Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

12 September 2011 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions in the Spanish Senate on September 12, 2011, in one of his final control sessions before leaving office.
Main themes
Parliamentary control session, Senate reform, constitutional reform, Conference of Presidents, General Commission of Autonomous Communities, economic crisis, regional autonomy policy, ETA negotiation, legacy of Zapatero government, interparty cooperation
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,563
93rd percentile
Sentences
187
87th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.50
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 46%42%
  • Economic 34%32%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

187 sentences in 80 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I believe this will be my last opportunity to address you in a control session; therefore, to a certain extent, it is logical that the intervention I will make today has a certain air of farewell.

More than seven years have passed since the first time you appeared here, in the Senate, in your capacity as President of the Government. On that occasion, you announced that a new era was beginning for the Senate. If you recall, you also spoke to us about your commitment to promote the reform of the Constitution, the reform of the Senate, and to revitalize the parliamentary activity of this Chamber.

The first thing I want to say is that I recognize, and I have always expressed this, your decision to come here once a month for control sessions, because this has been a practice that experience has shown to be very beneficial for the Senate and has made this Chamber a protagonist of current political events, at least once a month.

I would also like us to be able to congratulate ourselves today on the reform of the Senate, but unfortunately, that has not been the case. You began the processing by entrusting the Council of State to start the work, when we always defended that, as in other occasions, the best thing would be to start the work here among all the Parliamentary Groups. The Council of State gave you its report and until today. But I must also acknowledge that the political climate at that time, especially regarding autonomous policy, was not the best for advancing this reform.

However, I believe that today we must be optimistic. The experience of the last week has shown us that the Popular Party and the Socialist Party can work together, along with the other political forces, on a reform of the Constitution. Hopefully, this reform of the Senate can take place in the next Legislature.

Regarding the Debate on the State of the Autonomies, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, what do you want me to say? You have done exactly the same thing that you criticized then-President Aznar for: a single debate in two Legislatures. But, being optimistic, what matters is the future, and I am convinced that in the next Legislature all political groups will be able to agree to try to improve the format of that debate, which I believe we all agree is not precisely the most suitable.

You created, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the Conference of Presidents, an idea of Mr. Manuel Fraga, for whom I want to have a warm memory in this intervention of mine. However, this body, the Conference of Presidents, has not achieved the effectiveness or regularity that would be necessary or convenient. Look, in this Legislature you have only convened it once, despite the repeated requests from the regional presidents. I also hope that the definitive consolidation of the Conference of Presidents will take place in the next Legislature and that the Senate will have a much more relevant role in it than it has had so far, where it was only limited to ceding its facilities.

I will not dwell much on these issues, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. Just a mention also to the General Commission of Autonomous Communities, a Commission that, as you know, was born some time ago, in a reform of the Rules of Procedure of this Chamber, and it was intended to be the prototype of what the Senate could be, of what this Chamber could be, in the future.

Just a few notes. Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, this Commission has not met since last January, when the reform of the Statute of Extremadura was approved. Last year it only met twice. It has twenty-seven pending appearances of ministers, twelve of them for more than three years. Look, the last minister who appeared before it did so in June 2009. But, as we are optimistic today, I am sure that this Commission will also have a better life in the future in this Chamber.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, over these years you, as President of the Government, and I, as spokesperson for my Parliamentary Group, have debated many issues; issues that at each moment responded to the political current events, were matters of the utmost political relevance. In the last Legislature, I want to recall the reform of the Statute of Catalonia, the negotiation with ETA, local financing, and the problems regarding immigration, among other important topics. In this Legislature, practically all debates have revolved around the economic crisis and its effects on employment and social rights.

It is true, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that on many occasions the debates have been very intense and, even, on some occasions required the arbitral intervention of the President of the Chamber. But this is a Parliament, and Parliament is like that.

But I want you to know one thing, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero: that, despite the logical disagreements at each moment, you have always earned my utmost respect, firstly, for the respect due to the President of the Government; secondly, for the personal respect, which has the same or greater importance towards the political opponent, because I tell you that, regardless of the disagreements, respect is something that I believe, and the majority of us here believe, should always prevail in a parliamentary debate.

Because in debates, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I believe my intention has not been different from yours, which is to defend at each moment what we believe in. I tell you that we probably did not coincide: you believe one thing, I believe another thing, my Group believes what I defend; but we have always defended what each of us believes.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have recently announced your withdrawal from parliamentary life; therefore, in this last appearance of yours here, in the Senate, all I have left is to wish you all the best. I wish you all the best in personal and family aspects, and I also wish that in the future you can achieve everything you set out to do. Therefore, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, good luck.

And I consider the question posed, Mr. President: what assessment does the President of the Government make of the relationship between the Executive and the Senate during his years in office?

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, I thank you for your words and your tone in what seems to be the last moment of parliamentary control in the Senate. This allows me to make a very brief balance and some considerations of the present and the future.

My intention from the very beginning was for this Chamber to have the political and institutional prominence that emanates from the Constitution, as a Chamber of political representation and also of territorial representation. That is why I established the practice of appearing after each investiture, in 2004 and 2008, to hold a mini-investiture debate, which I hope will be maintained as a precedent. And that is why I have answered 156 parliamentary questions, establishing for the first time that the President of the Government answers questions and renouncing my Group asking me questions. I do not know if I was right or not, but in any case, that has been the case.

And I have also tried to ensure that this constitutional vocation, which is a mandate, to be a Chamber of territorial representation, that role for the Senate would acquire more and more significance. It is true that we have not achieved the goal of constitutional reform or Senate reform so that this institution can play the role it is called to play. I fervently wish that it can be achieved in the next Legislature. It is true that we have been trying for several Legislatures and it has not been achieved. It is not easy due to the representation of our country, due to the singularities involved in the election of senators and due to our institutional model of cooperation of the Autonomous Communities with the State as a whole, which tends to be situated, rather, in the Executive, in the central Government, especially on economic issues.

In any case, I must add that I have also appeared in five more debates in the Plenary, on the occasion of reforms of Statutes of Autonomies, and once --and you have recalled it-- in the General Commission to hold that Debate on the State of the Autonomies, whose format must necessarily change. After holding the first Debate, I understood very well President Aznar's reasoning for why he had only held one debate, and I joined his precedent. And, of course, exactly the same applies to the appearances of the ministers themselves.

Conference of Presidents. I believe we have made progress, with difficulties, let’s be clear, because we have a certain tendency --I will not say that it is only one political force, I say in general of the Spanish political landscape-- to also turn what are or should be institutions of a marked institutional character into forums for partisan political debate. I believe we need to learn the lesson. The Conference of Presidents, and some of the ones we have held have been useful, must be useful, and, logically, I hope that an agreement can also be reached between the two major parties.

But, undoubtedly, what has given more life, more prominence, and more political relevance to the Senate during this time has been, without a doubt, this parliamentary control process. Indeed, I will now leave parliamentary life after many years and I have always come to the Senate to answer questions with the best disposition, because Parliament, and therefore the Senate, is the center of public life in a democratic country and is also the representative institutional center. This is a good historical moment to reclaim the representative institutions that we have established, which we have fought to defend and that serve a country so well.

Indeed, we have had intense debates. You have recognized, and I thank you for it, I sincerely appreciate it, that this control process that I have led has been important for the Senate. I think it has also been important for you, and in that we have contributed. In any case, yes, there have been tense moments, without a doubt. On some occasions you have been tough with me, I must say, but I understand it within the democratic dialectic of a Parliament.

Therefore, you can count, of course, Mr. García-Escudero, on my respect and always, to be consistent with my demeanor and with the demeanor, respect, and appreciation, if necessary. And I also wish you the best, although you must understand that only in personal terms, not in political ones.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Narvay Quintero, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Quintero.- As has already been said here, I believe this will be the last control session of the Government in this Legislature in the Senate. Evidently, a legislature marked, without a doubt, by a crisis, a global crisis, which in Spain has made the harshest reality and severity felt most strongly in the number of unemployed we have in our country and the anguish of families unable to make ends meet. A current situation, without a doubt, and a crisis that we do not believe is only economic, but also social and one of trust.

Undoubtedly, Mr. President, I believe that citizens are asking us for another way of doing politics --with this economic crisis there is a social mobilization--: that we resolve the problems they present to us in a more direct and effective manner, and in a closer way.

Undoubtedly, Mr. President, if there is one Autonomous Community that has been above the national average in the percentage of unemployed, it has been the Canary Islands for various reasons. It is also true, Mr. President, that in recent semesters, thanks to the Canary Islands-State agreements, this number of unemployed has decreased. The main sector, the economic engine, of the Canary Islands is tourism, which is increasing, and we see a slight recovery, which is also the result of the work and consensus of both the Government of the Canary Islands and the State Government.

We have always said, Mr. President, that in the crisis all issues affect all territories; but also the solutions in all territories are different, because all territories have their singularities and their difficulties, but they also have their opportunities; all those differences, and we believe they should be treated differently.

Mr. President, if we believe that any Autonomous Community needs to be treated differently, and I do not say privileged or prioritized, but differentiated, it is the Canary Islands. The Canary Islands is an ultra-peripheral archipelago fragmented, over two thousand kilometers from Madrid and is not always understood in Madrid. But, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, if the Canary Islands are sometimes not understood in Madrid, just imagine the smaller islands. The Canary Islands are not just Gran Canaria or Tenerife; the Canary Islands are eight inhabited islands that are currently suffering real devastation from the crisis.

I come from El Hierro and I belong to El Hierro, and as a territorial Chamber, I ask for your permission to claim those issues today, in the last control session, that El Hierro has demanded. Both in your opposition stage and in the nearly eight years of Government, you promised many things for the Canary Islands and for El Hierro; some of them have been left unaddressed, such as the repeal of Royal Decree 192/2002, which you yourself promised when you visited us on the island, which declared a cultural historical heritage site like Pico de Malpaso, emblematic on the island of El Hierro, as a military interest zone and which, despite the efforts we have made, has not been fulfilled.

Also, Mr. President, allow me to pause on something fundamental: transportation. I have battled for nearly four years with inter-island transportation in the Canary Islands, and more precisely in El Hierro, and not because the State is not making a great effort; it is making a great effort, but we believe it is not the best way.

Mr. President, the subsidy we have for transportation is 50 percent based on the ticket price, instead of other parameters that we believe are fundamental. The higher the ticket price goes, the more the State allows it, and the more the companies raise it; look, the more the State pays, the more we passengers pay, the company earns double, the State half and the passengers half, which is very paradoxical. We have claimed that this public service obligation system, like inter-island transportation, needs to change. In my previous question, Mr. President, you committed, in that Bilateral Commission, to study and modify it. It is true that it has not been fulfilled either.

Mr. President, in El Hierro it is sometimes suggested that we are second-class citizens, because the people of El Hierro have to pay three to five times more for everything: to study, to see medical specialists, for companies to import or export goods, or simply to go to the theater or to engage in elite sports; from the smallest to the largest. We pay much more than other citizens and we wonder why. We are not saying that the money allocated to passengers between islands should be increased, but rather redistributed in a better way.

But also, Mr. President, I want to tell you that this party to which I belong, Coalición Canaria, has reached many agreements, has been responsible with the decision-making policy for the stability of your Government and the State, and that your Government has also fulfilled some agreements it has committed to. One of them, and fundamental, is the hydro-wind power plant of El Hierro, one hundred percent renewable and clean energy, which we hope will be a reality next year. It will be the first island to self-supply clean energy, and your Government has made a determined commitment to support this sustainable and renewable project for this island.

All this, Mr. President, I say so that those who stay and those who come understand that this territorial Chamber must address the singularities of all territories. I come from a very small island and we must try to understand that the problems of all of Spain are global, but that the problems that citizens demand from us today are particular and singular, in special territories, and for that we need to take specific measures. It is true that it will cost us more in many phases in global measures for all Spaniards equally, but I believe it is time and citizens are asking us to take specific measures for specific territories and problems.

Without further ado, Mr. President, I believe you have been a person who has always demonstrated the demeanor you have always manifested. You have been able to engage in dialogue with you and your Government. We have not always reached agreements and understandings, but at least you have always allowed dialogue and discussion. Personally, I wish you the best; professionally, I truly wish you the same, for the good of all.

President.- I thank you, Your Honor, for your last words. I must tell you that you are fortunate to represent an island like El Hierro that, as you recalled, I know and that is a good example of many of the good practices that create a sustainable future. I am also very aware of the difficulties that the insular fact entails in general and that, of course, implies the policy that must be made towards the islands, in this case the Canary Islands.

As you well know, the Government, aware of those difficulties, much more so in a time of economic crisis like the one we have lived through or are living, approved the Comprehensive Strategy for the Canary Islands; a Strategy in which objectives and commitments are specified until 2020 and a Strategy that has allowed maintaining a direct public investment from the State in ports, airports, and transportation subsidies in the Canary Islands, in a global effort amounting to two hundred million euros. Collaborating with the Government of the Canary Islands and the Cabildos in the development and improvement of road networks, which bear especially intense traffic, in 2011 the Government will contribute two hundred million euros, and also in what it means for the realization of hydraulic infrastructures: sixty million euros will be the investment in this chapter for this year.

In addition, that Comprehensive Strategy has been deploying actions to support fundamental economic sectors in the Canary Islands, with measures in the tourism sector for the renovation of the hotel plant. Only with the agreement on tourism infrastructure currently in force, the State contributes more than forty million euros to the Community, which is added to the aid for renovation and modernization. And, of course, I want to make a special mention --being here, in addition, the Minister of Development--, very dear to the Government of the Canary Islands, to what are the air fare discounts and their effects on tourism, whose estimated effects amount to twenty-five million euros in 2011.

We have also supported the maintenance of agricultural production, and on July 8, the Government approved twenty-three million euros for the Strategic Plan for the Canary Islands in this area. We are also in the process of reforming the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands.

We have also maintained and reinforced, because we know it is the essential problem of the Islands, the Comprehensive Employment Plan for the Canary Islands: adapting the third Plan and making significant budget contributions: during this Legislature, 42 million euros annually for the Special Employment Plans for the Canary Islands. Just as for the educational infrastructure plans.

These are commitments, most of which have been agreed upon with the Government of the Canary Islands and the Cabildos. Undoubtedly, there are some that remain to be fulfilled that affect this year, and we are working to ensure that in the coming weeks some of those affecting the island of El Hierro can be completed.

In any case, I can express from here our satisfaction with the agreements we have been carrying out with your Group and with the Government of the Canary Islands for the benefit of this Community, because they have always been present, from the first day, from the two Investiture Debates, in me the singularity and special support that a Autonomous Community like the Canary Islands deserves.

And I reiterate my gratitude for your words.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. José Manuel Pérez Bouza, of the Parliamentary Group of Nationalist Senators

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Pérez Bouza.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you will excuse me for, although this is your last control session and this is the last question you will answer, not dedicating all the time of my intervention to praising some of your virtues, which you have and which I recognize, and I will expressly acknowledge at the end of this intervention. But I cannot miss the opportunity, in this last control session, to ask you about the non-fulfillment of one of your Government's commitments with Galicia on an absolutely crucial issue for our territory.

When you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, took office as President of the Government in 2004, the High-Speed connection between Galicia and Madrid was nothing more than four lines painted on a paper that the previous Government of the Popular Party had drawn and to which it had given a pompous name of "Plan Galicia." You made a firm commitment in 2004 that by 2009 that High-Speed Line would be fully operational; a commitment that ultimately proved empty and which in 2006 had to be revised, because it was evident that, given the progress of the projects, by 2009 that connection would not be operational.

It was revised and a new time frame was established: three years later, 2012. Again, months passed, years passed, and the appropriate steps were not taken for the projects to progress, neither administratively nor, much less, at the execution level.

Therefore, in 2009, when you faced a change in the Ministry of Development and appointed Mr. Blanco, who is present today in this Chamber, it was necessary to review the commitments again and delay the time objective three more years, until 2015. Even Mr. Blanco at the beginning of his mandate, of his responsibility, signed a pact with the president of the Xunta de Galicia, Mr. Feijóo, called the "Pact of the Obradoiro," where a schedule of bidding, awards, and investments was established so that this could be a reality in 2015.

From the BNG we were very critical of this pact from the beginning because we were certain that it was impossible to meet those commitments.

To this day, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, two years later, unfortunately, and I tell you this sincerely, time has proven us right. None of the two objectives with which that pact was signed has been fulfilled. The first was to reduce institutional tension between the Xunta de Galicia and the State Government, and day in and day out we witness constant skirmishes between the Xunta de Galicia, the Ministry of Development, and the State Government regarding this issue. The other objective was to fulfill that schedule of bidding, awards, and investments. The express and literal objective included in that pact was that by December 31, 2010, all sections of the Lubián-Ourense line should have been awarded. We are in September 2011, only three of those sections have been awarded and are under construction, and about twenty, more or less, have not been awarded to this day, nor can they therefore be under construction.

You will understand that meeting that time objective of 2015 is absolutely, to this day, a true chimera.

But there are not only non-fulfillments regarding this line; there are other lines where your commitments have also clearly been unmet: Ourense-Vigo was also committed for 2015 and at this moment it is only with the initial projects, in a kind of invention that the Ministry of Development pulled out of its hat, specifically a preliminary project of the definitive project; Lugo-Ourense, totally paralyzed; the Atlantic Axis, with advanced works but without a start date, and Lubián-Ourense I have already mentioned how it is.

In short, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, a poor balance of your Government on an absolutely crucial issue for Galicia, riddled with non-fulfillments and unjustified delays. And I say "crucial issue for Galicia" and I reaffirm it. It is absolutely crucial because the social, demographic, and economic future of our territory largely depends on this infrastructure. And it is even more crucial because there are other territories, such as Andalucía, that have had this infrastructure for twenty years; others, like Catalonia and Aragón, for three years; Valencia, for a year, and in Galicia, at best, we will enjoy it twenty years later.

In short, and in light of the evidence of your non-fulfillments and given the importance of this infrastructure for the development of Galicia, I ask you what is the reason for the systematic non-fulfillment of the objectives that you have only set for yourself; no one has forced you to set them, but you have set them. Perhaps it is due to a lack of political commitment from your Government to this infrastructure, perhaps it is the incompetence of some political leader who has been in charge of the Ministry of Development for five years, or perhaps it is because in your Government there are certain ministers, certain members, who do not believe at all in the need to carry out this infrastructure.

Nothing more and thank you very much.

President.- Mr. Pérez-Bouza, since 2004 the Government has had a very marked commitment to the development of infrastructures with Galicia and, in general, with investment in that territory, in that Autonomous Community, especially with the High-Speed project. Allow me to give you a brief account of how things are and how stages have been completed.

The budgetary effort, to which I will refer later, that has been made in these seven years has allowed us to give a strong pace to the execution of the works; works, as you well know, that start from projects, undoubtedly, with orographic difficulties and of all kinds.

Starting from the ends of the route, the connection between Madrid and Olmedo, in Valladolid, began operations in 2007, and on December 10, the first High-Speed train will run on the section that connects A Coruña with Santiago and Ourense. The construction work in the provinces of Valladolid and Zamora is well advanced, and the 95 kilometers between Olmedo and Zamora could be ready by the end of next year. The 108-kilometer section that will connect Ourense with Zamora-Lubián was approved in April, and the bidding processes are being strictly adhered to. As for the direct connection from Vigo to Ourense and Madrid, via the Cerdedo variant, the projects are being finalized so that the works can be put out to tender starting next spring.

In summary, of the total of 650 kilometers that the route between A Coruña and Madrid will have, almost 300 kilometers will be in service by December — to be exact, 292 of the 650 kilometers — another 250 will be under construction, and one hundred more will be in bidding. That is the state of affairs.

The accumulated investment in Galicia over the seven budgets corresponding to this Government's term has amounted to 12.224 billion euros, a 137 percent increase compared to the previous term. Galicia today receives a total investment percentage of 9.3 percent of the entire State, which is much higher than its weight in GDP, which is 5.2 percent, and its population, which is 6 percent. In fact, there has not been a period in history for Galicia with such investment and such a percentage of investment relative to its GDP or its population in the overall State.

To add a piece of information, the years 2009 and 2010 were the highest in terms of execution in transport infrastructure in the history of Galicia.

In short, Ladies and Gentlemen, I believe that a significant investment and execution effort has been made, and that this effort, within a reasonable timeframe, will represent a huge leap in infrastructure provision for Galicia, especially with the launch of High-Speed rail.

It is true, as you have recalled, that in 2004 we committed to do everything in our power to complete High-Speed rail to Galicia; but the task was not to complete, it was to initiate. In seven years this is the balance, and the balance is a reasonable one, which demonstrates the political will and the effort that has been maintained to equip Galicia with High-Speed rail.

I remind you that by December, 45 percent of the route will be operational; another 38 percent will be under construction, and the remaining 17 percent will be in bidding. I believe that, reasonably, you should weigh that a significant effort has been made.

Mr. Pérez Bouza.- Mr. President, I thank you for the data you have provided, and I have no doubt that they are true, both in terms of investment, as well as temporal execution and percentage of work completed and pending; but you cannot deny that you have failed to meet the temporal commitments that you yourselves have assumed and that no one asked you to assume: first 2009, then 2012, and now 2015.

I also appreciate you providing data from Castilla y León, but I was exclusively asking about your Government's commitments to Galicia.

I also remind you that the 9.3 percent investment that your Government has made in Galicia in recent years is not voluntary on the part of the Government. That is a result of agreements with the BNG when you needed our support to approve the General State Budgets, and it is there that the leap to reach 8 percent or higher was made.

In any case, and I will conclude, Mr. President, because I do not want to finish without acknowledging some of your virtues, as I mentioned at the beginning of my speech, I cannot make a positive assessment of your Government's term in this Legislature, the Legislature that is ending, as you know we have many disagreements in general policy regarding how you have faced the exit from the crisis; nor can I positively assess the failures with Galicia, but I do want to acknowledge your virtues: I want to acknowledge your honesty, I want to acknowledge your dedication, I want to acknowledge your closeness, I want to acknowledge your commitment, your work, and, above all, that you have appeared in this Chamber and given us the opportunity to scrutinize your management.

So, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, good luck, and may you be very happy in your new stage.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Bouza. Thank you very much for your kind words, which you can understand simply convey to me the idea of the good relationship I have had with your Group, which I appreciate and thank for having supported me on more than one occasion in this Chamber and, especially, in the Congress of Deputies.

But allow me to make a clarification about the commitment and will with Galicia. The investment data is overwhelming, and if those data are as they are, it is because there has been a very special effort, not only with Galicia but with the majority of the regions in the Northwest. You know that you are part of a project very dear to me, conceived years ago with other colleagues, and that we have tried to materialize by also providing support in investment and infrastructure to Castilla y León and Asturias.

It is true that to ensure that the AVE reaches Galicia, we need to invest in Castilla y León. I believe that for the Galicians it is good that we have to go through Castilla y León to reach Galicia, and for the people of Castilla y León, it gives us great satisfaction to be so close to Galicia, because it is a land with so many attractions that, without a doubt, it is a place of attraction and meeting.

Regarding the timelines, we know what happens with the timelines of infrastructure in general. Experts tell me — I did not say it before, and now I will say it — that if we maintain the pace of investment in the AVE to Galicia, the High-Speed Line will be completed around the end of 2015. I convey this to the Chamber. It can be said: is it a commitment? It is a goal, it is an estimate, it is a plan.

The truth is, and this will remain in what the annals of these two Legislatures represent, that it is this, the Government I preside over, with the previous minister and now with a Galician minister, indeed, with José Blanco, the Government that has made the definitive push for Galicia to have High-Speed rail. That is the case, and it will remain so in history.

Thank you very much. I also wish you the best, Your Honor.