Final press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the issues of Kosovo, Darfur, and the Middle East, in Heiligendamm on June 8, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 June 2007 · Final press conference, G8 summit · Heiligendamm

Context
Sarkozy addressed the final press conference of the G8 summit in Heiligendamm, Germany on June 8, 2007, fielding questions on major international issues.
Main themes
Kosovo independence negotiations, G8 summit assessment, climate change and emissions reduction, Africa development and aid, Lebanon sovereignty and political stability, Syria diplomatic engagement, Iran sanctions and nuclear negotiations, WTO trade reciprocity, Kyoto Protocol and 2050 climate goals, EU agenda and European Council
Duration
~26 min
78th percentile
Words
3,170
78th percentile
Sentences
173
85th percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.3
14th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

173 sentences in 41 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - I am at your disposal to answer your questions.

QUESTION - You have spoken a lot about Kosovo, Mr. President, you have talked about the status of Kosovo, and so I would like to know how things have progressed?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, on Kosovo, things are not progressing. For a simple reason, it is that we cannot set a deadline for Belgrade and Pristina to continue talking as long as all the actors, especially our Russian friends, consider that the independence of Kosovo is an unavoidable prospect. That is the condition for an agreement. So, it is very likely that we will continue to talk about Kosovo.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, what assessment do you draw, for yourself, from this first G8?

THE PRESIDENT - That is not the question for me. For me, it does not matter much. What is important is the issues that have been addressed. I think the assessment is positive, even very positive. On climate, there have been quite remarkable advances and, just this morning, President BUSH confirmed that he was committed to the prospect of a 50% reduction. He did this to convince India and China to also commit to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. On Africa, we had, this morning, an extremely interesting discussion showing that we must be confident in the future of this continent, that Africa can succeed and that some African countries - I think of South Africa, Ghana, and others - are succeeding, and that this partnership is necessary to create wealth. I was very interested, by the way, in what President WADE said, who indicated that Africa does not need charity but development aid. That is exactly what I think. The discussions were very rich, very interesting. Again at noon, on the WTO, where I told President BUSH that I would fight to defend our interests just as he fights to defend the interests of Americans and that reciprocity was necessary and that naivety should be left at the door if we wanted an agreement. Moreover, this allowed for multiple multilateral contacts in 48 hours, which saves an extreme amount of time. At the same time, on European affairs, it also allowed us to advance on an agenda that is approaching since the dates of June 21 and 22 are extremely close and we need to find an agreement.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you told us this morning, at the end of your meeting with President BUSH, that you had the same approach as the Americans on Lebanon and that you discussed it with him as well as Iran. The American spokesperson said that you would have discussed Lebanon, Syria, and Iran. And since you have accustomed us to a lot of transparency in your communication, perhaps you could tell us what your approach is on Lebanon, Syria, and Iran?

THE PRESIDENT - On Lebanon, it is the right to independence for this country, free from any form of interference and naturally from occupation. It is support for the legitimate government and therefore for the army that is trying to restore order against all militias, and it is the necessity to find a political agreement with all the stakeholders, and God knows they are many. These are the initiatives that Bernard KOUCHNER and I are currently taking. And, from this point of view, I have not noted that, in the past, there was a divergence of views between the Americans and us. On Syria, there may be some elements of differing assessments, probably due to the fact that, for six and a half years, President BUSH has not seemed extremely satisfied with the evolution of his relations with the Syrian President. Should we or should we not, and at what level, resume discussions with Syria? That is a question that is being asked. It is being asked today, not at a political level, perhaps at a diplomatic level, from our point of view. Regarding Iran, it seems to me that there is a great community of views with China, Russia, and the United States of America to push the Iranian leaders to return to the negotiating table. As far as I am concerned, I think we need to send a message of firmness and certainly a tightening of sanctions. I believe that the policy of sanctions should create the conditions for a debate within Iranian society, which comes from a great civilization. We will indicate, of course, to make no amalgamation between the Iranians, a great people, and the current leaders, including the President, who makes perfectly indefensible statements. Or more precisely, who can be perfectly qualified.

QUESTION - Hello Mr. President, may I return to climate, environment, and sustainable development? At the last European Council, objectives were set for 2015. Today, objectives are being set for 2050. It happens that in 2012, a year that is important for you, is the end of the Kyoto process. Do you think we are burying Kyoto or surpassing it? Is it at this price that the Americans are coming and that we hope to bring in emerging countries like India and China, to whom we gave advantages during the development of the Kyoto process? What is your opinion on this?

THE PRESIDENT - My opinion is that we must show good faith and determination. You understand, of course, that a country like China considers that each Chinese emits a third of the greenhouse gases of an American. But finally, if the Chinese and Indians were to emit the same level of greenhouse gases as Americans today, given their numbers, you can see what catastrophe we would be heading towards. Secondly, Kyoto was a first step, insufficient, not ratified by everyone and not applied by everyone. I am thinking particularly of our Canadian friends. Whatever their good intentions over the years, not much has been done. But it was a step forward in global awareness. I especially note that this G8 has helped to strengthen the framework of United Nations negotiations with a view to reaching an agreement by 2009, to manage the post-2012 period. And therefore, undeniably, this G8 has strengthened the authority of the United Nations and allows us to consider the future, that is to say, the post-Kyoto period. It allows us to consider it as early as 2009 since, ultimately, I saw this as a validation of the Bali conference, as a step on the path that should allow us to find new objectives. One can always say that we could have gone further, that is true. But to say that we could have gone further is to accept the idea that we have gone further than what was imaginable upon arrival. And, from this point of view, I am satisfied with the progress that has been made and which is undeniable.

QUESTION - A question about the situation in Latin America, regarding the FARC. In your opinion, what is Brazil's role in this matter? What was the conversation between you and President LULA on this subject? It seems that there was a message from President URIBE read to you by Mr. LULA. Can you comment on that? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, of course. I called Mr. LULA on the phone to talk to him about my discussions with President URIBE. I thank President LULA for drawing President URIBE's attention to the importance of the issue of Ingrid BETANCOURT's release. Naturally, I am fully aware that the FARC have other hostages and I see that the humanitarian problem does not only concern one person. But who can blame me for caring about our compatriot? President LULA's influence has been very beneficial and the G8 paid tribute to President URIBE's actions. As for the rest, discussions continue. They are complex, they will be difficult. I hope they will be reasonably lengthy.

QUESTION - Mr. President, this morning, according to an American spokesperson, you would have told Mr. BUSH that France was ready to send additional soldiers to Afghanistan. Is that correct? And secondly, would these French soldiers sent to Afghanistan go to the south of the country?

THE PRESIDENT - We need to clarify things. First, I told our Canadian friends, our American friends, our allies that we will not break the solidarity of allies in the fight against terrorism in Afghanistan and to stabilize the Afghan state. First thing. Second, I told them that we would strengthen our means to train the Afghan army in the form of teams of 50 people who will mentor the army. Third, I told them about the possibility of promoting the reconstruction of this country, particularly through hospitals and schools. I want France's effort to be more of a training effort to prepare the Afghan state for the transition and in the form of reconstruction. I add that I have asked all interlocutors of Pakistan to raise awareness in this country about the necessity to help the forces that are there to eradicate terrorism and the drug culture.

QUESTION - Mr. President, can you talk a little about your meeting with the Chinese President, Mr. JINTAO?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, absolutely. The Chinese President invited me for a state visit to China in the second half of 2007. I accepted and we are preparing this visit with a number of economic projects, and, moreover, I believe I can say that the Chinese President was pleased with the position I took, which seemed reasonable to me, not to consider a boycott of the Beijing Olympic Games.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, we have talked about numerous cases of violence in Darfur. In your opinion, how can the Paris meeting at the end of the month succeed where others have not?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, on Darfur, I asked the Chinese President to use all his influence to pressure President BECHIR so that Sudan accepts the deployment of a hybrid force on its territory. Secondly, I asked the Chinese President for the presence of the Chinese Foreign Minister at the meeting of the expanded contact group. Thirdly, this meeting, which will be chaired by Bernard KOUCHNER, is not intended to replace the action of the African Union. I told the President of the AU Commission that it was not about complicating his task but, on the contrary, to help by all means to bring about a political solution.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, if France's interests are threatened, how far will you go regarding what is called preventive nuclear strikes?

THE PRESIDENT - The utility of nuclear weapons is deterrence. As far as my current knowledge goes, there is no urgency. The nuclear strategy and the French nuclear doctrine are those of vital interests. If France's vital interests were threatened, then, at that moment, like all the other Presidents of the Republic who preceded me, I could consider the use of nuclear weapons. Fortunately, that is not the case.

But, as for the precise definition of what vital interests are, I am not sure that this is the most appropriate framework to define them precisely. Even if I willingly acknowledge that the notion of vital interest has evolved since the time of General de Gaulle.

QUESTION - Mr. President, on the issues of AIDS, you recently reiterated your commitment to uphold the G8 commitments made in 2005 at Gleneagles. They provided for universal access to treatment for all by 2010. You even took a step further by saying that you would propose a financing plan to distribute the amount of funds to be provided among the different G8 countries. This is not in the final communiqué. Can you tell us a bit more about it? What happened?

THE PRESIDENT - The G8 committed to financing health in Africa to the tune of 60 billion dollars over the coming years. What is true is that the amount of the sum has been defined but not the exact number of years. These are considerable sums. The United States has committed to finance half of this amount. As for France, it will dedicate one billion dollars a year to health in Africa. I add that I proposed, when we met with the five NEPAD countries, that is to say, the African countries that have committed to defining a new partnership, that we should, before each G8 meeting, through experts, take stock of the promises made and the promises fulfilled so that we can move away from this debate where we throw figures at each other.

Regarding France, I would like to say that we are the second largest contributor to the Global Fund to fight AIDS, tuberculosis, and malaria. The first is the United States, the second is France. I truly believe that if there is a country that has nothing to be ashamed of in this regard, it is really ours.

QUESTION - Mr. President, may I return to Lebanon and Syria? Can we understand that French contacts with Syria are possible if the goal is to help stabilize the situation in Lebanon?

THE PRESIDENT - Let’s say that they are not impossible, if the goal is to guarantee Lebanon's independence, to find the assassins of Mr. HARIRI, and to offer peace to this martyred country.

QUESTION - Can you tell us more about what you have reached regarding the simplified treaty?

THE PRESIDENT - No, but I can tell you that, in principle, there will be a meeting in London in the coming days between Gordon BROWN, Tony BLAIR, and myself.

This is a response, Mr. RIDET, that will allow us to go a bit further in defining the main principles. Ultimately, what do we want? A simplified Treaty and not a small Constitution.

QUESTION - Knowing that you share many common approaches with American foreign policy, is France ready to consider this Plan B like the United States? That is to say, recognize the independence of Kosovo, without a resolution from the Security Council. Officials in Pristina have told us that if this proposal were to pass, it would be a betrayal. How do you explain to your friends in Kosovo that you do not intend to betray them by making this decision?

THE PRESIDENT - Wait, first I would like to say that yes, there are many common points between the positions of the United States and Europe. This is not new, but it has not prevented me from clearly highlighting two disagreements, one on climate, which was a rather frank discussion, sometimes tough, friendly, and the other on globalization where the exchanges were also very frank. I do not see, by the way, on what grounds friendship would prevent us from saying things, quite the opposite.

I have already pointed out several things, beyond the defense of our interests. I did not see globalization as a system without rules. And I did not see competition without loyalty, and I did not see market openness without reciprocity, and I did not see negotiation - I told Mr. LAMY - or rather I saw it without naivety.

Regarding the resolution, I think that France has really done enough and continues to do enough to be credited with sincerity. A resolution that would be voted on, more precisely that would be submitted and would receive a veto from the Russians, would lead to an inextricable situation in Kosovo. What would then be the legal status of the forces present there? I would like someone to explain that to me.

There would be European countries that would recognize the independence of Kosovo, others that would contest it. What would be the legal status at that moment, since the new resolution would not have been adopted, due to the potential, probable Russian veto? What is the legal status of the troops present there? What would the Kosovars have to gain? I would like someone to explain the situation to me.

I remain convinced that we must remain united, that the perspective is the independence of Kosovo. I said this in extremely frank terms to Mr. PUTIN. The question I ask myself is: "Do we really not have an interest in waiting a few weeks or a few months to find a consensus solution, or do we want to force it?" I think we have an interest in finding a consensus solution.

I have defended the principle of a well-recognized and guaranteed independence for Kosovo. I truly believe that this is the only reasonable position. It is up to us to put pressure, both on the Kosovars whom we have helped a lot, and on the Serbs who must understand that, in any case, they will live side by side, it is a geographical reality.

I do not believe that we have an interest in rushing things. Now, you know, the counsel of reason is not always followed. Finally, I have looked at the inextricable situation in which Kosovo would find itself if we wanted to force it. We can still think about this simply, it is not absurd, everyone knows the data of the problem.

There are thousands of UN soldiers, who work with a mandate, a resolution. What will happen if there is a new one that is subject to a veto, and if each of us starts to recognize the independence of Kosovo, without taking into account what others think? Do you really believe that at that moment we will advance peace? We will advance war and confrontations. I ask that we reflect on this, that’s all.

My commitment to the independence, the sovereignty of Kosovo is well known, it is inevitable. I even told Mr. PUTIN that Yugoslavia was over. When he says that there is a risk that other regions will demand the same conditions, I tell him no. I even went so far as to tell him that Yalta was over. Should we do it now or should we give ourselves six months? We can also think about it, it is not absurd. That is what seems to me.

I recognize that the situation there is extremely complicated. But, from the moment Mr. PUTIN says that the most likely scenario is that he will veto, I say that we must still think. This is not yielding to the threat, it is simply trying to align our wills so that we do not resume confrontations that would be bloody in this part of the Balkans. That is what I think, and the word betrayal, allow me to say, for a country that has 2,000 men who are there, I do not hold it against you and I do not take it personally, it is simply to reflect.

I proposed six months with a principle that is that of independence for Pristina and Belgrade to discuss. That seems extremely reasonable to me. It may be too ambitious for some, what do you want me to say? In any case, the Russian President should also see that there are realities.

I wish you all a good return. Thank you.