Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 February 2018 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a congressional control session on February 21, 2018, addressing Spain's science funding and economic record.
Main themes
Science and research funding in Spain, R&D investment levels, brain drain of Spanish scientists, economic progress and growth, state budget obligations, opposition criticism of government policy, European research programs, government commitment to innovation
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,420
66th percentile
Sentences
102
64th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.3
37th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 47%46%
  • Institutional 30%29%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

102 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Margarita Robles, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Robles.- Mr. Rajoy, what is your assessment of the situation of science and research in Spain?

President.- Ms. Robles, I believe that in Spain we have a good science system. We have researchers with a global impact in various areas, numerous top-tier centers, cutting-edge scientific and technological infrastructures, and significant participation in many of the largest European and international facilities. As in everything, there is room for improvement, and that is what we are working on.

Ms. Robles.- Mr. Rajoy, Spain is a great country and Spaniards should feel proud of Spain. Unfortunately, you and your Government are mortgaging the present and future of Spain.

You are mortgaging the present because you are not even able to present here a General State Budget Bill, failing to comply with the obligation imposed by Article 134 of the Constitution. You and your Government are incapable of fulfilling the commitments you make, even with the State Security Forces regarding salaries. And I won't even mention that, of course, you do not allow the opposition to present initiatives here.

But, while what you are doing is serious, mortgaging the present of Spain, what you are doing with the future of Spain is much more serious, and it is much more serious because a country that does not invest in research, science, technology, and innovation is doomed to have no economic progress. Economic progress requires sustainable growth, requires modernity, and requires science and research. Of course, Mr. De Guindos has had his personal agenda to position himself in the European Central Bank and has not dedicated himself to what he should be dedicated to.

In Spain, the resources allocated to science, research, and R&D are only 1.19 percent; the European average is 2.3 percent. Look at the difference, and very far from the 3 percent that will be allocated in 2020. We have lost twenty-seven thousand jobs in the sector and thirty thousand well-trained Spanish scientists have had to go abroad. We want a Spain with scientists like Severo Ochoa, like Ramón y Cajal, or like Gregorio Marañón. We have young people who can do it, and you, with your policy, are condemning them to exile.

I refer you to what scientists like Mariano Barbacid say, who states that with your policies the Welfare State will become more vulnerable every day. Or what our scientist Margarita Salas says when she states: "We have good young Spanish scientists and they are condemned to exile." Mr. Rajoy, stop mortgaging the present and future of Spaniards. You only have a past, but let us…

President.- Ms. Robles, you began your intervention not by talking about research and science, but by introducing two concepts into it.

First, you spoke to us about economic progress. Allow me not to grant you too much moral authority to speak about economic progress after five years of negative growth and job loss in Spain.

You referred, the second concept you introduced in your intervention, to Mr. De Guindos. I better not say anything. I simply refer to remind you of what happened with Mr. De Guindos and Ms. Valenciano, demonstrative of the patriotism and intelligence you have.

That said, as you know, investment in R&D began to decline in 2009, after we were told that, for the first time in our history, Spain was going to spend above the European average, which it did not.

Spain had five consecutive years of recession thanks to your economic progress, and this affected all economic sectors because, among other things, seventy billion euros in revenue were lost. Then, economic policy changed, economic growth began, job creation increased, revenue rose, and in 2014 the Government made a clear commitment to science, and in 2016 an 11 percent increase was consolidated.

I would recommend to you, after reminding you that the level of science in Spain is top-notch, that you start, for once, to speak well of Spain, because there are things worth remembering, such as that we are the third country that obtains the most projects in the Horizon 2020 Program of the European Union, the fourth in returns, and the one that leads the most projects. In addition, Spain participates in and leads very ambitious international programs, such as the Cherenkov Telescope Array consortium in the Canary Islands, the European Molecular Biology Laboratory, or the MareNostrum supercomputer in Barcelona, places you should visit to see how science is functioning in our country.

Progress has been made in some areas. We have launched the State Research Agency, we are on the right track, and we will continue to make a commitment to science and innovation in Spain, even if you have remained in the…

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pablo Iglesias, of the Confederal Parliamentary Group of Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President, does the Government have support to push through this year's General Budgets or does it intend to extend them?

President.- Mr. Iglesias, those are two questions. Do we have support to approve the Budgets? We are working to obtain support, as we did last year. If you want to join, you will be welcome.

And the second question is whether we are going to extend the Budgets. In reality, they are already extended. As you well know, Article 134 of the Constitution states that the initial Budgets of the previous year are considered extended until the approval of the new ones. Therefore, they are extended, and in fact, on December 29, 2017, as you also know, we approved an Agreement in the Council of Ministers to technically implement that extension.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. Rajoy, you told me the last time I asked you here: do not ask me about corruption, ask me about something else. You see that I am asking you about something else; the judges are already asking you about corruption.

I am glad that you have cited the Constitution because the Constitution says something very important, which is that the Budgets must be submitted to debate in the seat of popular sovereignty, in the Congress of Deputies. The Constitution provides that, in case you do not have the necessary votes, they can be extended; but it is your constitutional obligation to submit the Budgets to debate in the Congress of Deputies.

I must ask you to do your homework as a Government. We, modestly, have presented alternative Budgets; it is our duty as the opposition, we are paid for it. You have the obligation to debate the Budgets here.

I suspect that you want to evade responsibility, and that practice of evasion implies at least two things: the first is that we have a Government that does not comply with the Constitution, an illegal Government — you are already being called "the illegals" in some places — and the second is that you do not dare to have a discussion about the economic results of your Government. In this country, for the first time, spending on health will fall below 6 percent of GDP, we are at the bottom of Europe in education spending, and ninety Spanish citizens, with recognized dependency situations, die every day without receiving the resources and services to which they are entitled. That must be debated in the seat of popular sovereignty.

The situation of the accounts of Spaniards is what interests Spaniards the most. I suspect that you are interested in other accounts: those that Mr. Bárcenas took, which pointed to you as a recipient of illegal payments. And there is something very clear: someone who has financed themselves illegally should never put their hands on the accounts of Spaniards, but if they do, at least they must come to the Congress of Deputies to face the music. While you are free, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, come to face the music and do your job. Stop being illegal.

President.- Mr. Iglesias, indeed, this question is timely and reasonable, and I can tell you that my intention is to present the General State Budget Project on time, to have it approved by the end of June, just like last year. Then we were able to reach an agreement, and that was good for Spain and very well valued from abroad. I would like this to happen again in the 2018 Budgets. There is a piece of information that is very important and is sometimes overlooked, and that is that the spending ceiling has already been approved by this Chamber last June, and now we will continue working to take the second step, which is the approval of the Budgets themselves.

In any case, if it is not possible to reach an understanding, I remind you that the Budgets are already extended. Spain has Budgets, good Budgets, those of 2017, which served to generate more than six hundred jobs in Spain, and in addition, there are some other decisions that can be made through other procedures provided for in the legislation.

I have seen your budget initiative. You have no problem because you know perfectly well that it will not be approved; but when I saw it, I got the impression that it was the budget of a millionaire because there is no way to pay for it, quite frankly, Mr. Iglesias. Your budgets, or something resembling budgets, were budgets in which all items increased. Then there is no money to carry them out, which generates frustration and starts again with something we have already experienced in Spain and that should serve us all to know what to do and what not to do. The problem of the crisis in Spain was spending what we did not have and reaching a public deficit of 11 percent. We were on the verge of bankruptcy.

Therefore, let me make the Budgets and you dedicate yourself to other more entertaining activities.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Iñigo Jesús Alli, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Alli.- Mr. President, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, in its Article 22, states that people living in a society have the right to social security. In Spain, pensions are a backbone of the welfare system. Regardless of whether there is an agreement in the Toledo Pact, in which the Union of the Navarre People will always be in consensus to guarantee pensions, the three questions I ask you, Mr. President, are the following: first, what is your Government going to do to guarantee pensions currently and in the future? The second question is: what is your Government going to do to maintain the purchasing power of pensioners in Spain? And third, are you going to increase pensions by referencing them to the CPI? Nothing more.

President.- Ensuring the public pension system is one of the basic priorities of the Government, of yours, and, in general, of all Spaniards. When I first appeared in this Chamber to submit myself to the Investiture Debate, difficult times were coming. We were in the greatest economic crisis of our recent history, State revenue had fallen by seventy billion euros, which is no small amount, we all had to tighten our belts, and we did. There were only two exceptions: spending on pensions and spending on unemployment, which were the only items in the Budget that were not touched.

The goal now remains to guarantee pensions and their purchasing power, and for that, we must work in two directions: the most important is to create jobs, and the second is to continue making reforms within the Toledo Pact.

Mr. Alli.- Indeed, the condition of generating employment seems to me to be a necessary condition, but not sufficient. I say this because, if we analyze the quality of the jobs being generated, I must tell you that the contribution to the Social Security distribution system is indeed not a sufficient contribution to maintain stability and viability in the future.

I ask you this question for three reasons, Mr. President: first, because there is uncertainty in society, in the streets, and you have the opportunity to reassure pensioners currently; second, because even today, in this country, there are too many families whose pensioners are financially supporting many families and their children's families; and third, because, if I focus on Navarre — you must allow me this — I am very concerned about the situation of Navarre pensioners who are paying much more taxes thanks to the tax increase made by the Navarre regional government.

While no decision is made, pensioners at this moment, in this country, have received a burden, in which they are told that they are granted an increase of 0.25 percent of their pension. You and I know, Mr. President, that the inflation forecasts for this year and the future will be much higher than 0.25 percent. Therefore, the purchasing power of pensioners will be harmed.

That is why, Mr. President, my group, Union of the Navarre People, urges you to increase the pension revaluation index by referencing it to the CPI so that there is no reduction in the purchasing power of pensioners in Spain.

Mr. President, believe me when I say that I share your good intentions, as do all the members of this Chamber. The thing is, I have an important responsibility, which is to govern, and therefore, I must adjust spending to what the total income is.

I have told you that the most important thing to guarantee the pension system and its purchasing power is to create jobs. And I am going to give you a piece of information that is very revealing of what has happened in Spain in recent times: in 2011, when we came to power, for every pensioner entering the system, there were three fewer contributors to Social Security. 117,000 pensioners entered the system, and there were 355,000 fewer contributors at that time. However, in 2017, for every new pensioner, 6.3 jobs were created in Spain: 96,000 more pensioners in 2017 and 611,000 more contributors to Social Security.

This is the key. This is what allows us to guarantee that there is a pension system as good as the one we currently have in Spain and, at the same time, to ensure the purchasing power. Everything else is good intentions that must be held, but the responsibility of governing takes precedence over many things, as you know, Mr. Alli.

Thank you.