The President announced the State Modernization Plan at Casa Rosada.

Argentina Mauricio Macri · President of Argentina

22 February 2016 · Announcement of the State Modernization Plan · Casa Rosada, Buenos Aires, Argentina

Context
Macri announced Argentina's State Modernization Plan at Casa Rosada on 22 February 2016, outlining reforms for digital governance and transparency.
Main themes
State modernization, digital government, transparency and open government, public sector reform, e-government and paperless administration, human resources and public career, citizen services, federal digital agenda, accountability, technology and innovation
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,069
94th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
16.0
83rd percentile
Syntax
3.55
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%46%
  • Social 22%21%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Technological 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

180 sentences in 41 paragraphs

PRESIDENT.- Good morning. Before we begin, I want to remind everyone that today marks four years since the terrible tragedy we experienced on the Sarmiento Railway at the Once station, and precisely the parents and relatives, with whom we have been year after year, are the testimony of a State that must be present with works, with transformations, to guarantee not only our well-being but our safety. The theme of the day is precisely the State. Together with the great team that accompanies me, led - from the Ministry of Modernization - as we did in the City of Buenos Aires, we are committed to ensuring that the State is present, that it is at the service of the people, that despite attempts to convince us otherwise, we are all owners of the State. The State cannot act as if it were a refuge for politics. The State is the one that must guarantee that the hospital functions, that schools provide 21st-century education so that our children have access to jobs in such a competitive 21st century; that cell phones work; the trains; that the roads are safe; that energy is available; that we can go out into the street without fear, and many more things. It is there that we need the State to stop being a disordered, disarticulated, dark place, without information. Today we are here taking on the commitment to build that 21st-century State that we need to support the growth that we all want for our country, based precisely on transparency, on everyone knowing what is being done by the State, because the State functions thanks to our resources, to the taxes we all pay. That is why this transformation is based on the recovery of human resources, on technology, on processes, on systems, and on an Open Government. When I talk about human resources, I mean recreating the public career, the competitions, systematic training, that INAP dedicates itself to training each of our human resources, because the world evolves and the State must evolve. This will lead to each employee feeling proud of the work they do and being recognized by the rest of society. When I talk about systems, technology, processes, I mean putting an end to eternal paperwork, to mistreatment, to phones that do not answer, to long lines; something we have already done in the City of Buenos Aires starting with the electronic file. We had more than 30 million paper transactions per year that disappeared because now everything is electronic. The same must be done at the national level: organize the consultation system, have mobile applications that also allow us easy access to resolve our paperwork from a cell phone, from a computer, from a phone, recovering time, quality of life, respect from the State to the citizen. All of this is possible and we will begin to do it, as we will also do on the path of what is an Open Government that is accountable, that allows us all to control what is done with our money. There must be a unique purchasing platform, so that we do not find out late and badly through an official bulletin what has been done with our money. These are all things we are committed to, and with one more detail: we have the capacity, we know how to do it, and we want to invite every Mayor, every Governor, to be part of this digital agenda, to have a digital country. Some provinces have already started, and we invite the others and most cities to follow the model path that the City of Buenos Aires has taken, on a global level, to do it as a country. In terms of transparency, of access to information, Argentina - if I am not mistaken, Andrés - is ranked 54th in Open Government; access to information, Uruguay is 7th. We propose to be among the top ten countries in the world that provide the greatest transparency, greater access for citizens to their information, and for that, I insist, we want it to be an agenda not only of the national Government but of every province and every city in Argentina. We have a lot of capacity and infrastructure to share, as it should be in a federal country. Of course, none of these transformations that we have undertaken and that the Chief of Cabinet leads will happen overnight, but we are committed to being better every day, but for that, as I always tell you, I need every Argentine to continue supporting us, not to leave me alone in this task of transformation; and the responsibility of Argentine leadership to understand that we must move from words to actions, that means being responsible when it comes to managing and always being accountable with the same thing, which is telling the truth. It is from telling the truth and recognizing where we are that we will produce the changes. Now I leave you with Marcos and Andrés so they can delve deeper into any other questions you may have. Thank you very much.

IBARRA.- Good morning. The President made a broad overview of the topics that will be part of this Modernization Plan, which we are launching and which will indeed be framed in a decree that will be issued in the coming days.

I would like, before entering into the presentation we have prepared to understand the comprehensiveness of the plan, to make some references to what we have been seeing regarding the history and the journey of what has been developed and the State in Argentina.

The truth is that we have gone through different stages with States that have been subject - for example - to fiscal adjustments, but without any comprehensive plan aimed at the people, without any plan whose objective is the citizen, and we have gone from there to other States in different times, like the recent one, regarding transforming the State, in many cases, into true reservoirs of politics, of bad politics, of the malpractice of politics, which is financing certain types of militancy from public funds.

This plan aims to restore the State to its rightful place; to restore the Federal State to its place, and to encourage the different municipal States, the governorships, to do the same. That is why we consider it so important that the Plan be a comprehensive plan, which, as you will see, involves both a fundamental pillar such as human resources, as well as systems and technology; within the framework - as the President said - of a permanent transparency in the management of purchases and all management to share that information.

And I also want to emphasize something: we have analyzed a lot of what has been done in the relatively recent history of the country, much of what has been done in our places - and of course - we take into account decrees, such as the one from 2001, the modernization decree, during the presidency of De la Rúa; or more recent decrees like the one from 2005, from former President Kirchner, which was more focused on what was an electronic government plan; and some other developments that aimed at modernization issues, such as the creation of the Secretariat of Public Function, INAP itself. That is to say, there have been some attempts in the last 40 years - and some well achieved - regarding how a State should function in relation to the citizen. But this will be the first time that a plan is integrated, is comprehensive, considers all the pillars, and is part of the Government's priority agenda. It is not the plan of a Ministry, it is the plan of the Government, where all ministries and all areas of Government will work - and this is reflected in the decree itself - where we have set out to generate a plan with developments, with systems, that we will coordinate and push from the Chief of Cabinet with Marcos, from the Ministry, because we want to make a true fundamental transformation of the State.

I will now share with you the presentation, so you can see what it is about and, of course, over the days and months, we will share with you the different developments that we will carry out. Some images that are symbolic of what the State is today: the truth is that we find ourselves with these images of quantities and piles of files in all the offices you transit, and lines also for different procedures that need to be done. Well, that is what we are going to aim for, to improve all the internal bureaucracy, so to speak, to improve the timelines and make management transparent, and of course everything that has to do with the citizen.

In this area, we have developed the plan, based on 5 axes, as you see there, which has to do with what is, on the one hand, the digital country, that is, everything that has to do with the digital government strategy, the digital government technology plan, open government and public innovation; everything that has to do with results management and public commitments, and of course the development of our human resources.

We will go to each of the axes so that there is a better understanding one by one of what it is about; but of course we need to move towards an agile administration, with simpler, online procedures, and whose objective, as we said, is the citizen.

What main projects are we going to implement in this area? As the President said, everything that has to do with the electronic file, what we did in the City. This is a difficult process, area by area, that includes digitization but above all, all electronic processing to depaper the administration and speed up all internal procedures.

Also, from this, we are going to go to a very important project which is remote procedures, which allow the citizen, as you may have seen in the City, to request a driver's license, a procedure for a hospital, to register. There are countless registrations from different universes of citizens who need to stand in line, present documentation, all of this developing these platforms will be made feasible and will be greatly expedited.

Of course, what we are going to do, within the framework of all this, is to make management transparent; and there we will go to absolutely transparent purchasing systems and with platforms that are mostly digital, so that citizens will be able to follow and monitor all this; and of course all the use of the installed capacity and the technological capacity that the State has, because incredibly there is good infrastructure capacity in the federal Government that can be shared with the provinces and cities. And this gives us the possibility that if we do it well, public funds are allocated more efficiently, and can be assigned to other projects, because it is the federal State itself that provides these services in technological matters. And of course a project that seems very, very important to us and that today in the world, in different countries --in Latin America itself, as in Colombia-- is transcendent, is the concept of digital citizen, where each citizen can have the possibility of having access and a page, through which they can process all kinds of interaction with the Government, see the information regarding what they have done, based on their habits; and this really provides a significant management possibility that technology makes available to us today, among other projects.

Regarding what is the world of Open Government and public innovation, clearly the 21st century is the century of open government; citizens demand transparency from us, they ask us to share information, and this is what we are going to do. Not to mention, you already know - because we launched it in this room a few days ago - about the Open Government decree, which imposes on us, self-imposes the launch of the open data portal in which we will be recording information of all kinds; from the salaries of officials, from the works being carried out, from purchases, so in the coming days you will have information regarding the launch of the portal and the information we will consider. And as the President said, it is very regrettable that Argentina today occupies the 54th place in the ranking of Open Government organization; Uruguay is in 7th place and the truth is that we have the objective of bringing the country to the top positions in this area; not to mention, in the city of Buenos Aires, where we did this, where we launched the open data portal with the information Datasets, it is in a privileged position and has received awards in this area.

And of course, along with what is Open Government and public innovation, we will promote all participatory and collaborative spaces, the famous hackathons we did in the City, workshops with NGOs, with universities, because it is civil society itself that can help us a lot in this area, and we as Government and as Federal State, as we did in the City, must make information and infrastructure available so that together with civil society we can carry out many of these developments.

JOURNALIST.- (inaudible)

IBARRA.- Regarding results management and public commitments. This, based on the work that Marcos is carrying out through the Chief of Cabinet, is a crucial objective. For the Government to carry out its plans today, it must be an orderly government, one that plans, a government that takes on commitments. What happens is that the first commitments we must assume are our own commitments in each area of work, with our projects, our plans, and our management. And from there, we must make those commitments available to the citizens, and in this way generate a State that controls, that delivers results, that shows those results. So all of this is also a very transversal axis across all areas to have an orderly government that plans and fulfills what it commits to.

And finally, before explaining a little more about the digital country, the other key pillar in all of this is human resources; it is the development of our human resources. We have the example of what we did in the City of Buenos Aires; we need to value public employment, we need to elevate it, we need to assign staffing to the areas that need it, to the service areas. We need public employees to have their careers, which in turn should be closely associated with training. We need to revalue INAP, so that the courses relate to the current state of affairs, to technology, to information. And towards this, we have a goal, which is to have, at the end of this period, elevated public employees, satisfied, achieving their objectives, where merit is also an important variable that we will play in all of this.

There, you see the main projects related to careers, to INAP, to training, to competitions, of course. In the coming days, we will be generating - we are reviewing the competitions that have been held recently - as the ministries complete this analysis, we will quickly launch the competitions and ensure that every person entering public administration does so through a competition.

And finally, the axis that relates to the rest of the country is the digital country axis. The truth is that we not only have to bring these modernization initiatives and projects to the federal State, but we must encourage the entire country and its municipalities to work in the same way. The good news is that, as we have been discussing and as we have done in the last 60 days, we have met with dozens of 14, 15 provincial governments, with dozens of municipalities; and I told you that the good news is that the leaders and those responsible for each municipality are on this path, they are eager to understand that the state of public employment and the state of the States in Argentina is absolutely precarious. And the citizens demand that we rise to the occasion and provide them with developments that exist today in the world, that exist in the City of Buenos Aires and that exist in many other cities in the country.

So, we will promote this public policy by ensuring that there are developments such as the electronic file, various applications to save citizens time in procedures, so that appointments can be made online, to improve public service in general. And of course, a very important thing, which is everything related to infrastructure, to connectivity; and in this, the State has to play a huge role because the only way to reach these developments is to have connected citizens, connected countries, and for that, we will work a lot with the different connectivity networks and seeking that citizens enjoy all these benefits. Soon, for example, we will have 50 sites in different high-traffic cities, with wifi, and where you will see these different developments through agreements with the various cities.

In short, obviously, in honor of the limited time, what we wanted is to review the main axes and initiatives of the plan, but with an underlying message that is the need for integration, the need for the integrality of all these elements, because there is no possibility of transforming the State without considering public employees, public employment, on the same level of priority as technology and information and management systems. This is an integrated system of the entire government and that is perhaps the main message, beyond the innovation and the projects that we will be carrying out. So I thank you and I give the floor to Marcos, the Chief of Cabinet.

PEÑA.- Thank you very much, Andrés. Very briefly, I think the central issue here is not so much the discussion of whether the State is bigger or smaller, but rather a State that functions, that provides answers, that improves according to the possibilities of technology and the new tools that are available everywhere, in the national Government and also with the provinces and municipalities. A huge challenge, since there has been much deterioration, much damage after many years of empty discourse; a role of the State was demanded because at the end of the day, that was not verified in the daily lives of Argentines. So, in any case, we open the floor to questions and we will respond. Thank you very much.

JOURNALIST.- I want to ask about that, precisely. It is clear to me that the Argentine State is not functioning, that it is not at the service of the people, but there are urgent responses. You talk about 4 years to restart the State, to open it up, to make it transparent, to bring it to the forefront of transparency, as is the case in Uruguay; but what happens in the meantime, what do we do in the meantime? We need to provide answers today, and for example, one of the areas that is not functioning is the education sector: classes are starting now and there is a State that is not functioning much in that regard.

PEÑA.- When the President talks about 4 years, he is talking about a goal that obviously started on December 10. We are trying to change reality as quickly as possible, providing answers to some things, such as the Open Government decree, which is already in operation. What it takes is that many times we will take time ourselves as officials to have this information.

As the Open Government decree is already in operation, this leads to many of us taking time, even ourselves, as officials to provide the information.

There is little awareness of the deterioration that has occurred behind, sometimes, facades of much shine; but behind, there was a State that was dismantled due to poor organization, poor planning, and not having a real goal in that regard. So, I think it is not so much about waiting four years, but about working every day so that from here, not in the short term, but in the medium and long term, the trend begins to change.

IBARRA.- I complement Marcos. Indeed, every day, in the coming weeks, we will be generating different announcements and achievements regarding the things we are already working on. And, among other things, I give you an example: in the case of the Electronic File, the implementation of this will indeed have the entire organization of the State and the mechanism, let's say, and the platform of the Electronic File will probably be in place next year. This means that, gradually, in the different areas, you will see that the processing will be done in that way. And the same goes for the rest of the developments and projects. So, obviously, the objective of the Plan is for four years, but we will gradually have achievements and for that we have a plan and we will be realizing that plan with different initiatives and timelines.

JOURNALIST.- For the Chief of Cabinet: the President has placed special emphasis on training, as has Minister Ibarra just now. I want to go to a concrete fact: there is much concern regarding whether classes will start on Monday or not. This morning, the main representatives of CTERA said that there are no meetings scheduled with the Government and they have a congress on the 26th. I would like to know what the situation is from the Government's point of view.

PEÑA.- Here I think it is important to clarify a bit the things that happened last week, as you know, education is a service provided by the decentralized State in the provinces. For several years now, the national Government has participated in establishing a floor for the minimum salary, which is known as the national parity. But the reality is that the real parity occurs in each of the provinces. We, through the Ministry of Education, have been talking with all the governorships and with the City of Buenos Aires, precisely to coordinate a unique policy in that regard, with several objectives. On the one hand, to establish a minimum floor across the country, which is around 8,500 pesos - and that this is tied to the minimum wage for the future so that, precisely, there are no doubts, it is in some smaller provinces where this occurs, but it is where the most conflicts have arisen in recent years, because in many provinces where there have been strikes, they have been due to that issue. In fact, Minister Bullrich announced at the end of the year, in December, that the national State has helped those provinces so that no teacher's salary fell below the minimum wage. This is one issue. And another issue is what has been proposed and agreed upon with the governors to suggest that the provinces work on an idea around 25 percent plus the assistance that the national Government provides to reach the percentage of 30, 32 percent that has been worked on during this time. In the midst of that discussion, it was wanted - in our view - to manipulate the number a bit, that is, the conversation by some teachers' unions and, in that sense, the national Government considered that it was necessary to wait to sign the national parity until progress was made in the different provinces, which is what is happening now. If you remember, last year that national parity was signed a day before classes started, so it is not true that the argument is that the national parity is awaited to discuss in the provinces. In all provinces, there is a dialogue instance and discussions are taking place. Obviously, we want it to be resolved as quickly as possible so that classes can start normally, and that is our aspiration. We appeal, obviously, to the responsibility in that sense of all parties to be able to work in a frank and as honest a manner as possible in each of the provinces, to be able to resolve that issue and, from there, to be able to sign at the national level. What we are not going to do, and seeing that this could happen, we stopped for a few days what was done before, that is, that the national Government signed a national parity that did not take into account the reality of the provinces and then left each province to resolve on its own. That is not solving the problem; here the problem must be resolved as a team, together between the provinces, the City of Buenos Aires, and the national Government, and that is what we are doing. We are always optimistic and believe that, with good faith and sitting down at a working table, as is happening in almost all provinces of the country at this time, we will be able to bring that issue to a good conclusion. Then we will advance on the really pressing issues regarding education, such as the issue of educational quality, for example, or the possibility of improving education more and more as an equalizer of opportunities.

JOURNALIST.- For the Chief of Cabinet. I want to ask you about the Income Tax regarding two aspects. This morning it was revealed that the Ombudsman for the Elderly, Dr. Semino, disclosed that there are 110,000 retirees who, given the modification of the non-taxable minimum, will start paying Income Tax. I wanted to know if you will do anything to address that situation. And, secondly, is there a reason that justifies what the President of the Nation announced this weekend, so that during the 2016 period the update of the scales is not discussed in the National Congress, which, if not done, many tax specialists from all political parties say that this severely harms those who earn just above the non-taxable minimum.

PEÑA.- Regarding the second topic, I believe we were clear, and that is the essence of what was raised, that is to say, we want it to be discussed in Congress, because what we want is for a modification to be implemented starting in 2017, but clearly for that to happen, it has to be discussed in 2016. In this regard, I want to make two general considerations: on one hand, to be aware of the fragile situation of our country's economy. Argentina today has one of the worst fiscal deficits in our history, a situation inherited from the previous government, and that forces us to move with great caution and care in order to generate solutions to a structural problem such as the Income Tax, which, as a result of inflation, has transformed into something it was not; while at the same time we are trying to ensure that the State can also provide all the services and obligations it has. In that sense, an announcement was made that has a huge fiscal impact and represents a significant effort on the part of the State, not only at the national level but also from the provincial governments, which is a matter that also needs to be considered and that we have been working on with the governorships, since half of that tax is paid by the provinces because it is shared revenue. So, in that sense, almost 50 billion pesos are being transferred back to the citizens, generating a salary increase, regardless of the collective bargaining, between 9 and 22 percent. Almost tripling the non-taxable minimum, we believe that this is a very important step in this context and that the specific situations that arise, again, in a tax that is poorly designed and distorted by inflation, will be analyzed on a case-by-case basis. Our goal is to use 2016 to adjust not only this issue of that tax but also the tax system in general, which requires a lot of work. In that sense, open, frank, and responsible dialogue in Congress must be the way to move forward: to advance in correcting all these specific situations. I believe that, in that sense, we also appeal to the responsibility of political and union leaders who have said various things that we find all valid and worth considering because we start from the same place, which is wanting to correct this, but at the same time, we must be co-responsible because together we have to find a way so that one of the variables does not alter this fragile situation we are in, and we can quickly move towards the growth of our economy, which is the most important issue because we have been stagnant for four years in job creation, in growth, and that also affects the most vulnerable, the weakest, and impacts the entire economic system in general.

JOURNALIST.- Regarding the issue of retirees, will you address it?

PEÑA.- As I said, we will also address the issue of retirees. We have received that report, we will study it, and we will provide a specific response from the AFIP, but I want to be cautious regarding the information because it is very technical. Clearly, that issue, as we said last week, will be communicated by the AFIP or ANSES, in the case of family allowances, to avoid precision errors.

JOURNALIST.- You were just talking about technological advances and innovation for the State, but on the other hand, a major problem still persists with the lack of such an important resource as electricity for a large part of the population. Will the scheduled cuts continue, but what is the outlook for this coming year regarding this? And regarding the increase in gas prices, has the date at least been postponed for the start of winter? It has also been analyzed by some consumer associations the possibility that those affected by the lack of that service will not be subject to the increase. Is it likely that this will not happen to them?

PEÑA.- From the first days of government, we informed that we were in an emergency in the electrical system, especially in the Metropolitan area due to a very poor energy policy that generated, precisely, the collapse of the infrastructure, the enormous inequities in tariff issues, particularly between what is the Metropolitan area and the rest of the country, and the possibility of projecting a horizon of improvement. From there, we said that we would act with total transparency to make it clear that this problem is on the table and that it had been denied, because reality is stronger than everything, and we have been working on various measures aimed at proposing, in a horizon that will take two to three years, a normalization that will require a lot of investment, many works, and a lot of work. Therefore, the outlook remains the same as we proposed in December. We had been warning, and Minister Aranguren pointed out last week, that during times of high demand, due to several days of heat, there would be risks of cuts and that scheduled cuts were better as a way to avoid a more widespread collapse. That is what has been done and regulated day by day according to the demand resulting from the temperature. For now, that is the outlook for this year. We were clear in the sense that this will take time, but we do believe that all the steps being taken now are precisely to reverse the trend and that this will cease to be a problem in the future. Regarding the issue raised by consumer associations, as of today, we do not have a definition on that matter, but at first, we believe that it is a complex issue. Now, understanding that the increases are not necessarily increases based on a short-term result, but rather on a situation of equality given the enormous difference that existed with other provinces. So, in that sense, we do not see that it necessarily has that possibility. Regarding gas, we will announce it when we have a decision made. As of today, beyond the various pieces of information circulating, we are clearly studying the issue, but still, as we do with all matters, when we have a definition, we will communicate it in a press conference and analyze all of this.

JOURNALIST.- First, I wanted to say something: we were called for a press conference with President Macri. Beyond the prestige and the pleasure we have in speaking with you, we thought we would be asking questions to Macri, and he left, and we could not ask him any questions.

PEÑA.- We will be more precise in the invitation: the announcement from the President and the Government press conference.

JOURNALIST.- Perfect. Second, the question is this: President Macri has always said that he would have the best team in the last 50 years. In recent hours, Fernando Cerro was appointed as the Statistical Technical Director of INDEC, replacing the prestigious Graciela Bevacqua, a man who has a judicial case filed against him - by who was at that time a deputy and is now the Minister of Economy, Alfonso Prat Gay - for, among other things, overestimating GDP data. The case that Judge Sebastián Ramos has states that he is being investigated for fraud to the detriment of public administration, incompatible negotiations with public office, and the use of privileged information for profit. Will this man continue at INDEC or will you finally desist from appointing him?

PEÑA.- The appointment was made with awareness of the person (…) I mean, you can ask Minister Prat Gay more specifically about that, but what is considered is that, precisely, there is a more systemic problem at INDEC, not a personal issue. The key to (…) public, let’s say, the complaint we have made about a system that was based on a political decision to hide data and statistics and to alter that reality, beyond the role of the person. If he was considered for that role, it is because that person was committed to the President's objective of normalizing INDEC and being able to have reliable statistics, which is the central objective we want. This is also related to the State Modernization Plan. We do not believe that one should deceive, that one should lie, or that by distorting State information, one changes reality. Reality is reality, and today we have confidence in the team we have proposed. And beyond, obviously, lamenting the personal differences that may have existed in that case and the political commitment and political decision of this Government, it remains exactly the same.

JOURNALIST.- The question is for the Chief of Staff. I want to return a bit to the educational issue. There are some governors who have some difficulties in facing the increase in the teaching sector. Will there be assistance from the national government to the provinces in this case? And, second question, I would like to know if the Government can elaborate through you on how teacher training will be.

PEÑA.- Regarding the first issue, as I explained before, it is understood that the different provinces have different budgetary realities regarding the issue of teacher salaries, and clearly, we have been working together so that the national government can support the efforts being made by each of the provinces and that teacher salaries do not fall behind. This is done through various mechanisms, but it mainly relates to those objectives, that is, that classes start and that there are as few inequalities as possible - which there already are - between the teaching reality of each province. Regarding the specific issue, I would prefer that you discuss that with the Minister of Education, Esteban Bullrich, who can clarify it a bit more precisely than I can. Of course, we want to have the best teachers, to help them with the best training tools, the most contemporary and useful ones to work in the classroom. The teacher is a key piece in all that is the educational effort, which should not only be from the school but should be from the whole family, from the whole country so that in that way we can achieve the result we all seek: a better quality of education and that education serves as an equalizing tool of opportunities. Thank you very much.