Speech by the President of the Government at the plenary session of the Lower House of Parliament to report on the Conclusions of the European Council of 14 and 15 March
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed the Spanish Lower House plenary session in April 2013 to report on the March 2013 European Council meeting and the Cyprus banking crisis.
- Main themes
- Cyprus financial crisis, European banking union, Eurogroup response, deposit protection, banking sector reform, EU coordination and transparency, Eurozone stability, Spanish interests, European Council March 2013 conclusions
- Duration
- ~34 min
- Words
- 4,076
- Sentences
- 153
- Readability
- 44
- Grade
- 13.5
- Syntax
- 3.12
- Vocabulary
- 2.18
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other153 sentences in 61 paragraphs
I am appearing before the plenary session of this house to inform you of what happened at the European Council meeting held in Brussels on 14 and 15 March.
Immediately following these dates, the "Cyprus crisis" came to the foreground of our attention. This issue was not dealt with by the Council, but I do not want to stick rigidly to conditions of the formal request to attend this plenary session today, which is for a report on the European Council meeting, and avoid a question of undoubted interest to all. So in fact, let me begin with it.
The first thing I would like to say is that if we already had a real banking union in operation, the case of Cyprus would not have occurred, and it would not have occurred because the Cypriot financial sector would have been supervised externally and the Resolution Mechanism would be predictable and uniform with the rest of the countries in the European Union. I shall go further into this question later.
To put the problem into context, honourable members, you should remember that Cyprus, a country with a population of 860,000 and an income per capita of 20,800 euros, had at the time of the outbreak of the crisis a banking system that amounted to eight times its gross domestic product, which last year was 17.8 billion euros. The normal situation would be for the ratio of financial sector to GDP to be between two and three, not eight as in this case.
Cyprus had a plainly hypertrophied banking system, based on attracting funds from abroad, which had converted it into an important "offshore" enclave, as shown by the fact that deposits held by non-residents are clearly greater than those of residents on the island. This in turn involved significant investment abroad by the banks themselves. For example, as a result of the haircut on the Greek debt, the Cypriot banks suffered losses equivalent to 25% of their gross domestic product.
This, combined with fairly unorthodox operations by the two main banks on the island, led to a crisis in the financial system, and to Cyprus losing access to international financial markets. As a result, it was unable to finance its debt. This obliged it to request financial assistance in June from the Member States of the Monetary Union. On 16 March the Eurogroup response was issued to the Cypriot request in the form of financial assistance of 17 billion euros. To give you an idea, honourable members, this would be something like Spain requesting more than 1,000 billion euros for the restructuring of its financial system.
The Eurogroup proposal, which consisted of 10 billion euros in foreign assistance and 7 billion euros in internal adjustments, was rejected by the Cyprus parliament, leading to turmoil on the markets that affected us all. The solution finally adopted after initial indecision at the extraordinary meeting on 25 March between the Eurogroup and the Cyprus government appears acceptable to me: acceptable for the interests of Cyprus, for the whole of the Monetary Union and - why not say it - for the specific interests of Spain. This is for three reasons:
- First, because the losses are concentrated in the biggest investors; in other words the deposits most closely linked to speculative business. The small saver does not have to bear losses, in line with what is expected in the European Union.
- Second, because the agreement ensures that Cyprus is viable within the single currency. However, the country will have to undertake a radical change in its economic model.
- Third, because the solution takes into account that the problem in the Cypriot banking sector is a case that is different from that of any other country in the European Union. That is why the agreed solution is extraordinary and unique, and is therefore applied in exceptional circumstances in Cyprus. This point is very important, and it was initially received as such by the markets.
But I also have to say that to maintain confidence, it is important not only to take the right decisions, but also to maintain a high level of coordination, efficiency and transparency between all the affected parties. On this point I believe that the European Union and the Eurozone have to improve and we have to learn from this experience. For example, we have to be prudent when it comes to making declarations, act with precision and with restraint, and stick to the agreements reached. This is precisely the contrary of the unfortunate statements of the President of the Eurogroup, as I pointed out after my meeting with the President of the French Republic, Mr Hollande. As a result they generated doubts and fed uncertainty and provoked volatility with respect to the single currency. I hardly need to say that this harmed all of us.
Spain, as represented in the Eurogroup, made it clear from the start that deposits under 100,000 euros had to be protected. Although this figure is guaranteed individually by each Member State, for the Monetary Union it represents a minimum that, for reasons of security and credibility, must not be questioned.
In the end, 10 billion euros of financial assistance were granted to the Cypriot state, equivalent to 60% of its gross domestic product. This finance should be sufficient to act as a firewall and help provide security and credibility to the single currency. The case of Cyprus could not endanger the progress that has been made over the last year to guarantee the irreversibility of the euro.
At the same time, as in the cases of Portugal, Greece and Ireland, a condition has been established in the full economic programme that includes, among other measures, the restructuring of its financial system.
Honourable members,
An insufficient agreement in terms of amount would have had devastating effects on Cyprus, consisting in practice of its exit from the euro, with unpredictable consequences for the rest of the zone. An agreement that was too generous would have meant rewarding bad banking practices and bad supervisory management. To put it another way, the result could not consist in granting non-refundable finance to maintain a financial business that is excessively large and risky; a business that consisted of paying high returns to depositors - between 7% and 12% - through high-risk investments that were not viable. The bailout had to be coherent with this idea.
In short, honourable members, the Cyprus crisis appears on the right course, but it leaves us a clear message: the need to undertake banking union with greater speed. I said it before and I will say it again now: with a banking union in operation, today we would not be talking about a financial crisis in Cyprus.
Ladies and gentlemen of the house,
I will now turn to what happened at the European Council meeting of 14 and 15 March.
As you know, there are Council meetings of Heads of State and Government that we could call "decisive". A good example of these would be the Council held on 8 and 9 February, where the Community Budget for 2014-2020 was debated and approved. Others, in contrast, are what we could call "deliberative" or "reflective": they serve to define guidelines that later will become recommendations and concrete decisions. The last Council meeting falls into this category.
So what could we expect from this Council meeting? An extensive, intense debate, but without the "drama" of those others held against the clock and with long night sessions. To make it clear, on the agenda submitted by President Van Rompuy there were none of the most contradictory points or those that lead to the most heated debates. In short, the "Spring Council meeting" was a prelude to the ordinary Council meeting next June.
It began with a situation report from the President of the Commission on the state of the European Union; an analysis that would help the participants follow the debates and serve as a basis for joint reflection. As you can imagine, honourable members, it was a report full of figures and tables, from which I would like to highlight some aspects referring to Spain. For example, the clear improvement in the trend of our current-account balance of payments, or the also clear improvement in the competitiveness of our economy, both with respect to our main trading partners and with respect to our partners in the euro. But we should not forget that the report also points to the different levels of unemployment in European Union countries. Recalling it helps us strengthen our determination to achieve the primary and main objective of this legislature: a return to the path of job creation.
And without economic growth, job creation is not possible. The most worrying thing about the scenario presented to us by the President of the Commission, Mr Durao Barroso, was the realisation of the very limited economic growth rate of the European Union, and within it, the recession in the Eurozone. In fact, the Eurozone is the only economic area that will be in recession this year: the United States will grow by 1.9% this year and 2.6% in 2014; Japan by 1% and 1.6%; the rest of Asia, above 6.5% in both years, with China and India as outstanding performers; Latin America, around 4%; Australia, around 3%; and Canada, 2%.
Honourable members,
We should try to prevent Europe from being left behind. It is necessary, and with increasing urgency, to reverse the situation of stagnation experienced by Europe and we have to do everything possible for this, with the instruments we have available. This is the "force-idea", the main message I try to transmit, again and again, with insistence, to my European colleagues.
The bases of action have been designed, debated and approved; but we have to step up the pace of their execution and redouble the intensity of their development. Honourable members, I will give you an example. If you read with any degree of attention the fourteen Conclusions approved at this Council meeting and compare them with any of those from the Council meetings a year and a half ago, you will immediately note a change in content and language. When today the talk is of how - and I quote - "the unacceptably high levels of unemployment emphasise how crucial it is to accelerate efforts to support growth as a matter of priority, while pursuing fiscal consolidation," we note a very different language and priority to that which was common at the start of last year.
In fact, the European Council meeting of March 2012 was the first that combined the need for budget adjustments with the adoption of measures favouring growth. This is the underlying idea in the letter that on 20 February 2012 a number of heads of government, among them myself, sent to the President of the European Council, Mr Van Rompuy, and the President of the Commission, Mr Durao Barroso, proposing a plan for growth in Europe. The letter included eight proposals aimed at modernising the European economy, with the aim of gaining competitiveness and correcting economic imbalances.
But if you look back over the Conclusions of this Council meeting you will notice another thing. In some points they repeat, almost literally, the conclusions that have appeared in previous Council meetings. Some of us have fought for this to be so. We have wanted to highlight, to make clear, that these aspects continue current and that they have still not been achieved.
Honourable members,
I will not be telling you anything new if I say that feelings about some issues are very different in some countries than in others. All the Heads of State and Government subscribe to the need to establish policies for boosting employment among young people; but it appears reasonable that if Spain has a level of youth unemployment of over 50%, it should put more emphasis on this aspect than other countries with much lower levels. That is why it is worth stressing and insisting on this point so that it remains in the memory as a task that remains outstanding.
Because I do not need to remind you that in some fields of action - banking union or fiscal union, for example - any modification requires unanimous agreement. Any country, whatever its size, its economic power or its population, may slow down, or even veto certain changes in pace or content. We have to negotiate to the point of exhaustion for the principle of cohesion to be present always.
Honourable members,
The Government of Spain has based its vision for resolving the crisis in Europe on two "force-ideas": responsibility and cohesion. The members of the Eurozone should prove that we are credible partners that comply with our commitments, that we have identified the unavoidable measures which have to be adopted and that we are going to carry them out with determination. In exchange, the Member States who have embarked on a dynamic of far-reaching structural reforms and adjustments hope to have the support of the rest of the partners and institutions, so that the effort and sacrifices that we are undertaking are not at the cost of cohesion, which is a fundamental value of the Union.
That is how it should occur now, as it occurred, for example, in the great adventure of expansion to the democracies in the south, centre and east of Europe. At that time the Union made a generous effort of cohesion, which benefited the new partners, and boosted their convergence; but it also favoured the founding partners thanks to the opening up of new increasingly prosperous markets with greater demand for their goods and services.
Honourable members,
On a number of occasions I have insisted before the House on five points that form the foundation of our Government in the European Union: the first of them, fiscal consolidation, through the reduction of the public-sector deficit: an economy with permanent imbalances in this area cannot make progress; second, a process of structural reforms in the different Member States to achieve a sufficiently flexible economy to gain competitiveness without currency devaluation; the third is the continuous process of reforms in the Union, leading to a greater European economic integration in fields such as energy, transport, retail banking, services, etc. and avoiding the asymmetries that lead to a two-speed Europe; the fourth, the elimination of the financial segmentation in Europe and the appropriate provision of liquidity, particularly to our SMEs; and the fifth, the achievement of an authentic Economic and Monetary Union based on banking union and fiscal union, providing a solution to the problems of segmentation that persist in the European Union today.
These ideas took root in the debates and Conclusions of the transcendental Council of Europe meeting on 28 and 29 June last year. The leaders of the institutions and of the Member States managed to reverse the dynamics of the situation through the adoption of decisions aimed at stabilizing financial markets, breaking the vicious circle between sovereign debt and the debt of the banking sector and allowing the direct recapitalization of the banks. In addition, the so-called Pact for Growth and Employment was agreed; and finally, a mandate was granted to the President of the European Council to prepare a specific roadmap and a binding timetable that would lead us to real Economic and Monetary Union. In short, it put into action the idea that the solution to the crisis and the future of the European Union was more integration.
Honourable members,
Spain is complying with its commitments, and of the five points I talked about earlier, in the first two - fiscal consolidation and structural reforms - it has made an intense effort that has involved sacrifices for the whole of Spanish society. That was our responsibility and we are complying with it.
The other three points, reforms and policies within the Union, have been reflected in the successive summits since June. Now what we need is to maintain the pace of reforms and to move as soon as possible "from ideas to action". That is why I say I am satisfied only "in part" with the result of the Council in March. I subscribe to all the Conclusions of this Council; I am convinced that each and every one of them is good for the interests of Spain and Europe; but I would like to have seen a faster pace in the work and more intensity in the practical implementation of the plans that were approved.
But that, honourable members, is how the construction of Europe goes. You have to persevere and never give up the fight, because we, who are meeting our commitments, have every right to ask for the practical application of the principle of integration.
I am satisfied - How could I not be? - with the principles that this Council has backed for 2013: pursuing differentiated, growth-friendly fiscal consolidation; restoring normal lending to the economy; promoting growth and competitiveness; tackling unemployment and the social consequences of the crisis; and finally, modernising public administration. They are priorities that have been accepted for the current situation and they coincide, I remind you, with those of 2012; and they also coincide with the areas for action on which the action of the Government of Spain is focusing.
The Council's initial diagnosis that has led it to establish these priorities is clear: the lack of growth in Europe and the unacceptable levels of unemployment speak for themselves of how crucial it is to increase efforts to turn the situation around. So how can I not be in agreement with this analysis and with these Conclusions? After five years of crisis and difficult adjustment measures adopted in some countries, our citizens are demanding results. And they are right. That is why I have proposed within the Council to put more work into the lines set out in June last year. It is good for Europe, and above all good for Spain.
The European Council of next June will have to take important decisions. By then, we will have assumed the commitment to approve the operational framework for direct recapitalization and we have to steer the debate to the Single Resolution Mechanism for financial institutions. Before June we have to reach an agreement on the Banking Resolution Directives and the Deposit Guarantee Scheme, as they are being discussed with the European Parliament. In addition, in relation to Fiscal and Economic Union, the Presidents of the Council and Commission must present, also in June, a concrete programme on the coordination of economic policies, the social dimension of the European Union, the possibility of introducing agreements for promoting competiveness and growth, and financing mechanisms to support structural reforms.
The debate on all these points remains open, and as you can imagine, it is not easy to reach a consensus; but progress is key and it has to be done with a clear goal and a precise roadmap, with defined stages, similar to what was achieved in the Maastricht Treaty.
Honourable members,
These have been the reflections that were on the table at the Council in 14 and 15 March, and these have been the points of view I have defended within it, always based on the concern that our fellow citizens should see clearly that Europe is a guarantee for solving their problems.
Honourable members,
We have to recover the support and participation of the citizens in the European project. The citizens must have the conviction that they are the leading players in this project and that Europe is looking after their needs. If not, this worrying detachment from European affairs that can be detected today in some countries will only increase. And believe me, members of the House, nothing is guaranteed if the citizens do not clearly perceive what Europe can give them. That is why, at times of uncertainty we have to look back to observe what the last few decades have meant for Europeans.
Honourable members,
Sixty years ago, Europeans who were children of their time, but with a vision of the future, decided to close the door on animosity and open the window to hope. In this way they began the most beautiful utopia of the 20th century. Those founding fathers rejected preconceived ideas and committed themselves to innovative formulas. They looked for the strength of union in the principles and values that for centuries have constituted the common sap of the European tree. They strengthened the elements of integration and sidelined those that tended towards disintegration. They boosted the many things that united Europeans and sent to the attic for good historical quarrels and exacerbated nationalism that had lost its legitimacy.
Those visionaries laid the foundations for the triumph of peace over war, but not of peace at any price: peace based on democracy and respect for the basic rights of individuals, peace backed by tolerance and pluralism, peace founded on a system of social market economy and the participation of people in government decisions.
Peace, democracy and social market economy became the pillars of a supra-national organisation, first the European Communities and then, from 1991 the European Union, which became a buttress against the totalitarianism that held sway on part of our continent and crystallised a model, the model of European life, a model for the rest of the world.Lower
Six decades on, it is worth remembering that these years have been the best in history for Europeans. And we only have to recall what the previous sixty years were like, among other things, with two fratricidal wars, to reaffirm our conviction in this incontrovertible truth.
That is why when there are doubts, it is important to stress the value of a European Union founded on democracy and freedoms, with solidarity and economic, social and territorial cohesion; a European Union in which other citizens from our continent aspire to join, who have for decades dreamt of joining the European project. It is a European project that today represents a reality in which 500 million citizens from 27 countries participate.
This balance is the result of that utopia that was created in Europe half-way through the last century; but utopias also have to be renewed, because the weight of the passage of time may have an effect on dreams. First the financial crisis, then the economic crisis, and the crisis of credibility in the system, oblige us to call a halt and rethink Europe, rethinking its goals, the intensity of its integration and its political design.
I have not the slightest doubt that we are facing the most profound crisis in the construction of Europe since the creation of the Communities; a crisis that does not affect its fundamentals, principles and values, which are the foundations on which the European edifice was built and that in my opinion continue to prevail. But the world has changed decisively in recent times: globalisation, the extraordinary development of communications, the emergence of new countries and the appearance of new actors on the international political scene represent the landmarks of the new world that we are living in.
If mid-way through the last century the Belgian Prime Minister Paul Henri Spaak, talking of the European states, said that "all of them were small, but some had still not noticed," this statement is today truer than ever. If Europe wants to participate in determining the new rules of global governance; if Europe wants to be proud of the European model of society; and if Europe wants to continue to contribute to the prosperity and welfare of its citizens; then Europe must make a firm commitment to greater integration.
This greater integration is today a necessity, both in the economic and political sphere. I am profoundly convinced of this. I am also convinced that no one can impose timelines, methods, conditions, or intensity on this greater integration. The final result of this process must be the outcome of an agreement in which all take part, and when I say "all" I mean the effective involvement of the citizens in a task in which their future is at stake.
It falls upon me, because that is what the people have decided, to represent these ideas at the European Council, and as I believe that these ideas must have the greatest level of consensus possible, I will be grateful for any reflections, initiatives and proposals you may have for me.
That is all. Thank you very much.