Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

18 May 2004 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on Canary Islands EU status and the European Commission's demand for Izar shipbuilding aid repayment in a May 2004 control session.
Main themes
Canary Islands outermost region status, EU structural funds and aid, European Constitutional Treaty, banana and tomato agricultural trade, coordination with Canarian regional government, Izar shipbuilding EU Commission ruling, illegal state aid recovery, employment and industrial policy, Spanish government EU negotiation strategy
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,224
62nd percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
30
16th percentile
Grade
17.4
91st percentile
Syntax
3.69
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
72nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 43%43%
  • Economic 34%34%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

56 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Mr. Rivero.- Mr. President of the Government, both in the investiture session and in your subsequent appearance in the Senate, we have shared objectives, priorities, and concerns regarding the maintenance of the singularities that Canarias has before the European Union. Mr. President, what steps is your Government taking to defend the singularities of the Canary Islands within the European Union?

President.- Thank you, Mr. Rivero, for your question. As I have already expressed both in the Investiture Debate and in the appearance in the Senate, it is the firm will of the Government to defend the special status of the Canary Islands within the European Union. And I can inform you that from the first day we have developed our activity in the external sphere and specifically in the area of the European Union, we have firmly maintained this position.

I believe that to this day, the recognition of the character of an outermost region, which guarantees us other conditions of special aid, is on the right track, and I am convinced that this will be the achievement in the European Constitution with the effects that we will have for it later.

Mr. Rivero.- Mr. President, indeed, the problems that Canarias faces before the European Union are not temporary problems, but structural problems, and therefore require policies, both from a legislative and economic point of view, adapted to that singular reality with the consideration of an outermost territory that the Canary Archipelago has.

In that sense, Mr. President, we ask for the utmost concentration of your Government to defend the most important aspects that Canarias is currently facing: first, Article 56 and Article 330 of the new Constitutional Treaty, where, on the one hand, the level of aid is maintained despite the loss as a Objective 1 region; and, on the other hand, the guarantee, from the perspective of the new European Constitutional Treaty, that all policies are modulated with respect to the outermost territories.

Another fundamental aspect that requires maximum concentration is the issue of funds. The loss of Canarias as an Objective 1 region, having exceeded 75 percent of income, is not an obstacle to defend that the level of aid be maintained given the structural problems we referred to earlier.

The banana, which is currently necessary given the introduction of the single tariff, will be another of the issues that require maximum effort and maximum work; as well as the tomato, where the competition from Moroccan tomatoes makes it necessary to increase the marketing of Canarian tomatoes.

That is why we believe it is fundamental, Mr. President, to coordinate with the Government of Canarias and that within the Spanish delegation you invite a representative of the Government of Canarias to ensure coordination, transparency, and clarity in the entire negotiating process.

President.- Mr. Rivero, I reiterate the Government's conviction about the need for a special and singular policy for Canarias due to its status as an outermost region.

You have listed a series of specific problems that affect, in a very decisive way, the well-being and economic development and that are related to the position in the European Union.

I am convinced that we can achieve the maintenance of aid within what is the internal market regime. I am convinced that the sensitivity in the European Union is notable regarding what the singularity and the status of the Canary Islands as an outermost region represent. And I have the will that the defense of those objectives, that joint work, be the norm that the Government carries out with maximum cooperation with the Government of Canarias.

That is why today I can announce that next Tuesday I will hold a meeting with the President of the Autonomous Community of Canarias to coordinate that cooperation and carry forward the defense that Canarias deserves and that, of course, the Government is willing to practice at all times.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION FORMULATED BY MR. FRANCISCO RODRÍGUEZ SÁNCHEZ, OF THE MIXED PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rodríguez.- Mr. President, the claim for the return of 308 million euros by the European Commission to Izar for aid considered illegal occurs in a context where, first, there is no free competition; second, the European Union itself was forced in the last two years to regulate temporary aid mechanisms for ship contracts; and, third, after twenty years of continuous dismantling, which has led the Spanish State to practically become a victim of decisions that turn us into a country that renounces a highly important industrial and strategic sector.

How will the Government face the recent decision of the European Commission so that it does not lead to the closure of centers and loss of employment?

President.- Mr. Rodríguez, I thank you for your question for the interest and concern you show regarding the situation of Izar, which is the interest and concern of the Government.

I believe it is known to you and to public opinion that we are in a situation that has developed in recent years with various aids that the European Commission has considered not in accordance with community regulations, and that we are aware of the difficult financial situation of Izar, and we are also aware of the difficulties this entails for the immediate future after the position of the European Commission.

I can assure you that the Government will face the situation of Izar with the utmost political will with three objectives: the first of which is the maintenance, up to reasonable levels, of the activity of an important industrial sector for our country; secondly, with the will to have the maximum disposition in the field of labor and union dialogue, and we have already shown this because, after more than a year without signing the agreement, an agreement has been reached in Izar with immediate effect; thirdly, also with the maximum willingness to concert with the regional and local administrations due to the regional impact that, logically, the situation of Izar entails.

Mr. Rodríguez.- Mr. President of the Government, we would like the Government not to submissively accept the design that has been applied to us for many years and that culminates at this moment. In any case, let us rectify the internal causes of the situation, but let us also discuss the external and unjust ones that lead to social and territorial impoverishment and, of course, to disregarding a sector of great strategic importance, as I said.

In any case, I would like you to take the following into account: negotiate the return, in any case, of the money with the European Union in a timeframe that does not endanger the sector; secondly, maintain all productive centers in all territories of the Spanish State; thirdly, let us not renounce our production capacity; fourthly, and this is internal, Mr. President, let us intensify commercial activity, which is far from being done as it should; and fifthly, there is also something fundamental internally, which is to modify the organizational structures of Izar by creating comprehensive complexes of the naval sector, both civil and military, in the different territories.

Allow Izar-Fene to build ships. It would be paradoxical that the only center that has not received aid would now be the victim of a sword of Damocles with its elimination.

Finally, defend aid while the debate in the OECD lasts, which you know exists, and the litigations that even the European Union itself has brought before the WTO.

I believe that only with this design can we come out of this type of debate and conflict reasonably well, which is very concerning for the vast social majorities that exist, at least, in territories like Galicia or Andalucía, in Euskadi and, to a lesser extent, in Asturias.

President.- Mr. Rodríguez, you have made a brief and synthetic presentation of the causes for which we are in this situation that have led to the decision of the European Commission demanding a very significant amount of aid repayment.

This is not the time to delve into, nor does the Government want to, the causes of the management of Izar and the external circumstances you referred to. The Government wants to address the present and the future, and maintain a political commitment with the utmost willingness for economic, labor, and union concertation for the maximum maintenance of possible activity, employment, and the least labor and social impact.

I believe that the Government has reacted quickly and decisively. On May 12, we received the communication from the Commission.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION FORMULATED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, why have you renounced having the future European Constitution signed in Madrid?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the objective of the Government, the first objective, is that we have a European Constitution; that we achieve unblocking the situation we have experienced in recent months and that we can have a Constitution of the European Union.

As you know, for nearly two years Italy has been claiming that the possible signing of the new European Constitution should take place in the city of Rome. After the tragic attack of March 11 in Madrid, there has been a significant effort, continuous gestures of solidarity from many countries, also from the European Parliament, so that Madrid could be the place for the signing of that Constitution of the European Union. I want to reiterate, because I believe it is the expression of all Groups, our gratitude for so much solidarity, especially from the European Union.

But I must tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that you can share with me, almost certainly, that obviously whether the Constitution is signed in Madrid or in another city cannot be, and should not be, an element, after so much solidarity, of division or dispute.

Therefore, I express to you from here that the Government has made the decision it has made, without us yet knowing when and where it will be signed; it has made the decision to show itself open to Rome maintaining the position it held, and logically, that city could be where the future European Constitution is signed.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, I ask you this question because you, in the Investiture Debate, without anyone asking you, solemnly stated that you would do everything possible for the European Constitution to be signed in Madrid; also because the European Parliament, at the proposal of your party and Mr. Rutelli, who is the leader of the opposition in Italy, and with our support, addressed the European Council for this Constitution to be signed in Madrid -- you were quite unsupportive, by the way, with the European Parliament -- and also because your party's electoral program said, because you have now changed it, that the European Constitution should be signed in Madrid.

So, Mr. President, I do not know what has happened, and only two possibilities come to mind: that you have surrendered to the charms of Mr. Berlusconi, in which case you will have to explain here what those charms are, or that you wanted to surprise Mr. Berlusconi with a double portion of good will. But the truth is that who has been surprised is the whole of the Spanish citizens.

We must honor the word given, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, to what you said in the Investiture Debate. And I do not agree with what you say that it is the same whether it is signed in one place or another, because it would be very good if the European Constitution were called the Constitution of Madrid, just as there was the Treaty of Rome, the Treaty of Maastricht, or the Treaty of Nice, and they were signed there; because you generate serious material prejudices to Madrid, because the visit of twenty-five Heads of State and Government, with their entourages, is certainly not a minor issue, and because this would also be a magnificent opportunity, when Madrid is betting, among other things, to be awarded the 2012 Olympics, to demonstrate its organizational capacity.

Therefore, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have committed a frivolity. Honestly, I cannot trust you, and there are many people who have been hurt that you, in that chamber, in the Investiture Debate, solemnly said, "I will do everything possible for the Constitution to be signed here," and two days later you meet with Mr. Berlusconi and force Mr. Borrell, Mr. Barón, and your party to change everything that was said in your electoral program.

So, a little, even if only a little, less frivolity, because there have been many, Mr. President: yesterday it was housing, before it was the Unified Command, before it was the VAT on cultural products, before it was regional financing... We must tell the truth or, at least, be more prudent.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, everyone understands the construction of the European Union in their own way, and the results of recent times that we saw for Spain have been what they have been.

Solidarity is responded to with solidarity, and I can assure you that the position the Government has maintained you will understand and the vast majority of Spaniards will understand. I could understand, if we were in a debate between Paris or Berlin, your suspicion, but, regarding Rome, I find it very strange the position you have maintained, Mr. Rajoy, in this debate.