The speech of the President of Romania, Mr. Klaus Iohannis, delivered during the plenary session of the Superior Council of Magistracy.

Romania Klaus Iohannis · President of Romania

10 December 2019 · Plenary session of the Superior Council of Magistracy

Context
Iohannis addressed the Superior Council of Magistracy plenary session on December 10, 2019, reviewing judicial independence and anti-corruption efforts during his term.
Main themes
Judicial independence, fight against corruption, rule of law in Romania, Superior Council of Magistracy, constitutional role of the president, democratic values, judicial reform, Venice Commission recommendations, magistrate professionalism, institutional balance, European integration
Duration
~12 min
44th percentile
Words
1,489
44th percentile
Sentences
53
35th percentile
Readability
21
4th percentile
Grade
17.3
91st percentile
Syntax
3.21
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
70th percentile

Translated from Romanian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 81%81%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

53 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Madam President of the High Court of Cassation and Justice,

Mr. Interim Attorney General,

Honorable members of the Superior Council of Magistracy,

Looking back, the year 2019 will remain in collective memory as the year when citizens protected, through their vote, the independence of justice and its proper functioning in the face of systematic attempts to weaken the judicial system during the referendum on May 26.

Although the year began on the same tense note, with a judiciary on the defensive, confronted with extensive legislative changes and the imminent entry into force of a highly contested criminal legislation, the result of the May referendum forced political decision-makers to reconsider their actions.

Two days ago, we celebrated 28 years since the adoption of the Constitution, and yesterday, at the international level, the Day of the Fight Against Corruption was celebrated. These are two important events that remind us every year that maintaining democracy requires continuous effort.

By virtue of the constitutional role of the President of Romania to oversee the proper functioning of public authorities, I did not hesitate throughout my term to act whenever attempts were made to destabilize the justice system.

I used all constitutional means to remove the controversial provisions of the justice laws, including appealing to the expertise of the Venice Commission, I halted the entry into force of harmful and unfounded amendments to criminal legislation, and I opposed the jeopardizing of the proper functioning of the prosecutor's offices, from the perspective of the appointments and dismissals of prosecutors in high positions within these institutions.

I organized a broad debate on the situation in justice, with the participation of representatives of the judiciary and professional associations of judges and prosecutors.

In order to implement the recommendations of European institutions, I organized consultations with political parties and initiated the Agreement for the continuation of Romania's European path. At the same time, addressing each new generation of magistrates directly with the message that they are joining a professional body with a mission laden with great responsibility, which also involves a corresponding conscience and morality, I reiterated year after year my confidence in the justice system and my support for the entire body of magistrates.

In my relationship with the CSM, I assumed a partnership in strengthening European values and acted as a firm supporter of an independent judiciary and the continuation of the fight against corruption. Even though the assault on justice has been temporarily halted, the harm done must be repaired as soon as possible. This process evidently requires the real involvement of the CSM.

In 2015, at my first participation as President of Romania in a meeting of the Superior Council of Magistracy - which at that time had a different composition - I emphasized that institutions should not be personalized and identified with the image of the leader at any given moment, because institutions do not belong to leaders, and only in this way can we protect ourselves from deviations and manipulations, from dangerous and undemocratic situations.

And today I firmly believe in what I stated then. Internal tensions, egos, or personal interests must always be placed in the background when we are called to contribute to the democratic evolution of the Romanian state.

The tools available to the Superior Council of Magistracy become effective only when, behind the decisions and positions of the guarantor of the independence of justice, there is broad consensus and real, not merely declarative, support for the guiding principles.

Without an internalization of the values of the Constitution, democracy and the development of our state will always be hindered. Societies make determined steps towards progress only when there is trust and cohesion around a vision that places the citizen at the center of its concerns.

In a collegial body, such as the CSM, differences of opinion on the topics under discussion, diametrically opposed positions, and sometimes even singular, separate opinions regarding the resolution of various issues may seem natural.

However, Romanian society, in general, and the judiciary, in particular, expect from those called to guarantee the independence of justice a mature, wise approach, carried out in good faith and free from partisanship. In this regard, maintaining the independence and professional conscience of magistrates, as well as of CSM members, is essential.

The Superior Council of Magistracy has a fundamental role in the proper functioning of the judiciary and, implicitly, in maintaining a balance within it. For this goal to be achieved, a balance is also necessary within the Superior Council of Magistracy.

I believe I do not surprise anyone when I say that, in the past year, both in public perception and within the professional body, some of the decisions made by the CSM, in plenary or in sections, have seemed contradictory, while others have been strongly contested even by CSM members.

The activity of the Council often has an important technical component. The way the Council operates has sometimes raised concerns, from the way points of view are expressed, to organizational dysfunctions in meetings, and up to the lack of predictability in their scheduling, with direct consequences on the quality of debates and the fairness of the adopted solutions.

From this perspective, working mechanisms are necessary to ensure a coherent and responsible approach, including in public communication. A tense relationship within the CSM or with magistrates or other public authorities primarily harms the judiciary.

A good functioning of the Superior Council of Magistracy, both at the Plenary level and especially at the sections, involves predictability in decision-making, mutual respect, and the mitigation of any divergences.

Only in this way can the positions of the Superior Council of Magistracy and the efforts to ensure the independence of justice enjoy greater credibility in relation to other authorities, among magistrates, and at the same time, in the eyes of citizens.

We are part of the great European family. Romanian society has evolved in the spirit of the values on which the European Union is based, aligning itself with the highest standards of democratic states.

As European citizens, Romanians are increasingly active in realizing their rights, and justice, and implicitly the CSM, must keep pace with this reality.

Justice is a public service, at the service of citizens. Independent justice is the fundamental guarantee for maintaining social balance.

Citizens' trust in the act of justice is strengthened when those called to carry it out conduct their activities independently, respecting the principles of integrity and transparency. Through the manner in which justice is administered, through the uniform application of the principle that no one is above the law, the sense of justice among citizens is built and strengthened, thus protecting the most precious gain of democracy – the guarantee of fundamental rights and freedoms of the individual.

Through authentic dialogue and broad consultation, the CSM has the concrete possibility to pick up signals from the judiciary and convey them to other authorities, so that public policies in justice can address the persistent issues in this field: the workload of courts and prosecutor's offices, the absence of logistical equipment, and the lack of investment in infrastructure.

I trust that, as the guarantor of the independence of justice, the Superior Council of Magistracy will find ways to connect with society and will act with the realization of a modern and quality justice at the center of its concerns.

In this regard, I call on you to effectively support the implementation of the recommendations of the Venice Commission, the MCV, and GRECO, in order to align current legislation with European standards.

I would like to clarify here, as I have seen interpretations given to my statements regarding the nature of these recommendations and opinions.

I want it to be very clear what I meant to say.

The recommendations of European institutions are not optional, but they cannot be applied as such as long as they are not transposed into domestic legislation.

In the spirit of the provisions of Article 148 of the Constitution - alongside Parliament, the Government, and the President of Romania - the Superior Council of Magistracy also has the mission to participate in the process of transposing all these opinions and recommendations into domestic legislation.

This is one of the most important ways in which the judiciary can contribute to strengthening Romania's European path.

We are 30 years since the fall of the communist regime, and in these three decades, justice in Romania has made immense progress, not only at the legislative and institutional level but also at a profound societal level.

The broad participation in the referendum and its result show that whenever there is an attempt to deviate from democratic values, Romanians react, forcing decision-makers to reconnect with the aspirations of society.

Without unity around fundamental values, our democracy risks becoming fragile.

Therefore, it is our duty, as constitutional authorities, to respond to this mission and to rise to the height of these expectations.

I wish you much success and thank you!