Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 June 2004 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on Spain's foreign relations and domestic infrastructure policy during a government control session on 15 June 2004.
Main themes
Spain-Morocco relations, Spain-US relations, Morocco-US free trade agreement, parliamentary question time, Catalonia toll road discrimination, regional infrastructure policy, bilateral cooperation, immigration and security cooperation, anti-terrorism cooperation, EU concerns over Morocco arms sales
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,167
61st percentile
Sentences
65
43rd percentile
Readability
35
26th percentile
Grade
15.7
81st percentile
Syntax
3.62
97th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%49%
  • Geopolitical 23%23%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

65 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Mr. Rivero.- Mr. President of the Government, on the chessboard where the pieces of international relations policy move, there have been some movements of pieces over the last few weeks.

Spain's relations with the United States are more distant; they are currently, let’s say, lukewarm. France has regained its traditional relationship with the United States, just as Germany is also restoring its relations with the Americans. The United States declared Morocco a privileged partner, a preferred partner, just ten days ago. Just yesterday, an agreement was signed in Washington between the Government of the United States and the Alaouite Kingdom, declaring a free trade agreement between the two countries.

In this regard, I would like to know the opinion of the President of the Government on whether these types of movements or agreements that are taking place, basically the declaration of Morocco as a preferred partner by the United States, could affect the agreements reached by Spain and Morocco in the meeting held in Casablanca on April 24.

President.- Mr. Rivero, I must tell you that, following that meeting in Casablanca with the King of Morocco, relations with the neighboring country have clearly improved. There have already been various contacts between ministers of the Government of Spain and ministers of the Government of Morocco, and there has been an intensification of cooperation in the economic sphere, in the area of security, in the fight against illegal immigration, and also in the fight against terrorism.

I believe that the Government of the Canary Islands itself is a witness to this with the recent visit that the President of the Canary Islands made to Morocco and with that good climate and that new space for economic cooperation.

Therefore, focusing at this moment on the content of your question, I tell you: I believe that we are in a very good moment in the path of relations with Morocco.

Mr. Rivero.- Mr. President, my Group has always advocated strengthening relations with the Alaouite Kingdom, and that is why we thought it was a good step by the previous Government of Spain to restore relations in December, and we think it is a very good opportunity for the first visit that the President of the Government of Spain makes in this new legislature to also be to Morocco. Therefore, we are in favor of promoting all that means cooperation and development policies with Morocco, not only from Spain but also all those that can be promoted from the European Union and from other points of the International Community. We find that positive.

But at the same time, we are concerned to see how within the European Union there is currently more concern about the free trade agreement reached between the United States and Morocco than, for example, the lifting of the ban on sales of sophisticated weapons to the Alaouite Kingdom. Similarly, we are concerned, due to their inopportune nature, about the military maneuvers that are going to be carried out in the area at a particularly delicate moment...

President.- Mr. Rivero, I simply want to make a clarification regarding the angle of the relationship between Morocco and the United States. You know that this relationship has been improving for many years; that the declaration of preferred ally adds to a series of countries in different regions such as Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Pakistan, and the Philippines, with which the North American nation has that status; that the commercial agreement has been in the works for two years...

In any case, I was telling you, Mr. Rivero, that this collaboration has a long history; that, of course, in the military sphere it dates back to 1982 and that, beyond the reflection, coupled with the trade agreement that Morocco has signed with the United States, the one it has with Europe, everything that allows countries like Morocco to advance in modernization, in openness, and in a greater relationship with the Western world is undoubtedly good for Spain and good for Morocco.

Therefore, my assessment of that preferential agreement for the intensification of Morocco's opening, both in Europe and in the transatlantic sphere, is undoubtedly that it is favorable news.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOSEP ANTONI DURÁN I LLEIDA, OF THE CATALAN PARLIAMENTARY GROUP OF CONVERGÈNCIA I UNIÓ

Mr. Durán i Lleida.- Mr. President, what measures does the Government plan to promote to solve the current discrimination suffered by the citizens of Catalonia given that 59 percent of the high-capacity roads dependent on the State in its territory are toll roads, while the average for the entire State is reduced to 23 percent?

President.- Mr. Durán, as you know, this is a debate that has been ongoing for a long time and is a debate resulting from a situation that is objectively as you have described, that is, that in Catalonia there is a very high volume of high-capacity toll roads.

It is true that decades have passed with this debate and that even in recent years your Group has had a government collaboration with different Governments without addressing the problem. And I will say that you know, just as I do, that it is a very difficult problem due to what it represents from an economic perspective regarding the possible rescue of tolls on highways. Note that even in recent times or in the last years of mandate, toll highways have also been built by the Government of Catalonia.

In any case, the Government is willing to engage in dialogue on such a serious and enormously difficult issue. I can assure you that this dialogue with the Government of Catalonia must be the result of a consensus rather than a unilateral dialogue.

Mr. Durán i Lleida.- Do not always remind me of what we have done in the past because with the counter at zero in the Investiture Debate, it gives me the feeling that you forget it again, because, in any case, this is a problem that has been ongoing for a long time, as far back as the Government of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party. And, without a doubt, we tried to solve it both with you and with the Popular Party.

There is an objective reality that you have just recalled, that there is discrimination and, therefore, the citizens of Catalonia pay more in tolls. That principle of equality of citizens before the principle of the rights of the autonomies is broken here. What your Minister of Defense likes to remind us and that you and the Popular Party assume here is broken: the citizens of Catalonia are not equal.

I want to remind you of a statement by the Minister of Development regarding this issue, which says: "the future should only have toll highways in those corridors where there is already a high-capacity road for free use, that is, that the toll road must always have a free alternative that, due to its layout and serious state of conservation, constitutes a real alternative to the toll."

I believe that, regardless of whether you want to resolve this bilaterally with the Government of Catalonia, in the end it is the General Budgets, in accordance with the philosophy of your Minister of Development, that must resolve it. Therefore, I urge you, Mr. President, that now, to the extent that you recognize that there is discrimination with respect to Catalonia, in the next General Budgets of 2005 you start investing in Catalonia precisely to achieve this objective that you propose for the entire territory of the Spanish State.

Meanwhile, as it cannot be solved by opening highways that correspond to this philosophy in twenty-four hours or in twenty-four months, rescue tolls; progressively rescue, for example, the one in Martorell or it could also be the one in Mollet. We should not only look at the economic cost of rescuing the toll, we must also look at the intangible social value of this rescue. If there is an investment in roads, that is expensive; but, without a doubt, it is made because it has a social value. Therefore, progressively rescue, I understand, tolls so that this, let’s say, evolution of the tangible that has social value can also be possible.

President.- Mr. Durán, I have no interest in talking about the past, obviously, and for that reason I will avoid the toll highways that the Generalitat of Catalonia has built. I simply mention it as a fact for the objective recognition that we are facing a difficult problem, a problem of great economic magnitude, and that the Government has the will to dialogue and address it; certainly, from a first decision that is that the high-capacity roads that we are going to implement—some to be developed in their final phases, others to be initiated—in Catalonia will certainly be high-capacity roads and free of tolls, whether they are highways or expressways. Various expressways and other planned actions are in that situation.

As for the substance of the toll problem, I tell you: the Government of Spain is willing to talk with the Government of Catalonia about it.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rajoy.- Does the President consider that the actions of the Government he presides respond to a clear economic model shared by all its members?

President.- Yes, of course. It certainly responds to a coherent economic model, presented in the Investiture Debate by the person who is the President of the Government.

Mr. Rajoy.- You have received a very good economic inheritance: balanced accounts, Social Security with a surplus, economic growth higher than that of the countries around us, and good job creation figures. All of this has been due to the efforts of the Spanish people, supported by a known, predictable, coherent economic policy without internal contradictions that generated credibility and trust.

I asked you in the Investiture Debate about your economic policy; I posed several questions. I want to tell you that you did not answer any of them, and the various statements and corrections from members of your Government in recent weeks have created more confusion and, worse, unease. We have heard many things and very different things on such important issues as the deficit, budgetary stability, not to mention housing, commercial hours, taxes—the latest being the taxation of capital gains—, infrastructures, regional financing, and others. And all of this, Mr. President, does not generate either credibility or trust; rather, the opposite.

Your economic Vice President, rather than leading an economic project, acts like a goalkeeper dedicated to stopping the goals that his Ministers want to score, and in the end, it gives the impression that there are two Governments in one Government.

I ask you, Mr. President, who has been absent in this debate because you have not said a single word about all these matters, to lead an economic project, to set out lines of action, and to put an end to this carousel of ups and downs that is very unedifying and very dangerous. Do not rely solely on the inherited legacy, because it can be spent quickly.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, your question refers to the actions of the Government in my economic model. I simply want to refer to what we have done in two months, in the time since I was elected President of the Government.

The Government has agreed, in accordance with the Budgetary Stability Law, its budgetary stability scenario for the next three years; which, by the way, will be debated in this Chamber tomorrow. There, a whole framework of forecasts regarding budgetary stability, growth, and basic objectives is contained.

As I already expressed in the Investiture Debate, the economic model of the Government is growth, stability, macroeconomic stability, budgetary stability, quality job creation, and productivity through innovation. Those are the objectives that will be contained in the General State Budgets, which is undoubtedly a relevant economic moment to set the major objectives.

But, speaking of actions, in addition to the agreement I just indicated, we have taken some actions anticipating the most urgent needs, such as raising the Minimum Interprofessional Wage and increasing the amount and scope of scholarships.

Regarding actions, I do want to mention that we have encountered some actions that concern the Government, such as, for example, the debt of Radiotelevisión Española, which amounts to 7.2 billion euros, that is, 1,035,000,000 million pesetas; or the debt of RENFE, which amounts to 7.2 billion euros, that is, 1,200,000,000 million; or that of AENA, which already reaches 3.9 billion euros, that is, 650,000 million pesetas, which will undoubtedly continue to grow, or the burden of the management of IZAR.

These are relevant data, not opinions, that concern the Government and that will be addressed in the General State Budgets to create a more effective economic growth model and budgetary stability, more transparent, with more development and more social welfare, which are the commitments of my Government.