Declaration by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the historical heritage and Christian roots of France, Le Puy-en-Velay (Haute-Loire) on March 3, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

3 March 2011 · Declaration on the historical heritage and Christian roots of France · Cathedral of Puy-en-Velay, Le Puy-en-Velay, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a gathering at Le Puy-en-Velay on March 3, 2011, to speak on France's Christian roots and historical heritage at the renowned medieval cathedral site.
Main themes
Christian heritage of France, French national identity, preservation of historical monuments, architectural heritage, French landscape and territory, cultural roots, heritage as duty, identity and diversity, heritage budget and state responsibility, Fernand Braudel, Cathedral of Le Puy-en-Velay
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,656
83rd percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.15
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
73rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 65%61%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Institutional 12%11%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

150 sentences in 63 paragraphs

Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament,

Mr. President of the General Council,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

As I climbed the steps leading to the heart of the Cathedral of Puy-en-Velay, just as millions of people have done before me for nearly ten centuries, I was deeply moved and, like them, struck by the smiling Majesty of this immense stone reliquary coming to meet me.

Nearly a thousand years ago, inspired architects who had no other technical means than their talent and their faith had the crazy idea to throw the nave of their church into the void to free it from the natural constraints that held it back and thus make this original volcanic chaos of Mount Anis the support point of a formidable spiritual viaduct launched towards Heaven. I am happy to have come here; I will keep, I ask you to believe me, a very personal memory of it.

I have visited France in all its territories, and I must say that nothing resembles the one I have just traversed.

There were certainly traces of older, forgotten cults here, as I have been told so well, but this architectural gesture — you will not hold it against me for saying disproportionate, disproportionate in the sense that it goes beyond human measure, that it is inspired — has completed and transfigured the work of nature.

These landscapes that surround us are an integral part of the identity of France, this idea expressed so intelligently by Fernand Braudel, the historian who devoted a lifetime of reflection, and it is not a coincidence of the mind, to France and the Mediterranean.

These landscapes of Velay embody France just as much as Mont Saint-Michel, the Pont du Gard, the City of Carcassonne, or the Palace of Versailles.

No one can travel through our country without encountering its History. A dense, rich, multiple History, sometimes tragic, often sublime.

Chartres, Amiens, Reims, Strasbourg, Paris, none of these cities would be what they are today in the eyes of the French and the rest of the world without these cathedrals towards which faithful and tourists alike still converge.

None of our cities, even those that were martyred by the two world wars, would be what they are without the treasures they hold. Here is a private hotel designed by Boffrand or Gabriel, here a palace where justice has been rendered for centuries, elsewhere museums that house an artistic heritage of abundant richness.

None of our countryside would be what it is without the castles that kings and princes have scattered along their path as so many testimonies of our national greatness.

This heritage, my dear compatriots, obliges us. This heritage is a chance, but it is first and foremost a duty. We are obliged by this heritage. It obliges us because not only must we pass it on to the generations that will succeed us, but we must embrace this heritage, without complexes and without false modesty.

The first duty that this heritage imposes on us is to preserve and restore it. This is a mission that the State cannot and must not shirk. The protection of our heritage is a political duty because it is our architectural and artistic heritage that inscribes our country in the "long time" of a multi-century history.

Neglecting our heritage is betraying the history of a country. Protecting our heritage is protecting the legacy of France; it is defending the most tangible signs of our identity. I often recall Lévi-Strauss: "identity is not a pathology," as one might say about this idea, and to all those who rightly defend diversity, I would like to say that without identity, there is no diversity, that at the origin of diversity, there are identities, and that it is not a sign of closure to believe in one's identity in order to better share it with the identities of others. But if one does not believe in one's own identity, how can one share with that of others, and how can one even receive the identities of others? We must not oppose identity and diversity. We must understand that for there to be diversity, there must be respect for identity.

Thus, protecting our heritage is protecting the legacy of France and resisting, my dear compatriots, the dictatorship of the present, the dictatorship of the immediate, and dare I say, the dictatorship of the interchangeable where everything is equal, where nothing is earned anymore, where everything has the same value. I sincerely regret that this depth of our history and culture has too often been abandoned on the altar of immediacy, ease, and uniform thinking.

Thus, I want to remind you here that in accordance with my commitments, and while the most serious economic crisis since the war was hitting us hard, the budget for the restoration of historical monuments reached the historic amount of 380 million euros in 2008, and 400 million last year. I do not reduce everything to financial considerations, but if there were only a speech without finances, I would fear that it might provoke some irony among you.

Aware of the cultural but also economic role of a unique heritage in the world, the Recovery Plan adopted by the government has allowed the reopening of restoration sites that had been abandoned, allowing the most beautiful jewels of our architectural heritage to deteriorate inexorably. But when we allow our heritage to deteriorate, we are deeply deteriorating our identity.

Thus, between 2009 and 2010, 47 of the 86 cathedrals belonging to the State benefited from a restoration operation. This year, other major projects will be opened, such as that of the Abbey of Clairvaux, another exceptional place and a living testimony of the contribution of Christianity to our civilization. In saying this, I am simply recalling an obvious fact: the contribution of Christianity to our civilization. In a completely different genre, the Familistère of Guise, a rare example of those social utopias that fascinated the 19th century, will undergo significant work.

Puy-en-Velay has of course benefited from these new funds, even if the main part of the Cathedral had already undergone a significant campaign of work that began in 1992. This masterful restoration mobilized the multiple talents of our architects and artisans and required nearly 8 million euros.

The interior restoration of the lower hall as well as the hall of states will be completed in a few months. One will be able to host cultural events related to the Sanctuary, the other will house from spring the most beautiful collection of priestly and liturgical garments in France. The Fruman collection, patiently and passionately built by a couple of discerning collectors, will finally be presented to the public thanks to a generous sponsorship operation, but it is the State that has taken charge of the restoration of the places while the Centre des Monuments Nationaux ensured, dear Frédéric Mitterrand, the museography.

This operation is exemplary in many respects, and I want to express the gratitude of the Nation to all its partners: collectors, sponsors, curators, local authorities, Mr. President and Ladies and Gentlemen mayors, leaders of our great cultural institutions... The combination of their efforts allows us to continually enrich this cultural network, which contributes decisively to the radiance of our country.

Caring for our heritage is fundamentally one of the keystones of the "living together" of the French. The founders of our Republic, notably Renan, never lost sight of this principle: among the essential elements that make up the soul of a Nation are not only the desire to live together, which is rightly spoken of so often, but also "the will to continue to uphold the heritage that one has received undivided": both, one does not start from nothing. No matter how brilliant a generation may be, it goes somewhere and it comes from somewhere.

If this "undivided heritage" — I take up Renan's words — assigns us the mission to preserve and transmit our heritage, it also asks us to embrace this heritage, to embrace it intellectually, to embrace it morally, and to embrace it politically. There is no reason for us to be the only ones in the world not to embrace our moral, political, artistic, and cultural heritage.

Embracing our heritage is simply recognizing who we are, knowing where we come from. Embracing this heritage does not obligate anyone to share the faith of the builders of Notre Dame du Puy, nor does it obligate anyone to share the faith of the thousands of pilgrims who come here every year.

No one is imprisoned by the life and choices of their parents or ancestors, nor even imprisoned by the history of their country, but I want to say that it is always dangerous to amputate one's memory. For an individual as for a people, a society, my dear compatriots, ignorance of oneself rarely leads to self-esteem. And this applies to us and, of course, to what we pass on to the younger generations. If we give up transmitting, if the only ambition is to transmit nothing, let us not be surprised by the result. If we have the ambition to transmit a lot, we will have only good surprises in the result.

And it is in this spirit that I wanted, with the Minister of Culture, to create a House of the History of France. The intimate appropriation of their past and their history by the French is the very object of our project, which I have entrusted to Jean-François Hébert, who will be assisted in this by a pluralistic and independent scientific council chaired by an eminent historian — Professor Jean-Pierre Rioux. I have seen the controversies; I would have a hard time not seeing the controversies. By the way, could we live without controversy? Sometimes, we see the controversy, we do not see the reason for the controversy.

Thus, this project of the House of the History of France, which I believe in very much, will be concretely translated, starting this year, by the opening to the public of the vast gardens of the hotels of Rohan and Soubise, in the heart of Paris, and by a series of prefiguration events, particularly around the theme of the origins of France.

I am sure that the revelation of these gardens, now hidden, and the possibility thus given to the French to place themselves in a chronology, in a continuity, in the "long time," will meet with curiosity and success that will quickly overcome the controversies.

But remember the maneuvers that hindered for several years the construction of the Musée du Quai Branly! They seem quite ridiculous today, in light of its immense popular success. For the French, even before the opening of this House, to become aware of what it can bring them, we have decided to exhibit in a place as emblematic as the Grand Palais a selection of the most beautiful relief maps of Vauban that are currently sleeping in boxes at the Invalides. This exhibition will open in February of next year. I thus want to invite the French to come discover the face of their country and their cities in the 17th century. It is to such discoveries that the House of the History of France must contribute.

It is also in the same spirit that I have ensured the realization of the new center of the National Archives in Pierrefitte-sur-Seine. This project of over 120 million euros will open at the end of 2012, as originally planned. It will be a historic moment for the restitution of the memory of the State and the Nation to researchers but also to all citizens, whether they are genealogists, amateur historians, or simply curious. Because the National Archives are of course the "papers of the State," but they are also the papers of all the French: from their civil status, you see, the oldest in the world, to their family papers carefully preserved since the 15th century in the minutes of notaries.

Peoples are like individuals: if they obscure their past, if they deny all or part of their identity, they run the risk of seeing one day what they have repressed resurface, but in a worrying form.

Christianity has left us a magnificent legacy of civilization and culture: the presidents of a secular Republic. I can say this because it is the truth. I do not proselytize; I simply look at the history of our country. Once this is said, I want to say that France has drawn from other sources: a few weeks ago, I recognized and saluted the Jewish roots of France. Gregory of Tours, the oldest of our historians, who in the same pages of his History of the Franks, speaks for the first time not only of the sanctuary of Puy-en-Velay but of the synagogue of Clermont! It was in Auvergne already, and Gregory of Tours was writing nearly 15 centuries ago! This is France. The France we love, the France we are proud of, the France that has roots.

France has always been at the confluence of several cultural influences, the traces of which are clearly visible, right here in Puy-en-Velay.

It is difficult to pass by the ancient cedar doors of the Cathedral and their inscriptions in the Sufi language without being impressed and moved by this meeting between the language of Islam and Romanesque architecture!

It is difficult to visit the statue of the Virgin, which, in the very heart of your cathedral, Your Excellency, has been the object of the greatest devotion for centuries, without questioning, as I have taken the liberty to do, the symbol that a Black Virgin represents. I am not an archaeologist, I am not a theologian, I do not intend to settle - I have enough problems to manage as it is - a particularly scholarly debate, but, upon seeing this Black Virgin, I thought to myself: "What strength this Virgin in majesty possesses, whose skin was not the same color as that of the faithful who came to venerate her in the Middle Ages."

It is also difficult to read the Roman inscriptions integrated into the medieval wall of the Cathedral without thinking, as the historian Claude NICOLET rightly said, "we are all Roman citizens." I have not believed that since I married Carla... It is a more general remark.

It is obviously not a question of remaining silent about the political and philosophical heritage of the Enlightenment, which serves as the foundation of our republican edifice. Even here, in Puy-en-Velay, where the statues, dear Laurent, of the Virgin and Saint Joseph dominate the city, that of Lafayette, a child of the land, reminds us of what we also owe to the children of the Age of Enlightenment. But let us not oppose one to the other. There is a continuum. There is an addition that makes the particular identity of France.

France thus draws its genius from all the influences that have crossed it and that have each left a bit of what one might call their cultural sediments. And emotion, I must say it is true, emotion, we have the right to be moved in the face of beauty. Even if beauty is relative, it is fitting that it does not disappear from the debate. We cannot debate only the small, only the ugly. We cannot debate only what diminishes. Perhaps we can also debate what is ugly? I mean that the emotion I felt earlier when I crossed the doors of the Saint John Baptistery resembled that which I felt in Lascaux last September. It was, here and there, the emotion one feels when History embodies itself in a place and suddenly one feels that one is in a tradition, which has known its ruptures but which has made us, with its continuity and with its rupture.

Well beyond the architectural beauty of this monument, I was struck by what was revealed to me from the results of the last archaeological excavation campaign. It appears that the foundations of the building and the baptismal font date back to the end of the 5th century. This baptistery would therefore be the exact contemporary of the coronation of Clovis and thus of the birth of France. This is no small matter!

It is indeed a "Place of Memory" that your place is, in the sense defined by Pierre NORA, and I can assure you that I will personally ensure, dear Laurent, I owe you that much, that the budget necessary for the restoration of this distinguished monument is found quickly. In a few words, if there is a shortfall... to make the total... I feel obliged, with the vibrant support of the Minister of Culture. We cannot say that it is a place of memory here and consider that it does not deserve the attention, including financial, of the State.

The Republic, my dear compatriots, is secular.

It therefore belongs to all citizens without any distinction, just as history, heritage, and the cultural treasure that the centuries have bequeathed to it also belong to them.

This heritage, the Republic must know how to share and appreciate. We must give our children the means to understand and decipher it.

The privilege of understanding Georges de La Tour, of admiring Picasso or Matisse must not be a privilege reserved for a few. We cannot accept a form of cultural segregation, which, if it were to occur, would kill the profound meaning of the words Nation and Republic. That is why I welcomed the unprecedented and imaginative initiative of the Centre Pompidou mobile. A removable museum, a nomadic museum that will allow major works of contemporary art to be placed in the parking lot of a large store, at the exit of a suburban high school, in the heart of a business area. The initiative will be historic because it opens a dialogue between the heritage of tomorrow and the daily lives of the French.

France must not forget what it was and what it is on the pretext that the world is changing and globalizing. It is quite the opposite because the world is changing, because it is globalizing. France must deepen its values, which are, moreover, universal values, and which will allow us to face the changes of the 21st century.

Building the Europe of tomorrow is, in essence, continuing to follow the path traced more than a thousand years ago by the first pilgrims of Saint James of Compostela. Were they not the first Europeans, those pilgrims?

Yes, it is here, in Puy-en-Velay, that for the first time in our History, women and men came from all over Europe. They did not speak the same language but they shared the same faith or, at least, the same hope to refer to ideas that are dear to me, for I believe that there are pilgrims who make the pilgrimage without having faith but who have hope. That would be a whole other debate, but it is the first time they walked together, these women and men who did not speak the same language, and in the same direction, side by side. They then followed this path that leads to that other European Finisterre that is Galicia.

What can be said of this street of the Tables that we climbed together earlier and which bears this name because in the Middle Ages it was there that the money changers set up their tables to convert the different currencies arriving from all over Europe into the purses of the pilgrims who, to travel together, had to change money and agree on a common value? There was no euro, dear Jacques BARROT!

It is no coincidence that the Way of Saint James was the first cultural route classified by Europe. But in essence, Europe knew well what it owed to this route of Saint James.

This morning I was given a pilgrim's staff, perhaps so that I too may be the pilgrim of this Europe that draws so deeply from its roots in history.

It is by keeping alive what we have inherited in knowledge, wisdom, and tradition that the paths we trace, the stones of our monuments, the forms of our Art will retain a profound meaning for us.

See, the tradition of welcome and protection in Velay towards the weakest and most vulnerable. This tradition comes from the ancient pilgrimages that cast women and men onto the roads, often exhausted, stripped of everything.

This was the reason for the existence of the Hôtel Dieu that I crossed and which was founded as early as the Early Middle Ages for the reception of the first pilgrims. This was the reason for the existence of this former General Hospital in which we are today, Mr. President. It is here, in Velay, that in the 17th century, one of the very first networks of solidarity was established, "l'œuvre du Bouillon" - the soup kitchen, the work of the broth.

Many centuries later, it is a few kilometers from Puy, in Chambon-sur-Lignon, that Protestant humanism rose up to protect Jewish children condemned to the Holocaust by a mad ideology.

This tradition of help and comfort is part of our identity, has never wavered in our country.

To all those in this room today but everywhere in France, who forge this immense chain of solidarity every day, I want to express my admiration and gratitude today. They contribute through their commitment to the image but also to the identity of France.

I came here before you to say that France has a heritage that it intends to preserve.

I came to tell you that France has a legacy that it must share.

I came to tell you that France has an identity of which it must be proud, but here, in Puy-en-Velay, perhaps a little more than elsewhere, it is evident that France also has a soul.

Thank you.