Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the digital economy and the creation of the National Digital Council, in Paris on April 27, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 April 2011 · Statement on the digital economy and the creation of the National Digital Council · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed ministers, parliamentarians, and digital sector stakeholders in Paris on April 27, 2011, to announce the creation of the National Digital Council and outline France's digital economy strategy.
Main themes
Digital economy, Internet's economic impact, e-commerce growth, National Digital Council, digital transformation of society, digital divide, employment and job creation, public services digitization, transparency and open data, industrial and commercial disruption, training and digital inclusion
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,580
89th percentile
Sentences
221
91st percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%34%
  • Economic 23%21%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Technological 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

221 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen deputies and senators,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Dear friends,

Few phenomena have an impact on history as they touch and disrupt everything we know, forcing us to think about the world in new ways. The Internet is one of those phenomena. It opens a limitless virtual world. It disrupts the world as we know it.

Nothing today escapes the changes that the Internet and digital technology bring to our personal and professional lives. The Internet is everywhere, that is a fact, and many assert that this is just the beginning.

When we talk about the Internet today, we are not just talking about a technology or a medium but about a whole sector of activity. This sector has become essential to our economic growth as it contributes more than 70 billion euros to our gross domestic product. In terms of added value, it is already more than key sectors like energy or transportation.

The widespread use of the Internet, and this is its strength, is a driver of growth for other sectors of our economy. More than three-quarters of the added value created in our digital economy does not come from new players but from traditional companies that have developed online activities.

Thus, the Internet is much more than a sector; it is a transformative force that permeates our entire society and whose contribution to the growth of our economy and to employment is accelerating. I was very surprised, by the way, while preparing for this meeting, to note one fact: the Internet contributed to 25% of our growth over the last two years and created more than 700,000 net jobs in the last 15 years. The Internet accounts for more than one million direct or indirect jobs and a quarter of the new jobs created in France over the past five years.

The consequences of this major impact of the Internet on our economy are considerable.

The Internet has led us to rethink the retail sector profoundly: 28 million French people shop online today (+3 million in one year), for a total amount of more than 31 billion euros in 2010. There are 82,000 active e-commerce sites in France: if these shops existed in the physical world, it would represent more than 2.5 additional stores in every municipality in France... I apologize, I imagine you all know this by heart, but I believe it is important for the French to understand; they sense it, but they need to truly understand the major economic impact of the Internet.

For consumers, e-commerce is an opportunity. But for traditional retailers, everyone knows that the Internet is a headache that transforms their profession every day. I note that France has produced great successes in e-commerce, with business models that have inspired many competitors internationally.

Similarly, in industry as well as in services, the Internet has radically changed working methods and production modes. Electronic communications, collaborative management tools, the ability to exchange in real-time with a supplier or partner on the other side of the world, telecommuting are all new methods that our companies must integrate or risk simply becoming uncompetitive.

But the life of the company is often disrupted by the arrival of new professions, and digital technology is sometimes seen as a threat by those who do not master their tools. The digital divide is not just a question of equipment and infrastructure; it is also a question of training. The digital divide is what the worker experiences when he realizes that his company is asking him to change professions because the advancement of technology requires him to become open to this new technology, and one cannot work with someone who does not understand that this is not the world of tomorrow; it is the world of today. We must think together about these challenges so that the opportunity of the Internet benefits everyone. And you, the actors of the Internet, cannot accept that in the name of the Internet, there is exclusion, whether territorial or social.

The State itself is not immune to the upheavals of the Internet, which compel it to rethink some of its structures and missions. This is what led us to create the interministerial directorate for information and communication systems (DISIC).

In recent years, administrations have made significant efforts to develop online public services. It is true that these efforts are uneven, but there have been efforts, and beyond the development of online public services, the Internet has contributed to strengthening the demand for transparency that citizens are entitled to expect from their governments. Transparency is an important word; it is not without posing problems, but it is a requirement, transparency, and it is brought about by the Internet. It is for a more transparent State, an exemplary democracy, that I have asked the government to create an online public data portal, which we will do, because the issue of access to basic data is absolutely central and cannot be compromised. Either we will endure it, or we will claim it. It is not without difficulties. Moreover, all of you business leaders know perfectly well that access to your companies' data is an element of economic democracy, but it also poses problems for you. But just because it poses problems does not mean we should not do it. We must do it; it is a choice, and from my point of view, it is a choice without return.

The opening of public data should allow the ecosystem of developers and start-ups to invent new services for citizens. Again, we call on Internet entrepreneurs to imagine the services that the State has not yet created.

The Internet realizes part of what the Enlightenment philosophers set as a goal with Diderot and d'Alembert's Encyclopedia: to make all knowledge available and accessible to the greatest number. What they dreamed of, you have achieved. The sources of information are countless; simply, does their abundance suffice to form judgment and critical thinking? No, but that does not mean it is not progress.

Naturally, we must question the imperative for students to learn their lessons when they can mobilize all the knowledge of the world available on their Internet-connected mobile phones. And when all the students in the class are able to give the same presentation, we must also question the authority of the teacher when the student thinks he can know everything through the network, with a click. It is progress that knowledge is available, and it is progress that knowledge is abundant, but it nonetheless underscores the necessity of the hierarchy of knowledge and its organization.

The same goes for an even more fundamental dimension of learning: that of socialization. The Internet redefines how we meet others, how we exchange with them, and how we stay in touch.

Blogs, forums, and social networks multiply our capacity to exchange, discuss, and debate. The French are particularly active on these platforms: 14 million blogs, Skyblog is the leading blog publisher in Europe, and there are 20 million of us on Facebook. The image of a France resistant to this new world is absurd. Millions of couples have formed on dating sites, and it is no longer embarrassing today - I don't even know if it ever was - to say that you met your husband or wife, your partner, on Meetic.

The Internet is a tremendous tool for amplifying our capacity to know and exchange, to reach out to others. It is inconceivable to do without it.

So, the economy, industry, education, socialization: you can see that the questions posed by the Internet are eminently political, in the noble sense of the term; they question you, they question us about how we should organize the life of the city in all its dimensions.

More profoundly, by changing the way we work, how we inform ourselves, how we exchange, and by modifying how young people develop their personalities in interactivity, the Internet acts on all components of identity, not just of a country, but personal identity. My job, my learning, my knowledge, my friends are all elements that will define who I am or who I wish to be.

The change brought about by the Internet is therefore not only read at the scale of a change in economic model or a generational shock; it is read at the scale of civilization as a whole.

This is what makes the Internet an unavoidable subject. This is what makes censorship of the Internet or its collective deprivation an unacceptable violation of a people's freedom of expression, as we have recently seen in the Arab world.

For a people, the ability to communicate via the Internet lowers the threshold of tolerance to oppression: through the Internet, those who revolt can realize that they are not alone, that they do not necessarily have to be afraid when they go out into the street and when they have to face physical oppression. France stood against the cutting off of the Internet and telephone by the Egyptian government in January 2011.

So, in the face of these upheavals, what policy should be implemented? What is the role of the State in this dynamic, which everyone knows is driven by entrepreneurs, the private sector, and - a term I do not particularly like - civil society? What working method should we choose to make the right decisions? These are extremely weighty questions.

I believe that the role of the State cannot, in any case, consist of stifling the development of the Internet; that would be morally unacceptable and, moreover, it would not make economic sense. The role of the State is not to build Maginot lines against the uses of Internet users or to ignore the incredible space of freedom that the Internet represents. The role of the State is primarily to recognize that the Internet is a tremendous progress. It is progress, and it must be experienced as such. It is a land of entrepreneurs where anything is possible.

But the role of the State is also not to let things happen, to let behaviors pass that do not respect our fundamental principles. The last century taught us that every technological breakthrough required a reminder of our fundamental principles. Why? To avoid mistakes, and because, fundamentally, we cannot consider a technology as either good in itself or an end in itself.

What matters is what we make of it. The Internet is a territory still largely virgin, in permanent expansion: in itself, the Internet is neither good nor bad. The question is what we want to make of it. And we understand the place of the State when we understand the dynamics at work in the Internet and the role played by people like you: developers, creators, entrepreneurs.

My conviction is that the Internet is a limitless territory whose borders cannot be regulated solely by law, regulation, or authority because law, regulation, and authority can at any moment be challenged by technological innovation and by usage: a new way to listen to music, a new way to inform oneself, a new way to buy and sell, a new way to socialize, to exchange.

In these conditions, it seems to me that the role of the State is twofold.

The State must first ensure the rule of law and defend the fundamental principles and values that are ours.

And then, the responsibility of the State is to encourage the evolution of the rule of law to integrate the benefits of technological innovation. But as technological innovation moves so quickly, I would not want the rule to always lag behind. That is indeed the problem; it is a question of parallel speed.

I would like to address a topic that may have upset us, HADOPI. But HADOPI is not an end in itself. HADOPI is, at a moment in history, an imperfect solution found to a imperative that I consider categorical, immutable in my mind: the defense of intellectual property and the rights of creators. I am not someone who changes my mind on such fundamental matters. Creation needs to have its right to property recognized; France created copyright and authors' rights. This is not a small matter. It is an essential matter, at least in my eyes. But can we do better than HADOPI? Undoubtedly, but that is not really the question. For my part, I await the day when someone will come to tell me that HADOPI is no longer necessary, that we can do without it because an entrepreneur has found a way to guarantee a distribution system that allows for respect for intellectual property and fair compensation for creators. Ultimately, that would be the best outcome, because we will say: "But are you ready for HADOPI 3?" Of course, I am ready for it, but I am even ready for a HADOPI 4 that would be the end of HADOPI, because we would have found, you would have found, a system that guarantees fair compensation for those who are writers, who are authors, who are composers, who are directors. I also take my share of the error. The intuition I had was that we could not leave creators defenseless. But perhaps the clumsiness we exhibited was to give the impression that you wanted to attack creators. Ultimately, if we had learned to communicate better, - I should have taken the initiative earlier, by the way - we could have found another system. This is very important, but what I want you to understand is that HADOPI is not an end in itself in my mind. Just as the Internet is not an end in itself, just as technology is not an end in itself.

I say this to entrepreneurs: mobilize your creativity and your imagination not to break or infringe the constraint, but rather to rely on the constraint and surpass it.

To imagine the future, we must work together. For us, there is a revolution to understand this new world, but for you, it is also significant to accept the hand that is extended. It is an effort on both sides, because I believe we need each other. And that is why I wanted to create the National Digital Council. I thought, we cannot remain two worlds that ignore each other, that worry each other, that misunderstand each other. We must try to bring people together. I wanted to gather competent personalities from the French Internet, mostly entrepreneurs, so that for every project - I say every project - of legislative or regulatory provision that could impact the digital economy, the government would be obliged to seek your opinion and benefit from the insights that will come from the sector in question. That is the purpose of the National Digital Council. I can already see the vastness of those who do not belong to it, asking me why I did not want content publishers to be included. Why? Because they are already represented. They already have their own representation. I do not want the CNN to become a place for traditional oppositions. I want the CNN to represent your universe and give us your sentiment. I can also be told: "You do not have consumers," but they are already represented. The National Digital Council is neither to attack nor to defend content producers, consumers; it is to have the sentiment of the digital world on everything that is legislative or regulatory. We may disagree, certainly, otherwise it would no longer be a democracy, it would no longer be France. Imagine if we agreed on everything! A part of the essence of our country would immediately disappear before our astonished eyes!

That is not the question, but there is something much more important: that no one can say: "I was taken by surprise, I could not give my opinion, I could not make my argument heard." What drives people mad? It is not that they are not listened to, that they are not followed; it is not being able to make their arguments heard, defend their positions, make their expectations understood. I am sure that at that moment, we will achieve a sense of responsibility from everyone and that we will be able to find many more areas of agreement.

This insight from the CNN is that of a professional world dominated by youth, with a few rare exceptions, and I see them! A youth that characterizes this council whose members reflect this sector: free and enterprising. The CNN will therefore give opinions, formulate recommendations because it is not a question of you waiting for us to solicit you. Be proactive, propose everything that, in your eyes, can promote the development of the Internet in France. There are a thousand examples, but I know that when we eliminated a number of tax niches, without being aware of it, we affected the financing of some of the most dynamic digital companies. This is what you have pointed out to me. That is not at all the objective. But from the moment the world of the Internet was not organized, representative, it could not make itself heard on this. Know that the government is very much listening to you.

Naturally, the CNN will be free in its opinions and free in its initiatives. It is you who will set the agenda and your timetable. In any case, I wish that the government's decisions are informed by the reflection of the CNN, by its listening, by the dialogue with the sector, to avoid misunderstandings and delays.

I want to thank the 18 members of the National Digital Council who accepted this proposal. I specify that it is a voluntary mission. I know they have shown openness; it is not easy for everyone to accept this extended hand. I still believe that it is a sign of intelligence to open up, against the habits of sectarianism. It is a sign of responsibility. I want to acknowledge the work of all those who have made it possible to get here; I think of Pierre KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, with his consultation mission, of Eric BESSON, the minister in charge of the digital economy, who has done a great job, and of all those who participated.

One day, I was asked who should be the president of the CNN. We are in the digital realm, but there are still reflexes! I thought: "In the end, what if the 18 members freely elected their president?" The president who will be chosen will be just fine. I also say that the number 18 is absolutely not set in stone. There is a minimum level, because otherwise we could no longer work, but if it turns out that there are omissions or people who want to participate, why not. What I wish is for the CNN to be free to organize itself as it sees fit: the only thing I ask of its members is to work openly, in good faith with all the actors of the French Internet ecosystem, in all its diversity: consumer and child protection associations, large national or international companies, French developers and entrepreneurs. I also ask the CNN to create a close dialogue with the legislator. Some prestigious parliamentarians are here; it is up to you to create this close dialogue, and I want to pay tribute to the deputies and senators who carry the vision of the Internet and digital sector in Parliament. I am aware that there are immense inequalities in understanding and training in the digital world, but it can also be a mission of the CNN to help lift everyone up.

I will conclude by saying a few words, under the guidance of Maurice LEVY, who helps me a lot on this subject. The CNN would make no sense if it were confined to the national territory. I am even aware of the somewhat offbeat nature of planning a French CNN, that is to say with borders, to represent a digital sector that, by definition, is global and has no borders.

I ask you to consider the CNN as the first element of an international policy that we will pursue with the G8. I see only advantages in the French CNN initiating CNNs in other countries; we could even have a CNN of CNNs. It is a French initiative, but naturally what we want for the French digital economy would make no sense if what we decide among ourselves did not have the vocation to apply one day to the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, Japan, and everywhere else.

I wanted the Internet, which is a global phenomenon, to be on the agenda of the G8 summit of heads of state and government in Deauville. You cannot imagine what a force of conviction it took to convince 8 heads of state and government to talk about the issue of the Internet. There were all those who were passionate about the Internet but who said to themselves: "If we talk about it, they will think we want to regulate them." There are all those who are not absolutely passionate or who are overwhelmed by other problems and who say: "Listen, with Japan, Egypt, Libya, that's enough." But they all agreed. And in the lead-up to the Deauville summit, on May 24 and 25, we will gather in Paris the eminent representatives of the Internet world who will participate in an "e-G8 forum" whose discussions will inform the reflections of the heads of state and government. I have even planned for the representatives of the forum to speak directly to the 8 heads of state and government to tell them what they expect from us. It is colossal. Moreover, in the United States, they are watching what we are doing to see how they too can set up - I am careful with my words - what is the beginning of an organization.

I hope that French actors will be mobilized to contribute to this global reflection whose challenges are shared everywhere on the planet. Take a question like digital taxation; it is an extraordinarily difficult question. It is not a question of working on it without an international dimension and without you telling us what your point of view is. There are sensitive issues, like the Google tax. All these issues are precisely because they are sensitive that we need to talk about them and not say: "My God, I will set that aside." We need to talk about all this to avoid misunderstandings and to try to carry out a global reflection.

You are actors of the Internet; there is not one of you who is for tax fraud... officially, at least! In the vast majority, we cannot consider it normal that one comes massively into a market like ours and relocates all taxation with the sole concern of tax maximization. Tax competition is something healthy, normal. But is the systematization of this something you can accept? Here is a value that is part of a corpus of basic values, beyond the differences between the opposition and the majority, the left and the right. You live in a society: there are infrastructures, there are public services, there are words called generosity, solidarity, which are commonly used in the Internet. When there is a particular actor who, consciously or unconsciously, circumvents the entire system... Does that mean it would be normal for a state like ours to finance all infrastructures, but it would be abnormal for a state like ours, which has financed all infrastructures, to simply ask the question of the number of jobs created, of the taxes paid, and that this goes to a place in Europe or elsewhere because one pays less tax there? If you were in my place, you would ask yourself the question. It is not an illegitimate question. Between that and having a tax system that would penalize the creation of businesses on the Internet, between nothing and too much, is there not something to invent? Moreover, I would like to tell you one thing; there is undoubtedly in our legislation to clean up in front of our door, because I know perfectly well that a number of you are forced to place a number of platforms outside the country because the legislation is much more open. It is not just a question of taxation, but also of legislation.

I am deeply European, I believe in Europe, but I want the best regulations for my country, not the least good. So here too, these are subjects that are not taboo. When a number of you have to settle elsewhere, our reflexes can lead us to say: "Ah, the bad ones, the wicked ones!" But we can also ask ourselves: "What did they find elsewhere in Europe, why couldn't they find it in France? And what should we do for them to find it in France?" This does not mean that we will agree, but at least let us pose the problem. It is really an opening that I am making by questioning you about the balance to be found between no taxation and a taxation that would prevent you from innovating. Can we not find a meeting point? I am overwhelmed with requests from user advocacy associations. All the questions of morality, of fighting against pedophilia, I attach great importance to. But again, freedom is the foundation, it is the rule. However, can we not agree together on a minimum corpus that ensures that you, for the image of the digital economy and the internet, are not constantly justifying things that are completely foreign to you? Do we not have an interest in discussing these subjects rather than immediately defending ourselves? I have strayed from my speech, but this is truly what I think.

For me, in the National Digital Council, digital taxation is not a taboo subject. Anti-terrorism security is not a taboo subject; it is a subject I would like us to discuss with you. There are not irresponsible people on one side and overly responsible people on the other. The question of copyright, the question of funding and the independence of a number of you: this is what I wish to implement.

Furthermore, as part of the Grand Emprunt, we have allocated 2.5 billion euros for the digitization of content, e-health, and a number of initiatives that we are ready to undertake, with resources that are available. Our country has undeniable assets to strengthen its position in the internet.

I expect a lot from the National Digital Council. I thank those who have agreed to be members and those who have accepted to be in this place that is not necessarily a place where, spontaneously, on the day after an Easter weekend, you would have come. And ultimately, I appreciate that you think it is a place of freedom as well, and I would be very happy to be able to talk with you if you would agree to extend this official conversation in a more informal way.

There is one thing to remember, I have a lot of respect for what you have done, and I believe that people who have been able to do this can be capable, at the time of the maturity of the development of their sector, of building something themselves that they would have otherwise experienced as an intrusion from the outside. This is, therefore, really a sign of trust in the French digital sector.

Thank you all.