Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 June 2006 · Parliamentary control session (sesión de control)

Context
Zapatero responded to questions from CiU's Duran i Lleida in a parliamentary control session regarding Iberia's planned reduction of services at Barcelona's El Prat Airport.
Main themes
Catalan Statute of Autonomy, airport management devolution, Barcelona El Prat Airport, Iberia airline services, AENA oversight, autonomous community governance, Spanish airport policy, economic development, Single European Sky, parliamentary accountability
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,376
65th percentile
Sentences
83
54th percentile
Readability
38
30th percentile
Grade
14.7
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
69th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%64%
  • Economic 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

83 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Durán.- Mr. President of the Government, you know that during the debate and processing of the Project for the Reform of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, we were unable to introduce something that we completely agree on, which is that Article 150.2 of the Constitution will have to be used to transfer the management of the ports to Catalonia; that a special law will have to be made to declassify certain airports, and that a particular law will also have to be made to establish the conditions for participation in the management of the Prat Airport. This, on the other hand, is not simply part of a political agreement, but the Statute itself already provides for it, and the State of the Nation Debate also approved a Resolution in the same direction.

Today I am particularly interested, Mr. President, in talking to you about the Prat Airport and, specifically, about what the private company Iberia has announced, of course, but I will clarify why, in our opinion, the Government can and should intervene to try to mitigate and, if possible, prevent what Iberia has announced regarding the Barcelona Airport.

It is evident that Iberia, as I have just reminded you, Mr. President of the Government, is a private company, but it is evident that if I am addressing you, it is not because the Government has any relationship with Iberia, but because of the relationship that, of course, the Government has with AENA, which is the company that, as you well know, manages the Spanish airports. And you know that Iberia has had advantages, and in fact has them at this moment, as it is the main beneficiary of T-4 at the Madrid airport, where there has been an investment of more than 6 billion euros; a T-4 from which, apart from its gigantic dimension, Iberia is benefiting, as I have just reminded you.

Consequently, this Parliamentary Group cannot conceive that in the face of a decision that causes --not simply because this Parliamentary Group says so, all the political forces in Catalonia have said so, and so have the civil, political, and social institutions-- a serious detriment to Catalonia, AENA has no way to prevent Iberia from carrying out its objectives of abandoning the Barcelona Airport and simply staying with the flights of the "Puente Aéreo."

Are there criteria to ensure that this is not the case? Can AENA condition it? I would like to know, Mr. President, how and in what way you plan to do this through AENA to try to condition it.

On the other hand, it is not true, it is a lie, that Iberia is losing money with the management of those flights. There are criteria that the Pilots' Union has put on the table...

President.- Mr. Durán, as you know, the Government is in favor of the participation of the Autonomous Communities in the management of our airport system. We are fully convinced that territorial institutions can provide a decisive boost to respond to what our airport system represents today and each airport in particular: a determining factor for economic development.

We must guarantee what is a growing demand for air traffic; guarantee the control of safety and quality, and the progress towards achieving something that will be a reality, the so-called "Single European Sky."

We have a traditional management mode, which has had, as is known, a development for a long time in our country. It has allowed financial self-sufficiency, increased the capacity of our airports, and maintains the lowest and most competitive airport rates in Europe.

There is a Resolution and a statutory pronouncement aimed at promoting an equitable policy within the airport network in order to avoid any type of discrimination against the Barcelona Airport. And also a specific Resolution for the management by the Autonomous Communities of those airports that are not considered of general interest.

The Ministry of Development is working to propose for debate, for consideration, a management model that complies with the Resolutions and with the Statute of Autonomy, and that is, logically, a guarantee of the common elements that affect air traffic safety and, of course, local, territorial, in this case, autonomous interests.

I want to tell you that, of course, the Ministries of Development and Industry have been working to ensure that companies provide the best services at the Prat Airport and that, from our point of view, this Airport is currently experiencing spectacular development. I want to emphasize that it has the highest increase in passengers among the ten busiest airports in Europe, that in the first five months of 2006 it is the Spanish airport with the highest increase in traffic and number of operations, and that the investment made in 2005 and 2006 has increased by 60 percent compared to the previous legislature, with which El Prat will double its expansion in...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Puigcercós, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Puigcercós.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, what do you understand, as President of the Government, as a generous attitude in the interpretation, the implementation, of the laws?

President.- I have no doubt that Mr. Puigcercós is referring to the Statute of Catalonia, widely ratified by the citizens in the recent referendum on Sunday, June 18. As it is so, and I am sure this question arises from some public statement I have made regarding it, I must say that the Statute of Autonomy in its development has two aspects: one, that it must be done by the autonomous government itself, in this case the Generalitat, as there are parts that correspond exclusively to its application and development by the Government of the Generalitat; and another depends on the relationship between the State Government and the Government of the Generalitat.

I refer only to that part, and in that part I must reiterate and affirm that for that development of the Statute we will be respectful in the interpretation and with the principles that we have maintained of defense of an autonomy that has guarantees, such as those contained in the Statute, and that therefore preserves any risk of violation of that autonomy by an inadequate development of the basic laws.

On the other hand, we will be generous, if you allow me, or loyal to what the spirit and letter of bilateralism represent, which, from my point of view, is a very positive advance of the Statute, because it marks the path of cooperation, which is the path of good management in favor of citizens in the autonomous state.

Finally, we will be generous or loyal in the strict compliance with an additional provision, which will represent a significant advance in infrastructure and development for Catalonia with the clause, which you know very well and which I believe you have always supported, regarding what represents the volume of investment in Catalonia equivalent to the Gross Domestic Product in the whole of the State.

That is basically what represents a generous or loyal development of the Statute of Autonomy, which we are going to do, and I hope, of course, with your support because I am convinced, Mr. Puigcercós, that your Group will be the first to demand the full compliance of the Statute of Autonomy, even if you have not supported it, but you are fully entitled to do so.

Mr. Puigcercós.- First of all, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I want to congratulate you. It is true, you won the referendum, do not have any doubt, and it was with a significant percentage. I am one of those who recognizes things, like my party. We are not going to hide here with abstention.

But, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you are perfectly aware that after the trimming, or let’s call it whatever we want, many laws are needed in this Chamber to develop it. Mr. Durán has made it very clear what he refers to regarding ports and airports. It is the issue that refers to the transfer of Article 150.2 of the Constitution. As we have seen, it will not be through that route, it will be through another route that you have said the Ministry of Development is experimenting with or studying. It also refers to the LOFCA and take the example of the financing of the Autonomous Communities. It will be a law that will develop a part of the financing. The same can be said of a law that we have here in debate, such as the Organic Law of the Judiciary.

I believe that the word is not "generosity"; you have already corrected it and said "loyalty." But until today, disloyalty has been the common denominator, and I will give you an example: there are a few rulings from the Constitutional Court regarding the transfer to the Autonomous Communities of FORCEM, Continuous Training, or what refers to school or university scholarships, and they have been systematically breached.

When we refer to not wanting generosity and that what we want is loyalty and justice, that there be fair treatment, this is it. The spirit of the Statute, with trimming or without trimming, clearly implies legislative development in this Chamber: organic laws and non-organic laws. I believe it is not about, I repeat, being generous; what we must be is just and get to the point.

In the airport issue, for example, we have had a recent example of how it is not specified. There will be time to see it, but I believe that loyalty must be the motto from now on.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the facts I am asking you about are as follows, in broad terms: the Police detain five robbers in the act, who were going to rob a bank; they were an organized and violent group with a myriad of police records; the Court releases them because the prosecutor does not request provisional imprisonment; the scandal is enormous and public opinion is astonished. The issue would be laughable if it were not for its importance, because this is the prosecutor's response to the increase in insecurity and the existence of mafia gangs like this one, which is occupying us.

The Prosecutor then, logically, had to rectify and say that the robbers should be detained. He made serious accusations against the Police; he accused the Police of irregular conduct, of making deficient reports, and of using the issue for media purposes. The General Directorate of the Police responded by criticizing the Prosecutor and his statements.

I ask the President of the Government, if he has to do with the Attorney General and the General Directorate of the Police, to give us an assessment of this, to tell us who was right and, above all, to clearly state what he is going to do, because someone will have to be dismissed after this lamentable spectacle that has occurred.

President.- I feared that I would not satisfy Mr. Rajoy, because I do not plan to dismiss anyone from what represents the Attorney General or the Ministry of the Interior.

Mr. Rajoy, I must tell you that you have been Minister of the Interior and you know perfectly that there is some exceptional circumstance where there have historically been very, very specific and very isolated discrepancies or lack of coordination between the actions of the National Police and the Prosecutor's Office. Fortunately, they are absolutely exceptional, because we have a Prosecutor's Office that functions and pursues crime adequately, and we have a National Police that is committed to the fight against crime.

Therefore, I express my full support for the Attorney General and my full support for the Police, despite there being an isolated lack of coordination.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, you have answered me and told me: I am not going to dismiss anyone. In pure democratic logic, you should dismiss one of the two responsible: either the Attorney General or the Director of the Police. And I will give you my opinion: an Attorney General cannot insult the State Security Forces and Corps or attack the National Police in that way. That is unacceptable.

The same day that this event occurred, the Attorney General allowed --thank goodness the judge did not-- an illegal organization, such as Batasuna, to hold a demonstration in Pamplona. There have been many occasions in which the Attorney General neither respects the general interest, nor ensures compliance with the Law, which is his obligation, nor does things that are in accordance with common sense and the will of the majority of Spaniards.

Therefore, I defend the Police, the State Security Forces and Corps, the Director of the Police, and I call for the resignation of the Attorney General, because otherwise, you will be responsible for the actions that have been taking place in recent times.

President.- Your Honor, February 10, 2004. Do you remember who was the Minister of the Interior? "Justice releases fifteen criminals from two Romanian gangs with a hundred crimes behind them. The Police requested their detention, but the Prosecutor opposed it. Citizen astonishment in Madrid." This led to a meeting to address the situation between the Government Delegate of Madrid and the Chief Prosecutor of Madrid. Minister? Mr. Acebes. I did not hear you say anything about what you have said here, nor did I hear you call for anyone's resignation. Why? Because these things happen occasionally and exceptionally.

In Madrid, there are three thousand joint actions by the Prosecutor's Office and the National Police each year, like the one being debated today; three thousand. Among three thousand, if one occurs in a situation of discoordination or with an error from some other party, it does not justify the demagoguery you have displayed here today with the background I have just presented.

I support the Attorney General of the State, who has a magnificent track record in defending public service and legality in Spain.