Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 April 2007 · Parliamentary control session (sesión de control)

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions in Spain's Congress on education reform and Catalonia's bilateral commission during a government control session on 24 April 2007.
Main themes
Baccalaureate reform, Spanish education quality, school failure and dropout rates, PISA report results, education budget and spending, educational inclusion vs. selection, State-Generalitat bilateral commission, Catalonia investment, parliamentary accountability, government education policy
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,501
68th percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
37
30th percentile
Grade
14.7
74th percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%43%
  • Social 32%32%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

82 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Mr. Sevilla, I do not agree. This is neither education nor design. In this statement, there is no appeal to important principles in education such as effort, work, or study, and then the effects are very negative, Mr. Sevilla, because someone might believe they can make takeovers, liquidate the market, manipulate the National Securities Market Commission, all matters that I hope Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero will explain here.

But, in any case, to the point: it is evident that Mr. Sevilla's recipes are not valid and that those recipes do not work. Probably, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero's situation can no longer be fixed, but that of Spanish schoolchildren can, and that is why I would like him to explain his position regarding the proposed reform of the Baccalaureate that the Minister has put forward.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, perhaps this Chamber is more appropriate, not to talk about the shortcomings of those of us representing the citizens, which will always be subjective and which, in any case, I believe require a natural respect for what this institution represents, but to talk about the needs of Spaniards, of young people, and the need for education in our country.

In that sense, I must say that the proposal for the reform of the Baccalaureate made by the Government, specifically by the Minister of Education and Science, is a reform aimed at improving the quality and extent of education for our young people, priority objectives for this country and, of course, for the Government.

Mr. Rajoy.- I want to clarify that the issue of shortcomings is authored by Mr. Sevilla, not by this modest deputy.

Mr. President, the data on Spanish education is not satisfactory; the PISA Report has not been satisfactory, the data on school failure has not been satisfactory, and the data on early school leaving is not satisfactory.

We are talking about a very serious issue, which is the future of Spanish children, and we already have the example of compulsory secondary education. We all know that it has not worked, and there is no system in the European Union that works like this. Now to create a Baccalaureate where students can study subjects from the next course with just passing half of the first ones seems to me a huge mistake. Here, there is no talk at all of merit, effort, well-done work, study, or the authority of teachers.

We are talking, Mr. President, about children and their parents. This is not a takeover that you are making for fun; we are talking about children and parents. You are seriously endangering the future of knowledge in Spain, which is tantamount to seriously endangering the future of our competitiveness and our economy, and the improvement of people's well-being. Take note, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the Spanish educational system needs reforms and improvements because, indeed, there are some data that are not positive; some data that, by the way, all referred to international institutions go up to 2004, after eight years of your Government: specifically, the decrease in public education spending to 4.3 percent of GDP; specifically, the dropout rate from the Baccalaureate in 2004 was 31.7 percent of our students compared to 29 percent in 2000, and specifically, only 66 percent of our young people surpass what represents compulsory education, when the OECD average is 81 percent. Therefore, your balance was quite negative.

What have we done from the Government in these three years? Increase the education budget by 60 percent, with two hundred thousand young people who can have a scholarship and who did not have one before; incorporate seven billion euros in the economic memory of the Organic Law of Education, and have a clear objective: four out of five young people must have higher education than compulsory education.

For this, we need an educational system with more means, more resources, more support and reinforcement for those young people who may have difficulties. We do not need an educational system that excludes and selects; we need an educational system that expands, supports everyone, and integrates all the young people in this country so that they can reach the highest educational level. Your management has yielded poor results, but this Government's will improve education in our...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- The question is reproduced, it is extensive, clear, unequivocal; it has no trick. Therefore, I consider it reproduced, Mr. President: for what reason has the Bilateral State-Generalitat Commission not yet been convened in order to determine the volume of State investment in Catalonia for the fiscal year 2007 and beyond, as ordered by additional provision 57 of the General State Budget Law for 2007?

President.- I am pleased, Mr. Duran, to inform you that the Bilateral State-Generalitat Commission complied with the mandate referred to in the Statute, agreeing in its first meeting, on February 26, 2007, to establish a working group to establish the methodology for compliance with the third additional provision of the Statute. The working group, coordinated by the Ministry of Economy and Finance, on behalf of the State Administration, met for the first time on April 13, 2007, to begin its tasks, agreeing to meet again on May 7.

Furthermore, I also want to inform you that on January 11, just a month after the constitution of the new Government of the Generalitat, there was a meeting between representatives of the General Secretariat of Budgets and Expenditures of the Ministry of Economy and representatives of the Ministry of Economy and Finance of the Generalitat. In that meeting, the study of the necessary actions for the implementation of the Infrastructure Commission provided for in the third additional provision of the new Statute of Autonomy was agreed upon. Well, this very Friday the constitutive meeting of the tripartite Commission will be held, formed by the state, regional, and local administrations regarding state investments in Catalonia.

In summary, Mr. Durán, I am sure you will be pleased that I have been able to correct you on this occasion -- it is not easy -- confirming the full development of the statutory provisions within the expected timeframe, which is undoubtedly the desire of your Group, because it should be remembered that it had an important role and provided significant support for the approval of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

Mr. Duran.- Of course, we have different reading capacities of the articles of a law. You say something like "promote and encourage," but the commitment, which is now law, of the State Budgets says: "during the first quarter of 2007, the Bilateral State-Generalitat Commission will establish and implement the methodology to be used to determine compliance with the third additional provision of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia." It does not say "create a working group during the first quarter of 2007"; it says "create the methodology to be used to determine and implement...".

Consequently, Mr. President, I also feel compelled to contradict you. We do not agree; I do not feel satisfied at all. Moreover, the reflection I make is not trivial, because you know perfectly well that, depending on the delays in the preparation of the upcoming Budgets, it will cause Catalonia to have another delay in investment projects, because a project, until it is approved, elaborated, submitted for consideration, and applied, takes many years of delay.

On the other hand, Mr. President, you will recall that what I have just read is the result of a pact between the Government, specifically the Economic Vice President, and the spokesperson of this Parliamentary Group and this Parliamentary Group in particular. In that pact, you will remember that we requested that the investment clause, the methodology used, and the Government's percentage for 2007 be left without effect. At this rate, they will force us to ask again at the end of this fiscal year, in preparation for the upcoming Budgets, to leave that clause without effect.

This is not an opinion of this Parliamentary Group. The Barcelona Chamber of Commerce questions the State's investment effort in Catalonia and clearly states that the Government is complying and that, while in Catalonia it anticipates a 2.7 percent growth compared to 2006, the growth rate for the entire State exceeded 13 percent.

If that were not enough, today the former President of the Generalitat says that the effort made by the Statute has not been worth it. I do believe it has been worth it, as long as, of course, the Government fulfills its commitments, and the commitment is not to create a working group, Mr. President; the commitment of the Law, and in this there can be no double interpretation, is to approve the methodology to be applied. That is still to be done, and as time goes by, I insist, we are losing ground, we who represent what I have just denounced, and on behalf of the Chamber of Commerce as well.

President.- Mr. Durán, honestly, I do not see great differences in the reflections we have made in our interventions. I must tell you that it seems reasonable that to establish a methodology and a criterion, it must be studied, because there are different positions. I have told you that there is a next meeting on Friday, and do not have any doubt that we will have the methodology established in time for the process of preparing the General State Budgets for 2008. Therefore, we will strictly comply with the Statute, its development, and its application. And I hope you will be satisfied with this as you were satisfied...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Agustí Cerdá, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Cerdá.- Mr. President, you know that TV3, the television of Catalonia, has broadcast its signal uninterruptedly in the Valencian Community for more than twenty years. Through popular subscriptions, citizens made their financial contributions to cover the costs of broadcasting, and from 1986 the signal covered almost the entire Valencian territory. Canal Nou, created after TV3, was and is seen in areas of Catalonia; an act of normality between two territories that share and that we share, in fact, a lot.

In recent months, we have witnessed an attempt by some rulers to prevent thousands of Valencians who regularly watch TV3 from enjoying this right. What sense does it make that today the citizens of the Valencian Community can watch Al Jazeera or the German RTL -- said with all due respect -- and there is an attempt to somehow prevent the reception of channels from neighboring or bordering territories?

Yesterday we learned of a resolution from the Administrative Court of Valencia that denied the closure of the TV3 repeaters, arguing that, above all, the fundamental rights of Valencians must prevail. The ruling issued by the Court in Valencia is clear: the freedom of information and expression prevail, and TV3 in the Valencian Community does no harm to anyone. It is that simple: those who want to watch it, watch it, and those who do not, do not. No one forces anyone to do anything.

Therefore, Mr. President, we want to ask you what measures your Executive plans to undertake to administratively normalize a reality of more than twenty years, such as the presence of TV3 in the Valencian Community.

President.- As Mr. Cerdá well knows, it is a cultural association that retransmits the programs of the public television of Catalonia in the Valencian Community. The Valencian Generalitat opened a sanctioning file against this association for lacking an administrative concession, and, as you also know, the granting corresponds to the Valencian Generalitat itself.

For the granting of the public service of television by terrestrial waves, a habilitating title is required, and, in the case of terrestrial television of a scope less than or equal to the autonomous, the competencies to grant those concessions correspond to the Autonomous Communities; in this case, the Valencian Generalitat.

We are facing a conflict, then, in strictly legal terms, between the Valencian Government and a private cultural association, where our scope of competencies is very limited.

However, having stated this situation and reiterated respect for the competential scope of the Autonomous Communities, I want to express my will regarding the issue.

I can express to you, in general terms, my favorable opinion towards the broadest pluralism of media, which we have promoted in the corresponding scope, and to satisfy the rights and wishes of the largest number of citizens, as long as it is technically possible and allowed by current legislation. Plurality and the right to information are never superfluous in any area, neither in the autonomous, nor in the state, nor, of course, in any democratic society.

Mr. Cerdá.- I am glad, Mr. President, because the definitive legalization of the arrival of TV3 in the Valencian Community corresponds, indeed, to your Executive, in parallel and in accordance with the agreements that are being made between the Valencian and Catalan Governments at this time.

It is within the framework of the General Telecommunications Law and the Technical Plan for Digital Terrestrial Television that these broadcasts have legal standing. It is the Technical Plan that grants each Autonomous Community four channels for regional coverage. The channels in question, in this case, 47 and 55, have not been allocated to either the Generalitat Valenciana or anyone else; they are part of the State's radioelectric public domain, and our question is whether you intend to resolve this, and we ask you today, which is April 25. Today marks exactly three hundred years since the Battle of Almansa, a date that is for us loaded with symbolism and also with hope.

It is today, Mr. President, that I ask you if you have the political will to provide legal coverage for broadcasts that are felt as their own by many Valencians.

President.- I would like to remind you, Your Excellency, that the legislation expressly provides for the possibility that the Autonomous Communities agree on collaboration agreements to allow the broadcasting of one or several programs from their regional television within the geographical scope of others, as long as the radioelectric spaces in their territorial areas are adjacent and use the frequencies assigned to them. In fact, there is already an agreement between the Catalan Generalitat and the Government of the Balearic Islands.

I believe this is the way, the most correct way: the spirit of collaboration between Administrations in the service of the interests of citizens. If the two Autonomous Communities affected by the matter of your question, the Valencian Community and the Catalan Community, decided to make use of that legal possibility and sign a collaboration agreement that, from the Government's perspective, is the way forward and that we encourage, rest assured that the Government of Spain, through the General Administration of the State, will do everything in its power to…