Press conference of the President of the Government

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

28 December 2006 · Press conference of the President of the Government (year-end review)

Context
Zapatero held an end-of-year press conference on 28 December 2006 to review Spain's achievements in 2006 and outline government priorities for 2007.
Main themes
Year-end assessment of Spain, economic growth and job creation, welfare state expansion, labor reform and permanent contracts, public surplus and fiscal policy, social legislation, equality and individual rights, political objectives for 2007, Spain's standing in Europe
Duration
~70 min
97th percentile
Words
8,429
97th percentile
Sentences
300
95th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
14.9
75th percentile
Syntax
3.34
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

300 sentences in 138 paragraphs

President.- Good morning. In fulfilling the commitment I have established with all of you, and therefore with public opinion, I appear today to take stock of what 2006 has been and to set the main objectives for 2007, and to submit myself to any questions you may wish to ask on any topics you desire.

As you know, today we have held a Council of Ministers, but obviously, the purpose of this appearance is not to inform about the Council of Ministers. We have made a special and singular effort to have a broad reference of the matters that have been addressed and the agreements that have been adopted; therefore, I will go directly to take stock of the year 2006 and outline the perspectives of our political project for the year 2007, which, logically, must have continuity in subsequent years.

The first thing I want to affirm is that the year 2006 has been very positive for Spain. We are in a moment of great economic growth, of significant job creation, of stability and surplus in public accounts, which give us great confidence and security about our economic future and in terms of well-being. Furthermore, it has been a year of social achievements, especially with the approval of the Law on Personal Autonomy, the Law on Dependency, and the Equality Law.

Allow me to make, from this perspective, a general consideration: Spain is today at the forefront of economic growth, Spain is today at the forefront of job growth, Spain is today at the forefront of the Welfare State, strengthening our Welfare State and our social cohesion, and Spain is today at the forefront of the advancement of individual rights, public freedoms, and equality between men and women. These are four essential aspects for the evolution of a country and for the well-being of its citizens, and they are four pillars of our political project that at this advanced moment of the Legislature have and present a balance of facts and data that is objectively very satisfactory.

Growing above the European average or countries like France, Germany, England, or the United States; creating 60 percent of the jobs in the European Union; strengthening and incorporating new social benefits for citizens when many countries in our environment are considering cutting benefits and limiting the Welfare State, is undoubtedly a good testimony, a good example of the evolution we have as a country, and it is undoubtedly an evident expression of the success of the Government's economic, employment, and social policy.

Some data is very striking: a growth that is currently around 4 percent, which will allow us to end the year growing by 3.8 or 3.9 percent; 700,000 jobs created this year and a splendid year for employment stability.

I want to provide you with a piece of information: since the labor reform came into effect on July 1 until December 28, 1,200,000 permanent contracts have been registered; the figure, by far, the highest that has been recorded to date. That is, 454,673 more permanent contracts than in the second half of last year and a growth of no less than 61 percent in permanent employment. Of those 1,200,000 permanent contracts, 54 percent are conversions from temporary jobs. More than 600,000 workers who had temporary contracts now have permanent ones as a result of a successful employment policy, the labor reform, and our good economic evolution.

Consequently, in 2006 we achieved more permanent employment than ever, more stable and for a longer time, and at the end of the fourth quarter, as I have just emphasized, we will be close to 700,000 new jobs, and Spain will be practically touching the figure of twenty million employed. This figure alone expresses that very positive evolution of the year 2006 in economic and employment matters, considering that job creation is undoubtedly the priority of any social policy for a Government.

But also for the first time in democracy, we will have a legislature with all years of public surplus. It is almost impossible to look back in history to find a figure in our economy, in our public accounts, that allows us to close a fiscal year with a 1.5 percent surplus in relation to our Gross Domestic Product in a year, I want to remind you, in which Spaniards will also have a tax cut, both in the Personal Income Tax and in the Corporate Tax.

Furthermore, as I mentioned, we are making significant advances in the construction and development of the Welfare State. More than a million Spaniards, but in some way all Spaniards, will benefit from one of the clearest demands of Spanish society, which is the care for people who cannot take care of themselves, for the disabled, and for a group of families that have been bearing the burden, without any public help, of having to face various tasks of solidarity only in the private sphere.

This fourth pillar of the Welfare State will mark a milestone in our progress, in our social well-being. With the Law for Personal Autonomy, the Law on Dependency, Spaniards will be safer and more protected, they will be able to live better, and all families will benefit.

I want to tell you that, from a political point of view, this year has also been marked by the permanent ceasefire of ETA, announced last March. Just under a year ago, when I made this same appearance, I stated from this very place that we could be at the beginning of the end of violence, and I also stated here that the peace process, which had not yet begun, would be long, hard, and difficult. I want to say that the Government has worked and is working with that objective. It has worked every day of the Legislature to see the end of violence, horror, and terror.

A year later, I must tell you that, in terms of the fight against terrorism, in terms of the fight for the end of violence, we are, of course, better than five years ago, but we are also better than a year ago, and today I express to you a conviction: within a year we will be better than today. And, of course, the Government will continue to work, within the established principles, for the end of violence.

From the perspective of the development of territorial Spain, of our model of State, I want to emphasize that we have experienced a process of reforms of Statutes; three are already in force: Valencia, Catalonia, and Andalusia, pending the referendum that that Autonomous Community must hold. There are other Statutes in parliamentary process in the Cortes Generales and others that are still in their autonomous parliaments. With this, we are taking a step forward in what represents the Autonomous State, from normality, to ensure that the parts grow as Spain as a whole grows and to ensure that cooperation is the guiding principle that marks the functioning between the State and the Autonomous Communities.

A year later, it is evident that Spain was not breaking; rather, the opposite, Spain has grown, it is stronger economically, politically, and socially. That is the conclusion, and once again it will be demonstrated that the autonomous advances contribute to economic and social progress, and the autonomous advances contribute to solidarity and territorial cohesion.

Finally, I wanted to tell you that in terms of foreign policy, the Government has honored the word given and has fulfilled the values and commitments to carry out an active foreign policy based on essential principles: the defense of peace, international legality, and the commitment to the fight against poverty. This year, 2006, will also go down in history as the year in which Spain made the largest contribution in its history to the United Nations for the fulfillment of the Millennium Goals and will also go down as the year in which we doubled the volume of resources for the fight against poverty, for development aid.

I want to outline the main objectives for the year 2007, for this legislature, and that some, as I said, have projections in the coming years.

I have just mentioned that we have leadership in economic growth, leadership in job growth, leadership in the development of the social state, and leadership in the extension of citizen rights and equality. Spain needs, and these are the three major priorities that the Government sets before itself, to also be in three other areas in leadership and to break out of the pack in which we have been for too many years:

The first of these is the Knowledge Economy, Education, Research, Development, and Innovation. Therefore, we are increasing the volume of spending on R&D&I by 30 percent since we came to Government, and we want to address a new national strategy with the Autonomous Communities in R&D&I at the next Conference of Presidents.

The second area in which we want to position Spain in leadership is the area of environmental defense, sustainable development, and climate change. To this end, we are launching a block of environmental laws; some are already in the Cortes, such as the Law regulating the rights of access to information, public participation in environmental matters; or the Law on the evaluation of the effects of certain plans and programs on the environment; or the National Parks Law; or the Land Law.

Moreover, for the next period, the Government will present various Bills: the Bill on air quality and atmospheric protection, the Bill on the defense of natural heritage and biodiversity, the Bill on environmental responsibility, and the Bill on the reform of the Water Law, along with the Law on the sustainable development of rural areas.

In short, the environment, urban planning, the preservation of our natural conditions, and the commitment to climate change will be the second major objective of this phase of the Legislature.

And, thirdly, to intensify the process of modernization of our public services, a modernization process that must begin or that has as a priority security, security in all areas: citizen security with an increase for this year of nine thousand police and civil guards -- five thousand were added last year -- with the implementation of 50 percent of the Military Emergency Unit or with specific plans in road safety to continue winning the battle against so much tragedy on the roads. This has been a positive year in the pursuit of maximum road safety, with 260 fewer deaths than in previous years, but we still have much work to do.

Modernization of our security and modernization of the Administration for citizens, so that the Administration is in the same time of modernity as the citizens and society. Therefore, I announce that next Monday, it will no longer be required to present a photocopy of the ID card in any procedure of the State Administration; before 2008, more than twenty million paper documents that are currently required for various procedures will be eliminated; before December 31, 2007, three million Spaniards will have the new electronic ID, and in 2007 we will reduce, for example, the time for issuing university degrees by half.

These are measures, some of which are part of those three major objectives for this period of the Legislature, which are the three great needs of Spain.

In addition to this, I want to announce a series of Bills that, due to their significance, will also be part of the Government's task for this next period:

These are the most notable laws, although the Government will approve more Bills that we have for the next period.

I want to remind you that in the year that is ending, Parliament has approved 44 laws, whose projects had been sent by the Government. There are 35 more in the Congress and eight in the Senate, in different phases of the legislative process, and in the year that is now beginning, the Government, to fulfill its political program, to fully fulfill its political program, has around forty laws in the pipeline, some of which I have just mentioned, that will address all areas of political and administrative action.

I believe the introduction is more than sufficient, and therefore, from here, your questions.

Q.- I wanted to ask you about two issues that you did not mention, but I think are interesting, in addition to your commitment as President: one, domestic violence, for which a series of measures have been taken, but I would like to know what attitude you will have in 2007; another, workplace accidents, which I know is a scourge that also concerns you.

Finally, I wanted to know when you will relieve the Minister of Justice, if that can be known.

President.- Regarding the first, the Government's commitment against what domestic violence represents is absolute, against the criminal machismo that is incompatible with a modern society, with a society of values, with a democratic society.

We approved the Law against Gender Violence. We have conducted an evaluation of the Law and, as is known and as the Vice President announced, the Council of Ministers has once again increased measures through a plan for the development of actions and a budget increase in all areas to fight against this social scourge. The Law is fundamental, essential, but the battle of the Law and the battle against this social scourge will take us time, more economic effort, management, and, of course, all the awareness and social rejection that such a task of this magnitude requires.

Secondly, it is true that workplace accidents are another of the fundamental problems that directly affect safety. We have acted in three areas and our perspective is that the results are moving towards a favorable evolution in this area. We have incorporated legislative reforms regarding subcontracting, we have agreed on an ambitious plan with the unions, and, in addition, we are significantly strengthening the Labor Inspection because, without a doubt, it constitutes an essential tool in the fight against workplace accidents.

Finally, regarding the change of the head of the Ministry of Justice, I will tell you that it will be at the right time. There is not much time left, I must say.

Q.- You said that within a year we will be better regarding the peace process. I would like to know if you expect a qualitative change in the disposition of the terrorist organization ETA to abandon arms during this year that begins in a few days and if, at this moment, while street violence persists, the conditions set by Congress to maintain contacts with ETA, whether exploratory or formal, are met.

I would also like to know if the willingness, the offer, of Convergència i Unió to participate in the Government corresponds with your willingness, as President of the Government, to have nationalist ministers.

President.- Regarding the first question, I have expressed a political conviction: within a year we will be better. It has been more than three years since there have been any fatalities from ETA; therefore, we must consider what the task of seeking an end to violence represents as a process, a peace process, and in a process it is advisable not to be waiting for milestones or predicting transcendental moments. What is advisable is to work every day so that this process takes root and leads to the result we all desire.

Secondly, the Government has clearly established, in its declaration and in repeated statements, what the conditions must be for a dialogue between the Government and ETA. I will not reiterate them today.

You know that I have expressed on many occasions my respect and the good relationship I have with Convergència i Unió. It is a group that also, under certain circumstances, collaborates in governance and adds agreements to the task of passing laws. Therefore, I have the best disposition to continue in that dimension; but, evidently, talking about possible participation in the Government can be an interesting topic, but it is not a current topic.

Q.- Within the optimism you have expressed regarding the evolution of the peace process, I would like to know what interpretation you make of the discovery last week of a recently found cache of ETA.

On the other hand, do you agree with the idea of the Popular Party regarding Batasuna? The Popular Party is stating that it could not present itself for the upcoming municipal elections unless there is a definitive abandonment of arms by ETA. Do you agree with that or would it suffice, as the Law of Political Parties says, in principle, adhering to its wording, with a condemnation of violence?

President.- I will not make interpretations of events that occur like the one you just mentioned, among other things, because there are already so many people making interpretations. Let us refer to what is serious, which is the investigation that the Basque Autonomous Police must carry out and for that investigation to conclude. That may be the time to make interpretations, but let us respect things as they must be done and by whom they must be done.

Secondly, this process, the peace process, is under a series of principles. The first of these is legality, and legality also applies to participation in political institutions: what the Law says, nothing more than what the Law says and nothing less than what the Law requires of political parties to run and be in the institutions. Like all democrats, I hope that the conditions of respect for the Law of Political Parties are met so that everyone can participate in the upcoming electoral events.

Q.- A question about the recent resolution of the Security Council regarding Iran's nuclear program. I want to know your opinion on this resolution. Do you agree with this process to resolve the nuclear issue of Iran?

Another question about the relationship landscape between the two countries, Iran and Spain. Every day in the Middle East, urgencies are increasing and we have many problems in the Middle East, in Iraq, in Palestine, and in other countries. Does Spain have any plan in its initiative to resolve problems in the Middle East?

President.- Regarding the questions concerning Iran, I will say two things. The first is that, of course, the Government of Spain respects, and I believe it is a correct position, the Resolution of the United Nations Security Council. We understand that the so-called nuclear dossier must be resolved preferably through commitment and agreement, where Iran must do everything it can on its part and, of course, the International Community as well.

And I would say that the relations between Iran and Spain are normal relations.

Middle East. The last European Summit, the last European Council, made a call and established a mandate for Europe, as one of the determining integral parts of the Quartet, to redouble diplomatic efforts to consolidate the ceasefire in Gaza and Lebanon, and, of course, to open the conditions so that we can reach an essential Peace Conference for the entire region, because once again it must be stated that the conflict between Israel and Palestine is decisive for the stability of the entire region and, therefore, for the stability of the region with the most security problems in the world.

I hope that 2007 will be a year of progress in that process in the Middle East.

Q.- Following up on a question asked earlier, I would like to ask you what you believe is the most appropriate procedure that Batasuna must follow to be able to be in the institutions.

Secondly, I would like to know if you make any self-criticism regarding how the Government has managed the peace process over these nine months.

President.- The first is clear: to respect legality. And the Law of Political Parties is very direct and very specific about what the requirements are to be able to run for elections, to be able to participate in institutions from the perspective of democratic principles.

Secondly, the desire and eagerness of Spanish society to see the end of violence is such that the Government is willing to make any type of self-criticism. But it is advisable that we be reasonable when assessing things, because often certain statements or considerations lead to the purest absurdity. To say that today ETA, Batasuna, is stronger seems to me, simply, absurd. The question is: was it weak six, seven years ago? Five years ago?

It is essential that we make a reasonable and sensible approach to what the work for the end of violence and for peace represents; a work that, I insist, will take time and requires the utmost responsibility and also the utmost discretion.

Q.- What are the most notable challenges you see for the Spanish economy this coming year?

President.- It is evident that the fundamental challenge of the Spanish economy is to increase productivity. The data we have from the last period is positive. There is an increase in productivity and that increase in productivity, which will be the guarantee of improving our competitiveness and the Spanish economy abroad, which is also improving, by the way, focuses, above all, on our technological capacity, on our productive capacity; and that is Research, Development, and Innovation. That is why I have placed it as the first major objective where Spain must break away from the pack and be in the lead, as in other major economic matters, because it can do so and we will do it.

Q.- When you say that it is democratic and that you believe that all parties that respect democracy can run, I ask you a very personal question: do you believe that Batasuna can or cannot run in the upcoming regional elections?

Are you going to propose or not the advancement of general elections in Spain?

President.- Regarding the first, I reiterate. I cannot make any personal interpretation, especially being the President of the Government. Respect for the Law has a series of procedures in a Rule of Law, in a democratic State, and all public opinion, including the abertzale left, knows what that represents, which is the distancing from violence. That is the ultimate philosophy, the principles that the Law of Political Parties establishes, which are, on the other hand, well-reasoned.

Secondly, I can answer that more easily: yes, it is my objective, and we will fulfill it, to finish the legislature, of course. Moreover, with this economic, social, and employment landscape, there is even more incentive to do so.

Q.- President, returning to the issue of self-criticism. You have made a very positive assessment of your management throughout the year 2006. I suppose there is something on the negative side of the balance, something that you have not done as well.

I would also like to ask for your assessment of the seemingly imminent execution of the sentence of Saddam Hussein.

President.- Regarding the second, I have already stated once again that I believe that all dictators must answer for their actions, all dictators; that does not always happen in History. But I will never defend the death penalty even for the worst politician who has behaved in his career. I am against the death penalty and, therefore, I cannot support such sentences.

Regarding self-criticism, the truth is that there are sufficient elements in daily public opinion to talk about self-criticism. But, if you allow me to make a consideration in this regard, we have to hurry, we have to go faster, in what is strengthening our security systems, as this also strengthens the State. For example, I would have liked the Military Emergency Unit to be at 100 percent today; it will be at 50 percent, but I would have liked us to have been able to put it at 100 percent. It is true that it requires training of the personnel that integrates it, etc., etc.

In everything that affects security, I can say that when we came to Government, we found very deep weaknesses and now we are strengthening the security of the State: an increase in police and civil guards, and very concrete and effective measures in road safety. There was practically nothing in the face of situations of major disasters; the Government had very few resources in the face of emergencies, major disasters, and there we have to hurry as much as we can in a country that is close to 45 million inhabitants and that, in addition, has certain circumstances that sometimes produce disasters and create emergency situations.

Q.- President, first of all, regarding the peace process, I would like to know if you maintain the intention to hold a formal meeting with the terrorist group and if there are any premises for the approach of prisoners of the terrorist group in the coming months.

Secondly, I have not seen the Reference, but today the missions of Spanish soldiers abroad have been extended. I would like to know if the cap of three thousand soldiers abroad has been eliminated.

Finally, can you clarify how initiatives like the Alliance of Civilizations or the initiative for the Middle East can be discussed without having visited any country in the region and without having had hardly any direct communication with your counterparts in the Middle East region?

President.- I must refute the last assertion because I have had communication, and quite frequently, directly and, of course, the Government through the Minister of Foreign Affairs.

My intention is to visit the Middle East, but everyone can understand that it must occur under politically appropriate conditions to make the visit useful to the contribution that Spain can make in that difficult search for stability and peace, which we all desire in that region.

The Government has maintained the limit of three thousand troops, of three thousand soldiers and members of the Armed Forces, who can be carrying out missions abroad in today's Council of Ministers.

Finally, I reiterate, regarding the question of the peace process, the principles and conditions established; and, of course, also that any measure that may occur in the future, I do not say that it will occur to contribute to the peace process, will be communicated, first of all, to the Parliamentary Groups, when there is any relevant fact, in a phrase already coined by the Minister of the Interior.

P.- Mr. President, if you allow me, I have missed in your first summary of the year a reference to the issue of immigration, which week after week the Vice President has mentioned here, in this very room, as a priority of the Government. I would like to know what the Government is going to do to prevent, if possible, illegal immigration, that constant flow of illegal immigration during 2007.

I would also like to ask how the Government assesses the fact that, according to the latest CIS survey, citizens have once again considered terrorism as one of the three issues that concern them the most.

President.- This issue of surveys always has all kinds of interpretations; but it is evident that this year, 2006, terrorism has been the year with the lowest concern among citizens regarding terrorism. It is reasonable, moreover, because we have a permanent ceasefire and because it has been more than three years without fatalities.

Immigration. I believe that the Government has made a permanent effort, as you mentioned, to inform about immigration policy, particularly the Vice President every Council of Ministers and every Friday reporting on the Council of Ministers. I will tell you what our three objectives are, which are part of a structured immigration policy.

First objective: Europe. We have made significant progress in the European commitment to an immigration policy and, therefore, for a global perspective from European institutions regarding immigration, especially from the South, which includes cooperation, new agreements, and also integration policies.

Secondly, as a country, cooperation with the transit and origin countries of immigration. Cooperation in a dual sense: so that only legal immigration exists and, therefore, to avoid and, if necessary, repatriate illegal immigrants.

And, thirdly, a state policy on immigration, on the integration of immigrants. Therefore, we are going to debate it at the Conference of Presidents and we have significantly increased the fund that goes to Autonomous Communities and Municipalities for a social integration policy.

These are the three pillars and, if there is a policy that requires tenacity and demands consistency, strengthening of means, political action, diplomatic action, external and internal cooperation, it is undoubtedly immigration and it is undoubtedly one of the fundamental challenges that we, as a country, have.

P.- Mr. President, two questions. Do you plan to make changes to your ministerial team for the final phase of the Legislature?

Do you consider it possible to find elements of consensus with the Popular Party, as the Head of State requested in his last speech?

President.- There is only one change planned, and you all know it and it has already been mentioned in today’s appearance, which is the change of the head of the Ministry of Justice.

It is always desirable to have the maximum number of political agreements. I must say that during this period there have been disagreements and there are disagreements with the main opposition party, but there have also been important agreements. There will be agreements on all Statutes of Autonomy, except for one. Therefore, nothing more and nothing less than in what affects the state policy of autonomous development, the rule is consensus; the exception, disagreement.

There has been an agreement on the Law of Personal Autonomy, an agreement that I value as very important, because implementing this new pillar of the Welfare State requires the participation of all, especially the Autonomous Communities, and gives great confidence and security to the country, because all political forces have committed to ensuring that more than a million people receive the assistance they deserve and that today Spanish society can provide.

In a democracy, we must also evaluate the effort to reach agreements. The effort to reach agreements is measured, to a large extent, by the willingness for political dialogue. Allow me to remind you that, unless corrected, I am the President of the Government who has periodically and most often had contacts with the leader of the opposition, necessarily twice a year; who has received the most Autonomous Presidents and who has convened, for the first time in our democracy, the Conference of Presidents. We are going to hold the third. It is a forum for political dialogue and agreements, for seeking consensus, at the highest level: the President of the Government and the Autonomous Presidents. I believe it is important.

To not close the list of consensuses, I will say that we have recently reached one that has deep significance for me, a very important significance from the point of view of democratic sensitivity, which is the change in Radiotelevisión Española: consensus for the first time for the first president of the public broadcasting corporation who is elected by Parliament. That, from my point of view, has a very high democratic value. I am very satisfied to preside over the first Government that has turned traditionally party-controlled television into a television for all, with a president elected by Parliament, while we have also been able to carry out the necessary restructuring of a public entity that generated a gigantic debt just because the Governments had the whim of controlling the news broadcasts.

P.- Mr. President, you have announced a very intense legislative parliamentary activity for next year. The traditional partners of the Government, Izquierda Unida, Esquerra, and CiU, are, so to speak, pressuring you to clarify alliances, to establish preferred alliances. Do you intend to satisfy them or do you feel comfortable with the current system of support that you have woven in Parliament?

If I may ask another question, it has been recurrent to ask you about the famous meeting with Bush, whether it would ever take place or not. Is this now completely off any agenda? Are you no longer interested?

President.- Regarding the first question, almost from the beginning of the Legislature, we have always been asked, and even it was predicted—I do not want to remember the predictions about how the economy was going to evolve made by the main opposition party; more than anything, because I do not like to embarrass anyone—that we were going to have parliamentary difficulties. I say nothing when the Statute of Catalonia arrived in Congress to establish our majorities. Parliamentary difficulties… It was said that it practically implied bankruptcy.

We have just approved the Budgets, and they have been the easiest Budgets to implement in terms of seeking and achieving parliamentary agreements throughout the Legislature. And I want to thank all Parliamentary Groups that, in one way or another, on one issue or another, have been willing to agree with the Government to approve Budgets, to advance laws, and laws like those we are approving in this legislature, which represent profound reforms and great transformations.

In other words, when there is a political project and that project is a modernizing, progressive project, like the one we are carrying out, with good results, with data, with facts, it is logical that the Government obtains parliamentary support and reaches agreements with relative ease, without losing the political identity of each Group, to whom I reiterate my gratitude from here.

No, there are no updates on the other issue. It is true that it is striking that the PP seems to have forgotten about it. They were very insistent for a while, I do not know for what reason, but now it does not seem to excite them as much the possibility of a meeting with President Bush. But there are no updates on that.

P.- You have said that the exception is disagreement, but precisely the exception in relation to the PP is the disagreement regarding the end of ETA violence. I wanted to ask you about your impression after your recent meeting with the leader of the opposition, whether the Popular Party is going to support the Government or if it will continue along the lines it has been so far.

A second question. The AVT launched a campaign yesterday on its website asking that the socialist officials José Blanco and López Garrido apologize to the polio victim whom they accused of pretending to be a victim of terrorism. I wanted to know if that apology is going to come. Do you think it is appropriate? Are you going to urge these two officials to apologize?

President.- I do not know about that campaign. However, I do tell you that, if appropriate, that apology will be made. Of course, it will be made.

Regarding agreements, I have emphasized that the exception of disagreement has occurred in the autonomous reforms, in the reforms of the Statutes of Autonomy. It is also an exception, indeed, that there is disagreement in anti-terrorism policy, in the fight for the end of violence. It is an exception, but the exception in this case is from those who are in opposition, because from the beginning of the democratic transition until 2004, all opposition parties had supported the Government in this matter, through tough and less tough moments. It would seem reasonable that in a moment of expectation, favorable but difficult, it would also occur.

I always wish for that agreement to exist and I trust that 2007 can foster a more favorable climate for that understanding. I suppose we will all have to contribute something.

The interview, as the Vice President of the Government commented at the time, was, from my point of view, cordial. It is always good to talk in a democracy, especially about such crucial issues; even if there are disagreements, it is always good to talk. I have full confidence in the capacity of dialogue to bring us closer or to be in a better situation.

P.- Mr. President, you have already said before that you did not want to make interpretations about ETA's actions, but I did want to ask you if you can explain to citizens how your statement that we are better regarding ETA terrorism is compatible with some objective facts such as, for example, the discovery of a cache, with the fact that objectively in recent months ETA has more weapons after having stolen them in southern France, or with the substantial increase in street violence that has occurred in recent weeks. I wanted to know how you explain that.

Secondly, a very specific question, and that is whether you can clarify if you are aware of any meeting of anyone on your behalf with ETA.

President.- The first question is common sense: are we better off when there is a permanent ceasefire than when there were bombs, as there were a year ago? Undoubtedly. Are we better off than four or five years ago, when we also had tragic accidents (fatal attacks)? Undoubtedly. It is common sense; it is a minimal appeal to objectivity. Some parameter of objectivity must exist in democracy, and in this area, it does. Being in a permanent ceasefire is a better situation than a year ago, when there was no permanent ceasefire and there were actions, bombs, explosions, car bombs, coinciding, for example, with Christmas, and in other corners of our country.

I have commented on more than one occasion, and today I reiterate, that discretion—I said it the day I appeared in Parliament and I have said it many times—is going to be the norm of action that I will have regarding the process of possible dialogue with ETA for the end of violence, out of a sense of responsibility. It is part of my duty because, in addition, it also involves the security of the State itself.

P.- I wanted to know how you have seen the start of the new tripartite government in Catalonia, considering that a possible appeal against the Government has already been announced.

President.- I simply have to say that, regarding that appeal, there is now a period of dialogue. Of course, the Government maintains its positions. We believe that there is no violation of the legal order or the Statute. We are going to talk and, in any case, as you can imagine and as you know perfectly well, appeals of unconstitutionality or conflicts of competencies are part of the nature of the Autonomous State. I see the start of the tripartite as reasonable.

But allow me because I am going to meet with the President of the Generalitat, José Montilla, on the 8th, and there we will have the opportunity to exchange opinions and make a more in-depth assessment.

P.- Continuing on the same topic of conflicts with the new tripartite Government, there have also been announced, at least, discrepancies regarding the new financing model. I wanted to know if you could confirm that it is postponed until after the next elections, until 2009; if that is a breach of the Statute or if, perhaps, there will be no more money for the Autonomous Communities, but rather a new way of distributing it.

President.- We are in a controversy that I have seen in some media that so far has little foundation because the Government is working in an "ad hoc" group for the reform of the financing model. It is an ambitious reform and it must be done taking into account all the Autonomous Communities, also preferably with the maximum political consensus.

It will take as long as necessary, and the time that is necessary is, above all, the search for agreements so that the Autonomous Communities have adequate financing, in accordance with the public services they provide or the public services they may increase as a result of the reform of the Statutes, and, of course, financing that must preserve the financing needs of the State or, to be more specific, of the central Government and the central institutions of the State.

There is no established limit or political condition regarding the moment or the time. It will be the time required by the work of a task that demands doing things well. Therefore, I believe that for the moment there can and should be no controversy.

Q.- Mr. President, if the peace process advances adequately, do you rule out bringing the prisoners closer to the Basque Country in 2007?

President.- I have commented that I am not going to comment on future possibilities or hypotheses. We must work with caution. Every step we take must be a firm, solid step that can contribute to that peace process, and any step that may be taken, if it is taken in the future, will always be once the Parliamentary Groups are informed. As long as there is no call to the Parliamentary Groups, there will be no step.

Q.- Continuing with the topic of the peace process, I was struck by your request for discretion, which is respectable, but that you do not acknowledge something that is, let’s say, a fact in public opinion, which is the famous meeting that took place in the first or second week of December between certain government envoys and certain ETA envoys. The question is whether you do not think that this, let’s say, could distance the Government from public opinion, which is what the polls might be reflecting. I recall that the previous government acknowledged contacts in Switzerland and public opinion accepted it as normal. I do not know if you have reflected on this.

Secondly, when the European Court of Human Rights decides in February, I believe it is at the end of January or February, whether to admit the Batasuna lawsuit against its process of illegalization, will the Government adopt that decision of the European Court of Human Rights as its own and could it facilitate Batasuna's participation in the elections?

Lastly, I would like to ask you about the Historical Memory Law, which I believe you did not mention in your opening summary. My question is whether you consider the dialogue with the PP on this issue to be closed and whether you believe that without that dialogue and without the support of the PP, a law that, let’s say, is causing some uncertainty in certain sectors of opinion, to put it that way, can move forward.

President.- Regarding the first question, the principles and the method of work in the peace process are established. The principles are: respect for legality, for the rule of law, for democratic principles, a dialogued search for the end of violence, maximum cooperation with political forces, and working with responsibility and seriousness. Of course, the Government will comply with them, and within the responsibility and seriousness in the fight against terrorism and the search for the end of violence, there is the principle of discretion and not evaluating or commenting on many of the things that are published every day. This is how the peace process can move forward, and the Government must ensure that these conditions are met.

The Government, of course, respects and will respect any ruling from any court that binds it.

Finally, regarding the law that recognizes rights for people who suffered as a result of the Civil War and Francoism, the question is what the Popular Party opposes. Do they oppose expanding economic rights and benefits to people who did not have them, who suffered during the Franco regime and even during the transition? Do they oppose public administrations facilitating the identification of their ancestors for those who require it, which they have not been able to do for years? Do they oppose having a commitment and principles regarding the removal of symbols?

Is it possible to consider someone radical for understanding that symbols of authoritarian regimes are not good in a democracy? Does anyone think that in France, Germany, Italy, or any democratic country in the world, a political group, a government, a political leader could be considered radical for not wanting or understanding that it is advisable not to have symbols of authoritarian regimes or symbols that divide what was our tragic civil confrontation?

The answer is clear and forceful: no. In no democratic country in the world would any politician or party be considered radical, but simply reasonable and democratic.

This is what the law basically states. Whoever opposes expanding benefits or extending benefits, to allow Spanish citizens to facilitate the task of identifying the ancestors who were victims of the conflict of the war, or to a series of principles regarding symbols must explain why they oppose it.

How many times do we say that it is necessary for the demands of citizens, what is in the streets, to be brought to Parliament? Or have we not been seeing for years families and associations trying to find out where their grandfather, grandmother, uncle, or aunt was in the so-called mass graves; to have a process of identification? Does facilitating this for public authorities go against anyone? No. We are going to try to give a little more peace, calm, and tranquility to people who suffered. Does recognizing economic benefits go against anyone? No. It is one more effort of democratic solidarity; it is a prolongation of the spirit of the transition.

By the way, today someone with authority writes about the spirit of the transition, from those who were really there from the very beginning: Felipe González. It is recommended reading. Some who talk so much about the transition and were so little in it should read it because he was one of the great protagonists.

Q.- My questions are related to the topic of water. First, I wanted to know if today, as recommended by the Tajo-Segura Commission, a transfer for human consumption has been approved and, finally, a transfer for irrigation.

Also, to know if, just as you have said that topics such as R&D and immigration will be addressed at the Conference of Presidents, the topic of water will be a primary issue and if that Water Law, which you mentioned, must somehow come out of that Conference of Autonomous Presidents.

President.- First of all, I want to confirm that today the Government has approved a transfer of twelve cubic hectometers for human consumption from the Tajo-Segura system.

Secondly, water policy is a policy in which we want to seek maximum agreement with the Autonomous Communities. It is a policy that determines our development, that affects economic development, that affects environmental policy, and that affects the territorial balance of Spain.

I want to remind you that if we are bringing the issue of water policy to the Conference of Presidents, it is at the request of the Presidents of the Popular Party. We will all have the opportunity to know what the Government's plans are and what the policy is for ensuring sufficient water supply for the entire national territory, the planned investments, and the actions that are being carried out and will be carried out.

I think it is extraordinarily positive that all the Autonomous Presidents, along with the President of the Government, and therefore with the Government of Spain, can debate water policy. We have been debating water policy for a long time among various Presidents, but together it will be useful, positive, and constructive, even if the differences, which are likely to remain, on some issues that have been the subject of great public debate in recent times.

Q.- President, I wanted to know to what extent the Catalan Statute can influence the next system of autonomous financing, what the Catalan Statute marks in financial matters.

Then, do you think that during this year the rise in housing prices will approach that of general consumption prices?

President.- The trend is towards moderation in the increase in housing prices. We have already experienced this trend in 2006, and it is a predictable trend for 2007, to which is added a significant effort that the Government is making in public housing policy, although it does not cover all the objectives, obviously, that exist for a good number of families and citizens in this country.

But I want to remind you that this has been the year with the most public housing initiated, 86,000; that the 2005-2007 Plan will benefit 500,000 families for access to housing; that there is a reform of the Land Law that raises the percentage of reserve of urban developments for protected housing and that there is an effort, like never before, from the Government of Spain to cede state land to municipalities and Autonomous Communities to build housing mostly with some degree of protection and, therefore, more easily accessible to citizens. This is being done by the largest landowner in this country, which is the General State Administration.

It is well known that the Statute of Catalonia and all Statutes, as happened in the first wave of Statutes, establish a series of principles regarding autonomous financing. These principles must be taken into account; they are also part of the political will regarding the direction that the reform of autonomous financing should take, and of course, they will be present in the proposal that the Government makes: more financial autonomy for the Autonomous Communities and maintenance of the principle of solidarity as two major pillars, along with that condition or reserve of sufficiency for the expenses of the General State Administration, of the central government.

Q.- President, in your initial presentation, you spoke of forty laws that you have in the pipeline. You mentioned some of them, but I did not hear you mention two that, in my opinion, are important and that you promised right here, at this same podium, in February of this year, which are the Disciplinary Regime Law of the Civil Guard and the Law of Rights and Duties of Civil Guards. Those organic laws or projects were supposed to be presented before June, before the end of the previous session. I wanted to know their status, whether you will advance in military associationism, whether you will advance in making the Civil Guard non-military and demilitarizing it in view of how the Corps is today.

President.- The Law of the Disciplinary Regime of the Civil Guard is very advanced and will be one of the laws that we will bring to the next Council of Ministers. Logically, it is a law that represents important changes regarding the disciplinary regime of the Civil Guard, although it will not affect the nature of the Civil Guard Corps.

Thank you very much.