Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at the Business Round Table organized by "The Economist."

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 November 2009 · Autumn Conference of The Economist, Business Round Table

Context
Zapatero addressed The Economist's Autumn Business Round Table in November 2009, outlining Spain's path out of the financial crisis and its long-term economic growth strategy.
Main themes
Economic recovery, productive model renewal, Spain's growth potential, unemployment, real estate crisis and indebtedness, Sustainable Economy Law, labor market modernization, demographic advantages, investment and innovation, electric vehicle and strategic sectors
Duration
~74 min
97th percentile
Words
8,933
97th percentile
Sentences
275
94th percentile
Readability
34
23rd percentile
Grade
16.5
86th percentile
Syntax
3.51
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 59%59%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 0%

275 sentences in 121 paragraphs

Thank you very much to "The Economist" for inviting me to this Autumn Conference, of which, as you know, I have become a regular attendee, in good times and in less good times.

The title that heads this session, "Charting the Future Course of Spain," seems particularly apt to indicate what is, at this moment, the main task of the Government, its main responsibility; that is, how to leave the crisis behind, how to return to growth, how to create jobs in our country again, and how to do all this, moreover, knowing that we are not facing a simple succession of economic cycles, but rather the challenge of growing and creating jobs differently with a renewed productive model.

You are well aware of the latest data and you also know the forecasts and the revisions of the forecasts from international organizations. It is not necessary for me to remind you of that here today.

The recovery has begun. We do not yet know with what strength, with what progression; nor do we yet know with certainty when it will have sufficient vigor to create jobs in a stable manner; but it is already underway. With some differences in months and initial intensity, it seems to be starting everywhere; in developed countries and in emerging ones, with the latter showing more strength.

Also in Spain, we are about to register positive inter-quarterly data. We entered the recession somewhat later and we will exit it somewhat later. And, if just a few months ago we were all overly optimistic in our forecasts, we will soon see how, fortunately, the opposite occurs. Everything points to the fact that the pace of recovery is going to accelerate, but we must continue to be cautious.

In any case, it does not make much sense to debate the forecasts. I will not do so with those who indicate that Spain may grow more slowly than the euro area average in the coming quarters; but I do believe it is relevant to express the Government's position on the data that underpins those predictions forecasting a slower growth of the Spanish economy.

The primary factor they take into consideration is the difficulty of assimilating the real estate crisis and the consequences of the excessive indebtedness that has accompanied it in the short term. Well, I believe I do not need to tell you that the Government is fully aware of the specific weight that this imbalance of the Spanish economy has had and still has, fueled over decades by various causes and which the global crisis has so abruptly highlighted and exacerbated, because this imbalance is responsible for almost half of the unemployment that has been generated in the last year and a half.

I myself addressed this issue at some length in the last State of the Nation Debate in the Congress of Deputies. It is an imbalance that explains some of the measures we are already taking and, above all, the strong impetus we are going to give to the renewal of our productive model with the Sustainable Economy Law, to which I will refer shortly.

But first, allow me to lift my gaze a little from the present to gain perspective and explain how the Government sees and justifies the potential growth horizon of the Spanish economy, precisely because, in our view, this potential growth remains higher than the euro area average and is based on the following reasons:

- First, during the next decade, Spain will have a less aging population than the European average. Our dependency ratio, that is, the percentage of the population over 64 years of age compared to the total working-age population, will remain almost four points below that average.

- Second, among the new entrants to the labor market, there will be a higher percentage of graduates; specifically, nearly 40 percent of young people will attain higher education compared to 31 percent of the European average. In the next decade, we will be in a position to complete the process of incorporating women into the labor market in Spain, increasing the female active population by more than one million women, with a very relevant particularity: there will be 33 percent more women than now with higher educational levels in our labor market, a much higher increase than the European average.

- Third, we have a more modern productive capital, the result of greater investment efforts by our companies. Specifically, in the last expansionary cycle, the growth rates of investment in equipment have been more than double those of the European Union average. In the last year, and despite the crisis, we have made a significant modernization and innovation effort in our strategic sectors such as aerospace, biotechnology, and automotive, where, in addition to a competitiveness plan to promote innovation, last week, for the first time in Europe, a memorandum of understanding was signed between the public and private sectors, bringing together more than fifty companies from all sectors for the launch of the electric vehicle: manufacturers, components, electric companies, infrastructure, and ICT.

Fourth, Spain has an increasingly internationalized business fabric with leading companies in the field of information technologies and their application to services such as online healthcare, education, or security. Leading companies also in telecommunications, aerospace, and the financial sector, infrastructure management, renewable energies, the tourism sector, or digital content. This explains the continuous opening of new markets and the maintenance of the global market share of exports despite the strong expansion of emerging countries. Currently, Spain is already in fifth place among the world's major investors, with an average exceeding 75 billion dollars a year.

- Fifth, in recent years we have also made a significant public investment effort to strengthen the physical and innovative capital of our economy. Spain will have transport infrastructures significantly above the European average. Spain is already a leader in Europe in the network of highways and motorways, and in high-speed rail. We are also leaders in broadband coverage and in the implementation of digital terrestrial television.

Alongside this, we have made a leap in our relative position in R&D+i, which started from very lagging positions from 56 percent in 2004 in the European average, to 71 percent in 2008. And in the budgets for next year, despite the extraordinary need to contain all spending items, we have increased the relative weight of spending on infrastructure and R&D+i, in addition to increasing in absolute terms that of Education.

I wish to highlight in this regard that in 2010 there is a source of funding for Research, Development, and Innovation additional to that expressly allocated in the General State Budgets, coming from two new funds associated with the Sustainable Economy Law: the State Fund for Employment and Local Sustainability, already approved by the Council of Ministers and endowed with five billion euros, and the Fund for Sustainable Economy, soon to be approved, and endowed with twenty billion euros. Both Funds are largely intended to finance actions related to research, development, and, above all, innovation, education, energy efficiency, and infrastructures. Overall, therefore, public investment in Research, Development, and Innovation will be higher in 2010 than in any previous year.

Here are five new reasons to assert that Spain is in a position to recover vigorous economic growth.

The main obligation of the Government, then, is to push the Spanish economy as soon as possible towards the threshold of its potential growth, with which we will find its new cycle of employment growth in our country. What can we do to shorten that transition? I return now to the imbalances that threaten to slow our recovery in the first phase, which the Government intends to correct by accelerating the renewal of our productive model.

We are convinced that the pace of our recovery, as well as its consolidation and solidity, will depend on our success in undertaking this task. This is the best future course for the Spanish economy, a course that has already begun with an intense process of correcting our imbalances in at least three areas: in the normalization, inevitable although painful in terms of employment, of the real estate sector, in the excess indebtedness of the private sector, and in the inflation differential; three decisive imbalances for the recovery capacity of our economy.

The real estate sector, which came to represent 7.5 percent of GDP in 2007, has seen its weight reduced to the current 5.3 percent, which is already the European average, and the Government is contributing to its normalization with significant budgetary efforts and promoting regulatory and fiscal changes.

Renting has been encouraged on the supply side, with significant regulatory changes that provide greater security to landlords and with the creation of Real Estate Investment Societies. On the demand side, in addition to fiscal improvements for renting, we have extended the Basic Rent for Emancipation for young people to 150,000 beneficiaries at this time. And now we are facilitating the exit of a good part of the stock of free housing, not only as protected housing but also for rent. We will take some time to see the full results, but the weight of renting is progressively increasing and already reaches 13 percent.

And now, with the Sustainable Economy Law, we intend to accelerate the normalization of the sector with even more relevant measures. I will refer to them shortly.

Second, linked to the reduction of the real estate sector is the adjustment in financing among the different productive sectors. The financing needs of the economy, measured by its current account deficit, reached 9.6 percent of GDP in 2007 and has already stood at 5.8 percent of GDP in the first half of 2009. The adjustment of the financing needs has been contributed to by households and also, especially, by companies that have reduced their indebtedness to levels of 2005 in practically less than a year. This entails, as we know, the need to rationalize the size of the financial system to make it compatible with the new business perspectives, where credit growth will be lower than it undoubtedly was in the most expansive phase of the cycle.

Third, since the entry into the Monetary Union, Spain has observed a price increase superior, around one percentage point, to that of the euro area. This inflation differential had been affecting the loss of competitiveness of our exports compared to our main European partners. The trend has reversed in recent months, which is already being appreciated in our export activity. The simplification of the regulation of the services sector; the liberalization of domestic trade and of our electricity and gas markets, which we have initiated, will help to temper in the future what has traditionally been a structural factor of pressure on prices.

Therefore, rapid adjustments in the real estate sector, in credit demand, in the external deficit, and in the inflation differential explain, on one hand, the strong contraction of our economy, a contraction compensated by the intense counter-cyclical measures applied, but they also open a certain expectation of initiating growth on healthier bases.

Precisely to reach our potential growth sooner and to consolidate it, to make it more balanced and stable over time, the Government is willing to introduce new changes and reforms in the economic system.

Until now, since the crisis began, we have concentrated our energies on stopping the crisis, alleviating its consequences, containing its most negative effects, and preserving social cohesion during this particularly difficult period.

We have not only done that; we have also been promoting some reforms in the energy sector, in ports, or in the services sector within the framework of the E Plan. But now reforms, the transformation of our productive model, will be our top priority and will concentrate the bulk of our efforts.

A few months ago, on the occasion of the last State of the Nation Debate, I announced my intention to address a renewal of our productive model to make it more competitive and innovative, as well as socially and environmentally sustainable.

We have been working during all this time, and next Friday the Council of Ministers will formally pronounce on the results of this work. On Friday, we will approve the Draft Law on Sustainable Economy, but we will do something more, which I now announce: we will approve the Strategy for Sustainable Economic Growth, a global action plan to drive the change of the model. The Strategy will set the principles of the new model and its objectives, with a horizon of a decade, until 2020, delineated through indicators that will allow for the evaluation and oversight of the development of the planned initiative, and that will provide a sufficiently clear profile of what the changes, the reforms, we want to introduce into our economic system are. Alongside this, it will identify the instruments and the scenarios for the application of the new reforms.

The Law on Sustainable Economy is the essential instrument of this reform program, but by no means the only one. The Strategy will specify the other legislative or regulatory initiatives that the Government will commit to approve by the end of the Legislature, with explicit indication of the dates of approval or presentation, as the case may be, before the Chambers. Some initiatives are already well advanced and will be agreed upon in the coming weeks.

You know that I like to respect timelines and procedures. On Friday, you will be able to learn in detail about the Draft of the new Law on Sustainable Economy. For this reason, I will now limit myself to announcing the very diverse areas in which the Law impacts and in which it articulates reforms and innovations:

As you can glimpse, the Law contains a wide array of modernizing changes to our economy, mainly in three particularly important areas in light of the economic crisis we are facing: providing greater transparency to the financial sector, promoting business dynamism, and developing all the economic sectors that accompany the fight against climate change and in favor of innovation in all fields of our economy.

However, in any case, a task as ambitious and crucial for our future as renewing our productive model can only be conceived as a great collective and far-reaching task in which all agents and institutions of our country must be involved. In this sense, we propose that the adaptation to the new model has a projection in the realm of relations with and among the Autonomous Communities, within the framework of social dialogue and, regarding the sustainability of our pension system, in the Toledo Pact Commission.

The Government wishes to respect the logic of action in these spaces of social or institutional dialogue, which it is committed, in any case, to promote and energize, and we will start where we must start in democracy: in Parliament.

On the occasion of the processing of the Law, we are offered the opportunity to forge a broad consensus on the change of model, on the main lines of the future of our economy and, ultimately, of our well-being. But, before that moment arrives and to encourage the collective debate we need, I intend to appear shortly before the Congress of Deputies to present the Strategy for Sustainable Economic Growth that the Government will approve on Friday.

I will conclude.

In the face of this ambitious process of reforms and changes that will undoubtedly occupy a good part of public opinion in the coming days and weeks, I want to appeal to a dual confidence: first, confidence in a country and in a Government that since 2004 has tripled investment in Research, Development, and Innovation, has doubled spending on education, and has made the greatest effort in our history in the development of infrastructure.

Confidence in a Government that is capable of making always difficult decisions, although in this case necessary, such as the announced tax increase, after almost four years, it is true, of having reduced our main taxes in our economy and, despite that, having achieved the first public surplus in our history.

Confidence in a political project that has often throughout the history of democracy known how to lead and carry out significant reform processes. We did it when facing industrial reconversion, also during the crisis of 1993, and on many other occasions.

And, confidence, above all, in Spanish society, in its entrepreneurs and in its workers because they will be, they have to be, the great protagonists of the change of model.

The responsibility of the Government consists in promoting it, after an accurate diagnosis, in incentivizing it, and in applying to itself the guidelines that can promote it; but in a market economy like ours, what is decisive is the behavior of economic and social agents; ultimately, of all citizens.

In 1982, when Felipe González came to power, we had a per capita income of 6,500 euros; today, twenty-seven years later, it is 26,000 euros, and this extraordinary progress is primarily due to the vitality and adaptability to changes, which have been many since then, of Spanish society.

And we now have, at this specific historical moment, a serious problem to solve: the large volume of unemployment that we suffer; the great problem that we have to resolve. For this, we know that it is essential to grow again at a good pace, and we know that we cannot do it in the same way we did in recent years. We are going to introduce necessary changes and reforms to grow differently, and we will take advantage of the strengths that we have also acquired in recent years with a growing innovative capacity, first-class infrastructure, and leading companies in some of the most dynamic sectors. In addition, we have social peace and a very acceptable degree of cohesion in our country.

The challenge is within our reach. To that challenge, social agents must also contribute directly: employers and unions.

You know that we are in a new phase, in a new round, of the social dialogue process that has regained vitality after the bad moments experienced in July. I hope that this new round not only resolves issues related to the application of agreements but that in this second phase it contemplates a scenario of wage agreement for the coming years and that we can join a third phase, a third round, of dialogue in which we improve all the capacities that allow the proposals of social agents from the perspective of the labor market and from the perspective of contributing to confidence and expectations in job creation.

In short, we have a serious challenge ahead, but a challenge to which Spanish society will know how to respond appropriately. If we do it, if we do it soon, and if we do it with the guidelines that the Government understands are appropriate for Spanish society, we are fully convinced that the potential growth of the Spanish economy remains a high potential growth. This will allow us to continue on the path of our prosperity that has so surprised the world and of our development, and this will facilitate us addressing the great challenge, the main challenge, which is to reduce unemployment rates as soon as possible and to generate employment again.

Ladies and gentlemen, this is how I see the economic future of our country.

Thank you very much.

DIALOGUE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT

------------------------------------------------------------------

Q.- (Representative of Telefónica) I believe that these three characteristics of competitiveness, progressiveness, and autonomy in the functioning of companies are something that we should conceive as desirable in Europe, and probably in Spain. Therefore, my almost sole question for the President would be what we, as companies, can do to contribute to making that re-engagement with a significant and vigorous recovery in Spain faster and to proceed at a greater speed.

Q.- (Representative of Agbar) What I would essentially like to comment on are the comments, in general, that have been made from various social spheres and, in particular, those from the Círculo de Economía in Barcelona, where there are two basic issues: one, the economic issue, to which you have referred, and, basically, within the economic issue, unemployment. This is a country where we cannot sustain an unemployment rate like the one we have, structurally moreover, which is not of your Government but is traditional, despite the fact that we recover and now we are losing again. Therefore, I would leave a first question for the President of the Government: Will there be any labor reform? Will there be a thorough discussion on this issue in the Law on Sustainable Economy?

A second issue addressed by the Círculo de Economía is institutional stability and, therefore, the functioning of all institutions. In this sense, there was a call for a pact among all political parties so that the economic measures, both in the short and long term, for this country to continue growing are adopted from a perspective of consensus that does not become a daily debate and headline in the newspapers.

I agree with you, Mr. President, that there are many companies, like ours, that have internationalized, that will surely overcome the crisis, that we face with optimism; but it is also true that there is a whole series of small and medium-sized enterprises that will be left behind because they do not have financing, despite being viable, despite having made an effort to internationalize, despite having good products, and despite being in innovation. I believe that along the way we should see how that financing reaches those small and medium-sized enterprises.

I want to tell the President of the Government that that optimism is there, although there are many people who still have that look of the portrait of Jovellanos, right?, and who feared, let’s say, for the ruin of the Spanish spirit. We are not in that situation, and you can count on us for that optimism.

President.- The truth is that the two issues raised by two such solid companies with such a good track record are of great interest, and moreover, they address the central core of the response we have to give and of the problems that Spanish society suffers.

The representative of a company like Telefónica referred to which sectors must take over from the residential construction sector that has had that great potential for job creation in recent years. There are two major fields in which Spanish society, the Spanish economy, and Spanish companies have a certain ground to create jobs when the Spanish economy has, logically, the clear symptoms of recovery.

On one hand, the vast field of the energy transformation process and environmental sustainability in which we want and need to channel our productive model. On some occasions, you may have heard me say that in the next decade, those countries that take the lead in innovation in the fight against climate change, which is an extraordinarily broad field affecting productive sectors, will be the countries that mark the greatest capacity for sustainable growth and solid growth of economies in the world, just as at the beginning of the 90s, the societies that first took on the leadership of Information and Communication Technologies.

Therefore, first, the broad field of energy savings and efficiency, where our economy needs a profound transformation: energy savings and efficiency in companies, energy savings and efficiency in housing, in the residential sector, energy savings and efficiency in public buildings, and energy savings and efficiency throughout the economy. The potential for job creation in energy service companies is, in the medium term, of great volume, because all developed economies will undertake this renewal process in favor of savings and energy efficiency.

Within the field of the fight against climate change, this new energy model also leads to the expansion and development of renewable energies; a source of employment, in the medium term as well, of great interest.

Therefore, there is a vast field in everything related to the functioning of the model of transformation in the energy sector, not to mention water, the reuse of water, or water treatment. In short, everything that is in the realm of that environmental adaptability, of that environmental sustainability, which has, as you can understand, a great traction, a great force, in the high technology sector, in the research sector, and in the innovation sector.

Second, our country has a certain field of development in the area of services to businesses, where we are still far from reaching our growth potential and our potential, therefore, for job creation. It is a sector that can favor a great creation of jobs.

And third, it is important to clarify that for the dynamization or the ability to create jobs, there must be a direction of trust and expectation from the companies in our country. It does not seem convenient or sufficient to wait to create jobs when the profits are already certain profits from the companies. We must also introduce an incentive component where, as I mentioned earlier and linking it to the question of labor reform, we are in a new round of dialogue among social interlocutors. This new round will include a new phase in which the Government will be present, strictly related to our labor market and to establish new measures that facilitate and promote trust in companies in view of the cycle, which we hope will start as soon as possible, of new hiring and job creation. Therefore, I believe I have answered a question.

The aspects related to the labor market, which we want to have a response in the first quarter of 2010, must be situated in social dialogue. Is there a need to do things? Yes, but the superiority of doing them with agreement seems unquestionable to me before incorporating them unilaterally through a law. Is there willingness from employers and unions? In my opinion, there is a better willingness than we had before the summer, and we must try to preserve it.

Two issues have been raised regarding credit, small businesses, and institutional stability. It is evident that we live in a certain contradiction in this regard, and I believe that in the economic debate it can be rigorously established. There is not a single economist, and surely no political leader, and I believe that companies also agree, who does not admit that the Spanish economy must reduce its level of indebtedness.

I have given the figure: the pace of reduction of the level of indebtedness, of the current account deficit, is spectacular: from 9.7 to 5.7 percent in just over a year. It is evident, this is an adjustment, and the adjustment, in this case, is being made at the expense of credit, when we are now at practically zero growth rates of credit in our country after having experienced in 2006 and 2007 a growth of 30 percent of credit in our country that is unprecedented and that, of course, was the highest growth of all European economies. Therefore, we are in a phase of absorbing a process of credit exaggeration, which led us to nearly 10 percent of the current account deficit.

I want to emphasize, and I have said it before, that this indebtedness was not from the public sector. The public sector was saving at that time; the indebtedness was from companies and families. It has reached a volume of 1.2 percent of GDP for companies and 0.8 percent of GDP for families in Spain, and now it is being adjusted. Of course, if it is adjusted, there are more difficulties for credit. Even so, I must say that 25 percent of the new credit being given in Spain to SMEs is going through the Official Credit Institute at this moment, 25 percent through the ICO. Does it not reach everyone? Agreed, but it is evident that we are making an effort from the public sector to support the maximum responsibility of credit.

And it is not surprising that in the same discourse of some actors in political or economic life, there is a call to reduce the deficit and indebtedness, and to promote credit from the public sector, which has its complexity for coherence, because I must remind you that every time the public sector facilitates or shares risks when it comes to credit, it is logically imputing debt to the whole of the Public Administrations.

This is the situation. We must strive for a balance, maintain the maximum possible capacity to generate credit, but being aware that the adjustment had to occur, and surely due to the severity of the economic crisis and the intensity of the recession, the adjustment is occurring in a very abrupt manner, as the Spanish economy is uniquely suffering.

Now, as you know, a new measure is being implemented by the Government, which is related to credit facilitators who will carry out a follow-up task on the denial of credit to SMEs by financial entities and facilitate, help, or contribute to ensuring that credit can flow more, because certainly, all the availability of resources that the ICO has, which we have allocated for this year and which we will allocate for next year, must be exhausted to limit the damage that the credit restriction is causing.

I have said it in my speech: as the adjustment in indebtedness and credit that the Spanish economy must necessarily experience is inevitable, it will also produce the obligation of a restructuring in the financial sector, because the framework, the margin, the magnitude of the business will be smaller with less credit. For this, we have established legal measures, we have the work of the Bank of Spain, and we hope that by spring there can be a whole process of restructuring of the financial system that is necessary so that the good process that our financial system has gone through in the crisis, where only a small entity had to be intervened compared to all European countries, maintains that position and that in the exit from the crisis we have as a result a restructuring of the financial system where we maintain, with restructuring, solid entities and that costs us the least possible to public accounts.

So far, we are perhaps the country that is costing us the least in supporting the financial system from public accounts, but this is also a fundamental angle for the outcome.

Q.- (Representative of "The Economist") In just a month, Spain will assume the Presidency of the European Union, although a President of the Council, the Belgian Herman Van Rompuy, has already been elected, and I wanted to know if during Spain's Presidency of the Union there is any plan to revive the Lisbon Pact, which among others was approved by Spain and the United Kingdom ten years ago, to take on a new role regarding the world economy, which is a goal that has truly not been achieved. The Lisbon Agenda involved deep reforms, including in Spain, which have not yet been undertaken. Is there any plan to give new life to this Lisbon Agenda?

President.- One of the fundamental objectives of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union is economic policy, the exit from the crisis, and the promotion, the design, of a more sustainable economy in the Union. Within that great objective, which is the primary goal of the Spanish Presidency, there are two fundamental issues, and the first of them is to incorporate new instruments for coordinating economic policies in the European Union.

If we have learned anything from this crisis, especially from the financial crisis, the origin of the great crisis, it is that coordination is fundamental in a globalized world. When you have actors of the relevance and potential of China, the United States, or emerging economies, Europe must respond with a more coordinated economic policy, with more common European policy. This will entail advances in issues that need a boost, such as completing the internal market, or incorporating new measures in the Eurogroup and in the field of economic policies. I will not detail more at this moment.

Second, in coherence with this idea, which seems very clear in a globalized world, we must renew the so-called Lisbon Strategy. The Lisbon Strategy was a good idea, it is a good idea, it is a good document, but its application has been very deficient, because we have not been able to reach the objective that the Lisbon Strategy proposed, which is to make Europe the most innovative economy. Why? Because the Lisbon Strategy has quite a bit of analysis and quite a few generic measures, but not enough commitments or sufficiently effective, direct tools that commit, that obligate, countries and the Union to apply and develop that strategy in the fields of innovation, labor market, combating climate change, etc., etc.

Consequently, let us renew the Lisbon Strategy. It is undeniable, and this is under the Spanish Presidency, that in the renewal of the Lisbon Strategy, everything that affects the fight against climate change will carry great weight, and, two, innovation as a key element in which we must incorporate new measures and new economic policies from the Union.

Consequently, two concrete aspects: more coordination of economic policies, of macroeconomic policy, of the various countries, which is a great challenge, against traditionally nationalist positions, but either we have a historical vision, or we realize how the distribution of influences and decision-making is in a globalized world, or we will not succeed; and, second, renewal of the Lisbon Strategy with more operational instruments. There must be less rhetoric and more decisions that obligate.

Q.- (Representative of Philips) There is a very interesting issue, with which we collaborate very closely with the Government, the issue of energy efficiency. It is a reality that it is a very evident and very important issue at the Spanish and European level, an issue that concerns us, and what we want to say as companies involved in lighting and energy efficiency is that innovation and technologies are changing at a rapid pace. What we thought was efficient and appropriate six months or a year ago is no longer so.

So, the offer that I, as a member of the Board of Directors of the Electric Sector, make to you is to collaborate more closely with the Government to see, looking to the future, what is necessary in energy efficiency. In this case, I speak very clearly about the issue, for example, of "LEDs," which is the future. So, I wanted to make that offer to the Government to collaborate more closely.

President.- Thank you very much. I believe that the intervention is sufficiently eloquent apart from thanking, taking note, and starting to work immediately—but if something determines the economic future, as it has throughout economic history, and fundamentally since the development of the so-called industrial economy, it is energy. That is to say, those countries that have known or had the opportunity, for one reason or another, to better adopt the energy condition for the functioning of the economy are countries that have grown more and have had more capacity to innovate.

Today the challenge has the scope it has had in other historical moments. We know that there is a certain energy model that has been functioning fundamentally at the peak of the expansion, of the use of oil, and that model is in regression and there must be a new model.

The primary source of energy today, the primary source of energy, the most secure source, is savings and energy efficiency; then, renewable energies and all the others we want. But the first is savings and energy efficiency.

I am glad to know that innovation in this field has the speed that our interlocutor has just expressed. But the results, even without applying those latest achievements in the field of innovation, are already spectacular. Wherever they are being promoted—I will refer only, not to civil buildings, but to public buildings or public lighting systems—wherever there has been a process of renewal of the energy system, of energy contribution, and lighting, for example, in Town Halls, moving to innovative models of efficiency, the savings are spectacular. They practically save half the energy cost that an average Town Hall can have where this has occurred.

By the way, some of these projects have been funded by the Local Investment Fund, which we have had this year and which has sometimes received so much criticism; and, of course, much more will be done with the Investment Fund for 2010 of five billion euros, because one of the aspects that the Fund expressly contemplates is precisely everything that means the renewal of lighting infrastructures that represent an extraordinary energy cost.

Therefore, I greatly appreciate your offer; this is a priority issue for the Government, not only in public buildings but also in the private sector of housing and residential construction. You know that at this moment we have tax incentives for renovation aimed at energy savings, but we will have more in the Sustainable Economy Law, and therefore, we believe that there must be a genuine mobilization of companies from different sectors in favor of making a great and profound renewal of our energy structure to achieve savings and efficiency. Moreover, we know that we have good companies in that field, but it is a sector to be developed; that is, this is a clear niche for business initiative in the coming years, without a doubt.

Q.- (Representative of the Real Instituto Elcano). I want to ask what your Government is going to do to solve the terrible problem of school failure.

President.- I should say that we need to improve the ratios, the percentage, of young people who pursue studies beyond compulsory education. I must specify that we are a demanding country in our educational statistics, demanding of ourselves, and therefore, school dropout, which you refer to as school failure, must be drastically reduced. It has already begun to decrease in the last two years, and a year ago there was an agreement between the Government and the regional governments to reduce school dropout.

School dropout needs, above all, two fundamental actions: one, to have a progressive increase, in line with what has already begun, with support for students who have more problems and, consequently, to strengthen their will and attitude to continue in the educational system; two, there is now a natural process of less school dropout, because there are fewer expectations in the labor market, especially in the construction sector, where many young people went to work in previous years with significant remuneration. And what we must do is to encourage, in part, some to return to the educational system to complete cycles of their training. It will be good for the country in the future and, of course, for each young person individually.

Therefore, we do not have a problem at the top of the pyramid as a country due to the percentage of graduates we have, due to the percentage of young people accessing higher education and their qualifications; we have a problem at the base of the pyramid, because we need to widen the number of young people who pursue studies beyond compulsory education.

But I must make a clarification, which is often not taken into account from outside our country: if one looks at where we started thirty years ago compared to the educational levels of our European partners in terms of illiteracy, thirty years ago there was illiteracy in Spain, when in Europe there was 70 percent of young people completing education beyond compulsory education. One must look at the data from thirty years ago in Spain regarding how many young people had a high school diploma. The journey we have made in thirty years to get closer, although we are still a stretch away from the European average, has been spectacular.

Therefore, I believe it is unfair to the Spanish educational system, I believe it is unfair to Spain, I believe it is unfair to educators, to teachers, and to our system that we can make a comparison, taking into account where we started from a disadvantaged situation, because one can gain ground if one has funds, and we have had them thanks to Europe, in providing infrastructure to a country; but it is much more arduous to catch up in terms of training levels and combating school dropout in relation to what has historically been a severe delay that Spain accumulated, fundamentally as a consequence of the entire process of the authoritarian regime.

What has democracy done, apart from raising all educational levels? What democracy has done is to promote a spectacular equality of opportunities. In fact, it is almost never said, it is important, and we feel proud that the Spanish educational system is one of the most equitable in the world, because it greatly promotes equality of opportunities.

But we have a great task ahead to combat school dropout; we have a great task, and the Sustainable Economy Law addresses this issue in relation to Vocational Training, and of course, we need a little more time to reach the levels of the European average.

Q.- (Representative of The Economist) Mr. President, what about universities? Spain has three of the best business schools in Europe and yet has no university among the top one hundred.

President.- There is currently a Government plan, which is the first plan that exists, called Universities of Excellence. We have incorporated around fifteen universities so that within these we can have some of them among the best in a reasonable time, I do not know if among the hundred or among the two hundred.

But I return to the same reflection. It is true that we do not have, in terms of research quality and excellence, those universities within the groups of universities in the world; but it is no less true that our university system guarantees more equality of opportunities than the vast majority of systems in the most advanced countries, where there is indeed that excellence, because here there has been a commitment from democracy to equality of opportunities.

Educational mobility has changed radically in access to the University thanks to our model, thanks to a certain political option, and this has generated a lot of social mobility, great social cohesion, and a percentage of university enrollment similar to that of France and I believe slightly above that of the United States, which will undoubtedly be a very positive factor, as I indicated earlier in my speech, in economic recovery.

Now we have a great challenge, which is to increase the quality of our universities. Note that we are the tenth power in research. That is to say, we have good researchers, but what do we need for those universities to start being among the best or in the group of the best? We need much more business in the University and much more University in business, this is what we need. Our university management system, our university model, has been quite disconnected from business. Fortunately, today we already have positive signs. Unlike large countries like, for example, Great Britain, where business lives in the University, here this was something unknown until very recently, and we still have a lot of ground to cover.

We will not improve the excellence of our universities if we do not make many more companies present in universities researching with an emphasis on applied research, respecting basic research, just as we need more universities, more doctoral students, and more doctors in companies so that our private sector has much more power in Research, Development, and Innovation. Fortunately, we are taking important steps. I believe that the latest data on public spending in R&D&I supports the good direction, but we are still at around seventy percent of the European average, more or less the pace, the time, or the percentage that we have left to place some of our universities in that leadership position.

But let us not undervalue, for what it has of a great process of social cohesion, of great capacity for social mobility, that in these decades we have created an educational system with enormous potential for equality of opportunities. In the long term, that is a great asset for the country, because incorporating as many as possible into the offer, into the possibility, of obtaining a university degree, a qualification, makes a country much stronger for economic growth, for its growth potential, and we hope also to emerge from the crisis.

Q.- (Representative of the American Chamber of Commerce) I am concerned about the productivity of the Spanish economy; I was concerned before the crisis, and I am still concerned today. Of the three perhaps most important vectors for improving productivity, reference has already been made to labor issues or labor market flexibility; reference has been made to education, especially higher education, and perhaps it would be worth expanding a little more on Research and Development. I would like you, if you can, to elaborate on that point.

And I would also take the opportunity to reformulate one of the questions that the organizers have put on the panel, which says: Where is foreign investment most needed? I would like to ask you, Mr. President, where you think foreign investment will be considered attracted to Spain in a period, say, of three to five years.

President.- The productivity of the Spanish economy is improving, and the President of the American Chambers of Commerce asks whether the contribution of Research, Development, and Innovation is decisive and how the Government is addressing R&D&I in this area.

First assertion, Spain is cutting back, and it has done so especially since 2004; I must be very emphatic about this, the serious setback we have had in relation to the overall spending of society on R&D&I and, therefore, on our innovative potential, which is a fundamental factor in the productivity of the economy.

I will give a piece of data: in the last four years, public investment in R&D&I has been more than double that in the eight years of the Popular Party's Government, and today we are at 1.37 percent of GDP spending. Our commitment is to approach 2 percent as soon as possible, but I must say that it is public spending on R&D&I that has increased the most, and however, private spending on R&D&I is growing, but slowly.

What are the two paths we need to promote? One, public-private collaboration in R&D&I is being a success, like the CENIT program, for example, within the large INGENIO program; the synergy of the public and private sectors in R&D&I is yielding great results. Two, we must facilitate incentives for the private sector to engage in Research, Development, and Innovation, and there will be such incentives in the Sustainable Economy Law.

In addition to that, a culture of research in business is needed. The culture of research in business is to have a long-term business perspective. The results of research and development in business are always long-term; they are contrary to easy enrichment, and we have had an excessive sector of residential construction, which precisely has another component; not that of civil engineering, nor that of certain construction sectors, which also have a great contribution to innovation from research and development, but that of promotion, that of the real estate sector in the strict sense.

Consequently, more public-private collaboration, incentives for the private sector in research, and I also propose as a third idea a more solid research career, where we have made progress, will lead us to reach that 2 percent of GDP spending on Research, Development, and Innovation that is decisive for productivity.

In which sectors can there be foreign investment in Spain? I believe it will undoubtedly be in sectors with the most innovative potential: broadly speaking, the entire communication technologies sector; the biotechnology sector, which I have not referred to in detail but which has enormous potential; everything that affects health sciences, the sciences of aging, and social services has great potential, and moreover, we are well positioned as a country; and, of course, everything that affects the vast field of energy model renewal that I have already referred to in much more detail, where foreign investment will undoubtedly have interest, it already has, and attractiveness, while there are also Spanish investors making strong operations, strong investments, in other countries around the world.

But for me, those are the three clear sectors where we can have a source of attraction for foreign direct investment, which we are very much in favor of, where Spain has been a good example in recent decades, especially of American investment. As the President of the Chambers knows, this was one of the fundamental issues I addressed in my meeting with President Obama. In fact, we are working in a bilateral economic cooperation forum between the United States and Spain, where investment from the United States in Spain and from Spain in the United States occupies the central theme, with a wide presence of Spanish and American entrepreneurs.

Q.- (Representative of Google). My question comes in terms of the evolution of services to citizens by Public Administrations, of which I believe we have seen substantial improvement for many years, both in the central and regional administrations, as we are carrying out many projects with all Public Administrations in our country as Google. However, we believe there is still much to be done, especially in the area of cost reduction, improving services to citizens in terms of developing the Information Society and maximizing the efficiency of public bodies. My question is: Does the Government have any plans for investment in the development of these instruments towards the Information Society in terms of Information Technologies?

President.- The truth is that we have had, we have, and we will have, because it is good for the productivity of the economy and for the effectiveness of the Administration, plans, among others, the Avanza Plan, which has been fundamental for the extension of ICT and the effectiveness of management from the different Public Administrations. In fact, I believe we have made groundbreaking advances. For example, in the eight billion euros of the Local Investment Fund that were carried out in 2009 under the E Plan, all projects have been managed and have been around thirty thousand projects in a telematic manner, with an effectiveness unknown in Public Administration.

Now, there are many areas, fundamentally in the realm of the direct relationship between the Administration and the citizen, that still need and are subject to programs of renewal and efficiency in management in the area of the network. We have some Administrations that already demonstrate their great competitiveness and effectiveness, such as, for example, the Tax Administration; but there are others, like the Administration of Justice, where we have this year the most important investment plan in new technologies of the entire General State Administration, where we have a regrettable delay, very serious, in my opinion, for the competitiveness of the economy and the productivity of the economy, because a modern, agile justice that operates through the network is an essential condition for the economy to function. This is a permanent burden on companies and in legal-economic traffic.

Just as I highlight that Social Security has a modern and efficient Administration, which resolves the issue of unemployment pensions with great speed despite the volume of millions of affected citizens, our Administration of Justice as a public service has been forgotten and is now, in fact, the only Ministry whose expenditure in Chapters 1 and 2 is increasing, because we deemed it essential. The Minister of Justice has presented a modernization plan, which aims to create a compatible, modern network in the field of Justice. This is where we would like to have the maximum collaboration from the Ministry, because this is a key issue for us.

Then there are other areas where we are making progress, I insist, in the relationship between Administration and administered, such as the Civil Registry and other services that are produced. Now, alongside modernization through ICT in the Administration-administered relationship, we have the Sustainable Economy Law, which will also incorporate new measures to reduce administrative burdens in the strict sense, because this will reduce times, facilitate management, and stimulate the renewal of activity.

In this, we still have ground to cover. It is true that we already have a broad chapter on reducing administrative burdens, and in the Sustainable Economy Law, we will give it a new twist.

I also draw attention to the advisability of extending this reformist spirit in the field of Administration management to the Autonomous Communities and to the Town Halls, which process a lot of administrative management in direct relation to citizens; but the Government, both from the Ministry of Public Administrations and from the Ministry of Industry, Tourism and Trade, which oversees the area of telecommunications competencies, and the Ministry of Justice are currently engaged in a broad program of reform and incorporation of Communication Technologies.

Of course, we appreciate all the collaboration from the sector and new ideas that may arise, because there is no modern, competitive, and innovative country that does not have an efficient Administration and, above all, an agile justice. This seems to be the great utopia of Spain. The great utopia of the Spanish State seems to be to have an agile and effective justice, and we must overcome this almost ingrained difficulty in our country.

Thank you very much.