Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 June 2004 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded in Spain's Congress to questions from the Basque Parliamentary Group about the legitimacy of the Council for the Reform of state-owned media in June 2004.
Main themes
Reform of Radiotelevisión Española, auctoritas and legitimacy of reform council, public media governance, independence of state-owned media, parliamentary accountability, electoral commitments of Socialist Party, professional credentials of council members, regional and municipal public media reform
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,277
63rd percentile
Sentences
68
45th percentile
Readability
35
24th percentile
Grade
16.0
84th percentile
Syntax
3.53
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%50%
  • Social 25%25%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

68 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Madrid, June 23, 2004

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOSÉ RAMÓN BELOKI GUERRA, OF THE BASQUE PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Beloki.- This Group has no doubt whatsoever about the need for a profound transformation necessary in Radiotelevisión Española. This Group also has no doubt that the Government, with this objective or another, is perfectly entitled to create a working group, which it deems appropriate, with the men and women it considers most suitable, to prepare the report it desires. That, subsequently, once that report has been prepared and delivered to the Government, it decides to incorporate the basic principles and norms of that report and transplant them, as the Vice President expressed, into a bill that serves the announced objectives, is also within the Government's purview. That for all this the Government grants or recognizes the "auctoritas" that seems appropriate to those men and women, there is nothing to discuss either. Another matter is that, just like that, the Government intends for everyone to recognize that "auctoritas" in those persons it recognizes.

Hence our question: What "auctoritas" are we talking about? Is it a supposed political "auctoritas" that should lead us all to what, as the Director General of Radiotelevisión Española stated in the Commission, quoting, by the way, the President himself, will lead the Government to fully and integrally adopt its proposals when processing them as future law? Is it an "auctoritas" recognized or granted by someone who, moreover, has never been questioned or asked, as is the case with this political force, or is it an "auctoritas," which I do not know whether to call cultural or professional, that leads, not only politicians, but also the entire group of professionals and society in general to see, for once, with clarity and unanimity, where the solution to the numerous and serious problems that Radiotelevisión Española has lies?

But, in addition, the Government, apparently, is not satisfied with this. As the Vice President herself said at the time, it is the Government's will -- and the President has expressed this on several occasions -- that the reform of state-owned media serves, moreover, as a mirror for the rest of the public media, both regional and municipal. That is the extent of the "auctoritas" of the men and women.

In short, and this is the question, could the Government explain to us then and specify, to the extent that it is possible, what that "auctoritas" of the men and women with whom it has created the Council for the Reform of state-owned media is?

President.- Thank you very much for the question, Mr. Beloki Guerra. I want to tell you that, as you well know, the Council for the Reform of public ownership media was an electoral commitment established by the Socialist Party, to address one of the areas of the public sector that needs the most evident reform, in the face of which we could say there is a notable discontent among citizens: discontent from a democratic point of view and discontent from the perspective of its public management and what it represents for the overall expenditure of the State Administrations.

Certainly, the criterion of that independent reform Council, as a method to signify that the Government did not want to be the one to decide on a reform, but rather through an open debate with society, has been none other than the relevance, the professional prestige of the people that the Government has appointed and what we consider suitable for the function they are entrusted with, as specified in the Royal Decree itself.

Mr. Beloki.- I want to tell you that it is not this group's issue to question this or that person; but, like all people, we will know them by their fruits.

President.- I would not want the little time left in the last phase of the question to prevent me from specifying something that I am indeed interested in highlighting; but I want to reiterate the names and what they represent: Emilio Lledó, who chairs the Council, is a university professor, a member of the Royal Spanish Academy since a decade ago, and a lifetime member of the Institute for Advanced Studies in Berlin; Enrique Bustamente is a professor of Audiovisual Communication and Advertising, director of the Center for Communication Studies and holder of the UNESCO Chair in International Communication; Victoria Camps is a professor at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, a councilor of the Audiovisual Council of Catalonia, and chaired the Senate Commission for Reform; Fernando González Urbaneja is president of the Madrid Press Association, and Fernando Savater is a university professor and has published numerous studies related to ethics and education, analyzing the role of the media.

I believe, Your Honor, that the roster of people who make up this Council is hardly disputable. There will be many other people who could have as much representativeness and be as suitable; but certainly these, in my opinion, clearly are.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOAN HERRERA TORRES, OF THE GREEN LEFT-UNITED LEFT PARLIAMENTARY GROUP INITIATIVE FOR CATALONIA GREENS

Mr. Herrera.- Mr. President, what are the Government's reasons for not recovering the dialogue and consensus framework of the Immigration Law 4/2000?

President.- Mr. Herrera, the Government maintains the commitment of the investiture and has full will for what the legislation and the application of policy in immigration matters represent to be a policy resulting from consensus. There is an investiture commitment to reach a great pact regarding immigration, and, of course, the Government maintains that principle.

Mr. Herrera.- The reality today is that we have a legal framework that places the immigrant person in a state of blatant legal inferiority. In fact, it is unjust laws that have caused us to surely move from the phenomenon of immigration to the phenomenon of exploitation. And the truth is that we have a breakdown of the democratic value of equality. The situation is one of collapse, and some of the things that have been pointed out we believe are going in the right direction: the possibility of establishing stable forms of regularization for the "undocumented" based on labor ties or, of course, multiplying personal resources in the different Administrations to address this situation of such an undignified collapse.

But our question is whether a regulation that puts patches is sufficient but does not resolve, from our point of view, the terrible law that is currently in force. It is not enough for us, and we believe that unjust laws must be modified in those sections that are unjust as quickly as possible. In fact, the current legal framework does not allow for the right to asylum, and we do not say this, Amnesty International does. It is not enough for us because so-called irregular immigrants continue to lack fundamental civil rights: the right to assembly, the right to demonstration, and the right to association. Why wait for the Constitutional Court's ruling on the appeals filed? Do immigrants not deserve an initiative for the recovery of their citizenship status?

Moreover, the Regulation is not sufficient because police control over the municipal register ends up dissuading people living among us from registering, and this means that thousands of people are expelled from basic social rights such as education, health, or access to housing.

One cannot pursue a different immigration policy without different laws, and what we propose is to return to a consensus, to the consensus of Law 4/2000. We ask you not to look in the rearview mirror at the Popular Party on this issue, to create the necessary framework for a society with equal rights and stable regularization frameworks; to make immigration not a problem, but an opportunity.

President.- Your Honor, as you well know, the Socialist Group at the time appealed to the Constitutional Court the legislative reform initiated by the previous majority in this Chamber. Fundamentally, that appeal of unconstitutionality focused on the deprivation of rights that we consider essential also for immigrants.

It is true that we have a legal framework that is not satisfactory, from the Government's point of view. It is no less true that we have a horizon of transposition of very important European Union Directives in immigration matters, which will occur next year, in 2005, probably more in the second half of 2005. That will be the time to address, in accordance with what those Directives represent and their mandatory transposition, a reform of the legislation on immigration.

In the meantime, we are about to approve, in a phase of consultations with practically all Groups, Autonomous Communities, and organizations, the Regulation that develops the Law, and I hope it will also be the result of broad consensus. I proclaim from here that, in the reform of the Immigration Law, when the European Union Directives have to be transposed, the Government's criterion is that we must reach a great consensus to have stable legislation in the face of the phenomenon of immigration, in matters of immigration, of course of asylum, and I am convinced that in a fairly broad majority that agreement will be possible.

In the meantime, we cannot remain idle; we must address the serious problems of saturation for the Administration and the management of immigration with the criteria that the Government has outlined, which you already know, and certainly with a perspective of guaranteeing rights for immigrants, also of duties...

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY BREY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rajoy.- Does the President of the Government believe that budgetary stability is a negotiable principle subject to parliamentary arithmetic?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the Government defends the principle of budgetary stability and the Government is consistent with the positions it has maintained regarding budgetary stability over the last four years.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, budgetary balance and stability are not dogmas of faith, but they are indeed good foundations for the economy to grow. We have seen this in recent years, and, moreover, you and your Minister of Economy have indeed ratified this. Therefore, from a purely theoretical point of view, we agree; but what happens is that then, in practice, things are different.

I told you in the Investiture Debate that you did not come with a Government program nor did you come with 176 votes and that, therefore, you were going to have many problems. I told you that this was not good for various aspects, including the economic aspect. Of course, now we have seen that in order for the spending ceiling to be approved, you had to make concessions to Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya, then to Convergència i Unió in the Senate, and we do not know if also to the Basque Nationalist Party, all after your Ministers of Economy, Mr. Solbes, and of Public Administrations, Mr. Sevilla, voted in favor of zero deficit for the autonomous communities in the years 2005, 2006, and 2007 at a meeting of the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council. Of course, a few days later, as a result of pressure in the Cortes, what has happened has happened.

All of that is very well, but I believe that the principle of budgetary stability must be preserved, especially if one believes in it, against some Groups and also against some Autonomous Communities that may have different criteria, regardless of the party, because that generates credibility and builds trust. In that, I am willing to help you, as we would have helped you if the spending ceiling you presented in this Chamber had not been 6.2 percent, above nominal GDP, but had been below nominal GDP, as it was in previous years.

Therefore, I ask you to defend the principle of budgetary stability and to act accordingly. Of course, know that from this Group we are willing to help you so that you do not make the concessions you have to make to other Groups that do not contribute to generating credibility and trust in Spanish society.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, what the Government has defended, as I told you in the initial response, is what we have been defending when we opposed the Budgetary Stability Law, which you will remember we appealed to the Constitutional Court, just as many Governments of Autonomous Communities governed by socialists did. We defend the principle of budgetary stability throughout the cycle; we have a different conception of how to articulate the principle of budgetary stability in relation to the Autonomous Communities; we said this in the debate on your Budgetary Stability Law, and what we are going to do now is simply to embody those criteria with the support of a parliamentary majority, which is now called parliamentary arithmetic, but at other times was called parliamentary majority, stable majority, sufficient majority... in many ways. Now it is arithmetic.

I believe it is legitimate for a government to aspire to have the support of the budgets. In any case, with the utmost sincerity in the world, I thank you very much for the help you are providing to the government in that area, in line with your defense of budgetary stability. But, speaking of concessions, Mr. Rajoy, there is still a long time ahead, and perhaps we will never hear, as we heard for a long time in Spain, those famous words from Mr. Arzalluz, who said that he had achieved in fourteen days more than the Aznar government had in fourteen years of the Felipe González government. Those were indeed concessions. Here there is a project that is shared, that is discussed, and that is negotiated.