Interview of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in "Hindustan Times" on January 25, 2008, particularly on Franco-Indian relations, the fight against terrorism, nuclear non-proliferation, and Franco-American relations.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

25 January 2008 · State visit to India

Context
Sarkozy gave this interview to Hindustan Times ahead of his state visit to India on the occasion of Republic Day on January 26, 2008.
Main themes
Franco-Indian relations, civil nuclear cooperation, G8 expansion and global governance, fight against terrorism, nuclear non-proliferation, India as emerging global power, defence and arms sales, Franco-American relations, climate change, UN Security Council reform, IAEA safeguards
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,466
67th percentile
Sentences
124
73rd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

124 sentences in 26 paragraphs

1 - How do you envision India? In your opinion, is India part of the circle of major global powers, or is it, above all, a developing country struggling to meet the basic needs of millions of inhabitants?

THE PRESIDENT - I am particularly pleased to visit India for this state visit. I am even more pleased that France will be honored on this Republic Day, January 26, when we celebrate our common values: liberty, equality, fraternity. For me, India encompasses three very important realities.

First, it is a great civilization, and we need this dimension as the problems of the world call for cooperation among all cultures. Secondly, it is a democracy and a peaceful country, committed to the United Nations, devoted to stability, in a complex environment.

Finally, it is a new economic miracle transforming the lives of hundreds of millions of people, but it is also a country facing formidable ecological and social challenges that must be addressed.

All of this makes it clear that India, which accounts for nearly one-sixth of the world's population, must be considered a key player. I will have the opportunity to express this to your President, Mrs. Pratibha Patil, as well as to the Prime Minister, the leaders, and the Indian people.

2 - During your term - the term of the President of a new France - will India, alongside other nations, be included in an expanded G8, as you have mentioned several times? How will you seek to include India, China, and Brazil in the new world order, following the priority you set in 2007?

THE PRESIDENT - My answer is very simple: we can no longer address global issues without India, China, Brazil, Mexico, and South Africa. It is a matter of common sense: how can we fight climate change, eliminate poverty, or tackle global trade issues without giving a leading role to representatives of 2.5 billion inhabitants? That is why I support India's candidacy for a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council, the body responsible for maintaining international peace and security, and that is why I wish for the G8, an informal consultation body on global affairs, to gradually expand to become the G13. We initiated this process last year during a G8 meeting in Germany where I had the opportunity to meet your Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh, for the first time. It is one of my international policy priorities, and I hope that at the next G8 summit in July in Japan, we will take a significant step in this direction.

3 - Do you want to sign with India an agreement similar to the 123 Agreement signed by the United States with New Delhi? Is it conceivable that France sells nuclear reactors to India if it has not obtained authorization from the Nuclear Suppliers Group, even though India has always behaved impeccably regarding nuclear non-proliferation?

THE PRESIDENT - We are on the verge of reaching an agreement that will allow for the development of civil nuclear cooperation with India while fully respecting its sovereignty and international rules, while preserving and strengthening the non-proliferation regime. This is one of the essential issues of my visit to India: to bring this crucial evolution to fruition for India's development and for the protection of the global environment.

The only promising path is the one currently being taken by India in its relations with the IAEA and with a number of countries, including France. This should lead to a special regime for India within the framework of the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG).

As soon as India concludes the safeguards agreement with the IAEA and the NSG has made its decision, we will be able to sign a cooperation agreement with it. This agreement will allow, in particular, for the delivery of nuclear power plants using the latest technology. More broadly, we will be able to develop with it a large-scale industrial and scientific cooperation in the field of civil nuclear energy.

4 - Are you disappointed by the cancellation of the tender that selected Eurocopter? Will you respond to the Indian Air Force's tender for 126 multi-role combat aircraft?

THE PRESIDENT - Eurocopter presented top-quality helicopters that met the needs expressed by the armed forces. I regret that this did not come to fruition, but of course, I respect the decision of the Indian authorities. I am convinced that the nearly forty years of cooperation between France and India in this area will not be interrupted and that Eurocopter will rise to the challenge. Regarding the 126 combat aircraft, the Rafale, one of the best aircraft in the world, can meet the needs of the Indian Air Force, just as the Mirage 2000 has been serving it well for years. If the manufacturer Dassault decides to submit a bid, the French government will support it.

5 - During a press conference with President Bush last year, you emphasized that Pakistan, a country of 150 million inhabitants, possesses nuclear weapons. You stated: "It is very important for us that we do not wake up one day with a government, an administration in Pakistan that is in the hands of extremists." Do you think the emergence of such an extremist regime is more likely after the assassination of Benazir Bhutto? Six years after September 11, Pakistan is in a much worse situation, with Musharraf and the military unable to neutralize extremist elements. By supporting it no matter what, has the Western world made a grave mistake? Is a change of course possible now? Do the United States/NATO have a contingency plan to protect or neutralize Pakistan's nuclear weapons?

THE PRESIDENT - I must first tell you that I am impressed by the determination and wisdom with which India and Pakistan have conducted, for several years, and despite difficulties, what is called the composite dialogue, aimed at establishing a peaceful relationship between the two countries. Regarding the internal situation in Pakistan, I am aware of the Indian authorities' attachment to a stable, peaceful, and democratic Pakistan. France fully shares this goal, and that is what I told President Musharraf in Paris last Tuesday. In the face of today's Pakistan, confronted with immense problems, we must exercise wisdom and great caution. I therefore leave you the responsibility for your assessments. The assassination of Benazir Bhutto was a tragedy, which France condemned vigorously, and whose effects will continue to be felt. Like everyone, I am concerned. What is needed now is for regular elections to take place and for the democratic process to resume. The fight against terrorism and Islamist extremism must be conducted with unwavering determination. As for the question of nuclear weapons, it simply demonstrates how essential it is, in nuclear matters, to act in accordance with the fundamental principles of non-proliferation.

6 - You have been at the forefront of highlighting the risks of a confrontation between Islamist forces and the West. Does this support the theory of the clash of civilizations? What should the world do to avoid such a clash?

THE PRESIDENT - To avoid this clash of civilizations, we must combine three ambitions. Total determination, first, in the fight against terrorism, which can never be justified, just as in the fight against the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, which is always the work of regimes hostile to peace. We must help the forces of moderation and modernity, so that an open and tolerant Islam can develop. A sense of diversity, next, so that adherence to universal values goes hand in hand with respect for difference. And, from this perspective, the example of India, where so many nations, languages, and religions coexist, can inspire us. Finally, openness to reconciliation with those who choose peace over doctrines of hatred and blind violence. These ambitions must be pursued, and I believe that India and France can work together on this.

7 - The American-British invasion of Iraq, aimed at ending an imaginary nuclear weapons development program, and the repeated threats against Iran, will they not contribute to increasing Muslim discontent, encouraging vocations for terrorism?

THE PRESIDENT - France disapproved of the war launched against Iraq, as you know. The Iranian question is very different. Here is a state that has been developing a clandestine nuclear program for twenty years in violation of treaties and with the help of an international proliferation network. A state that calls for the annihilation of Israel. A state whose IAEA cannot establish the peaceful nature of this nuclear program and which is developing enrichment activities that have no civilian justification and do not correspond to any need. Therefore, it was necessary to react, and Europe did so in the most measured way possible, by proposing a diplomatic approach, approved by the United States, China, and Russia, and supported by the overwhelming majority of the Security Council and the IAEA. We say to Iran: prove your goodwill by responding to the demands of the international community, let us negotiate, and we will offer you political, economic, and civil nuclear cooperation. But Iran refuses to listen. Therefore, measures had to be taken to make it understand that we will never accept a nuclear-armed Iran. We are determined to resolve this issue through dialogue. I am personally committed to this. But we will not compromise on this issue, which is essential for the peace and security of the world.

8 - Does your presidency mark a break from the foreign policy of your predecessor, Jacques Chirac, regarding relations with the United States? Will you be a new Tony Blair in your foreign policy towards the United States?

THE PRESIDENT - I do not define myself in relation to others. I was elected by the French people to fulfill the commitments made during the campaign. I was elected with the will, the utmost determination to act, to conduct a coherent, ambitious, and effective foreign policy. What drives me is the desire to defend France's interests and values, to advance Europe, to contribute to peace and stability in the world, a world facing immense challenges and great dangers. The French have been allies of the United States since the founding of this country. We even fought alongside them for their independence. They came to support us during World War I. They were the essential instrument of Europe's liberation from Nazi barbarism. They protected Europe when the Soviet Union was threatening. Therefore, for me, there can be nothing but friendship towards this long-standing ally and, at the same time, the complete freedom to assert at all times France's interests and positions, because there is no friendship without freedom. I said it before the United States Congress: France is a standing friend, an independent ally, a free partner.

9 - Are we dealing with an activist French presidency that sees no harm in dealing with the Hugo Chavez and Muammar Gaddafi of the world?

THE PRESIDENT - I regret that you have such a caricatured view of things. Colonel Gaddafi, whether we like it or not, has changed his policy. He has renounced his clandestine nuclear programs. He has agreed to release the Bulgarian nurses and the doctor who were unjustly accused. He has cut ties with all sorts of dubious movements. There is therefore no reason to refuse to discuss with him or to refuse to receive him. On the contrary, we must encourage him on this path, showing him that it opens the door to full reintegration into the international community. Moreover, how do you expect to convince countries like Iran to comply with the demands of the international community if, at the same time, you refuse to reintegrate into that same international community those who have taken responsibility and made the effort to respond to its demands? As for President Chavez, I see no reason why France should not have relations with him. I am a president determined to act and to achieve results. President Chavez has offered his help for the release of Ingrid Betancourt and the hostages of the FARC in Colombia, who have been suffering for so many years, and I remind you that two hostages, Clara Rojas and Consuelo Gonzales, were released a few days ago. But I will be clear so there is no misunderstanding: this diplomacy of reconciliation is in no way a diplomacy of complacency.

10 - In addressing the French Ambassadors in August 2007, you said that the very concepts of the third world and non-alignment had lost their meaning. Many Indians are convinced that non-alignment simply means an independent way of thinking and making decisions. Is this concept really outdated?

THE PRESIDENT - I believe that the modern world is faced with a new reality, interdependence, which compels us to rethink our approach to international relations. Non-alignment is a concept that emerged in reaction to the bipolar world, which has now disappeared. We must draw the consequences from this! Today, what is at stake? It is about fighting against terrorism, an international phenomenon that disregards borders. It is about combating climate change, which ignores nations. It is about tackling nuclear proliferation, which operates through international networks. Therefore, it is essential that each nation is respected in its identity and independence, which France is very committed to, and that all nations cooperate, in accordance with the law, to control these scourges. For me, this in no way imposes alignment with anyone. On the contrary: multilateralism means that we are equal before international law, seeking common solutions. What is needed is to create a global order suited to the 21st century, and this involves, among other things, reforming the United Nations Security Council, the International Monetary Fund, and the G8.

11 - What do you think of the resurgence of Russia? Is Russia today posing a new strategic challenge to Europe? Do you believe that multipolarity is necessary and possible in the contemporary world? THE PRESIDENT - With Russia, we have a joint responsibility to ensure international and European security. Russia's economic recovery is obviously welcome, as it stabilizes the country. At the same time, it is clear that Russia's position as a producer of oil and gas raises questions about its relations with Europe on this issue. We also wish, it is evident, for democracy to be fully respected in this country. France and Europe offer Russia a relationship of trust and friendship, based on mutual interest. I have met President Putin several times, and we have had frank and positive conversations. As for the rest, it is not a matter of whether we think multipolarity is good or bad. It is an increasingly evident reality of our world. The question is whether we will be able to organize international relations harmoniously, or whether we will allow them to deteriorate through thoughtlessness or clumsiness.