Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 March 2005 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on government transparency, anti-corruption conventions, and tax reform during a congressional control session in March 2005.
Main themes
Government transparency, anti-corruption measures, Council of Europe corruption conventions, public sector contracts reform, political party financing, Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, family tax deductions, income tax reform, Transparency International Spain ranking
Duration
~18 min
59th percentile
Words
2,104
59th percentile
Sentences
66
43rd percentile
Readability
38
32nd percentile
Grade
15.5
80th percentile
Syntax
3.49
93rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 62%62%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

66 sentences in 35 paragraphs

President.- Mr. Puigcercós, I thank you for your question. As is well known, the Government maintains a firm position in defense of the best practices in public management, of transparency, and of the trust that this generates in the citizenry. To this end, the Government has been developing a broad program of initiatives to reinforce that transparency; that is why we have approved a Code of Good Governance for Senior Officials of the Administration, that is why we have approved a Bill on Conflicts of Interest for the Government and Senior Officials, which strengthens preventive measures; that is why in the Royal Decree Law on Productivity Enhancement there are modifications to the Public Administration Contracts Law to introduce more transparency and competition, and that is why we are already working, in an advanced manner, on a Public Sector Contracts Bill to reinforce the principles of publicity and to improve the award criteria, eliminating inaccuracies or vagueness.

In addition to this, I can announce to you today, surely to your satisfaction and certainly to that of my Government, that Spain, through the Minister of Justice, will sign in Helsinki, on April 7, and almost six years after its opening for signature by the member states of the Council of Europe, the two Conventions, criminal and civil, on corruption. The first of them, already signed by 43 states, is an ambitious instrument whose objective is to achieve, in a coordinated manner, in all European states the criminalization of a huge number of behaviors linked to corruption practices. The civil convention, signed by 37 states, defines for the first time the common rules at the international level in the field of Civil Law and corruption.

I can also inform you that several new delegations of the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office have been created in recent months in various parts of Spanish geography and that, as you know, the Attorney General's Office has three basic priorities: gender-based violence, workplace accidents, and the fight against corruption and any type of fraud and organized crime, as has been very evident in recent days.

Mr. Puigcercós.- I appreciate your words, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. These were some of the Conventions that in recent years the Spanish Government did not ratify; criminal and civil conventions that the majority of European states had ratified, and it is paradoxical that this change was needed to be able to ratify these Conventions.

The organization "Transparency International" has very recently published its annual corruption perception index in the world, according to which Spain is situated among the last countries in the European community, behind France and Belgium, and only ahead of Portugal, Italy, and Greece.

According to statements from a leader of this entity in the United Kingdom, on the occasion of the global presentation of the report from London, corruption in Spain is fundamentally located in public works and local administration. This is stated by "Transparency International."

We sincerely believe that this must be a priority for the Government, as it must be a priority for the Government to eliminate any hint of doubt and opacity in the contractual relationships that the Administrations have.

You already know —you have read it in the press— that the Catalan Government has also decided to create an Office against Fraud to combat these dynamics that can be said, at the very least, to create a permanent doubt among the citizenry.

And we also communicate to you on behalf of the Esquerra Republicana Group that we also believe that the citizenry needs to know with more transparency what the management of political parties is. We have already advanced for days that the Esquerra Republicana Group will present a Bill to change the Political Parties Financing Law. We believe that this debate is necessary.

Citizens have the right to know that, although it is legal and there are anonymous donations, there are also donations and who they are from. We believe that there have been too many cases, we will remember, such as the Naseiro case and the Filesa case, which are cases that deserve an explanation. And not long ago, in the Assembly of Madrid, elections had to be repeated due to a situation that was also dubious.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOSEP ANTONI DURÁN I LLEIDA, OF THE CATALAN PARLIAMENTARY GROUP OF CONVERGÈNCIA I UNIÓ

Mr. Durán.- Mr. President, does the Government intend to reduce the family deductions for dependent children applicable to the Income Tax base?

President.- As you know, the Government has the commitment, expressed in the Investiture Speech, to send to this Chamber a tax reform. Specifically, the commitment is a tax reform in the second year of the legislature, that is, this year. Today I can specify something more from the point of view of the temporal horizon.

At the end of this month, the Economic Vice President will publicly present the bases or principles of that tax reform so that they can undergo a public debate regarding such an important task as taxation in a country. In the last quarter of this year, the regulatory projects for tax reform will be sent to this Parliament for debate and approval if applicable.

I have expressed on several occasions that this tax reform seeks two basic objectives: simplicity in the Personal Income Tax and greater equity. And, from my point of view, from the Government's point of view, it is possible to achieve greater equity in the consideration of the family circumstances of taxpayers and in what logically affects deductions for children according to current legislation.

Mr. Durán.- I sincerely appreciate that the Government intends to explain to public opinion and send to the Chamber, in any case, its proposal for tax reform. I believe that to date, based on statements from some members of the economic team, the only thing that has been done is to launch trial balloons, and the citizen in general and the businessman in particular need solidity regarding the fiscal proposals of their Government.

I want to remind you that in that chapter of trial balloons, the Secretary of State Mr. Miguel Ángel Fernández Ordóñez said that the Government announced changes in the deductions for dependent children, adding that the current system favors families with higher incomes and intending to replace in any case —evidently, using the language that "only favored the rich"— the deductions in the base for deductions in the quota.

Our Parliamentary Group agrees, and will insist, that the family is one of the priorities of fiscal policy. Spain is at the bottom of aid to families and, consequently, would not accept the replacement of deductions for children in the taxable base today for the replacement by deductions in the quota.

We understand that the Personal Income Tax is basically a tax that taxes wealth and that what a family spends for its personal sustenance or for the sustenance of its children, the vital or family minimum, cannot be considered wealth. Consequently, on that basis, no fiscal burden can be imposed on children in any way.

On the other hand, you know perfectly well, Mr. President, that the Personal Income Tax is precisely a tax that is mainly paid by the middle classes; that is, more than 50 percent of the revenue that the Public Treasury collects from the Personal Income Tax comes from the incomes of modest people or middle classes. For those with great fortunes, it is not the tax route through which they contribute or settle their efforts in fiscal matters.

From this observation, consequently, we defend that the Government, contrary to what the Secretary of State for Finance maintains, should not do what would be a grave error, because it would mean burdening families more and burdening the middle classes more, against the right and need to support families also in fiscal matters.

President.- Mr. Durán, I am convinced that you share with me that it is good to have a broad public debate process regarding what a tax reform is. That is why I have just expressed to you that at the end of this month the Government will announce the principles or bases of the reform until the last quarter when it will send the regulatory texts to the Chamber.

Regarding family circumstances, regarding family aid policy in the Personal Income Tax, I must give you a piece of data and suggest a reflection that the Government has made and in which, of course, it has reached an evident conclusion. The data is to take a situation at this moment of two taxpayers, two citizens, with one dependent child; one earns 10,000 euros and the other 60,000 euros. In the current system, the first deducts 210 euros and the second 630 euros; that is, exactly triple.

Mr. Durán, I am convinced that you consider that this system can be much more equitable to favor and help families much more, yes, all of them, but especially families that need it the most.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY BREY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, a few days ago a columnist referred in a national newspaper to a reflection by Ralf Dahrendorf: "when politicians have no ideas, they decide to reform the Constitution." That is you, but in addition, you delegate it to another, I don’t know if because you don’t know what you want or because you want to offload the responsibility or blame onto that other. And the one who receives the commission surprises us with various ideas, the latest being that in Spain there are Autonomous Communities that are national communities that extend to other Autonomous Communities and to part of abroad. Some socialists endorse it and reflect it in their reform proposals, while others, such as your Minister of Defense, criticize it, and today a prominent socialist leader.

I ask you what your opinion is, what is a national community, if you are in favor, what is the plus regarding nationality, what are its effects, who can constitute it and what is the purpose of this whole debate, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I know that there are political forces that have an allergy to reforms. It is a historical fact, just as it is historical that all the Constitutions in our European environment have been reformed on various occasions. And the political forces that always refuse to reforms are usually reformed by citizens at the polls.

I will tell you that I express my respect for the freedom of opinion of the President of the Council of State, who has an established trajectory of intellectual, personal, and state service authority, and who, from his independence, will carry out a brilliant function in the service of the general interest by informing the constitutional reform that we have proposed.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, the problem is that you are the President of the Government, and that is a real problem, not Mr. Rubio Llorente. Spaniards want you to tell them what you want to do, what your criteria is, what your opinion is, and to stop consulting committees of wise men to then do nothing.

I ask you to withdraw the consultation to the Council of State, which is not there to replace either your lack of ideas or your absence of convictions. I don’t know if it is bad to have an allergy to reforms but, certainly, having an allergy to knowledge, being the President of the Government, is devastating, Mr. President.

A President of the Government must have, at least, a certain idea of Spain and share it, and not create problems where there are none, and sometimes have some criteria and define himself on something, because one cannot live permanently on archangelic declarations, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, of what I have heard from you in recent times, the assertion that I am the President of the Government is the most accurate thing I recall.

Since we are talking about statements, yesterday I heard you say that the Government has a foreign policy that seems like a permanent orgy. Mr. Rajoy, I don’t know what they have told you, but I can assure you that it is not that much. In any case, you cannot complain, because in this very Chamber I invited you to go to Poland. You did not want to go and, if you are encouraged in the future to travel, you will be able to verify that it is not that much, that there is no permanent orgy.

Thank you very much.