Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

19 December 2006 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on the arms trade bill and the Air Madrid collapse during a December 2006 Spanish Congress control session.
Main themes
Arms trade legislation, parliamentary consensus, NGO participation, Air Madrid airline collapse, passenger rights, government accountability, Spain's arms exports to sub-Saharan Africa, EU code of conduct on arms, aviation safety, consumer protection
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,042
58th percentile
Sentences
68
45th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 34%31%
  • Economic 31%28%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 10%9%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

68 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Herrera, of the Parliamentary Group of United Left-Initiative for Catalonia Greens

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Herrera.- I do not know if from humility, but certainly from curiosity, I would like to know when and how the Government plans to fulfill the commitment made a year ago, in a non-legislative proposal, in which the Government was asked to draft a bill on arms trade. I want to know when it will be fulfilled, with whom it will be fulfilled, if it will be done with the NGOs that promoted it and with all the parliamentary groups that supported the initiative. I want you to satisfy that curiosity.

President.- Mr. Herrera, I will tell you with satisfaction, I imagine, and also with humility, that the Council of Ministers will approve before the end of this year, that is, immediately, the Bill you are interested in, on arms trade, and I commit, Mr. Herrera, to seek the greatest social consensus and, of course, political consensus among the different Parliamentary Groups in this Chamber because for the Government this Law is also an important law, just as it is for you.

Mr. Herrera.- The truth is that we want to congratulate ourselves on the fact that this Bill is being fulfilled, with a few days of delay but that it is finally being fulfilled. We understand that it is important, moreover, that the process begins, not only for the Government to fulfill, but for Congress to fulfill, so that at the end of the Legislature we have a good arms trade law.

What we want to convey is the need to share this Project, first of all, with the Parliamentary Groups. We know that on many occasions Projects have been previously agreed upon and we urge the Government and the Socialist Group to generate this consensus in this Chamber.

Secondly, we ask that the NGOs that have promoted the initiative participate in the Bill: Amnesty International, Intermón Oxfam, and Greenpeace; an initiative, ultimately, that has great significance.

Thirdly, we want it to be a bill with the characteristics requested by the Congress of Deputies: with a transparent procedure for the authorization of transfers, with periodic control by Congress, with binding application of the European Union's code of conduct, with indication of what statistics regarding the transfer of armament material should contain and that limits the confidentiality of arms sale operations; with all that.

We understand that it is especially important in Spain. We have talked a lot about Africa, about the drama that Africa is experiencing. Well, it must be said that today Spain is the world's largest exporter of ammunition to sub-Saharan Africa; sometimes, as hunting ammunition, but we understand that when we are the world's largest exporter of ammunition to sub-Saharan Africa, that people do not only die when they come to Spain, they also die in Africa, we have a responsibility and that responsibility is to make the law as demanding as possible regarding arms trade.

For all this, I want to congratulate myself and I hope that we can thus create the Arms Trade Law.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Parliamentary Group of the Popular Party

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- With all humility, Mr. President, the facts are as follows: 130,000 humble passengers stranded in airports around the world; 300,000 humble passengers with tickets to nowhere; 1,270 humble workers with unknown employment status; dozens of airports collapsed with public order and humanitarian problems; yesterday, 80 Colombians were evacuated who blocked a security checkpoint in Barajas; the image of Spain and Madrid in question, especially after what happened in El Prat; a situation of legal insecurity and a monumental fraud to consumer rights, and travel agencies that do not know what to do with the tickets issued to their clients.

Neither the Minister of Development nor the Minister of Health has come here to give explanations, and it is a democratic shame; that said, the Minister of Development told us today the following: we are not a travel agency nor are we here to pay for anyone's vacations.

What do you think of all this, Mr. President of the Government? Do you believe that your Government has anything to do with it?

Mr. President.- The situation created with Air Madrid has two aspects. The first is that Air Madrid has failed to meet its legal obligations and the Government has fulfilled its responsibility by preventing any risks to passenger safety. Air Madrid fails and the Government fulfills, because it has been inspecting and ensuring safety and, when we talk about passenger safety in aviation, we know what we are talking about and you also know what you are talking about.

From there, aware of the impact and social effect that an inevitable and necessary measure would have, the Government has put all possible means in place, despite the dates we have, to mitigate the negative effect that is undoubtedly causing serious difficulties and disruptions for many citizens. We have attended to thousands of people so far and have facilitated their ability to fly with other companies, so they can return, and we will continue to do so. I can assure you that we are putting on the table economic, material, and human resources that in most circumstances of other countries that have also gone through situations of this nature have not been put.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, I do not come here to talk about private companies, I come to talk about what the Government does when certain situations arise.

I want to say that the Government is responsible for not adequately guaranteeing safety, as has been demonstrated by the multiple irregularities reported, and nothing has happened because God did not want it to. The Government is responsible for renewing a license knowing the existence of countless problems. The Government is responsible for not trying to mitigate the problems with viable solutions before the scandal erupted. The Government is responsible for not adequately protecting the interests of consumers and users at a critical moment when it was already known what the fate of the company would be, allowing tickets to be sold. The Government is responsible for once again managing a crisis very poorly, which exposes Spain and also Madrid to the eyes of the whole world. And the Government is responsible for not adequately addressing the humanitarian problems that have arisen at the airports.

There has been too much ineffectiveness and incompetence, Mr. President. There have been Fórum, Afinsa, El Prat, the problems with the fires, the cayucos, and then you complain that I tell you that you pay too much attention to the Alliance of Civilizations. In a normal country, in a civilized country, Mr. President of the Government, the Minister of Development, who now sits next to you, would not be Minister of Development, but would have immediately left the Government, or say that she would not.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as a result of the continuous and systematic inspection activity, it has been discovered that Air Madrid had no guarantees and that is why the decision was made. If today we can say that there is safety and that no citizen will run risks flying with Air Madrid, it is due to the actions of this Minister of Development. One.

Two. The Government has put the means at its disposal in the face of a significant problem and in a planned manner because we knew that this situation was coming. The Minister will appear on the 26th.

Finally, I want to say that I am glad that you care so much about those humble people you have not wanted to help, because most of them are workers who have been regularized under the Government of the Socialist Party. It is very good that you remember those humble people.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Agustí Cerdà, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Cerdà.- Mr. President, as you well know, El Prat airport will reach a figure of thirty million passengers in 2006, a figure that places it among the eight major airports in Europe. Moreover, the growth of this Barcelona airport has been this year, after Beijing, the most significant among the forty main airports in the world. Despite these indicators, we still have practically no intercontinental flights that connect Barcelona directly with the world and that allow El Prat to become a reference "hub" in southern Europe, in fact, the connecting airport of the Mediterranean basin.

Our question is the following: Is it a priority for the Government that El Prat airport becomes a second "hub" for intercontinental flights in the Spanish State?

President.- Mr. Cerdà, I must tell you that, as you know, the Government is developing a wide range of investments in El Prat airport included in the Barcelona Plan, among them and of special significance the construction of the new terminal area which, along with the parking lots, will allow for an increase in annual passenger movement by more than twenty-five million. Adding the current operational facilities with the future ones, Barcelona airport will be able to accommodate more than 55 million passengers a year. As you know, the integration of rail and AVE into the terminal and the creation of an industrial, logistics, and service area, the airport city, of almost three hundred hectares is also planned. All these actions will mean an investment reaching three billion euros and as of November 30, 1.685 billion has already been invested.

It is, therefore, evident, Mr. Cerdà, that El Prat airport is a clear priority for this Government, which will be one of the major European airports and will also present significant excess capacity that will allow it to operate as a true center for international traffic distribution in a liberalized European environment.

I can assure you that the Government is willing to firmly support any business initiative that is technically justified, which enhances traffic and the "hub" status of airlines at El Prat. We are confident, Mr. Cerdà, that this airport can go even further, not limit its potential or that of the companies operating there, and become a reference "hub" for intercontinental flights, of course, in Europe.

Mr. Cerdà.- Mr. President, you know as well as I do that today a large city or territory that does not have an intercontinental airport does not appear on a global map, effectively limiting its possibilities, in this case both those of Barcelona and those of Catalonia as a whole, to host major events or for multinational companies.

You will also know that last week the world's first airline alliance, Star Alliance, made public its intention to establish its connection center or "hub" at El Prat airport for southern Europe. To do this, attending to these operational criteria, it asked AENA to allow all its companies to be together, effectively, in the new southern terminal that is being built. Although we should not get ahead of ourselves, a strategy in these terms from the world's leading airline alliance could facilitate El Prat's positioning on the map of intercontinental flights.

We know perfectly well that our request does not detract from anyone. We come to add, we know perfectly well that one plus one equals two and that, in any case, more El Prat does not mean, by any means, less Barajas. In this sense, from Esquerra Republicana we believe that a firm commitment from the Spanish Government is necessary to guarantee that all actions within its reach will be undertaken to allow Barcelona airport to definitively become a second "hub" for intercontinental flights also in the Spanish State.

President.- I simply want to reiterate the commitment that is a commitment based on credibility, which is the effort that this Government is making in investment in El Prat airport. If we are making this investment effort, of renewal, of expansion, and practically of doubling the potential of El Prat, it is because we know that El Prat, and Barcelona, can and deserve to be a great airport also for intercontinental flights.