Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the fight against global warming, relations with Russia, the question of Kosovo, and the simplified European treaty, in Heiligendamm on June 7, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 June 2007 · Press conference · Heiligendamm, Germany

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference at the G8 summit in Heiligendamm on June 7, 2007, addressing climate agreements, Darfur, Russia, Kosovo, and the European treaty.
Main themes
Global warming and greenhouse gas emissions, G8 summit outcomes, UN role in climate action, 50% emissions reduction by 2050, Darfur humanitarian crisis, Russia-France relations, Kosovo question, simplified European treaty, forest conservation, humanitarian intervention, sanctions on Sudan
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,422
81st percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.6
17th percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

170 sentences in 30 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, I ask you to kindly excuse my delay, which is due to the length of the dialogue I just had with Mr. Putin. Would you prefer that I respond directly to your questions?

QUESTION - Mr. President, what clarifications could you provide us regarding the progress and the agreement that has been reached on climate?

THE PRESIDENT - The advances on climate are quite significant since we started from a point where President Bush said: "there are no problems, there are no consequences from carbon emissions and greenhouse gases, man has no responsibilities." The first gesture, President Bush said: "there is a problem." The second gesture is the responsibility of man, the third gesture is that we must act. That was the situation yesterday. Last night, another element was unlocked: President Bush accepted the idea that the solution to this problem of climate degradation goes through the UN, thus through Bali. This did not, from our point of view, hinder a meeting of G8 countries and emerging countries to move things forward, but the recognition of the UN and the role of the UN was a red line for us because the solution to climate degradation involves reducing greenhouse gas production but, at the same time, encouraging countries, especially poor ones, that have forests to reforest, knowing that a tree, in its lifetime, consumes a ton of carbon. From this point of view, the Republic of Congo, for example, is not a greenhouse gas emitter, given its poverty and economy, but at the same time, it is the second largest forest in the world, and it is of the utmost importance that it be maintained, developed, and preserved. While reducing greenhouse gases, we must increase the role of forests to consume carbon. This point - which was a very difficult point - regarding the legitimacy of the UN to act to defend the climate and the balances of the planet is a resolved point. Finally, the last advance, at the end of the morning and the beginning of the afternoon, I was very keen that a figure appear in the final communiqué. It is the famous figure of a 50% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. This was one of President Bush's red lines, and you will see that the communiqué states that the G8 countries are seriously considering the goal of a 50% reduction. We must state things as they are: I would have preferred it to be an imperative goal; there is still a little way to go. But look at where we are starting from, and the term seriously, that one, was fought for in the early afternoon. So, despite everything, I believe I can say that there have been significant advances. I had made it one of the priorities of this G8; we cannot wait; we must act. It would be an unforgivable moral fault not to do so. It is a priority of French diplomacy, and from this point of view, this G8 has led to very significant advances on the issue of climate and the preservation of the future of the planet. So, is it enough? I leave it to you to debate this endlessly. For me, what is important is that there has been a trajectory and that we are progressing on this trajectory. We have made progress, and this goal of 50% by 2050 is in the communiqué. How many of you, who are specialists, thought it would be in the communiqué?

QUESTION - Mr. President, you called for an international conference on Darfur in Paris. You are in favor of a political solution, for humanitarian corridors, but do you share the Americans' view of imposing sanctions on Sudan?

THE PRESIDENT - I think that with the United States of America, we have a position that is very close. I would like to say that I feel close to all the countries around the world that believe that we cannot let people die on the borders of Sudan, Chad, and the Central African Republic. Just because they are poor and abandoned, we should not let them die and be killed by guerrillas, by gangs, by rebels in conflicts in which they have no part. And so, since the United States is in favor of action, France is, for its part, also in favor of action. We cannot remain silent. There have been something like 250,000 deaths. Is it genocide or not? I do not think it is genocide, but it is a humanitarian catastrophe, in any case. So what solution do we propose? We have agreed on a solution. First, we need, as quickly as possible, a hybrid force, that is to say, a military interposition force in this part of the world, composed of soldiers from the African Union and soldiers and personnel from the UN to prevent people from being killed. Secondly, we need a political settlement, and all parties to the conflict must agree to discuss, and from this point of view, it is in the wake of the conference in Tripoli. Thirdly, I have asked Mr. Kouchner to tour the region to give us an update on the situation to see how to strengthen humanitarian aid. We are, as you know, not to simplify anything, in the rainy season. There are about two hundred camps in Sudan and Chad, in an area as large as France. The notion of a humanitarian corridor is a nice idea, but we need to find the means to realize it. Fourthly, on June 25, there will be a conference in Paris of the foreign ministers of the contact group expanded to a number of countries, including China, whose influence on Sudan is very positive, and Egypt. I will receive the ministers. Last point, if a certain government that I will not name were to oppose either humanitarian intervention or a political settlement, it goes without saying that the international community would be justified in proposing sanctions against that government. This was the subject of unanimity in the G8.

QUESTION - How did your meeting with Vladimir Putin go?

THE PRESIDENT - It was frank, as we discussed all the topics: Chechnya, the journalist, human rights, the rights of homosexuals. We did it calmly, serenely. I did it without any aggression, and we exchanged views. I found a man open to dialogue, accepting discussion on these complex issues. I myself tried to understand the problems of the Russians who have faced many crises and difficulties for the past twenty years, it is undeniable. I told President Putin that Europe did not want to isolate Russia. Besides, how can you isolate a country as large as a continent? I also told him that France wanted to have a genuine partnership of trust and friendship with Russia, that France brings together energies and, in no case, seeks to divide. I believe I can say that it went well since it lasted much longer than expected. I found a man very knowledgeable about his files, very calm, very intelligent, and it was very interesting to discuss all this. He explained to me in detail the proposal he had made to President Bush just a few minutes earlier regarding the radar and missile issue. I proposed that French and Russian military experts meet to see what the situation was. I must tell you that I had a lot of pleasure and interest in talking with President Putin.

QUESTION - You spoke with President Putin about sensitive topics. You talked about the assassinations of journalists; can you go into detail and explain what was said?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, I raised these questions without the intention of giving lessons, and it is not for me to provide or explain President Putin's responses, nor to explain the difficulties he faced, nor what he told me on the subject. I told President Putin that the world needed Russia to ensure its stability and that this is very important. You know that Russia's influence on a complex issue such as Iran is something that matters. We talked at length about Kosovo, and I made a proposal that I can detail for you. I also indicated that we, too, older democracies, could also have lessons to learn on the issue of human rights, that I was perfectly willing to discuss it myself and that my intention was not to hurt Russian national sentiment. My idea was to understand and draw attention. And we did this in a very calm manner. Regarding Kosovo, I made the following proposal: first, I believe it would be a very difficult situation to present a motion, a resolution to the Security Council and oppose the Russian veto. Indeed, from that moment on, I draw your attention to the fact that we would find ourselves in a situation of having hundreds of men on the ground without knowing what their legal status would be. That is to say, with some countries recognizing Kosovo's independence and others contesting it. I think we should avoid going to conflict right away. And the proposal I made is that President Putin recognize - words have meaning - the inevitable prospect of Kosovo's independence. For six months, we would ensure the sustainability of the legal effects of resolution 1244 to give a mandate to the soldiers on the ground; we would push Belgrade and Pristina to discuss and dialogue together. And, after six months, either Belgrade and Pristina have found a better status, and in that case, that is the one that applies, or they have not found it, and in that case, it is the Ahtisaari solution that would apply. This would have the advantage of allowing Mr. Putin, who fears above all the enlargement to other situations, to have a little time. I believe this would be good for the balance of the region.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you met today with Prime Minister Tony Blair. You spoke to him about the future of the institutional treaty, and after this meeting, you stated that you had agreed on what the framework of this treaty could be. Can you give us a bit more detail on this agreement? And do Mr. Blair and Mr. Brown have exactly the same view on this subject?

THE PRESIDENT - First, with Tony Blair, we had planned to meet to talk about the simplified treaty, and we agreed to say that what we wanted is a new treaty and not a small constitution. Here too, words have meaning. I am speaking in front of specialists; you will understand the difference.

Our advisors in charge of European affairs are working together to agree on the details, but I am not sure that the G8 framework is the best suited to discuss this, especially since I will have other appointments starting next week as I am going to Poland. I may be able to make other trips. There will be one that will address the question you just asked me. Regarding Gordon Brown, he is a man I know well since I was Minister of Finance at the same time he was. He is a man I appreciate a lot, and I will have the opportunity in the coming days to show that the position I am discussing with Great Britain is a common position, naturally, for both men.

QUESTION - I would like to return for a moment to what President Putin responded to your proposal on Kosovo.

THE PRESIDENT - This is not a proposal that I made to President Putin; it is a proposal that I made to the President of the G8, in the presence of President Putin and President Bush and all the participants. We agreed that tonight, the sherpas and the political directors would meet because, after all, they did not have such a small night last night! They still have a little leeway for tonight to see how, possibly, we could put this into shape. If you look at Mr. Levitte's expression, he is even quite disappointed that we are not asking him for more; he could do much better!

QUESTION - My question concerns the G8's 2005 commitment to universal access to treatment for AIDS by 2010. As you know, since 2005, the commitment has not yet been financially translated by the G8 member countries, and indeed UNAIDS has noted a paradoxical doubling of the funding shortfall in the fight against AIDS. On Tuesday morning, you committed to proposing to your G8 colleagues to launch negotiations to agree on who will pay and how much of the financial burden represented by this promise. When do you think you will have the opportunity to raise this point, and what is your prognosis?

THE PRESIDENT - It is tomorrow morning that we will address this important question. This is the whole issue of meetings with the press as we go along, because you know, I feel that since yesterday, time has flown by very quickly. We do not have a minute between two topics, between two meetings, and we are indeed constantly in meetings. We even have no collaborators during lunch. Thus, we have a very frank, very free, very quick, very attentive discussion, and I assure you that we have not wasted any time.

Tonight, we have the cycle of DOHA and the WTO, you can imagine the issues at stake. Tomorrow, we will meet with a number of African heads of state, and it is tomorrow that the question will arise. I said it, I committed to universal access to AIDS treatment in 2010. I committed to doing more for the health of Africans. And, to the question that was asked of me the other day about a contribution, if you remember, proportional to wealth, I remind you that France finances 10% of the total expenditures on the AIDS, malaria, tuberculosis program, etc. So, it is not a question of saying this to say: "that's enough." On the contrary, we are ready to do more, but here are the data on the problems we will discuss tomorrow.

QUESTION - May I ask you a question about the missile shield? You spoke of discussions between French and Russian military officials, but do you think this issue could be addressed in a multilateral framework that is not just the G8? If so, is it within the framework of the European Union or could it be within the framework of NATO or the NATO-RUSSIA Council? Are you considering this type of discussion?

THE PRESIDENT - There is a debate about this. First of all, there is a framework which is the NATO-RUSSIA framework, since we are still within the context of decisions that have been made by the United States with Poland and the Czech Republic, within NATO. The natural framework is therefore the NATO-RUSSIA framework.

But if I want to be totally intellectually honest, the easy way for me would be to say that this is a bilateral matter. Initially, it is a matter between the United States and the Russians, but that is not satisfactory. Secondly, I could even say it is a NATO-RUSSIA matter. This is indeed what diplomacy advises us. But if I have the right to grant myself a bit of freedom, just a tiny bit, it is also a European problem. Because, after all, two European countries made a decision and it was their right. We must also understand their history and the memories of history. But it is never satisfactory when Europe is not united. From the moment President PUTIN gave me, in detail, the elements of his proposal through AZERBAIJAN and the radar station located there, and if France wants to play a role in bringing energies together, in easing tensions, in being a bridge, in being a factor of peace and unity, and to avoid misunderstandings, to avoid returning to a period we no longer want - the Cold War period - I really do not see why I would not seize this opportunity to propose understanding Mr. PUTIN's proposal.

I am not a specialist in arms affairs, and so there you go, Mr. VERNET, I believe I have been very frank and I have allowed myself a freedom. I hope that French diplomacy will not hold it against me. But I think it is always in our interest to be frank, I think it is always in our interest to be direct. I did not want to give lessons to anyone, I did not want to be arrogant with anyone. I tried to understand, but I want in this effort of understanding, others to understand us as well.

I think that just because it is international, just because it is diplomacy, it should not be obscure for all the people who listen, who watch, and who wonder what we are doing, what we are talking about, what is happening. Perhaps by speaking frankly, we can find solutions more quickly than by making so many detours, using so many codes that in the end we part ways, each sure they have listened to or heard something different. I am not saying that I am right, but in any case, my words are unambiguous. Once again, I can understand the position of Poland, the Czech Republic, the Russians, and the United States. I see misunderstandings but let us try to move forward. The international community did not come this far to return to the Cold War. We are not going to look at this simply, and accepting the Cold War makes no sense.

To put it plainly, I do not think that President PUTIN, deep down, wishes for it. My analysis is that all of this is more a political problem than a military problem. So, let us not let things drift and let us find political solutions.

QUESTION - I would like to talk about your upcoming visit to Warsaw with President KACZYNSKI?

THE PRESIDENT - KACZYNSKI, SARKOZY, it rhymes but they are two! I will come without my brother, but I will come nonetheless!

My idea is very simple. First of all, I have always thought that Poland is a great country in Europe and those who follow me know perfectly well that I have always thought this. When I created the G5 of Interior Ministers, I have always sought to transform it into a G6 to include Poland because Poland has more than 40 million inhabitants. It is a country that matters in Europe. It is a great country in Europe, it is a country whose population is equal to or comparable to that of Spain. I want to go see our Polish friends to tell them that they have their rightful place in Europe, but I also want to tell them that we all must learn the culture of compromise.

You know that I care a lot about the Simplified Treaty. Not for reasons of personal satisfaction but because it is the only way to get Europe out of immobility and institutional blockage.

In fifteen days, I believe I have seen Italy, Portugal, Spain, Belgium, the European Parliament, the Commission, Germany, with the Chancellor. I will soon have seen Poland. I am trying to gather energies so that the German Presidency can, on June 21 and 22, make the best possible proposal.

I spoke on the phone with Mr. BALKENENDE, the Dutch Prime Minister, Mr. Jean-Claude JUNCKER, the Luxembourg Prime Minister. I will have seen many people so that we can come together. It is progressing but we are not there yet. The Poles have a role to play but Europe is also about learning compromise. If each of us wants to be right on our side, we cannot unblock the situation. Everyone must make efforts. Spain, which voted yes with more than 70% in the referendum, accepts the principle of a Simplified Treaty. France voted no, it accepts the principle of institutional advancement. If we arrive at the European Council table saying: "I am right," we do not move forward. And especially, and I saw this when I had lunch with Mr. SOCRATES, the Portuguese Prime Minister and the next President of the Union, it is that we must act quickly. We will have a solution all the more easily if we act quickly and I want to refute all those who think that Europe has time and that time arranges things. I think that time complicates them.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much.