On the Question of Socialist Commodity Production

China Mao Zedong · Chairman of the Communist Party of China

9 November 1958 · Second Zhengzhou Conference

Context
Mao delivered remarks in November 1958, dated 9 November in the source, urging cadres to develop socialist commodity production, use the law of value and avoid rushing into communism, drawing on Stalin's writings.
Main themes
Socialist commodity production, law of value as an instrument of economic accounting, people's communes and ownership by the whole people, peasant question and the five hundred million peasants, gradual transition to communism, false reporting of grain output, Stalin's Economic Problems of Socialism in the USSR, Engels on commodity production, expansion of allocation and commodity exchange, premature abolition of commerce, Great Leap Forward excesses
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,876
74th percentile
Sentences
153
81st percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from Chinese Source: GitHub qinglee/maoxuan (毛泽东选集) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 64%60%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Institutional 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

153 sentences in 18 paragraphs

I

Many people avoid talking about the question of commodities and commerce, as though doing otherwise would not be communism. The people's communes must produce socialist commodities suitable for exchange, so as to raise each person's wages step by step. In the sphere of means of subsistence, socialist commerce must be developed; and the form of the law of value must be used, during the transition period, as an instrument of economic accounting, so as to facilitate the gradual transition to communism. Nowadays our economists do not like economics, and the same is true in the Soviet Union; they think that whoever mentions the law of value is somehow disgraced, as shown in a letter written by Yaroshenko. These people do not approve of commodity production; they think the Soviet Union is already communist, when in fact it is still very far from it. We have been building socialism for only a few years, so we are even further away.

Lenin vigorously advocated the development of commerce, because at that time in the Soviet Union there was a danger that the circulation of commodities between town and countryside would be cut off. We also faced such a danger in 1950. Now transport conditions are poor, and a state of semi-interruption has appeared. In my view we must develop in two directions: one is to expand allocation, the other is to expand commodity production. Unless we do so, we cannot pay wages and cannot raise living standards.

We advocate seeking truth from facts. Do not make false reports; do not report other people's pigs as your own; do not report three hundred jin of wheat as four hundred jin. This year's nine hundred billion jin of grain is at most seven hundred and forty billion jin; it would be more prudent to count seven hundred and forty billion jin as the real figure and treat the remaining one hundred and sixty billion jin as false reporting. The people cannot be fooled. In the past, with war bulletins, false reports of military successes could only deceive the people; they could not deceive the enemy, and the enemy laughed when they read them. Where there is truth there is bound to be falsehood, and when truth and falsehood are mixed one cannot sort them out. Yanshi county originally intended to conceal its output, reporting less than it had; others reported more than they had. The People's Daily had better be a bit calmer. The question of working methods must be treated as the key point: Party leadership, the mass line, seeking truth from facts.

Stalin's book Economic Problems of Socialism in the USSR must be read again. Cadres at the level of members of provincial Party standing committees and prefectural Party standing committees and above should study it; all should study the first, second and third chapters of this book. In the past, when we read it, we were not interested; now it is different. These three chapters contain many things worthy of attention; there are also some things that are not well written, and some more that he himself had not figured out.

Chapters two and three deal with commodities and the law of value. What are your views? I fairly much agree with many of the viewpoints in them; it is very necessary to explain these questions clearly. Stalin holds that in the Soviet Union the means of production are not commodities. In our country it is different: the means of production are both commodities and not commodities; part of the means of production are commodities, since we sell agricultural machinery to the cooperatives.

Entering communism must proceed by steps. We are expanding in two directions: on one side developing self-sufficient production, on the other developing commodity production. Now we must use commodity production, commodity exchange and the law of value as useful tools to serve socialism. On this, Stalin gave many reasons. Does commodity production have negative aspects? If it does, then restrict them!

Our country is one where commodity production is very undeveloped, even more backward than India and Brazil. India's railways and textiles are more developed than China's. Last year we produced three hundred and seventy billion jin of grain, of which thirty billion jin went as the public grain tax and fifty billion jin were sold to the state as commodities; taken together, commodity grain did not reach even a quarter of total grain output. Economic crops other than grain are also very undeveloped; for example, tea, silk, hemp and tobacco have not recovered to their historical peak output. There has to be a stage of developing commodity production; otherwise the communes cannot pay wages. Hebei province, for example, has three kinds of counties: one kind has only enough to eat, one kind needs relief, and one kind can pay a bit of wages beyond feeding itself. Paying wages in turn falls into several situations; some can pay only a few jiao. Therefore, besides producing grain, every commune must also develop things that can be sold for money, and develop socialist commodity production and commodity exchange. It must be affirmed that socialist commodity production and commodity exchange still play a positive role. The products that are allocated are only a part; most products go through commodity exchange by buying and selling.

There is now a deviation, as though the faster communism comes, the better. Realizing communism must proceed by steps. Fan county in Shandong has proposed realizing communism in two years; someone should be sent to investigate. Now some people keep wanting to achieve communism in three to five years.

II

The Great Leap Forward has left some people utterly muddled, and there is poetry everywhere. Some say "poetry has no definitive interpretation"; this is not right. Poetry does have a definitive interpretation: "definitive" means thoroughly understood, and "interpretation" means precise and certain.

I could not sleep, and wanted to say a few things. I am trying to bring in Stalin to continue persuading some comrades. I consider myself correct; if the comrades on the opposite side are correct, then I will submit.

It is still the peasant question. Some comrades have suddenly come to regard the peasants very highly, thinking that the peasants come first and the workers second; the peasants are even higher than the working class, they are the elder brother. In some respects the countryside has gone ahead; this is the appearance, not the essence. Some think that China's proletariat is in the countryside, as though the peasants were proletarians and the workers petty bourgeois. Is this way of seeing things Marxist? Some comrades are Marxists when they read Marxist textbooks, but as soon as they run into practical problems, they discount it. This trend involves several hundred thousand, even several million people. As for the masses, some of them are also in a daze. So, cautiously and carefully, they avoid using capitalist categories that still have positive significance—commodity production, commodity circulation, the law of value and so on—to serve socialism. The way Article 36 is written is the evidence: wording that is as vague as possible is used to slip through, so as to make it appear that the peasants have entered communism. This is an attitude toward Marxism that is not thoroughgoing and not serious. This is a matter concerning several hundred million peasants. Stalin said that the peasants cannot be expropriated. In our people's communes, not only the seeds but also the fertilizer and the products are owned by the peasants. If the state does not give them things and does not carry out exchange of equal value, they will not give you their products either. Is it better to treat this question rashly or carefully? The Party secretary of Xiuwu county did not dare to declare the commune to be under ownership by the whole people. His first reason was fear that if there were a disaster and agricultural output fell, wages could not be paid, and the state could not take full responsibility and could not give subsidies; his second reason was fear that if there were a bumper harvest, the state would transfer the grain away. This comrade thinks things through; he is not reckless. We did not declare the land nationalized; we declared that the land, seeds, livestock, and large and small farm tools are owned by the commune. During this period, only through commodity production and commodity exchange can the peasants be guided to develop production and enter ownership by the whole people.

Now some of our people show a strong tendency to want to abolish commodity production. They yearn for communism, and as soon as commodity production is mentioned they become anxious, feeling that this is a capitalist thing. They have not distinguished between socialist commodity production and capitalist commodity production, and do not understand the importance of using the role of commodity production under socialist conditions. This is a manifestation of not recognizing objective laws; it is a failure to understand the question of the five hundred million peasants. In the socialist period, commodity production should be used to unite several hundred million peasants. I think that after the people's communes have come into being, commodity production and commodity exchange must develop even more; socialist commodity production must be greatly developed in a planned way, for example livestock products, soybeans, jute, sausage casings, fruit trees, hides and furs. Now some people are inclined to do away with commerce; at least several hundred thousand people want to do away with commerce. This view is wrong; it goes against objective laws. If we take Shaanxi's walnuts and eat them without paying a single cent, would the peasants of Shaanxi agree? If we transfer the cotton of Qiliying without compensation, heads would be broken right away. This is failing to understand the five hundred million peasants, failing to understand what attitude the proletariat should take toward the peasants. Engels once said, "Once society has taken possession of the means of production, commodity production will be eliminated, and with it the domination of the product over the producer." In the old society, products had a controlling effect on people. Stalin's analysis of this formula of Engels is correct. Stalin said: "What Engels had in mind in his formula was not the nationalization of part of the means of production, but the nationalization of all the means of production, that is, the conversion into the property of the whole people not only of the means of production in industry but also of the means of production in agriculture." "Engels held that in such countries, together with the socialization of all the means of production, commodity production should also be eliminated." At present our ownership by the whole people is only a small part; it holds only a small part of the means of production and of the social product. Only when all the means of production have been taken over can commerce be abolished. Our economists do not seem to have understood this.

Stalin said that there is a kind of "pitiful Marxist" who holds that the small and middle producers in the countryside should be expropriated. We also have such people in our country. Some comrades are in a hurry to declare the people's communes to be owned by the whole people, to abolish commerce and to carry out allocation of products; this is expropriating the peasants, and it would only make Taiwan happy. We made a bit of a mistake in 1954: we procured too much grain, and the entire peasantry opposed us; everyone talked about grain, every household discussed unified purchasing. This too was "pitiful Marxists," because we did not know how much grain the peasants really had in hand. That was still procurement, only going a bit too far, and the peasants opposed it. We have had this experience and made this mistake; afterward we reduced it, deciding to procure only eighty-three billion jin. Now the peasants' labor, like the land and the other means of production (seeds, tools, water conservancy works, forests, fertilizer and so on), is their own property, and therefore they have ownership of the products. For some reason, our philosophers and economists have evidently forgotten these questions. If we forget this point, we are in danger of becoming divorced from the peasants.

Commodity production must not be lumped together with capitalism. Why fear commodity production? It is nothing but fear of capitalism. Now it is the state doing business with the people's communes; capitalism was eliminated long ago, so what is there to fear in commodity production? Do not be afraid; in my view we should greatly develop commodity production. Are there still capitalists exploiting workers in our country? No, there are none, so why still be afraid? Commodity production cannot be viewed in isolation. Stalin's words are entirely correct; he said: "Commodity production must on no account be regarded as something sufficient unto itself, something independent of the surrounding economic conditions." With commodity production, one must look at what economic system it is linked to: linked to the capitalist system, it is capitalist commodity production; linked to the socialist system, it is socialist commodity production. Commodity production has existed since ancient times; the character "shang" in the name of the Shang dynasty signifies that commodity production already existed at that time. It is completely wrong to regard King Zhou, Qin Shihuang and Cao Cao as bad men. King Zhou was a very capable man, accomplished in both letters and arms. King Zhou attacked the Yi of Xuzhou and won the battle, but his losses were too great and he took too many prisoners to absorb, and so his state perished. The talk that "the blood flowed so that it floated the pestles," that King Zhou was extremely cruel, is an exaggeration in the Book of Documents. That is why Mencius said: "If one believes everything in the Book of Documents, it would be better to have no Book of Documents at all." In the slave era, commodity production did not lead to capitalism. Stalin said that commodity production "served feudal society, but although it prepared some of the conditions for capitalist production, it did not lead to capitalism." This statement of Stalin's is not very accurate; it should be said that the capitalist mode of production was already gestating in the womb of feudal society.

At the Second Plenary Session of the Seventh Central Committee in 1949, my report already spoke of the question of restricting the capitalist sector of the economy; the capitalist sector was not to be allowed to run rampant without limits. Starting in 1950, we allowed the capitalist sector of the economy to develop for six years, but at the same time we were already carrying out processing on order, unified purchase and guaranteed sales, and joint state-private ownership, carrying out the socialist transformation of the capitalist sector. By 1956 they had in fact come over empty-handed; the "certain decisive economic conditions" Stalin spoke of, we already had completely. Stalin said: "Why then, one asks, cannot commodity production similarly serve our socialist society for a certain period without leading to capitalism?" This sentence is very important. We have already eaten the ghost, so why still fear the ghost? Do not be afraid; it will not lead to capitalism, because the economic base of capitalism no longer exists. Commodity production can obediently serve socialism and guide the five hundred million peasants to ownership by the whole people. Is commodity production a useful tool? It should be stated affirmatively: yes. For the sake of the five hundred million peasants, this tool should be fully used to develop socialist production. This question must be put to the cadres for discussion.

The labor, the land and the other means of production all belong to the peasants, are under the collective ownership of the people's communes, and therefore the products also belong to the communes. They are only willing to exchange the products they produce for the commodities they need; they will not accept any method other than commodity exchange for taking away the commune's products. We must not think that Chinese peasants are especially advanced. The thinking of the Xiuwu county Party secretary is entirely correct. The necessity of commodity circulation is something communists must consider. Only after products have been fully developed can commodity circulation tend to disappear. Comrades, our state has been founded for only nine years and we are already in a hurry to do away with commodities; this is unrealistic. Only when the state has the power to dispose of all products can the commodity economy become unnecessary and disappear. As long as two forms of ownership exist, commodity production and commodity exchange are extremely necessary and extremely useful. Henan has proposed making the transition to communism in four years; that is "too much" Marxism. Do not be in a hurry to accomplish it in four years. Do not think that four years from now the peasants of Henan will be the same as the workers of Zhengzhou; that is impossible. We spent twenty-two years waging revolutionary war, and waited patiently for the victory of the democratic revolution. How can we build socialism without patience? Without patience it will not work.