot accept either extremism or radicalism; we cannot conceive of it; on the contrary, we must have an understanding, an embrace, that melts all of this away. We always say that violence breeds violence. We must avoid all of this, but we can only do so to a certain extent. That is why we must take action, and if today we are trying to put thought on the table and if we manage to keep our political relationships alive, I am convinced that humanity will be able to move forward.

I agree with my esteemed friend Rodríguez Zapatero and all the support we have received from the Secretary-General; his positive position and the step taken by the High-Level Group have really made this work a truly concrete and not virtual effort.

Regarding the other question, perhaps I should leave this for later, but it is related to the topic, so I would like to clarify it, as there is an attempt to discuss this. As you know, the Pope will visit Turkey as a guest of the President of the Republic, and the Pope has two qualities: one is his political side, and the other is his religious side. Of course, on the political side, he has been invited by our President of the Republic and will be received; as a religious figure, our head of the religious institution will receive him.

I have a NATO Summit in Riga, and the Prime Ministers and some heads of state will be meeting in Riga. I will be in Riga at that time. The Pope, as the head of a state, visits Turkey; but I cannot cancel my meeting, my Summit, with NATO. I do not have the luxury of not attending this invitation.

The world goes on, and we have responsibilities to do our own work. It is not a position-taking, and I would like people not to strain to find a bad thought there. We have had this type of meetings up to now, and we will continue to have them. We do not have this type of problems, but we have the NATO Summit in Riga, and I have the responsibility to be there. There is no other possible explanation.

Q.- My question is for both Prime Ministers. I would like to ask if you think that the Alliance of Civilizations is against those who think in terms of the clash of civilizations, perhaps the United States, England, or Israel. Could this report perhaps bring about some change in the policies of Israel, the United States, or England? Have you been able to receive any signals from them?

President.- The report does not point to countries, flags, or political leaders; the report points to ideas, principles, and a way of working to avoid confrontation and expand the spaces for dialogue and encounter. It is, therefore, a report that transcends a situation, a political leader, and the attitude of a country at a specific moment. It analyzes the underlying problems and sets orientations. It is above governments and political leaders who, as is well known, are always subject to the circumstance of temporality.

Mr. Erdogan.- The Alliance of Civilizations is as it is called; it is not the alliance of states and countries; it is the Alliance of Civilizations. In this work, the people belonging to these civilizations and the people will unite feeling part of those civilizations or they will not participate; but right now it is the UN that will continue the process. The President of the Government of Spain, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, and I have been co-chairs on this issue; that is how we have made the way.

The High-Level Group has done work from the beginning and has developed this final report. For this, they have had to do group work from different cultures, different civilizations. Surely, there will be people who will support this report and others who will oppose it; but we will continue on our path. Our goal is peace; our goal is for people in the world to love each other, to come closer to one another, because we can find everything in love, in affection, and in peace.

We will continue our work in that direction. Some may see it negatively, but that does not concern us. We have this dimension, and we will continue to work on it.

Mr. Annan.- There were two pending questions. One for me and another for the Prime Minister of Turkey.

Regarding the question about Cyprus, I want to say that we, the United Nations, remain committed to the issue of Cyprus. I have a representative who is trying to work with the parties to develop measures that reinforce trust and allow for the resumption of talks and negotiations between the parties. In fact, I will meet with Mr. Talat, the Turkish-Cypriot leader, in Geneva next week, and everyone agrees that the problem of the Cyprus issue is in the hands of the United Nations. I have been doing everything possible for quite some time, and I will continue to do so until December 31, at midnight, and my successor will have to take over from there; but I will, of course, provide him with all the information I have and encourage him to remain involved and work as much as possible on the issue.

Mr. Erdogan.- I would like to respond to the last question that was asked of me. I had said that I would not speak on this topic before April, and I do not intend to do so. It is not on the agenda. We have talked about the principles. According to our Constitution, certain principles are established. In addition, there are the principles of our party. Before April, I will not speak or make any statement on this topic because we have other things to do, and we need to focus on these works to move our country forward.

Thank you very much.