Excerpts from an interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in "L'Express" on May 4, 2011, on the fight against terrorism, the situation in Arab countries, the future of the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, European construction, immigration, and the assessment of his policy since his election in 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

4 May 2011 · Interview in L'Express

Context
Sarkozy gave an interview to L'Express on May 4, 2011, covering terrorism, the Arab Spring, Libya, and his presidency's record since 2007.
Main themes
Fight against terrorism, death of Osama bin Laden, Arab Spring and democratization, Libya and UN Resolution 1973, Israeli-Palestinian peace process, French foreign policy, immigration, European construction, hostage-taking policy, Islamists in democratic politics, assessment of Sarkozy presidency, stability vs. democracy
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,481
89th percentile
Sentences
259
93rd percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.70
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
60th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

259 sentences in 69 paragraphs

Q - Osama bin Laden is dead, but does the attack in Marrakech and the video of the hostages from Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb not show that France has once again become a target of terrorism?

R - France has always been a target for terrorists. Since the 1980s, there has not been a period when it has been spared: hostage-taking, attacks... The response is first and foremost firmness: we do not yield, we fight the terrorists. There can be no compromise between terrorism and democracies, there is no middle ground. We must combat this medieval form of barbarism head-on, without any compromise. The elimination of Osama bin Laden is a historic success, but unfortunately, it is not the end of Al-Qaeda and its ideology of hatred. The fight against the criminals who claim to represent it must unite all states, especially Muslim ones that are confronted with this scourge. Then we must support with all our strength the emergence of democracy in Arab countries. It will be the best response to these fanatics who also feed on the absence of freedom of expression. The Arab street expressing itself for democracy and non-violence is the best news for democracies, and the worst for obscurantists. The negative energy and frustrations accumulated over the years by these young and repressed societies will disappear with the rooting of democracy, which will generate growth and economic progress.

Q - Can we include "presentable" Islamists in the democratic institutional game?

R - Gathering is a necessity. There can be no gathering with terrorists, but we cannot exclude political or religious currents that nourish these societies, as long as they respect the rules of democracy. When there was the democratic transition in Spain in the 1970s, it was the designated successor of Franco, King Juan Carlos, who was at the center of it. In Libya, Muammar Gaddafi is disqualified from embodying even a little of the future, but to posit as a postulate that no personality linked to the regime will ever be able to hold responsibility would be a mistake: the system has been in place for 41 years! The president of the National Transitional Council was himself a minister, which does not prevent him from being a remarkable personality.

Q - Should we pay money to recover hostages?

R - The French state does not pay ransoms and does not yield to blackmail. It is a matter of principle. But there is another principle to which I am attached: every life is sacred. If a journalist from L'Express were taken hostage, would you not be willing to pay? And if your shareholder said "no, it's too expensive," how would you react? It is when you enter this concrete reasoning that you can measure the difficulty of the decisions to be made. If a company engages resources to save one of its own, it is a decision that I understand and respect.

Q - France has achieved success with the adoption of UN Resolution 1973 on Libya.

R - No, there is not yet a "success." The "success" will be when the Libyans have the freedom to choose their future. We are at a turning point in the foreign policy pursued by France since the end of colonization. I willingly accept the criticism of not having immediately seen the full significance of what became the Jasmine Revolution in Tunisia, even if I wonder who in the world saw it. François Mitterrand or Jacques Chirac, and then myself, were criticized for discussing with Ben Ali in Tunisia. But let us not forget that most of the regime's opponents were welcomed in France and that we had to have relations with the government in place. What happened in Tunisia forced us to reflect. The same goes for Egypt.

From General de Gaulle to Jacques Chirac, France's policy towards this region revolved around one word: stability; rather non-democratic regimes than the risk of a fanatical dictatorship. That was the reasoning. No intervention was possible from the outside, because one does not make a revolution by proxy. This time, the peoples have taken their destiny into their own hands, as in Eastern Europe once: it is Lech Walesa, it is Vaclav Havel who changed the course of events, not the West. Similarly, during the French Revolution: when the people decided to put an end to the monarchy, they did so without outside help. As long as the peoples did not manifest themselves, we could not do it for them.

Since the beginning of my term, I have assumed the continuity of French policy. Today, we have decided on a break that seems to me to be commensurate with the events we are experiencing: when the peoples demand their freedom, France will be by their side. Stability is an objective to be achieved through democracy and respect for human rights; it is no longer a reality to be preserved at the cost of so many injustices. In the name of stability, some of my predecessors preferred two Germanys and the maintenance of the Soviet Union...

Q - In Libya, how do you assess the situation on the ground?

R - It is improving on the military front: the National Transitional Council is better organized and the savage violence of Gaddafi's henchmen no longer allows them to progress. Without our intervention, the fate of Benghazi would have been ten times worse than that of Srebrenica. There were then 8,000 deaths, in front of the eyes of the international community; Benghazi has nearly a million inhabitants, and Gaddafi would have kept his promise to be merciless, as he showed in Misrata by indiscriminately bombing civilian homes. Today, his troops are retreating, the tribes are distancing themselves from him, and only the climate of terror reigning in Tripoli, with mercenary snipers on the rooftops, prevents the city from revolting. France has called for the intensification of strikes on military targets in order to achieve a genuine political and diplomatic negotiation. This is the only way to force Gaddafi's regime to return its soldiers to the barracks. As for the CNT, it must continue to open up to all currents of society. Once these steps are taken, we will let the Libyans build the new Libya. It should be a matter of a few months.

Q - That is to say?

R - Once the military objectives are achieved, political discussions will need to begin. France will take the initiative in the coming weeks for a major conference of friends of Libya, to build the future of this country, with all its political components, including, if necessary, members from Gaddafi's regime, provided they have broken with him and have no blood on their hands. It is not the same thing to serve a regime out of fear and to be complicit in its crimes. If we want to isolate Gaddafi and accelerate the rallying to the CNT, we will need to show openness.

Q - Are you seeking to eliminate Gaddafi, as the bombing of his palace seemed to indicate?

R - No. Democracies cannot act like that. It was a command center that was struck, not a man. The same question arose for Laurent Gbagbo, a dictator who wanted to plunge his country of 21 million inhabitants into civil war. Eliminating him would have been a crime; we did not want that and did everything to protect his integrity. I support President Ouattara, who wants to reconcile Ivorians and includes former members of Gbagbo's party in his team. The world is progressing. His governance, thanks to the UN, is more efficient. Today, a bloodthirsty dictator knows that he will not go unpunished. It will be the same in Yemen, where President Saleh will have to leave.

Q - And Bashar al-Assad in Syria?

R - The behavior of the regime is unacceptable. There is no future in violence against the people, in live fire against demonstrators. What is happening in Syria is deeply shocking.

Q - Do you regret having reached out to Syria at the beginning of your term, breaking with Jacques Chirac's policy?

R - No, because it is enough to look at a map to see that Syria is a major player in the Middle East. France's outstretched hand allowed for the cessation of attacks in Lebanon, the democratic election of a president, Michel Sleimane, the holding of free legislative elections, the formation of Saad Hariri's government, and the opening of embassies of Syria in Beirut and of Lebanon in Damascus. We discussed transparently with Bashar al-Assad and achieved these results. But the minute he represses his people in blood, the outstretched hand closes. That is what gives strength and coherence to our policy.

Q - What more can be done?

R - We will not accept that a regime sends the army against peaceful demonstrators. However, it is not necessary, in light of different political realities, to act the same way every time. We must be clear-eyed; military intervention will remain the exception, it cannot be the rule. For Syria, we will act for the adoption of the most severe sanctions. This will be effective. In Yemen, where Saudi Arabia is influential and doing a good job, the end of the regime is written. In Libya, there was no other way in the face of a regime that announced the massacre of its people. That is what I told President Barack Obama to explain the reasons for an intervention that had become urgent.

Q - Did you have to twist his arm to get him to agree?

R - You do not force a friend and an ally... Even if France's willingness to intervene differed from his, because the United States has other concerns than North Africa. They are on the other side of the Atlantic while we are Mediterranean.

Q - Are you not disappointed by the American waffling in the Libyan affair?

R - President Obama's situation is not easy. He is criticized for both his presence in Afghanistan and his "absence" in Libya. I regretted the departure of American planes from Libyan skies; I am pleased with the arrival of their drones. We need them, even if they and we do not always have the same priorities.

Q - But we cannot act without the United States...

R - Yet that is what we did in Côte d'Ivoire. I believe in another line of force in French policy: it is our responsibility to give credibility to the UN. The world of the 21st century needs a functioning UN system, which is not a wooden sword. The necessary tool for a multipolar world is the UN. France gains influence by playing the UN card, by being more collective. Similarly, with France's return to NATO, which some criticized me for because it was supposed to make us lose our sovereignty; it is a great satisfaction to see that this has not been the case: it is France and Great Britain that are currently exercising leadership in NATO in Libya.

Q - Is there a global American disengagement on the planet?

R - I do not think so, but the world has become multipolar. It can no longer and must no longer be dominated by a single superpower. I love the United States, their culture, the American dynamism. The French and Americans resemble each other more than they imagine, because they are the only two peoples that have a universalist conception of their message. China with its vast population, India with its diversity, Japan with the weight of its economy: none of these countries seeks to export its values, has the ambition of universality. France and the United States do.

Q - The United States less than before...

R - There is the weight of the Bush years, marked by unilateralism. And then economic challenges put domestic issues at the forefront, in the face of this emerging giant that is China.

Q - Diplomats have criticized the aspect of your initiative in Libya: the role of Bernard-Henri Lévy. What do you say?

R - I must listen to all criticisms and take all opinions into account. I smile, however, when I am told that I am giving too much of a role to Bernard-Henri Lévy, who is on the left, who supported Ségolène Royal in 2007 and says he will not vote for me. There is a French tradition of intellectual engagement, which is to the honor of our country. Why reproach them for real courage? Remember his commitment in Bosnia where he took François Mitterrand to Sarajevo: I approved at the time! When France intervened for Georgia in August 2008, so that Russian tanks stopped 40 km from Tbilisi, intellectuals like Bernard-Henri Lévy or André Glucksman were there: it is salutary and it is to the honor of France to have engaged intellectuals. They do not direct our foreign policy, however. Bernard-Henri Lévy went to Libya and brought the rebel leaders to Paris: I am pleased about that. But he is not my spokesperson and I am not his.

Q - The world is also changing in the Middle East: what is the evolution for Palestine?

R - First of all, it was a mistake to make the end of colonization a prerequisite for discussion between Israel and Palestine. France is unequivocally against colonization, but it makes no sense to set its cessation as a prerequisite for any discussion, because we know very well that at the end of the negotiation, some territories could return to Israel, others to Palestine, as part of an agreed exchange. The question of borders between the two states is therefore fundamental. Secondly, it is the Israelis and the Palestinians who will make peace, not the Westerners. Thirdly, peace will not be achieved if the United States does not get more involved. Fourthly, the Americans will not succeed alone. The meeting in September in Washington was a mistake, because there was neither Dmitry Medvedev, nor Angela Merkel, nor David Cameron, nor France. Fifthly, I will speak this week to Benjamin Netanyahu; he must, in my opinion, make it clearer that the Palestinians have the right to their state and act accordingly. France expects him to take the risk of peace. Throughout my political life, I have been a friend of Israel, but there will be no security for Israel without a viable, democratic, and modern Palestinian state.

Q - What are you going to do?

R - Europe must engage politically and not just financially. We will take an initiative before the summer, with the Europeans, to relaunch, with the Americans, the peace process, because Europe cannot be the largest donor to Palestine and remain a political dwarf in this matter. I want to express my support for President Mahmoud Abbas, and my satisfaction in seeing him act to unite his people, because nothing will be possible without Palestinian reconciliation. France wants the peace process to be relaunched before the difficult meeting in September at the UN.

Q - What is your position on this meeting, where the Palestinians will ask the United Nations to recognize them as a state?

R - If the peace process resumes during the summer, France will say that the protagonists should be allowed to discuss without rushing the timetable. If, on the contrary, the peace process is still at a standstill in September, France will take its responsibilities on the central question of the recognition of the Palestinian state. For 20 years, we have known the parameters of peace and we have hardly advanced. The idea that we have time is a dangerous idea. We must conclude. There are two good news: Palestinian reconciliation around Mahmoud Abbas and the democratic movement in Arab countries. Israel cannot be content with economic development in the occupied territories. The duty of Israel's friends is to tell it the truth. And the truth is that there will be no security for Israel without a democratic Palestinian state at its borders.

Q - The events in the south of the Mediterranean worry Europe: how to strengthen the Union?

R - The more time passes, the more I feel committed to the European ideal; I am more so than at the beginning of my political career, and even more than at the beginning of my term. I have learned that one cannot do things alone, no matter how strong France is. The defense and sustainability of our model of society depend on strengthening Europe. The main danger for Europe is stagnation. The priority is to integrate the Balkans: let us not leave a partly Muslim state alone in the heart of Europe. As for the rest, you know my position: enlargement to Turkey would be a historical and geographical mistake. Geography makes history, demography accelerates history. Finally, we must continue the economic integration of the eurozone. The debate between federal and confederal no longer makes sense, because we need both: federalism in the eurozone with the economic governance we have put in place; confederalism for those who are not in the eurozone, because the more numerous we are in Europe, the more flexibility will be needed.

Q - And Schengen?

R - I believe in Schengen, but the system must evolve; it is currently at the end of its rope. With the democratic prospects in North Africa, we must be ready to train students, welcome businessmen; but to accept everyone, as the French socialists say, no, it is the entire balance of our social system that would be called into question. These countries need their elites to develop. Who manages Schengen in Brussels? No one. Who evaluates Schengen at the borders? No one. Who assesses best practices in Schengen? No one. Sangatte, in 2002, was like Ventimiglia today: Kurds, Iraqis, Somalis wanting to go to England. It took us 5 years to resolve the issue. Europe must help Italy to do the same with the Tunisians. France, the most generous country in terms of asylum, will make proposals at the European Council in June. After the first elections in the new democracies of North Africa, there will need to be concerted immigration rules and shared economic development.

If a European country cannot maintain its borders, the question of the temporary suspension of Schengen must be raised without taboo.

Q - Is the rise of populism in Europe a consequence of this stagnation?

R - Why do you say "in Europe"? What are the Tea Parties? And Sarah Palin? And Hugo Chavez? The more the world becomes a village, the more people realize that their fate depends on what happens at the other end of the world, and the more they are viscerally attached to their territory. Contrary to predictions, globalization has strengthened the need for rootedness. One of the greatest French intellectuals of the 20th century, Lévi-Strauss, said: "Identity is not a pathology." That is the key. Citizens of the world understand that they are interdependent, but do not want a flattened culture. However, interdependence creates a middle identity, a middle culture, which feeds fear and gives rise to movements like the "True Finns." Rather than saying "that it is immoral, that it is ugly, populism!", comfortably settled in the feeling of belonging to such an arrogant elite, let us understand these fears and provide concrete answers: reform of Schengen, regulation of globalization, economic governance, tax on financial transactions...

The response to the suffering of peoples and fears must be concrete, pragmatic, grounded in reality, and in no way moralizing or lecturing.

Q - Meanwhile, Marine Le Pen and the FN are rising, as seen in the cantonal elections...

R - Let us analyze the facts precisely: out of 1,900 cantons at stake, only 2 cantons were won by the FN. And even then, this party did not receive more votes than in the regional elections of 2010. In the first round, because it does not count, some of our fellow citizens may feel that they can vote for the FN to express their dissatisfaction. But we must realize that there has never been in the history of the world since 1945 a crisis like the one we have gone through, affecting all sectors and all regions. Let us not be complacent in the face of this phenomenon; responding to fears with moralizing is unbearable. When I see calls to Tariq Ramadan, who is a fundamentalist, to respond to Le Pen! I wonder if some see the gap between what they say and what the French are experiencing.

Q - Claude Guéant's proposals on limiting legal immigration are raising criticisms, such as that of Alain Minc: "It is a theme whose unconscious rhymes with protectionism, corporatism, malthusianism, all tinged with a hint of xenophobia." Do you hear them?

R - Claude Guéant was right not to make it an ideological question: the working population of France is increasing by 110,000 people per year. That is to say, before reducing unemployment by one unit, we must have already created 110,000 jobs! With our difficulties in providing work for all our nationals, and an unemployment rate of 23% for non-EU foreigners, we must ask ourselves the question of legal immigration: it is common sense. I would not say the same thing if I were leading Germany, where there are 100,000 fewer workers per year. I have never been for zero immigration, because civilizations collapse through inbreeding and not through the "melting pot." But we must adapt economic immigration to these realities and ensure that our vocational training meets the needs of our economy.

Q - Is an austerity cure inevitably awaiting France in the coming years?

R - I do not like the word "austerity." Why should we choose only between austerity and laxity? What if we simply had to follow the path of reason? France has created a million civil service jobs since the early 1990s: that is unreasonable. We have eliminated 150,000 since 2007 and we must continue this policy, because France has a level of public spending that is too high. The problem, particularly in education, is no longer the number of civil servants, but the quality of their remuneration and training, as well as the redefinition of their mission: this will be a great debate for the next presidential election... I was not elected for France to beg or extend a hand. I ask the French to look at what is happening in Greece, Ireland, Portugal, and even the United States. France has 1,590 billion euros in debt and pays 45 billion euros in interest per year. If we had not reformed pensions and implemented the "one in two" in the civil service, France would no longer be rated "triple A," which allows us to borrow at 3.6%, while Greece borrows at 16% for ten-year terms. Those who say they will reverse the pension reform are lying to the French. Those who say we need to hire civil servants and increase our spending are lying to the French. We have reduced our deficit this year by 14 billion euros more than expected: we must continue. This is not austerity; it is reason. And it is time for France to be reasonable after 35 years of budgets presented in deficit.

(...)

Q - You have been on the front line since 2002: do you ever fear that your personal connection with the French will be broken?

R - There is suffering because of the crisis, and it is only natural that as head of state, the dissatisfaction is directed first at me. But I lead France, which presides over the G8 and G20: do you think I have time to engage in such a narcissistic exercise? Moreover, while I doubt a lot, I fear very little. I must doubt in my work, then overcome my doubts to find solutions. In the face of each problem, I strive to find the right answer. Asking whether an initiative will please or displease is not the idea I have of the role of head of state. In the face of the crisis, the Arab revolutions, the reform of Europe, I have a duty to the state, which is to make and explain decisions; I do not have the luxury of thinking about my "personal connection." I am in perpetual questioning about what I do; I do not question my image. I have believed for a long time that the best communication is results and facts.

Q - Does the 2007 program remain your reference?

R - Yes, but not because it was my program, but because I believed in it and still believe in it: rehabilitation of work, refusal of work sharing, restoration of authority and security, refusal of assistance... Obviously, there was the crisis that made things more difficult, but I have done everything to implement my commitments, and overall, I believe that collectively we have largely succeeded, thanks to the efforts of the French. With Prime Minister François Fillon, we have not backed down on any of the difficult reforms: minimum service, autonomy of universities, pensions. Even in terms of purchasing power, to your surprise, the results are encouraging: France is one of the only developed countries where, according to INSEE, it has increased during the crisis, including in the civil service, with +3.6% in 2009 and +2.0% in 2010.

(...)

Q - Is it important for France to keep one of its own at the head of the IMF in the coming years?

R - France proposed Dominique Strauss-Kahn because he is a man of quality, not just because he is French. I am always pleased to see a Frenchman at the head of international institutions. Likewise, I proposed Mario Draghi for the European Central Bank because he is excellent, not just because he is Italian, even if we feel so close to Italy.

(...)

Q - Is your candidacy for a second term "an open secret," as Alain Juppé said?

R - I am pleased every day to work with Alain Juppé as Minister of Foreign Affairs... I appreciate his competence and sense of state. I therefore take his remark as a compliment.

Q - Do you regret not having appointed him earlier?

R - What would regrets serve? What is certain is that he is a major asset for French diplomacy.

Q - So we can believe what he says about 2012?

R - He is a credible man who says the right things! However, I am the last one who can express any desire regarding the next presidential election. I am the president. I hold the office, so I have a duty that others do not have. It is called the servitude of power. I do not have the right to engage in calculations so far from a deadline that is not yet on the minds of the French.