Speech by the President of the Government at the Plenary Assembly of the International Labour Organization

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 June 2004 · Plenary Assembly of the International Labour Organization · Council Chamber (International Labour Organization)

Context
Zapatero addressed the 92nd ILO Plenary Assembly in Geneva on June 8, 2004, in his first UN system speech as Spain's new Prime Minister.
Main themes
Multilateralism and international governance, social dimension of globalization, ILO's role in international relations, social rights as 21st century priority, labor standards and workers' rights, alternative to unilateralism and neoliberalism, sustainable development, European integration and social cohesion, human dignity, tripartite dialogue, trade liberalization and social rules, cosmopolitan international order
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,430
81st percentile
Sentences
111
68th percentile
Readability
15
1st percentile
Grade
18.7
96th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 30%30%
  • Economic 26%26%
  • Social 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

111 sentences in 60 paragraphs

Mr. President, Mr. Director-General, ladies and gentlemen Delegates,

I would like to congratulate Mr. Milton Ray Guevara, Secretary of State for Labor of the Dominican Republic, on his appointment to preside over the 92nd International Labour Conference. I also wish to thank Mr. Somavía for his kind words, whom I greet and admire for the way he carries out his role as Director-General of this Organization.

This is the first time that, as President of the Government of Spain, I take the floor before an Assembly belonging to the United Nations system. I do so with a feeling of special emotion, just a few meters from the Council Chamber, that symbol of the old League of Nations donated to the Organization by Spain in 1937, when, despite the war ravaging my country, the maxims of Francisco de Vitoria and the frescoes of José María Sert were chosen to proclaim the supreme values of peace, justice, respect for international law, and the defense of human dignity.

Speaking about work in a multilateral international organization is a way to express my political concerns regarding the social effects of globalization and, more generally, about the governance of the world. Addressing these issues in a United Nations body is to bet on a multilateral political vision of international relations, in contrast to the temptations and realities of unilateralism.

The United Nations system opens a path for the institutionalization of international society, beyond mere power relations. It is currently essential to reform and enhance the functioning of the United Nations and the multilateral cooperation frameworks on a global scale. The ideas of a cosmopolitan vision of the international order express the need to consider sovereignty as an authority legitimized based on respect for human rights and democratic values.

The alternative to unilateralism and neoliberalism entails a more complex vision of world politics and the evolution of the economy. Specifically, in the social sphere, we must advance, in parallel, in the international application of the principles of the traditional social democracy project and in consolidating progress in international multilateral coordination.

Addressing the role of the International Labour Organization in this new international project means including an objective of giving a social dimension to international relations. This must be the great objective of the 21st century.

If in the 20th century human rights emerged as a universal conquest, if in the 20th century political and citizenship rights were consolidated and extended by more and more countries around the world, the 21st century should be the century of social rights; social rights that are and constitute the necessary balance to economic development, to development, to the liberalization of markets, to economic cooperation, and to a permanent opening of the world economies, because reform or trade liberalization must necessarily occur within the framework of a global strategy for sustainable development. And there is no sustainable development other than development that integrates social rights and rights in defense of the dignity of individuals.

This Organization has a dual dimension: on the one hand, it develops international standards and is also a forum for the tripartite meeting of governments, trade unions, and business associations, all within an increasingly global context of the international economy. This makes the International Labour Organization a key institution for providing that necessary social dimension to the globalized economy and international trade.

The experience of many years in developing international standards by the International Labour Organization; the existence of conventions that establish frameworks of basic rights, as enshrined in the 1998 Declaration of Principles and Rights at Work, is a guarantee of that essential role.

Freedom of association, the abolition of forced labor and child labor, non-discrimination, would be key references to understand that a state can participate in the international economy from economic and social conditions not based on the violation of principles of universal recognition.

From a European country like Spain and from a government like the one I represent, which wants above all to promote the consolidation of the European political project as a political project identified by dialogue, unity, peace, and social cohesion, I want to recall how the Council of the European Union has used the criterion of compliance with the international social rules of the ILO as an element of assessment for trade opening. If Europe understands that it is not only compatible but necessary to apply social rules to globalization, the International Labour Organization is an obligatory reference institution.

Achieving a balance between market liberalization, the application of minimum social rules, and development aid is undoubtedly not an easy task, but it is an essential task that must be addressed urgently, because a market liberalization that does not take into account the social effects of these processes will be as socially negative as establishing a new protectionism that uses social rights as a cover. One cannot act with formulas that seek an artificial elevation of the social costs of developing countries, even if it is with the politically correct cover of fighting against social dumping.

Labor relations systems must be based on trade union freedom and collective bargaining. They must be systems in which social costs are consistent with the economic situation of the country, but are also the result of decisions by social agents expressed in their free negotiation.

Mr. President,

The International Labour Organization is now 85 years old, and throughout this period, it has never abandoned its two main characteristics: being an instrument for world peace and doing so from the struggle for social justice.

However, over the course of these years, the world has changed. Our Organization has become universal and has ceased to experience the effects of the ideological divisions of the Cold War. But today we face other challenges of the same dimension, especially those linked to internationalization, the liberalization of trade, the universal respect for human rights, and the development of the least developed countries.

The systems of values and social aspirations, the relationships between citizens and states, and the relationships between different countries and regional spaces are today subject to conditions that did not exist at the time when this Organization was born and developed.

In the economic sphere, the multilateral context and conditions have changed radically in recent years. New technologies and scientific progress are engines of the economy that have compressed time and space, revolutionized exchanges, and called into question certain social achievements. They have also forced governments and public authorities to review their role.

The globalization of trade, laden with possibilities for development, paradoxically places us today, as it did 85 years ago, before new forms of what was once called the "social question."

Poverty is gaining ground, and it must be reiterated time and again, affecting, above all, women in all regions of the world.

The disgraceful exploitation of child laborers is unfortunately a current issue, especially in regions of our planet, which should provoke a collective rebellion against such indignity.

And over the last decade, reflection on sustainable development and, in particular, on environmental protection has also imposed itself.

Despite all these changes, the International Labour Organization has been able to face with lucidity and determination the development of its place in the United Nations system and is consolidating new methods capable of optimizing the role of international tripartism in the progressive claims of labor rights.

I would like to highlight here, in particular, two outstanding initiatives: the Organization's Declaration on Principles and Rights at Work and the opening of an in-depth international debate on the social dimension of globalization. I believe that the political reflections I made a few moments ago connect perfectly with the decision in 2001 of the ILO Governing Body to create the Commission on the Social Dimension of Globalization. The report of this Commission and the start of the debate around its conclusions on the 7th of this month at this same Conference give us hope that we have criteria to advance in the direction we advocate.

In my opinion, the report of the World Commission offers us very useful ideas for strategic reflection.

First, building a social dimension of globalization through strengthening good governance systems is an important task that will be on the international discussions in the coming years. My reflection on the globalization of the economy and its social consequences stems from the need for decent work or "dignified work," as we say in Spain, to become a great global objective and not just an objective of the International Labour Organization.

I also believe that the ILO could respond to the Commission's call to improve participation and accountability in the multilateral system through the mobilization of global tripartism, thus contributing fully to building a social dimension for globalization.

We desire and advocate for a process of globalization endowed with a social dimension, based on shared universal values and respect for human rights and the dignity of the person; a fair, inclusive globalization, governed democratically and offering tangible opportunities and benefits to all countries and all people in the universe.

On many occasions, attention has focused solely on achieving efficient market functioning; however, very little attention has been paid to what globalization means for individuals, families, local communities, identities, and the possibilities and risks it poses for advancing gender equality in the world.

However, it is worth remembering the benefits that can be obtained from the process of globalization in which we are now immersed: it allows for the promotion of open societies, open economies, more opportunities, and a freer exchange of goods, knowledge, ideas, cultures, and people, and shows that great aspiration of humanity: to build all that we can do together to achieve a more equitable world.

This globalization not only implies the internationalization of physical and financial capital factors, although these are the ones that move the fastest, and often without control, without social responsibility, without democratic governance; but it also implies the internationalization of the labor factor. It is in that framework where immigration comes into play.

Immigration, like other elements of globalization, poses challenges and opportunities. It is undeniable that to gain greater benefit from these opportunities and mitigate their possible costs, it is necessary for migratory movements to be channeled and ordered according to the reception capacities and the needs of the labor market at each moment in the destination country, in such a way that dignified working conditions are offered that meet the requirements of applicable regulations. Immigration must be seen as an opportunity for host countries that an effective and progressive government must transform into growth and progress.

I would like to apply at this moment my reflection to the existence of three dimensions of the globalization process: the globalization of financial flows; the transnationalization of business activities; and the development of information and communication technologies.

It is true that the globalization of financial markets, the increase in the power of transnational companies, and the revolution in information and communication technologies have created unprecedented development opportunities, but they have not yet reached many regions of the world that are left out of the game of global competition and the benefits of ongoing changes.

It has been estimated that the goods and services produced worldwide in the last hundred years, and mainly in the last fifty years, exceed everything that humanity has produced since history has been known. Our potential for the future is immense. However, the comparison between the realities we know today offers shameful results: immensely rich countries and others that are almost beggars. One-sixth of the world's population lives in poverty and does not even know if they will have food for the next day. A large number of people earn barely a dollar a day, and yet there are countries with per capita incomes of 30,000 dollars, about 82 dollars from the United States per day.

I do not believe that the imperatives of free business competition condemn us to choose between economic efficiency and social justice. There is no such dilemma. There are multiple examples of policies that combine both, but without a doubt, education is the most eloquent. An educational system that includes the teaching of languages and new technologies promotes equality of opportunity while increasing productivity and growth potential, thus achieving a more efficient and equitable economy.

The challenge we face, and we know this very well in Europe, is not to defend any model at all costs that may need reform; it is to find effective responses and adapt labor legislation, institutions, social dialogue practices, and collective bargaining to the demands of an economic competition in which innovation and knowledge occupy an unprecedented place.

I am firmly convinced that the response to such a complex challenge involves a serious effort of tripartite social concertation, and it is this last aspect that, in turn, requires a certain boldness and mutual willingness regarding political commitments. Without that openness to dialogue, which is the essence of this institution, and without an interaction of responsibilities among the institutional protagonists of political and social life; without that awareness that the collective good and the notion of public service must prevail over particular interests and strategies, the probability that we can contribute to the building of truly supportive societies will, in my opinion, diminish significantly.

It is worth remembering that new actors are taking on an increasingly important role on the international stage: the International Monetary Fund and the World Trade Organization, primarily. The ILO, this institution, backed by its tripartite tradition, its experience, and its competence to understand the most everyday realities, must assume its role as a pioneer. In particular, it must develop new ideas and redefine its mission within the International Community.

Intergovernmental cooperation, in conjunction with the new actors in the economy, must develop in various areas and particularly in conjunction with the World Trade Organization, the Bretton Woods institutions, and the entire set of institutions of the United Nations system.

Regarding the World Trade Organization, there is an evident complementarity between the objectives of the multilateral trading system and those of the International Labour Organization. Openness to trade has been a powerful vector of economic growth and prosperity. The increase in living standards around the world has made a significant contribution to social progress.

Openness evidently fosters job creation. However, although the adaptation process generates advantages for the entire population, it also entails negative effects for many directly affected individuals. It then falls to the State and international organizations to assist those individuals through concrete measures. The report "World Employment" from 1998 already showed that the most open countries to international exchanges also have very developed social redistribution mechanisms.

But let us not limit the problems solely to the States, considering them separately. Rather, let us globalize our response, the social response to globalization. Therefore, effective cooperation must be established between the World Trade Organization and the International Labour Organization. This approach should allow for the development of an open debate on the interaction between trade and fundamental labor standards: new rules, extension of rights, social guarantees; ultimately, dignity for workers around the world.

On the other hand, we need tools that allow us to better utilize our knowledge. The Declaration of the International Labour Organization concerning fundamental principles and rights at work and its follow-up is one of them because it promotes that activity. The aim is to ensure that each country recognizes that respect for fundamental social rights is a comparative advantage that demonstrates the proper functioning of the national economy. This would represent a decisive step towards uniting social policy with economic policy.

The International Community, ladies and gentlemen, is currently condemned to respond better to these questions than it did during the Great Depression. Thanks to the great competencies of international organizations and the growing moral authority, such as that of the International Labour Organization, it is in a position to provide an adequate response to our questions.

Mr. President,

Spain's relationship with the International Labour Organization has a long history. From its past, I would like to simply recall the contribution of the International Organization and, within it, the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions to the restoration of trade union freedoms suppressed by the Franco dictatorship. The contribution of a well-known figure in this organization was decisive for the creation of these trade union freedoms that the dictatorship shattered: the Minister of Labor of the Second Republic, Francisco Largo Caballero, whose figure I wish to remember today.

From the present of my country's relationship with the International Labour Organization, I would like to recall our commitment to the Organization expressed in the ratification and compliance with conventions and in the development of multiple forms of cooperation, which I intend to expand and develop.

The future of the ILO and its role in a new international order that enhances the social dimension of globalization and social rights in the 21st century, as I have had the opportunity to express extensively in this intervention, constitutes a key aspect of my political vision of international affairs.

Therefore, I wish to thank this noble institution once again for the opportunity it has given me to contribute to this necessary reflection.

But I want to dedicate my last words to express solidarity and also to ask for your support. As everyone knows, the terrorist attacks in Madrid on March 11 resulted in a tragic loss of human lives. Recently, the Spanish Government decided to express its recognition of the victims in their capacity as workers, because we believe that they were all united by the fact that, in one way or another, they were performing work for society.

For all those victims of terrorism whose working lives were cut short, I now ask for the recognition and solidarity of those attending this International Labour Conference; a recognition and solidarity that I want to extend to all those who suffer the effects of violence, misery, and war, especially to the citizens of Iraq.

A recognition and solidarity that must be accompanied by a commitment from all of us, from all delegations, from all representatives of governments, business organizations, and trade unions: the commitment to the principles of freedom and equality of all men, the commitment to the eradication of war and terrorism, the commitment to the dignity of individuals and the safeguarding of their lives and integrity.

To say this here, at the International Labour Organization, in this institution that is part of the United Nations system, aims to constitute a call for the reinforcement of what represents a universal vision of human civilization; for what it represents in an organization like this, which knows no borders, languages, cultures, or different peoples. For an organization that unites around one of the most precious rights that gives dignity to man, which is work, it is a call to overcome differences, to ensure that the dialogue that was established as a working tool of this organization is, without a doubt, the great aspiration of a new world order.

Dialogue is the emanation of reason, and reason is always built from ethical principles, from values of coexistence. Where reason and dialogue reign, where the construction of a house of words takes place, rights are always extended, the most humble are always improved, and there is always the capacity to recognize that the history of humanity is a manifestly improvable history, in light of what we have experienced in the 20th century and in light of the many things and the many sufferings that so many human beings endure.

In the old building of the International Labour Organization, which is now the headquarters of the World Trade Organization, there was an inscription that read: "Whoever wants peace prepares justice." I firmly believe that this is still the best rule to follow for the International Labour Organization and for all of us and the best expression of that collective commitment.

Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. President,

I represent a government and a country that are committed to defending the rights and dignity of workers around the world; I represent a government and a country that have as their great objective towards the world solidarity and peace; I represent a government and a country that believe in the United Nations, that believe in the International Labour Organization, and will deploy all their effort, all their capacity for utopia, to strengthen the United Nations, the shared vision of the world, and the rights of workers in every corner, convinced that in this way we will leave a legacy of great dignity on Earth and profound improvement in the 21st century.

Thank you very much.