Press conference of the President of the Government and the Prime Minister of the Republic of Turkey.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

24 April 2018 · High-Level Hispano-Turkish meeting (sixth), press conference

Context
Rajoy held a joint press conference with Turkish Prime Minister Yildirim following the sixth High-Level Hispano-Turkish meeting in Spain on April 24, 2018.
Main themes
Spain-Turkey bilateral relations, trade and economic cooperation, EU-Turkey dialogue, counterterrorism cooperation, infrastructure investment, refugee crisis, Mediterranean peace and stability, Syria conflict, NATO and security, rule of law
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,757
84th percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
3.00
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

174 sentences in 68 paragraphs

President.- Ladies and gentlemen, good afternoon, and thank you very much for attending this meeting.

As you know, today the High-Level Hispano-Turkish meeting took place, the sixth since the inauguration of these meetings in 2009. The last one was held in Ankara.

On the occasion of this High-Level meeting, four sectoral ministerial meetings were held: Interior, Development, Environment, Agriculture and Fisheries, and Economy.

Two specific agreements have been signed, a declaration on forestry, and a memorandum of understanding on transport.

If there is one thing to highlight from this High-Level meeting, it is its marked economic dimension.

The Prime Minister of Turkey has been accompanied by a business delegation that has met with representatives of CEOE and Spanish entrepreneurs.

Turkey is one of Spain's main trading partners outside the European Union and a strategic market for our country. Both countries are part of a Customs Union. Our economic and trade relations have strengthened over the past few years. Since 2010, bilateral trade has increased by 74%.

Turkey is a prominent country for our trade and investment. It is our eleventh trading partner in the world, and fourth outside the European Union, behind China, the United States, and Morocco.

In 2017, bilateral trade increased by 15.3% compared to the previous year. Turkey is also an important destination for Spanish investment, with a high level of interest from our companies in the country. To give you another figure, although I do not want to overwhelm you, the stock of Spanish investment increased by 57% between 2013 and 2015.

Spanish companies are committed to strategic and emblematic projects for Turkey, particularly in the field of infrastructure. For example, the railway section in the tunnel under the Bosphorus, the Ankara metro, which I attended the inauguration of, the modernization of refineries, etc.

I believe that the experience and good performance of our companies constitute a valuable reference for the opportunities that may arise as a result of the Investment Plan launched by the Turkish Government.

Regarding the dialogue between the European Union and Turkey, I conveyed to Prime Minister Yildirim the fundamental importance of the rule of law and constitutional guarantees.

Turkey is an important partner for the European Union as a whole, and in the fight against terrorism. The cooperation we maintain regarding foreign fighters is key to preventing terrorist attacks. Today's sectoral meeting on Interior addressed this crucial matter and agreed to further strengthen the existing cooperation in order to ensure the safety of our citizens.

Another aspect we discussed is Security and Defense. We talked about threats and interests that affect us as allies situated on the borders of NATO. These are problems we face together, such as the aforementioned terrorism, migratory pressure, or the need to continue building an alliance that also defends us from the challenges faced by Southern countries. Therefore, we continue to deploy a battery of Patriot missiles in Turkey, which I visited at the end of 2015.

In today's meeting, we also addressed the situation of the more than three million refugees in Turkey. The European Union has already committed 3 billion euros to meet their basic needs, and we hope to increase this contribution soon.

On other international issues, Prime Minister Yildirim and I have shared our visions on the Mediterranean as a space of peace and prosperity.

We believe that the only possible way to achieve this goal is through political dialogue. We also believe that cooperation on concrete projects among all countries on both shores of the Mediterranean is essential. Ultimately, the citizen must always be at the center of our actions. For this, the ideal instrument remains the Union for the Mediterranean.

We have also reviewed the situation in the Middle East. Spain seeks to contribute to the stability of a region that is fundamental for Europe.

I conveyed to the Prime Minister our concern about the seriousness of the situation in Syria. Only a political transition process in line with United Nations resolutions can bring lasting peace to this country. An agreement among Syrians is essential to guarantee the territorial integrity and political unity of Syria.

Furthermore, Spain and Turkey welcome the holding today of the Second International Conference on Syria in Brussels.

In short, it has been a multisectoral and positive High-Level Meeting for our economies. I hope that political, commercial, and cultural relations between both countries continue to strengthen, as should the ties between our peoples and the alliances between Spanish and Turkish companies.

I want to thank, as I have done before, I want to do it now here publicly, in front of the media, the Prime Minister of Turkey and the people accompanying him in this delegation.

We have very good bilateral relations, for a long time; we have common objectives, security, the fight against terrorism, and addressing the most important challenge we will have to face today, and for many years to come for European countries, which is migration and the problems of refugees, are undoubtedly challenges that will require us to work hard, I hope well, and, of course, to do so jointly.

Mr. Prime Minister, thank you very much, whenever you wish.

Mr. Yildirim.- Thank you very much, Mr. President Rajoy, esteemed ministers of the Spanish State, my dear colleagues, and esteemed members of the press,

Today, we have had the sixth summit between Turkey and Spain, and I am very happy to be at this summit, after the bilateral negotiations, we have evaluated our cooperation. We talked about the economy, trade, investments, how to increase these relations, the fight against terrorism, and also illegal migration and what we can do about these phenomena in our countries and in Europe.

And as the esteemed President of the Government has said, we have grown by 15.3%, and now we have, in 2017, trade valued at 12.7 billion dollars between the two countries. And what matters most to us is balanced and sustainable growth for both countries.

However, there is much more potential between Spain and Turkey that can be leveraged, beyond this, and much more can be achieved, and we are here to talk about these opportunities.

We also have men and women in business from different sectors, who are having simultaneous meetings. Businessmen whom we will also hear from later about possible investments and actions that can facilitate their work in both countries. And, also, our ministers have evaluated different sectors on Environment, Agriculture, and, above all, the fight against terrorism.

The ministers of both countries have talked about many issues, with the Minister of Economy; we have discussed the Trade and Economy Committee between Turkey and Spain, and they have decided to continue with this initiative to promote our collaboration. It is important to accelerate and facilitate our trade relationship.

And, also, regarding investments, we can see that there is a positive trend, especially in the infrastructure sector, Spanish companies are working, especially, in high-speed train infrastructure, the banking sector, and also other sectors that can promote the economy of both countries, and that contribute to the economy of our country as well.

Right now, we have more than six hundred Spanish companies in Turkey. These are not companies that invest in the stock market, but are making long-term investments and are contributing to the Turkish economy, and, at the same time, they are also making profits.

In Spain, we have one hundred Turkish companies; in relation to tourism, every year we have more relations and regarding the fight against terrorism, which is a key issue for us, Spain and Turkey have very similar experiences. For years we have had separatist terrorist organizations in both countries, and we have fought for many years, and we have spent a lot of energy fighting against these organizations. Therefore, we have emphasized cooperation against these terrorist organizations between our two countries.

As you know, we had an attempted coup in 2016, on July 15, with the responsible party for this coup attempt being the FETÖ Organization. We know that Spain supports our democracy and we will not forget Spain's support in this democratic process. Thank you very much for that. However, we have also warned the President of the Government that this Organization also has activities in Spain, therefore, we have requested that actions against this terrorist organization in Spain continue, and we have asked for your cooperation. We have also shared our thoughts on this matter.

Last year Spain had conflicts in Catalonia, and we have a very clear position. We support the constitutional order and the integrity of the country, of the State of Spain. Territorial integrity is important to us, and we support this integrity.

We have also talked about different regions, for example, in Syria, for seven years, there has been a civil war, with numerous victims and the loss of many lives, being a very serious humanitarian problem. Turkey, the United States, the United Nations, all these parties are seeking a solution, and then, Syria and Iran are also following a process (No translation) and we can see the result of this process. Now we can see that there is less tension in the region, there is a cessation of confrontations and battles in this area. And I believe that we will be able to see how the territorial integrity of Syria is preserved and a sustainable long-term peace is achieved for all the people living in the area.

In addition to all the work that Turkey has done in Syria, it also protects the European Union from migration. We are contributing to European security, because if it were not for Turkey's efforts, there would be much illegal migration to Europe, and we could see more conflicts in the area. And Turkey, as a NATO member, is also protecting its borders. Spain has supported us with its air defense forces, and that is very important support for us, and I want to thank the President again for this support.

Also, as you all know, we are in the process of accession to the European Union, we have been following these negotiations for many years. Spain has always supported us, but at the point we are at now, to resolve our problems, we need a new vision from the European Union. It is something mandatory, it is important to see a new, renewed vision from the European Union, and we hope to see this vision soon.

Therefore, Turkey and Spain are at both ends of the Mediterranean, and by working together we are working to promote trade, to increase trade in this area. Next year we will have an Intergovernmental Summit, where we will share our experiences and evaluations and we will talk about how to take our relationship further, not limiting it to Turkey and Spain. We will talk about cooperation in Africa, in Latin America, and in other areas; what kind of cooperation we can have. The geography surrounding Turkey has a very large population, there are the Caucasus republics, the Turkic republics, there are many countries. There are more than five hundred million people who speak Spanish. Cooperation can also be established in Africa, on different issues. We have talked about all these opportunities.

Unfortunately, there is xenophobia, racism, and to fight against these issues we have an Alliance of Civilizations in which Spain and Turkey are co-chairs. We have also emphasized that we will contribute to the fight against xenophobia, Islamophobia, and racism, and we have highlighted these issues.

Finally, I want to thank the President again for his hospitality, for the welcome he has given us, and we want to see him very soon in Turkey.

Thank you very much.

Q.- From the newspaper 'Sabah', Turkey. We have news that the Patriot missile air defense systems will be operational until the end of the year or what is your forecast.

President.- There are 6 missile batteries in Adana, as you know very well. I have had the opportunity to be with the Spanish military in Adana, they are very proud and satisfied with the role they are carrying out. They do it within the framework of NATO, Turkey and Spain are NATO members, we are allies and we jointly defend our security, the rights and freedoms of our nationals. We have been there since 2015. There has already been some extension. At the end of 2018, as you recalled when you asked your question, the deadline would end. The Prime Minister has raised my country's position for the future, and I told him that I viewed that request very positively and that we will resolve it when appropriate.

Q.- Good afternoon, Albert Calatrava from Catalunya Radio. These are questions for the President of the Spanish Government about the situation in Catalonia.

The first question is whether the Spanish Government plans to appeal the decision of the Parliament's Board to allow the delegation of the vote of Antoni Comín. Then, whether the Minister of Finance, Cristóbal Montoro, has his support, the support of the President of the Government, when reiterating that not a single euro was allocated to the referendum, that there was no embezzlement of public funds.

And abusing your patience, a third question. Following the complaint filed by the prosecutor against nine teachers for classes after October 1, whether the State Inspection detected any problems in the Catalan school system, and whether you believe there is any problem in the Catalan school system.

President.- Well, in relation to this third question, I must say that the episode seems lamentable to me, and I think I am being quite mild in my description, and therefore, I support the actions carried out by the prosecutor.

Regarding the Minister of Finance, I want to say with absolute clarity that the Government's collaboration with the Courts has always been, is, and will be total and absolute. And I want to say, secondly, that there is no discrepancy: each one, within their area of responsibility, ensures compliance with the Law.

What did the Government of Spain do? Well, something that I think is very well understood, it appealed to the Constitutional Court to ensure that there were no budget items dedicated to the events that occurred on October 1, it won, and therefore, there ceased to be items that could be allocated to what happened on October 1 in Catalonia. From there, that was the Government's function. What are the judges trying to determine now with the actions they are carrying out? Well, to see if invoices have been falsified or if they cover other services different from those listed in the Budget, or if there are invoices that simply have not been submitted to the Intervention, but that is already a task for the judges.

The Government has already fulfilled its duty, which is to ensure that there were no budget items dedicated to those effects. And as you can understand, if we have done everything possible to ensure that there were no budget items dedicated to those effects, it would be absurd for us not to collaborate with those who are investigating whether or not there was fraud from that point on.

Regarding the third question, which is actually the first, due to the order in which you asked it. Regarding the deputy, Mr. Comín, look, the first thing we are going to ask him, but not as a Government, we do not have the authority to do so to the Board, is that his position be that Mr. Comín cannot delegate his vote, this, at least in my opinion, and in the opinion of many, makes no sense at all.

From there, we will study all legal actions to prevent decisions that contravene what our current legislation establishes. But the most important thing, you see, is not Mr. Comín. The most important thing is to recover sanity, and that we are capable of restoring normality. Political, economic, and social normality. That is to say, what we are seeing now makes no sense.

Look, in any democracy, what Parliaments have to do, once decisions have been made, is to elect people who are qualified to govern and, therefore, I believe that now what everyone wants, or the vast majority at least, except for one, two, or three, or ten people who are undoubtedly very important, what they want and what they desire, what should be done is to recover political, economic, and social life, to set up a Government, a Government that complies with the law, and a Government that tries to dialogue with the Government of Spain, for which, I, of course, as long as the dialogue takes place within the framework of the law, am at your disposal.

That is to say, in the end, I think it no longer makes sense to be discussing the things that one does, those of another; if one travels here, if another travels there. Come on, let’s get to the main point. And the main point is that Catalonia needs a Government now. A Government that is legal, and that has the capacity and the will to dialogue with everyone. And there are some of us who are willing to do so.

Q.- The first question for the Prime Minister of Turkey, and then for Mr. Rajoy. In the last statement from the European Parliament, they declared that the elections to be held in Turkey would not be democratic, and there is a recommendation that these elections will not be democratic.

Mr. Yildirim.- The Council of Europe has to deal with its own affairs, because elections are a matter for Turkey. Turkey has held many elections, they have all been transparent, they have all been democratic, they have always had more than 85% participation. We have given a lesson in democracy. We have provided a dominant air of democracy, but the Council of Europe and the European Parliament, by making such a statement, what they do is allow a terrorist leader to go to Parliament and speak, and that serves neither for peace nor helps in the fight against terrorism, nor does it even protect the values of the European Union.

Q.- The same question. What do you think about this statement? What is your opinion on it?

President.- About the European Parliament and the Council of Europe?

The European Council has not adopted any statement on that matter, and in the European Council is where I sit and express my opinion. And therefore, what the Council of Europe says and what the Parliament says, they have every right to say it, which does not mean that I agree with what I think, or with what the Heads of State and Government of the Union think.

Q.- Good afternoon. Susana Camacho, from Noticias Cuatro. My questions are for you, President Rajoy.

You know that a motion of censure has been raised against President Cifuentes, and I understand that neither of the two scenarios, that Cifuentes resigns or that this motion of censure prospers, is pleasant for you. I wanted to ask you what decision you are going to make? whether to maintain Cifuentes or the Government of Madrid, and whether you will do it before May 2, and if you allow me, in the key week of the Budgets, whether the Government is considering ceding the management of Social Security or penitentiary policy to the PNV?

President.- Well, thank you very much.

These are two different issues. Regarding the first, what I have to say to Mrs. Cifuentes, I am sure you understand, if I have anything to say to her, I will say it in due time. But I think the best I can tell you all today is what I pointed out here not long ago, when in response to a question about this same issue I said, "I sell advice, for I have none for myself." It is somewhat amusing that for those who are raising a motion of censure, the people, even the one who formally presents it, the first, has falsified their curriculum and claimed to have a degree in mathematics. Therefore, equal treatment for all and "I sell advice, for I have none for myself."

Regarding the second question you ask me about whether I am willing to give or to stop giving. Look, I am the President of the Government and I have something to do with the Budgets. Absolutely no one, absolutely no one, has spoken to me about prisons, nor has absolutely anyone spoken to me about Social Security, so, well, in the end, a news item arises, and we are debating a news item that is absolutely false, because no one has told me that. I am not, on the other hand, negotiating with anyone. The only thing I am aware of is that tomorrow the Budget debate begins, which will be voted on Thursday, that there are some parties that have said they will not vote, or that they will not present a total amendment. Well, let’s see if we can get them through. I don’t know if they will then present amendments, I don’t know either. And, in any case, we will study the amendments that are presented.

But the most relevant, and the most important thing is that this is false. And, of course, then everyone opines about something that, really, we have to try to do things better, because that is plain and simply false.

From there, I think it would be important for the Budgets to go ahead. They are good Budgets. For the first time, we have already been able, after an agreement with the unions, to give a salary increase to civil servants, we have also been able to raise pensions, I believe that investment is increasing. They are social Budgets, they will comply with Europe, and therefore, I am happy with the Budgets I have presented. I will try to get them through, but, well, I, throughout my political life, I believe I have proven some things, and, of course, I am not going to change, especially when no one has asked me to, and even if they did, the Budgets, for transfers, competencies or such. I will study the amendments proposed by the different Groups. From there, we will try to seek understanding and agreement. But, I insist, this makes no sense, does it? And seeing what political parties do regarding analyses on things that are not true, well, it really does not say anything good in favor of politics, in general.

Very well. Thank you very much.