Press conference of the Prime Minister and the Secretary-General of the United Nations.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 March 2005 · Press conference of the Prime Minister and the Secretary-General of the United Nations

Context
Zapatero and UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan held a joint press conference in Madrid on March 8, 2005, during the Conference on Terrorism and Democracy.
Main themes
Fight against terrorism, United Nations reform, Alliance of Civilizations, March 11 Madrid bombing solidarity, international cooperation, Millennium Development Goals, Middle East situation, Alliance Against Hunger, responsibility to protect, peace and international order, Spain-UN relations, UN Summit 2005
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,613
82nd percentile
Sentences
115
69th percentile
Readability
33
22nd percentile
Grade
16.3
86th percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

115 sentences in 50 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. I want, first of all, to express my deep satisfaction with the presence in our country of the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Annan, and to express, as well, my gratitude because this presence, which has as its fundamental objective the participation of the Secretary-General in the Conference on Terrorism and Democracy, is an expression of solidarity, first and foremost, with the victims of the attack of March 11 of last year and solidarity with the people of Madrid and with the Spanish people.

This is a permanent solidarity that we have received from Kofi Annan and a permanent solidarity from the United Nations that I want to highlight, just as I want to express my conviction that the fight against terrorism and the reduction of terrorism have as their fundamental channel the strengthening of the United Nations, the strengthening of the values of the United Nations, the capacity of the United Nations to unite efforts, to add decisions, and to address the issues that affect the international order and security in general.

I also want to express that the United Nations means, for the Spanish people, international legality, it means peace, it means the fight against hunger and against misery. Every time the United Nations and its Secretary-General mobilize for these causes, they know they can count on many countries, but with Spain as the foremost. The Spanish people have expressed this on many occasions, in the streets and in their daily attitude. Now I say this to Kofi Annan in person and on behalf of all: always count on Spain.

For this reason, Spain is an active country in strengthening the United Nations. We are the eighth largest contributor to the International Organization that represents the hope for peace, international legality, and understanding. In this last year, we have been increasing our contribution to the various Programs led by the United Nations. This year we have been adding initiatives and efforts in the realm of the United Nations, such as our participation in the Alliance Against Hunger, to demand and hold ourselves accountable for the achievement of the Millennium Goals. And also in the realm of the United Nations, which is the keystone of a system of peace and international order, we have proposed the Alliance of Civilizations, an idea and project that we are working on with the United Nations Secretariat.

I reiterate my gratitude to the Secretary-General for his presence in Spain, for his solidarity, and for the efforts he makes to strengthen an Organization that, without a doubt, is the best hope for a just international order.

Kofi Annan.- Thank you very much, Mr. President, for those warm words and for the wonderful welcome you have given to my team and to myself.

I am delighted to be here in Spain to participate in the Conference on Terrorism and Democracy. We live in a world where the issue of terrorism affects us all. When people are attacked in Madrid, New York, or Baghdad, it has an impact on all of us. I am here to express the determination of the United Nations to work with governments, countries, and peoples around the world to fight against terrorism and to express our solidarity to the victims of terrorism here, on March 11, and also our solidarity with the victims of terrorism worldwide and with the victims of terrorism in Spain.

I hope that this meeting, which will bring together leaders and officials from around the world, will allow us to reaffirm the need for international collaboration so that we all work together to ensure that terrorists are not given financial, logistical, or refuge support in any of our countries. Tomorrow I will make a statement on this issue, so I do not want to spend too much time on this matter.

I also want to thank the President for the suggestion he has made to us regarding the Alliance of Civilizations, in which we hope that peoples and governments will focus on how we can work together so that peoples share a planet and work in harmony and solidarity to thus reinforce peace, development, and harmony among peoples. It is a topic we are working very closely on, and I hope to be able to tell you more about it in the not-too-distant future.

I have also been able to talk with the President about other matters of mutual interest: we have talked about Iraq, we have talked about the events in the Middle East, the events in Syria and Lebanon, what is happening in Africa, including Western Sahara, and other issues; of course, also about the reform of the United Nations and the Summit that will be held in New York in September. I hope that the Summit will bring together Heads of State and Government to make important decisions together that will allow for the reform of the United Nations. Issues of politics, issues of the use of force, of the responsibility to protect citizens living in situations where human rights violations or even potential genocides occur; issues where governments do not respond to their obligations are a responsibility of the Security Council, and it is also the Council's responsibility to reform itself, as well as to achieve economic development to meet the Millennium Goals.

For all these issues, I have no doubt that Spain will provide us with its support, and I am sure that we will be able to work with other governments to adapt the United Nations to the challenges of the 21st century.

So, once again, Mr. President, allow me to thank you for your hospitality and to tell you how happy I am to be here. I hope to join all those who have come to this very important meeting, not only to discuss terrorism but also to offer our solidarity to the victims of terrorism, wherever they may be.

Q.- I wanted to ask the Secretary-General several questions. Can you advance anything more regarding the Alliance of Civilizations? Are you willing to lead a high-level group to put into practice the idea of President Rodríguez Zapatero?

Secondly, I would like to know your opinion on the fact that the United States has appointed a new Ambassador to the United Nations who is an openly critical and very tough diplomat, particularly with multilateralism and the United Nations.

Mr. Annan.- First of all, I would say that we are working very well on the issue of the Alliance for its realization. There are teams working together; in fact, there is a team here in Madrid that is discussing with representatives of the Spanish government to see how we can continue to advance. I believe we are making good progress, and I think we will be able to identify other governments that are willing to join the process and possibly create a "group of wise persons" that can continue to elaborate on the topic. We will keep you updated as we progress, but I assure you that we are indeed making good advances and that it is a promising project.

Civilizations are often spoken of in terms of conflict, and this time we are talking about the Alliance of Civilizations to focus on the common denominator we have and to emphasize that it is not necessary to detest the other to love what one believes in. We will provide details progressively, but I will certainly cooperate with the Government of Spain and the Prime Minister on this issue.

Regarding your second question about the new American representative to the United Nations, first of all, the appointment of ambassadors is a prerogative of each President; therefore, President Bush has made the decision about who should represent the United States at the United Nations. I have worked well with previous American ambassadors and with other permanent representatives in New York, including the Spanish representative, Juan Yáñez.

Certainly, we have many challenges ahead; we have a very important Summit in September, we have a very full agenda: a reform agenda, an agenda for the fight against poverty, an agenda for seeking new innovative sources of financing, and an agenda to emphasize the importance of international collaboration and the importance of multilateralism. Certainly, Mr. Bolton is welcome to work with us on all these fronts.

Q.- I have a couple of questions for President Rodríguez Zapatero. There is a call for unity in the fight against terrorism, both in a forum being held in Madrid and in the dialogue you have had. Do you not find this request, this demand, contradictory with what is being seen in Spain regarding the division that has occurred concerning the conclusions of the March 11 Commission?

On the other hand, I would like to know more details about the project of the Alliance of Civilizations. Specifically, could you detail what more details you have shared with the UN Secretary-General?

President.- In relation to the first question, I have always expressed the need for the unity of all democrats in the fight against terrorism. I have not only expressed it, but I have practiced it, because I want to remind you that when I was the leader of the opposition, I proposed a Pact against Terrorism and for Freedoms to the previous government, a Pact that has yielded good results. Since I have come to power, I have maintained that agreement, and I have extended information and collaboration to all political forces regarding what represents the fight against terrorism.

Certainly, in the fight against international terrorism, collaboration, cooperation, and unity of efforts must be an essential objective, and I am fully convinced that, just as in the international order that unity is increasingly greater and that unity must be based on the defense of the values of democracy as the best way to defeat terrorism, also in what affects international terrorism in our country we will achieve a solid and strong unity, beyond the events we have experienced and beyond the development of an investigative commission that has another objective.

I have no doubt that the democratic political forces in Spain want and desire great unity against terrorism, and, above all, they want it, they desire it, and they have the right to demand it from us, all citizens. That, without a doubt, will be my commitment and the commitment for which I will work.

Secondly, the Alliance of Civilizations. A moment ago, the Secretary-General said that we have had two areas of debate in recent times: clash of civilizations and dialogue of civilizations. The proposal made by Spain is: Alliance of Civilizations. The Alliance of Civilizations represents that people, that citizens, who are part of different peoples, different cultures, and different civilizations, come together to prioritize their condition of universal citizenship over their belonging to a particular culture, a particular religion, or a particular country.

In a world where globalization presides over the course of History, in a world where the international order has more possibilities than ever to be built around Law and not force, the Alliance of Civilizations is a necessary condition for that objective of a just international order, based on Law and not on force, to gain ground and consolidate the desires of the vast majority of countries.

We are working, as the Secretary-General said, to develop what could be an organization of sponsors, a High-Level Group, which should produce a whole program of action. As I already said at the United Nations Assembly, it is a proposal from Spain to the United Nations. From this moment on, it is already a proposal from the United Nations, which will carry the pace, which will carry the content and the development that the Secretary-General and the United Nations deem appropriate, with our collaboration and with the collaboration of many other governments that are interested and that have expressed their commitment to participate in the Alliance of Civilizations.

Q.- I wanted to delve a little into what you are commenting on. Are those measures, which, as you say, will follow the pace that is imposed in the United Nations or that somehow have to be carried out, have those concrete measures been addressed in this meeting with the Secretary-General? Is there any that you can advance to us, even if it is already a measure from the United Nations, it is always a proposal from Spain? Is there any concrete measure, considering that many countries, specifically those of the Arab League, where you will soon present this idea of civilizations, have already expressed their support? Can you advance anything about that calendar? The question is for both.

A question for the UN Secretary-General. Have you received the support of the Spanish government in that idea you have of a new consensus to fight against terrorism, a new consensus in international politics based on multilateralism? Has that support you have received from the Spanish government been received from many other countries, and do you expect to receive it from all, including the United States?

President.- In relation to the development of the Alliance of Civilizations, we are in the phase of sharing ideas and initiatives, of bringing together people and personalities to set a path, a work agenda, which, I insist, will take the pace and time that the Secretary-General himself decides. Without a doubt, there are already concrete ideas to involve other countries, other governments, and other presidents; but, logically, there needs to be a whole process of dialogue with various countries and various leaders, which, of course, we will finalize in a reasonable time and which will consolidate and strengthen what I hope and wish will be an ambitious program in the realization of that Alliance of Civilizations as a fundamental element of the international order.

Mr. Annan.- Regarding your second question, let me say that cooperation between governments in the fight against terrorism already exists. The United Nations has been very active in this fight, the Security Council has adopted very important resolutions, we have a Counter-Terrorism Committee, chaired by Ambassador Rupérez, who is here with us, and the General Assembly itself has adopted twelve conventions against terrorism and is working on the thirteenth.

The Security Council resolutions have the force of law and all governments are, in principle, required to implement them. Naturally, some have more resources and capabilities than others, and we are now trying to see the necessary means to assist those governments that do not have the means themselves, as is the case with some small countries. We are also concerned about weak states and failed states where terrorism can develop. This is one of the reasons, in fact, why we have linked terrorism and development so closely.

The Group I have created examines this challenge and has made it very clear that we cannot define threats too narrowly; that threats must include weapons of mass destruction, terrorism, extreme poverty, diseases, or environmental degradation, and that we must find responses to all these challenges.

So, frankly, if you go to other parts of the world and ask a person in another place what concerns them most, some areas will say "terrorism," but others will say "poverty," and others will say "I am more concerned about environmental degradation." Therefore, we must address these issues and find a balance on these matters as an International Community so that we can help each other.

Consequently, the issue of cooperation and international solidarity and the aspect of a multilateral approach to terrorism is an integral part of the culture of the United Nations and of the United Nations approach. We need police, legal experts, politicians, diplomats, and intelligence services to work together; all must work jointly to prevent terrorists from carrying out their attacks. Naturally, sometimes force must be used, but this only as part of a comprehensive approach to the struggle.

Q.- I would like to ask the Secretary-General of the United Nations for his opinion on yesterday's proposal from Hezbollah in Lebanon, in favor of the presence of Syrian troops in the country, which seems to contradict the United Nations Resolution from September.

Mr. Annan.- We have been in contact with the governments of Lebanon and Syria, and I have a personal representative who is working on the matter and who is, in fact, here today in Madrid, and is going tomorrow to the area to speak with President Assad and President Lahoud of Lebanon.

The Security Council Resolution requires Syria to withdraw all its troops and also security personnel from Lebanon. Syria has expressed its willingness to withdraw its troops. The Security Council Resolution calls for a withdrawal from Syria. Syria has also mentioned that they would implement it in accordance with the Taif Agreement; but I believe that, from the perspective of the Security Council, the fundamental point is that a total and complete withdrawal takes place, regardless of whether it is based on the Security Council Resolution, the Taif Agreement, or an agreement from the Syrian government itself. What is essential is that this withdrawal occurs, and the Syrian government has not rejected the Security Council Resolution.

We will work with them, and when my personal representative informs me of their conversations, I will have a clearer idea of the timelines for the withdrawal and I hope to be able to provide them with a schedule at that time.

Q.- I wanted to ask the Secretary-General. The Spanish position at this moment on the Sahara conflict or what Spain is suggesting is that it is necessary to introduce some adjustments to the Baker Plan for it to be viable. What is your opinion on that proposal and what willingness do you see in the parties to the conflict to accept adjustments?

Mr. Annan.- I had a very interesting conversation with the President and the Spanish delegation on this issue. I believe that, regarding the ultimate goal of wanting to resolve this Polisario conflict and wishing for the issue to be resolved so that the Maghreb Union can revive its activities and work as a union, which has a consequence, of course, on its relations with the European Union; we agree that everything possible must be done to resolve the conflict as soon as possible, working with Algeria, Morocco, and the Polisario.

I know that Spain has excellent relations with all parties, and as we move forward, we will rely on countries like yours, as you have such good relations to help us resolve the conflict.

As for what the final solution would be, it will be the result of the conversations that will have to take place between the parties. We cannot impose the solution on them, but it must be the result of negotiated solutions, and we intend to promote these efforts.

Q.- This is a question about the Alliance against Hunger. What would be the practical manifestation of this matter?

President.- As you know, the Alliance against Hunger has two basic objectives, after having managed to bring together a very high number of countries.

The first objective is to raise awareness and achieve an increase from developed countries for development cooperation aid. That increase, of course, is going to happen, it is happening in Spain and also, as a result of that awareness, it will happen in many other countries. I want to remind you that this year we have reached 0.3 percent of Gross Domestic Product in development aid and that in the next three years we will reach, as a country, 0.5 percent of Gross Domestic Product in development aid.

The second objective is the development of new formulas for international financing of development aid. These new formulas are being studied by a working group made up of representatives from all the countries, from the main countries that are in the Alliance against Hunger; new formulas for development financing that may involve an international levy on certain types of transactions, which may relate to the process of consolidating other types of remittances generated or originated by immigration or that may relate to a commitment to the application of various international instruments.

Logically, for new international instruments for development financing to be consolidated and effective, I insist, without determining in advance what can be taxed in international transactions, there must be political will from a sufficient number of countries that are willing to commit to it. And at this moment, there is a significant number, from our perspective, of countries that are willing to commit to new rules in the international order of transactions so that there is a levy that goes directly to development, to the fight against poverty and against hunger. It would be a historic qualitative leap if achieved.

It is true that it also depends on the attitude of some great power and the attitude of the most developed countries in the world; but we must maintain a prudent expectation in this regard.

These are the two main objectives that the Alliance against Hunger is working on, which ultimately has a clear destination: to achieve the Millennium Goals in the fight against poverty. We are going to examine what is currently the compliance with the Millennium Goals, and the Alliance against Hunger fights for that examination to be one that the International Community can pass, and that passing of the International Community in the compliance with the Millennium Goals and in the fight against hunger is the passing of dignity, it is the passing of dignity for the International Community, for developed countries, because with not a very great effort we could prevent many deaths from hunger and many deaths from diseases for many human beings in the world.

Thank you very much.