Press conference of the Prime Minister after the meeting of the Heads of State and Government of the European Union.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

23 February 2018 · Informal meeting of the Heads of State and Government of the European Union

Context
Rajoy addressed press after an informal EU Council meeting on 23 February 2018, outlining Spain's priorities for the post-2020 Multiannual Financial Framework.
Main themes
EU Multiannual Financial Framework post-2020, Common Agricultural Policy funding, cohesion policy, Brexit impact on EU budget, European security and defense, competitiveness and research investment, Erasmus and education, Spain's EU budget priorities, internal market and employment, border control and immigration, climate change response, Leaders' Agenda
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,118
92nd percentile
Sentences
210
90th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

210 sentences in 73 paragraphs

Good afternoon and thank you very much for your attendance.

Allow me, before I begin, to express my condolences for the death of the ertzaina Inocencio Alonso during the incidents that occurred yesterday near the San Mames stadium. He died in the line of duty, ensuring the safety of so many people who wanted to enjoy a sporting event that should never be tarnished by the violence of groups that must be eradicated from the world of sports.

As you know, we have just concluded the informal meeting of the twenty-seven members of the European Council. In it, as you also know, institutional issues and the post-2020 Multiannual Financial Framework have been addressed.

If I had to summarize the purpose of this meeting, I would say that it is about discussing what kind of Europe we want for the future, and this is no small matter. As you have heard me say on more than one occasion, Europe has been, is, and will continue to be a primary source of well-being for citizens. It is a reality that we have built over several generations of Europeans, which has yielded great results and that we want future generations to share with increasing intensity.

The future of the Europe we are designing is framed within the Leaders' Agenda initiated by President Tusk to strengthen the debate on these issues, which is proving to be very useful for everyone.

Both at last night's informal dinner and at today's meeting, we have analyzed what the political priorities should be for the preparation of the European Union's Multiannual Financial Framework after 2020.

As you know, the Commission plans to present its proposal for the new Framework in May. From there, formal negotiations will begin in the Council and with the European Parliament, which the Commission would like to conclude before the end of the current legislative period, that is, before April 2019. This is undoubtedly an ambitious timeline. We will work to advance as much as possible because it is a very important issue for Spain. We have already presented a position paper and will continue to work in the coming months.

The Multiannual Financial Framework is key, as it sets the maximum ceilings for the European budget for each of the policies and, therefore, determines the actions of the Union in the upcoming period. That is why President Tusk's initiative to first discuss priorities at the leaders' level is very positive, and I have expressed my gratitude for that.

We are facing particularly complex negotiations. There are two circumstances that make the situation different from previous budgetary periods: on the one hand, the exit of the United Kingdom and, on the other, the need to provide a European response in new areas. In particular, Europe must do more in areas such as security, defense, combating climate change, border control, and immigrant integration.

In these circumstances, Spain will maintain, as we have always done, a constructive attitude. We believe that to reach an agreement, it will be essential to have a fair distribution of effort. For us, this means that the final outcome adequately reflects the differences in the relative economic position of the countries. That is what we are advocating.

Regarding priorities, we share the vision of a stronger and safer Europe that encompasses new areas of action; but this should not affect the fundamental role that the European budget has, which is none other than to promote the proper functioning of the internal market and to foster growth and employment; and, with that, the well-being of people.

In this regard, it is key, and I have defended this before my European colleagues, to ensure sufficient funding for the Common Agricultural Policy and cohesion policy. These are policies that are very important for the European Union and very important for Spain.

Indeed, both the Common Agricultural Policy and cohesion play a fundamental role in promoting convergence and supporting the development of all European regions. They are policies, in Europe and in Spain, appreciated and valued by citizens. And that is why we will defend adequate funding for our country in the Common Agricultural Policy and in cohesion.

Furthermore, the European budget must also pay special attention to policies that are key to ensuring the competitiveness of the European Union. I am referring, in particular, to research and development policies; education and training — an area in which the Erasmus program has special relevance, as it is a clear example of a successful European program — and investments in transport, energy, and telecommunications infrastructure.

Being competitive is key to growing and creating jobs, and those are the areas that need to be emphasized. That is why we are working in Europe and also in Spain. That is how we can continue to improve the well-being of people.

Well, that is, in broad terms, Spain's starting position, but as I have said, we know that these are complicated negotiations and we will maintain a constructive position in them, as we always try to do.

As for the second topic we addressed at last night's informal dinner and throughout today, the institutional chapter, we have jointly analyzed issues such as the composition of the European Parliament, the process for appointing the President of the European Commission, transnational lists, and citizen consultations.

In particular, we have discussed the new composition of the European Parliament following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the Union. According to this proposal, approved by the European Parliament on February 7, Spain would gain five additional seats, increasing from the current 54 to 59. Spain and France are the countries that would gain the most seats, five each. This is good news for our country, as it will allow for better representation of Spanish citizens in an institution where, as everyone knows, important decisions are made for them.

We have also debated citizen consultations on the future of Europe. I explained to my European colleagues that the Government of Spain considers it essential to involve citizens in the debate about the future of the European Union and to understand their concerns and aspirations. To this end, we will soon promote the holding of debates to identify priorities, concerns, and ideas that will help design the Europe of tomorrow. Europe is, and must continue to be, a project by and for citizens; a process in which the voice of those citizens must be heard and taken into account.

We have also addressed transnational lists. As you know, the European Parliament rejected the proposal for the creation of a European electoral constituency on February 7. We have agreed to continue reflecting on this idea, which could contribute to strengthening the European political debate ahead of the European Parliament elections in 2024.

We have also discussed the process for appointing the President of the European Commission. As you know, in the current situation, the European Council, taking into account the election results, proposes a candidate who is then elected by the European Parliament. It seems reasonable that this procedure be maintained, as well as the practice whereby the candidate to preside over the European Commission comes from the most voted party in the European elections.

Finally, I would also like to mention the meeting we held this morning with the five countries of the G5 Sahel, representatives of the United Nations, the African Union, and other international organizations, as well as with third countries to acquire specific commitments with the aim of fighting for the stability of the Sahel, an area of the world that for Spain constitutes its advanced border and is fraught with difficulties.

As you know, this is one of the poorest regions in the world and will double its population within two decades. It is also an area plagued by terrorist groups and mafias involved in all kinds of illegal trafficking that take advantage of the porosity of its borders.

This insecurity has led to the closure of more than six hundred schools in northern Mali. If we do not manage to make the Sahel a safe space, others will fill that space with radicalization, violence, and crime. We have the moral responsibility and strategic interest to offer the youth of that area of the world a future that does not involve the networks of terrorism or drug trafficking or risking their lives in search of a horizon in Europe. That is why we must decisively support initiatives such as the joint force created by the five African countries, which, equipped with five thousand troops and a capacity for cross-border action, represents a determined effort for local ownership by these five African countries.

Spain, which has been present in the area for many years, contributes significantly to the stabilization of the Sahel. We are the largest contributor in terms of troop numbers to the European Union missions and provide more than half of the personnel for the training mission in Mali; our planes in Senegal and Gabon carry out more than 30 percent of the air transport for French operations in the Sahel, and we have now made flight hours available to the G5 joint force, which will provide it with greater flexibility.

Spain will also send teachers to the Sahelian Defense College and supports the gender platform of the Permanent Secretariat of the G5. In addition, the Civil Guard leads, within the framework of the European Union, the project, together with France, Italy, and Portugal, to create gendarmerie units in the G5 countries and Senegal.

Finally, in the area of development cooperation in the strict sense — there is a part that is security and another that is development aid — Spain plans to invest more than one hundred million euros in the countries of the region over the next four years. There is no security without development, nor development without security.

I believe that these contributions demonstrate Spain's commitment to an area of enormous strategic importance for our country, for the protection of our citizens, and for the stability of the entire Mediterranean area.

In short, we have talked about things that may not be very urgent — today was an informal Council, as I mentioned at the beginning — but are very important for the future of Europe and for the well-being of citizens. After so many Councils driven by the need to make urgent decisions prompted by events, I believe it is a good initiative by President Tusk to convene us to reflect calmly on the decisions we will have to make in the near future.

From this moment on, I am at your disposal for any questions you may have.

Q.- I am Carina Verdú from Antena 3. In European terms, I wanted to ask you. When you defended that agricultural policy, those cohesion funds, what response have you received from your colleagues?

In national terms, two questions. I wanted to know if you can already advance who will be the substitute for Luis de Guindos and, regarding the Budgets, to know if you have already secured the support to present them before Holy Week.

President.- As is often the case, whenever a debate of this nature takes place, there are opinions for all tastes. But this has occurred today, which was a debate; then, as I have also told you, the Commission's proposal will come in May, and then there will be further debate, we will go to Parliament, and this takes time. There are opinions for all tastes; but there were opinions today, and there were opinions in the last negotiation of the Multiannual Financial Framework in which I was already present as the President of the Government of Spain.

There is a very important group of countries that defend agricultural policy; certainly Spain, but also important countries like France, Italy, or other Eastern countries, which will undoubtedly be good allies when it comes to defending positions and making the final decision when it is appropriate, which, I insist, the Commission would like to be this month.

The same goes for the issue of cohesion. I referred mainly to those two issues and also to others that I alluded to a moment ago when I presented the first part of my speech; but there is one issue that I consider crucial, and I have said it in this Council meeting: one of the new policies, although progress has been made in recent times, must be the one referring to the African continent. We are talking about a continent that is there, that Spain shares a direct border with Africa, and with many problems. I previously outlined the issues in the Sahel; but there are areas with many difficulties, with poverty levels that are certainly tremendous, with security levels that are also alarming, and with a problem of lack of institutions that is crucial for living in harmonious coexistence.

I believe that the European Union must make a great effort in this regard. I said that for me this was a priority issue and that I would fight, in the good sense of the word "fight," to ensure that this is taken into account for the Multiannual Financial Framework in the coming years.

In relation to the appointment of the Minister of Economy, the Minister of Economy is still, officially, not the Vice President of the European Central Bank; but what I wanted to say is this: today he is the Minister of Economy and in the coming days we will appoint another Minister of Economy; but the most relevant aspect of the appointment of the Minister of Economy, if it is finalized, as Vice President of the European Central Bank, is the recognition it entails of his performance here and in Spain, and also the credit that Spain has today as a result of the economic policy that has been carried out in recent years.

You can be completely and absolutely certain that, if that happens in 2012, the Minister of Economy would not at this moment be a member of the European Central Bank. In fact, I arrived in the Government at the end of 2011, at the beginning of 2012 I proposed a candidate against a Luxembourger and we did not have support from anyone. I believe this is a very important change in what is Spain's position and in the assessment of the economic policy that has been carried out in our country in recent years.

Regarding the Budget, I believe that the rules of the game are more or less already closed. We will present the Budget before Holy Week. Last year we presented it on March 31 and in this case Holy Week begins approximately on March 25. The objective would be that, once presented, it is definitively approved, that is, the procedures of the Congress and the Senate are fulfilled, before the end of June; a model similar to that of last year. We are talking with different political groups, I believe it would be positive for Spain to have a Budget and we are hopeful that common sense will prevail and we can have the Budget you are interested in. But at this moment I will not go into more details because, among other things, it makes no sense and does not serve much.

Q.- Jorge Valero, from "El Economista". You have said that these discussions on the Financial Perspectives were particularly complex. I don't know if you could describe a bit how the debate has been up there, if there has been tension among the different leaders and if the starting positions are very different.

Regarding the successor of Minister De Guindos, on Monday the minister will appear before the European Parliament and, precisely, he has been criticized for his political profile. Do you not think that, if he arrives on Monday still as minister, the criticisms will be even greater?

President.- In relation to this second question, Minister De Guindos has already been in Parliament and is returning to Parliament. There is no written rule nor does it make any sense to criticize a person for having engaged in political activity, who is also not a man with party activity nor has he ever run for elections. What he has been is the Minister of Economy of a political party with which, evidently, he shares those approaches.

But I believe that it does not lead to anything positive for a person, because he has been a politician, to no longer be able to assume any other responsibility. Let us not take things to those extremes. Mr. De Guindos is absolutely qualified, and that has not been questioned by anyone, to be the Vice President of the European Central Bank, just as Mr. Vítor Constâncio was, who had been the Secretary General of a party. Therefore, I do not think that this should influence and, of course, it does not affect at all the independence, which is what should be demanded of a member of the Executive Committee of the European Central Bank, from Mr. De Guindos who has demonstrated it throughout his life.

Regarding the first question, it was a debate, as I told you, that I believe had a fundamental objective, which was for the Commission itself to listen to the heads of government or heads of state to understand what their approach was. There were no details entered into there nor was a single figure pronounced.

Now you tell me where there may be discussions. I can tell you that we have a different situation. I have pointed that out before. In the revenue chapter, without a doubt, there may be discussions. Why? Because there is a net contributor, which is the United Kingdom, whose exit from the Union may lead to approximately ninety billion euros less in revenue and then there are new policies, which are the ones we have been discussing in recent times, which may be, approximately, although this, I tell you, is very debatable, about one hundred billion euros. So, we have ninety billion less in revenue, plus one hundred billion more in spending, and we are at 190 billion.

One debate is: are we going to put in more money or not? Revenue chapter. I will tell you what my opinion is. My opinion is that I believe Spain should be open to putting in more resources, among other things, because if we want to continue deepening European integration, I think it is positive that we do so. And then, in the expenditure chapter, the debate will be what we are going to dedicate the resources to.

I say that I defend agriculture because it is very important for many reasons: for environmental reasons, for reasons of also keeping people in the villages, to avoid depopulation… This is very important for Spain. Spain, in addition to agriculture and livestock, has a very powerful agri-food industry that is often the second largest exporting industry in Spain, only surpassed by capital goods. What we export the most are capital goods and then there are automobiles, the agri-food industry, and chemical products. For us, for many reasons, it is very important. Others, who are in your mind, are not interested in agriculture and prefer other things.

These things always work the same way and always at the last minute everyone ends up yielding in their maximum proposals because, if this were not the case, it was evident that we would not be going anywhere. I am optimistic that an understanding can be reached on this matter.

Q.- Ana Núñez-Milara, from Informativos Tele 5. According to the latest Catalan CIS, support for independence would have decreased by eight points in the last three months. In this sense, I would like your assessment.

Then, insisting a bit more on the De Guindos issue, today the minister himself has said that the Government will announce before Monday when he will leave his responsibilities as minister. I don't know if you can confirm if this is the case. Is it expected, therefore, that he will resign before Monday? And I don't know if you can give us any more hints about the candidate. What requirements should the next Minister of Economy have?

President.- The fundamental requirement is competence and capacity for work. Period. What is needed is a minister who knows the subject, who knows it well, who does not have to study the issues that he will find on the table, who has the capacity for work and who has enthusiasm; that is, fundamentally: competence, capacity for work, and enthusiasm. As for before Monday, no. I already tell you that I will not give you dates because there are no dates at this moment. That is to say, when the appointment of the new minister occurs, you will know; you can be completely and absolutely certain.

Regarding the question about the Catalan CIS, quite frankly it is good news. I believe it is very positive that during this time there are people who have reflected and thought about whether everything they have lived and what we continue to live now is worth it. In any case, the most important thing, and we must always try to go for the greater good --that, of course, I insist, is very positive--… What we need at this moment is institutional normality, political normality, economic normality, and social normality. People want tranquility, they want normality, and they want the Parliament of Catalonia to start addressing the issues that matter to citizens, they want this situation of Article 155 to pass because there have already been elections and I hope that common sense is recovered, that a candidate is proposed who is not involved in judicial problems, that we look forward and, from there, that we try to build something positive.

Certainly, what we have seen during this time --I believe that many people have realized this-- does not lead anywhere, does not help coexistence, does not benefit people, and does not benefit relationships between people. We all know the ruptures that occurred between friends, neighbors, families, etc.

Therefore, it is very positive that the number of people who declare themselves independentists decreases and now what is necessary is that we return to normality, we all get back to our own and try to build something and, certainly, on the part of the Government, there will be full willingness to try to build something reasonable.

Q.- Mariano Calleja, from the newspaper "ABC". Continuing with the European Budgets, the next ones, I wanted to know if you could specify a bit more how much Spain has at stake, how much is at stake for our country and if the Government assumes that Spain may stop being a net recipient of funds in the next Budgets.

President.- How much Spain has at stake is difficult to know at this moment. What Spain has are its priorities. It is difficult to know because we also do not know what the revenue budget will be. We know that there is a net contributor who is leaving and that there are ninety billion euros less.

So, the first decision that must be made is how much money we are willing to put on the table and the second decision is what the criteria will be for putting in resources. Spain wants the criterion that decides what each one puts in to be gross national income; it is the most reasonable, the most sensible, and I believe the fairest. That would be the second debate and then the next debate would be what we dedicate the resources to. Keep in mind that today practically 70 percent --the figure may only be approximate-- is dedicated to cohesion funds and agriculture; but that is very important for the reasons I mentioned earlier: because it is a way to help achieve economic convergence, a similar standard of living, among all the countries of the European Union, and I believe that these solidarity policies must be maintained and we will work to ensure that this is the case. The rest we will see little by little.

Q.- Jacobo de Regoyos, from Onda Cero. Is the Government willing to raise the pension revaluation index?

President.- That is an important issue and it is a topic… I will try to give you the clearest answer possible and not to extend too much.

I understand, logically, that people want a greater increase in pensions, just as people also want a greater increase in civil servant salaries and greater attention for healthcare or education. We all want that; that is to say, there is no one, no matter how they think, who does not want this to happen.

I am convinced in the case of pensions because, as you know, throughout this crisis when I was subjected to the investiture in the Congress of Deputies, I said that there were two items that would not decrease under any circumstances, which were pensions and unemployment, and that is how it was done. Thirdly, we avoided the bailout and that, in turn, prevented us from being imposed decisions on pensions as those that occurred in other countries of the European Union. In some cases, you know that they had to lower them by up to 30 percent.

That is why I tell you that this is one of the truly important issues and I am glad you asked me this question. Pensions account for 30 percent of total public spending in Spain, 30 percent, and it is a little more than 40 percent of the Government's Budget; that is to say, of the money that the Government of Spain earns, more than 40 percent is dedicated to pensions. And I will give you another piece of data that is also very important: this year, simply, even if we did not raise pensions at all, the item dedicated to pensions increased by 3.7 billion euros. Why? Because of the people who enter the system. 3.7 billion euros. And then, there is another piece of data that is also important: in 2017 we managed to recover the State's revenue from 2007, because in 2008 and 2009 we lost seventy billion euros in revenue, which was one of the aspects of the crisis. Well, during that period we collected the same as in 2007; but spending on pensions increased by fifty billion euros.

This is the data and, therefore, because this is the most important issue that Spain has posed for the future --this, the first, and the second most important is spending on healthcare--, is why I have brought the debate on pensions to the Congress of Deputies and that is why I find myself once again obliged to ask the political forces not to politicize this issue, because that is the Toledo Pact. Because it is very easy to say "raise pensions." How much? "Whatever they want." But, if then there are no resources to pay for it, what we will be doing is pulling the wool over people's eyes.

And there is another thing that should not be forgotten: the great crisis that Spain has experienced and that, fortunately, we are now beginning to overcome, was caused by generating a brutal public spending that did not correspond to revenues. We reached an 11 percent public deficit.

Therefore, let us take it step by step. Now things are better. Look, in the year 2011, when we came to power, for every new pensioner entering the system, three jobs were lost, three contributors to Social Security. Today, for every pensioner entering the system, there are six more people contributing to Social Security. We are on the right track, but let us not make mistakes. With absolute frankness, I understand the views of all people; but I am the president of the Government and I have to look out for the medium and long term, and we already have a bad experience: I repeat, the greatest crisis we have lived through in many years.

Q.- Natalia Segura, from "El Punt-Avui". Two questions. First, what do you think about the possibility of including a conditionality in the Budgets linked to the Rule of Law?

And second, regarding Catalonia. If Esquerra Republicana and Junts per Catalunya reach a government agreement without people who are outside or in prison, will the Government lift Article 155?

President.- Article 155 will be lifted automatically, not as a consequence of any decision by the Government, when the president of the Generalitat elected by the Parliament of Catalonia takes office. That is how it will happen, and that is why, as I have already said before, it would be the most sensible and reasonable thing to present a candidate who submits to a vote, and whoever comes out, logically, that means the end of Article 155. That candidate cannot be Mr. Puigdemont. Mr. Puigdemont cannot be the candidate because the Constitutional Court --that is why the president of the Parliament has not held the plenary session-- has said that one cannot be president of the Generalitat without going to the Parliament, and that if Mr. Puigdemont wants to go, he needs the authorization of the Supreme Court.

What makes no sense is that because of the situation of one man, we are all, starting with the seven million citizens of Catalonia, in a situation like this. I, honestly, cannot understand how there are no people capable of saying something as obvious as this: because of the situation of one man, seven million citizens of Catalonia are being harmed. And I believe that the sensible and reasonable thing is for it to be a person who does not have judicial problems. This, honestly, I think, but the vast majority thinks so because it is a matter of common sense.

As for the conditionality of the Budgets in relation to the Rule of Law, I do not quite understand that question.

Q.- The idea has been raised that in some structural funds there should be a certain conditionality when granting them to certain countries or regions depending on the situation of the Rule of Law in certain countries. I wanted to know your opinion.

President.- I want to say that I have not raised that; in fact, I have not even thought about it. I have not said a single word on that matter nor have I ever heard a debate on that topic. I do not know if, in the end, you are referring to the problems that some countries have had; but no one, neither at the informal dinner yesterday nor at today’s meeting, has referred to that. That is not on the table.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for your attention.