Pronouncement by President Lula during the opening of the 5th National Conference on Science, Technology, and Innovation.

Brazil Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva · President of Brazil

2 September 2024 · 5th National Conference on Science, Technology, and Innovation

Context
Lula addressed the 5th National Conference on Science, Technology, and Innovation in Brazil on September 2, 2024, unveiling a national artificial intelligence policy proposal.
Main themes
Brazilian artificial intelligence policy, national science and technology conference, sovereign AI development, Big Tech regulation and taxation, government listening and learning, role of Brazilian scientists, media engagement with science, intellectual potential of Brazil, public investment in innovation
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,756
72nd percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
70
98th percentile
Grade
7.4
3rd percentile
Syntax
2.70
13th percentile
Vocabulary
1.75
0th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 33%28%
  • Ceremonial 25%22%
  • Institutional 21%17%
  • Economic 9%8%
  • Technological 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 15%

172 sentences in 49 paragraphs

I, as usual, had a written speech.

But, as is also customary, I am always the last speaker, and I find myself following people who are saying what is written in my speech. So it makes no sense for you to wait so long for me to say the same thing that others have already said. I want to apologize to all the colleagues here present, to the ministers, to the scientists, to the entrepreneurs, to our researchers, that I will not read the list of names.

The list is very long. I did not realize, I did not know that at the launch of an artificial intelligence proposal that you are making for the government, the platform had almost the same number of people as there are in the plenary. Honestly, you did a great job, Luciana [Santos, Minister of Science, Technology and Innovations].

You or someone. Look, but what I wanted to say to you is short and quick. The first thing we must be aware of is that a building manager, a city mayor, a state governor, or a president of the Republic must have as their highest virtue the ability to listen, the ability to learn, the ability to converse with diversity, and the ability to yield.

And, much more importantly, the ability to learn. And I am very happy because today is extremely significant for Brazil. I made a statement on Sunday night.

I took a long time to make that statement. And what I wanted to show in that speech was that Brazil has to take a step forward. We cannot spend our whole lives complaining about what has not been done and not doing what needs to be done.

You cannot spend your whole life saying that there is no money and not doing things. I am the son of a woman who, many times, when it came time to put food on the table, having nothing to put there, she never complained. She would say, “Today there is none, but tomorrow there will be.”

And when I decided to challenge Brazilian scientists at that meeting of the National Council of Science and Technology, it was because I was already tired. In every debate I go to, in every ministerial meeting, in every conversation I have, people talk, you know, artificial intelligence, artificial intelligence, artificial intelligence. And I keep thinking, if this thing is so good, why is it artificial? Why is it artificial if it can be manipulated by human intelligence? Deep down, it is human intelligence that can improve it, because it is nothing more than our ability to collect all the data, and we have the Big Techs that do this without asking for permission, without paying taxes, and still charge money and get rich by disclosing things that should not be disclosed. And I kept thinking: can we, a country of 200 million inhabitants, a country that has already completed, you know, 524 years, a country that has a respected intellectual base, a respected intellectual base in the world, including, that has such a generous people, that lives in such extraordinary diversity, cannot create its own mechanism instead of waiting for artificial intelligence to come from China, come from the United States, come from South Korea, come from Korea I don’t know where, come from Japan, come from... No, why can’t we have our own? And what I think is important is that today, I don’t know if the press is realizing this, but I will tell you one thing.

Today is the first act, after my statement, and nothing could happen better. After my statement, I received as a gift from Brazilian scientists a proposal to be discussed with the government, but accompanied by the Council of Science and Technology, which will follow every step the government takes, because what you presented cannot be left in a drawer. It cannot.

What you delivered to me, next week I will already have a meeting with ministers to present to the group of ministers our artificial intelligence policy proposal that you delivered to us. And from there, we will make decisions to know how we will make this thing happen in fact and in law in this country. And I wanted to say to the press, it was very important that you do not treat today as an insignificant thing, just another act that Lula does, just another speech he makes.

No, here my speech does not matter. What I wanted to challenge the press, written, spoken, televised, is the following: here are the scientists, look at this, this is a potential of intelligence that few people can gather and they are gathered here why? Thinking about Brazil, and that you invite these people for debate, instead of having those newscasts giving opinions about everything, let’s discuss Brazilian artificial intelligence. Let’s discuss, invite the scientists.

If you have difficulty inviting scientists, I will give you a list of scientists. Luciana, you have to prepare a list. Sérgio Rezende [former Minister of Science and Technology], a list of 500 scientists to give to the press. There are no shortage of scientists capable of debating here. Now, please, do not go looking for one who disagrees, who is against.

At least have a debate so that we can show what you were able to produce. And why am I valuing this so much? And what I am saying to the press is true. I hope that this week, every afternoon, evening, and morning, there is a debate about artificial intelligence and invite our scientists, invite our minister to have a debate, so that this country knows what we are discussing.

I have always said that a democracy is not a pact of silence. Democracy is the result of a society in manifestation fighting and demanding things that it still does not have. And this is the beginning of that.

I had the pleasure of having Sérgio Rezende and I am not afraid to say that he was the best Minister of Science and Technology this country has ever had. I am not. And I have, Luciana, when you came to the government, I just want you to follow in Sérgio Rezende’s footsteps.

Because, you see, we managed to spend between 2007, 2011, 2010, 41 billion reais that we put into the PAC by ministry. And this money was used entirely and who coordinated the execution of this money was not the comrade Sérgio Rezende, it was a council that was set up within the SBPC. The scientists helped us manage and use this money.

That’s how it should be done. That’s how it needs to be done. Because when we detect that there are no resources, we have to go after the resources.

I cannot say: there is no money, and then stay quiet. There is no money, there is no money. If there is no money, it is up to me to try to find money, to try to find money, to try to rummage through the budget so that we can allocate money to do the things that are considered essential. I am very alarmed, my comrades and fellow scientists, when I see articles in the newspapers saying that artificial intelligence could cause 16 million unemployed.

For that, I do not want. What is this thing that is so important and will cause problems for society? Our artificial intelligence has to be intelligent. And we want to make it a source of generating jobs in this country, that we train millions and millions of young people prepared for this debate.

I was telling my comrade Camilo Santana [Minister of Education], we announced the construction of 100 new federal institutes. Now, we are discussing what courses these comrades will have, and these girls? Will they learn the same old things? Or will we have to do new things for these people to be our artificial intelligence? That is what we will have to decide from now on. And what chance am I giving you?

See, the chance I am giving you. There was no humility here. What am I saying? It is because you will not have another government that has the capacity to listen.

And do you know why I learned to listen? Because I do not know things. And since I do not know things, I want to learn. If you had a doctor in my place, he would not listen to you.

This country has never had a president of the Republic who held meetings with rectors. Never. Not even when the Minister of Education had been a rector.

I keep wondering if a president of the Republic does not have the courage to talk to rectors, and I do not expect them to ask for an audience, no. I am the one who invites them, all of them, from the institutes, from the universities, to discuss. Come on, tell me what you want, I will say what I can, and let’s say what we have to do.

Well, because we who are in office are passengers. But the country is not a passenger. Society is not a passenger.

So, everything we do, and that is why I like to involve councils, is because it is not something of Luciana. If tomorrow I have to remove Luciana from the ministry, or she wants to leave, you know, whoever comes in knows that there is a policy that was not elaborated by her, it was elaborated by the scientists, and that we have to follow.

If you do not want to, do not enter. That is how things work in this country for us to be able to succeed. I think we are living a very important moment in Brazil.

I want to tell you the following, I have said this publicly and I will repeat it. What you did today by delivering a document to me about an artificial intelligence conceived by Brazilian universities, conceived by Brazilian scientists, is a milestone in this country. Pay attention.

Today is a landmark day for Brazilian society. Brazil needs to learn to fly. Brazil needs to learn to fly.

I have five swallows living inside the Palácio da Alvorada. There are some swallows that every mating season they go inside the Alvorada and stay there in the corner, we are having coffee, they are flying over us. It’s funny because they have a chick and they spend a long time trying to teach the chick to fly, encouraging the chick until the little thing flies away.

Brazil needs to learn to fly. Brazil cannot depend its whole life. We are great, we have intelligence.

What we need is to have the audacity to make things happen. And when I say... And when I say that I am the opportunity you have to make things happen in this country. And I will say this, you know why? Because I have said, I am not me, I am you.

It is you who reached the presidency of the Republic. It is you who have to help govern this country. It is you who need to say what needs to be done.

So it is this country that we will have to build. I have a little over two years left in my term. And I can tell you one thing: I will be tireless so that we can execute the things we are doing.

Once I tried to set up an intelligence committee in this country. After those attacks in the United States, the towers, I was president here, after I won the presidency, I decided to create an intelligence room. I tried to involve the Brazilian Army, my minister of the Cabinet was General [Jorge] Felix, I tried to involve General Felix as coordinator, I tried to bring in Abin, I tried to bring in the Federal Police, the Navy, and the Air Force. And it did not work, because they did not communicate with each other. Intelligence is power. So people do not want to tell each other what they know.

It’s the same in government. The government possibly has the most important database this country has ever had, we have.

Now the database in government is personal. We have the SUS database, we have the CADÚNICO database, we have the Social Security database, we have the Ministry of Labor database, we have the tax database... Wait a minute. And the database of Brazil, are we not going to have it? Our artificial intelligence starts there.

We need to create a structure so that all the data of this country are compiled and available to Brazilian society. There should be no secrets. We need to have the courage to put out our desire to grow, our desire to be different, our desire to be bolder, our desire to ask for permission out of politeness and not out of fear. This is the challenge that is placed before me.

So I wanted to say to you the following, I am 78 years old and I tell my companions every single day, I am living my best moment in my passage through planet Earth. I am living my best moment. I am a person today who has a lot of awareness of things, I know what I want, I know where I want to go, and I know what is possible to achieve in this country.

That is why we made a very great effort to do what has been done in just 18 months. In 18 months, I have already met more as president of the Republic than before in my eight years. And the sum of what I did in eight months is more than all the presidents, from Marshal Deodoro until now.

Well, because if you want to be great, you need to connect with people, you need to listen, you need to talk, discuss projects. Is this country going to remain eternally a developing country? A poor country, a country that has literacy, a country that does not have... That is over. That is over, comrade Minister Camilo Santana.

When this country, called Brazil, was making its first university in 1920... It is a shame. It is a shame for all of us. The first university was born in 1920.

In 1918, Argentina was already making its first university reform. In 1554, Peru already had its university. And we took so long.

And now I am eager to do more. And from time to time people ask: “Lula, why are you obsessed with education? You want to create universities for everything.” It is because I did not have the opportunity. I did not have the opportunity, and I want all Brazilians to have the opportunity, regardless of their social background, regardless of where they were born, regardless of their color.

I do not want to know if they are evangelical or Catholic; I want to say that they must have the opportunity. That is what we must have. And that is the country I want to leave as a legacy.

Therefore, dear companions and fellow scientists, who presented me with this proposal, prepare yourselves to be held accountable, because I am ready to hold you accountable. Do not think that your work ended when you delivered it to me. On the contrary, your work truly began now with this delivery you made to me, because from now on my obligation is to make this happen.

To happen in Brazil. To make us a model, so that people abroad, even a little Chinese kid can say: “Look, Brazil has artificial intelligence.” The guy from South Korea: “Hey, Brazil has it.” The United States, from Silicon Valley: “Brazil did it.”

This pride, it is this pride that we must carry within us. You know? The pride of someone who is not superior, but is not inferior. Of someone who wants to be just equal, who wants to have the pleasure of doing things.

This is the President of the Republic who was elected in this country in 2023, and it is this President of the Republic who wants to leave as a legacy a society with a capital S, a Brazil of knowledge with a capital C, a Brazil of men and women with a capital H and M, a Brazil of proud people who are thirsty for wanting more and always more. A hug and good luck to Brazilian scientists and good luck to our government.