Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the priorities and challenges of research policy, in Orsay on January 28, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 January 2008 · Statement on the priorities and challenges of research policy · Orsay, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed researchers at Paris XI University in Orsay to honor Nobel laureate Albert Fert and outline France's research and higher education priorities for the next five years.
Main themes
French research policy priorities, Nobel Prize recognition of Albert Fert, university and CNRS reform, fundamental vs. applied research, France's global scientific standing, higher education modernization, public investment in science, talent attraction and retention, Franco-industrial collaboration, national scientific legacy
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,747
93rd percentile
Sentences
282
94th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%40%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Technological 6%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

282 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Madam President,

Ladies and gentlemen, professors and researchers,

Dear Professor Fert, the year 2007 was rich in events for France... There was a Rugby World Cup, and there is one event that the history of science and human knowledge will remember, which is the Nobel Prize in Physics awarded to you.

This Nobel Prize is good for France, it is good for Paris XI University, it is good for the CNRS, but this Nobel Prize is above all yours, that of your team, yours because it is the reward for an extraordinary scientist, whose scientific genius has revolutionized physics and electronics.

I have come to express today the gratitude of the Republic, the gratitude of all the French people, for the renown you bring to French science. May this Nobel Prize attract young people to physics, one of the problems of French research, especially since it is a sector where jobs are plentiful. I have come to thank you for showing that France does not only dwell on its past but is capable of writing the future.

You laid the foundations for the digital revolution of the 1990s and 2000s. Your discoveries paved the way for the astonishing multiplication of mass memory capacity. Ultimately, the iPod is a bit of you, well, in summary, no, there were more scholarly things written, but honestly, I stick to the iPod!

In any case, you embody the diversity of French research, the competence, I say competence, of several of its greatest institutions, since you work in a mixed research unit: you thus bring visibility and renown to our university research as well as to the CNRS. I would add that Thales has joined your mixed unit. You demonstrate to everyone that it is possible to conduct fundamental research at the highest level, at the pinnacle of global science, while working with industry to realize the applications of its discoveries. This is an extraordinary example that goes against all those who imagine that fundamental research is ennobled by refusing to apply itself, or who might believe that applied research can do without very high-level fundamental research. You are the perfect example of the necessity to work in a team, but a team in the broadest sense.

If I wanted to come today to Paris XI University to celebrate the rightful recognition of one of the brightest French minds, it is also to unequivocally mark the paramount importance that we will attach to the growth of French research in the next five years.

Research and higher education are two concomitant subjects that deserve particular attention. I know well, there are so many researchers here in this amphitheater, in the one next door, that research has always been a proclaimed priority, and fundamentally, whether it is a left or right government, it is quite rare to say that research does not interest us. But this research, proclaimed as a priority, I know perfectly well that it has rarely been so in practice, and that many of you, as soon as you are told that research will be a priority, think: will they disappoint us as we have so often been disappointed?

If I wanted research, with Valérie Pécresse, to be a priority, it is a thoughtful choice. It is first and foremost the idea we have of a country like France. Its place in the history of sciences and in the history of ideas, the legacy of all the great scientists: Pascal, Galois, Pasteur, Curie, imposes on our generation the duty to continue this adventure. I do not want us to be the lost generation of the great lineage of French science. It is not possible for France to be in the second division of world science, because a France in the second division of world science would no longer be France. Before being an economic or practical question, it is the question of the idea we have of France and science.

But if it is now, in 2008, that research and science must become priorities for our country, it is precisely because I am aware that our country's place in the construction of human knowledge is today threatened. This is not a coincidence. There are indeed many reasons for the problems that arise.

Our contribution to the totality of scientific publications places us in 6th place worldwide, behind Great Britain and Germany. Our research sector in life sciences files fewer patents than the single Johns Hopkins University in the United States. This is a fact. And the reputation of our universities, another fact, suffers in global rankings based on their scientific output. This is not to criticize anyone, but to make a diagnosis.

I do not believe that this is the fault of our doctoral students and researchers. The quality of French scientists remains, as we can see, exceptional. So, what is happening? What is happening that there are so many problems, so many difficulties? Despite this, I believe we must question our system. We cannot say, the men and women are of excellent quality, the system is of excellent quality, and yet, in the end, our place is threatened. It is either one or the other, or the diagnosis is wrong. But if the diagnosis is wrong, we must provide concrete elements to refute the current diagnostic concern.

I will go a little further, when entire generations of young researchers leave for abroad, when in the opposite direction so few brilliant foreign minds are attracted to our country, when those who want to return are discouraged by the environment and the remuneration they find - both, not just the remuneration - we must have the courage to recognize a disease in our system and to treat it. This goes well beyond alternations. Every government is confronted with this analysis. So it may not be pleasant. But if we refrain from making a diagnosis, there is little chance that the remedy will be the right one. I am not one of those who prefer to pretend that everything is fine to avoid hurting anyone and especially to change nothing. Moreover, it would be curious not to change anything in a field where we know that to find, one must not hesitate to change. It is not because the treatment is difficult that we must censor the diagnosis. Because the diagnosis, whether from the right, the left, the center, or whoever you want, will catch up with all those who are in responsibility.

So obviously, the easiest thing is to say, it is a financial problem: a classic French issue. Problem: not enough money. So let's look: is there a problem with public financial effort? We never do enough, but we devote 0.51% of our GDP to fundamental research, which is more than in the United States and well above what is done in Great Britain. This is not widely known, it is a fact. The proportion of scientific personnel in our active population is higher than it is in Germany or the United States. So is our question not primarily one of organization and allocation of resources? I think that the first thing is indeed to change that. Of course, there needs to be a financial effort, and I will do it. By 2012, we will raise our research effort to 3% of GDP, which means an additional 15 billion euros, of which 4 will be borne by the public authorities. But I want to take my responsibilities and be clear before you: this massive budgetary effort will be inseparable from reform. Because increasing a public research budget that is already one of the highest in the world, without making reforms, is pointless. In the same way, and with the same honesty, I want to tell you that it is impossible to carry out major reforms without injecting additional resources. I am fully aware that reforms can only take effect if everyone understands that we do not make reforms to reduce the effort but rather to justify its increase. My first orientation, and I will be judged on facts, I will not compromise on this, is increasing budgets that will go hand in hand with reforms.

I note that there is no longer in France a space for strategic reflection giving the executive the means to set long-term research orientations. It is curious. I know well that Lavoisier said: "discoveries cannot be commanded." That has not changed. It is perfectly true, and the greatest scientific breakthroughs are precisely those that no one could foresee. But the means of research must indeed be guided. Who can imagine increasing budgets without them being guided? Lavoisier, who was a farmer-general, did not have this concern and financed his research himself, which is not given to everyone. I am also in favor of doing everything possible to help and encourage every researcher and every laboratory to seek out sponsorships and donations that will support a project they have freely defined themselves. But when we talk about public funding, someone must define a strategy, or else it is not public funding.

I say this at the risk of shocking, but we cannot always say easy things. From my point of view, it is indeed up to Parliament, the government, and particularly the ministry in charge of research, to allocate public money and set strategic orientations. This may not be the best system, but all the others are worse. I do not know what else a ministry of research would be for.

It is not for an organization, however large, respected, and powerful it may be, to define alone the scientific policy of a country. It is not for an elected body of scientists to decide this policy either, because science must not operate in a closed loop; science must be accountable to society.

On the other hand, it is fundamental that the public decision-maker surrounds themselves with the opinions of indisputable scientific personalities, capable of an accurate assessment of the quality of work in a global reference framework. It is the meeting of the two competencies, that of the public official and that of the scientist, that will allow for the development of a strategy.

I believe we must also put an end to the balkanization of France's scientific policy. For years, we have been circumventing the fundamental reforms of the university. Why circumvent them? Because it is complicated. Because they are difficult, regardless of the governors and well-meaning people who are involved. If it were easy, it would be known. For years, to circumvent the fundamental reforms of the university and research organizations, we have had one response: we multiply the Institutes. To avoid reforming one, we circumvent it by creating others: the GIS, the GIP, and other structures, always tasked with responding urgently to societal problems. And what do we end up with? A stacking of organizations whose result is the dilution of our research effort, a multiplication of redundancies that has gradually led us to paralysis. A severe observation, do you think? The countless meetings I have had with various individuals lead me to believe that this observation is less severe than what they say in private. It is true, I say it in public, but it is my duty.

But the dispersion of our structures has also been very detrimental to the relationships between public research and industry and therefore to growth and employment. The dispersion has led to the multiplication of "valorization" cells, lacking critical mass and resources, unable to recruit the necessary skills from industry for a good interface between science and industry.

On this subject, I wish that the cultural barriers that have long existed with our main competitors and friends finally fall in France. There still exists today in our scientific community, how to say, a sort of embarrassment in valuing its work. I say embarrassment; I could have said a feeling of indecency. As if there were an incompatibility between "true" research, good because it is free and entirely disinterested, and its applications, sometimes suspect because they are sources of profit. As if, to be a good researcher, one had to be poor, obstinately refusing to interact with the business world. This state of mind is suicidal for growth, for employment, and for the future of French research. And it is especially completely erroneous. It is one of our greatest scientists, Louis Pasteur, who wrote, "there is not fundamental research on one side and applied research on the other. There is research and its applications, united to each other as the fruit of the tree is united to the branch that bore it." That is Pasteur!

And I do not forget that the same revolution must take place in business. Not all companies have a true affinity for science and research like Thales. There is not the closure of one world and the opening of another. There is the closure of both worlds. It is a French ailment that our large companies do not recognize the doctoral thesis for what it is, a guarantee of creativity, rigor, the ability to lead a project and to carry it out in an extremely competitive and demanding environment. It is a French ailment that so many grandes écoles do not firmly encourage their students to dedicate three more years of their lives to science and discovery, and that companies do not recognize the intellectual depth acquired during these three years in the salaries they offer. We must massively strengthen the links between grandes écoles and doctoral schools, and between doctoral schools and business.

The time has come, therefore, to change mindsets, to reform through consultation, through dialogue but with determination, a research system that is half a century old and which penalizes us. The task is complex, and that is why I wanted to surround myself with the greatest French researchers, of whom you are naturally a part, to see how we could reconfigure our scientific system and make its management as effective as possible. I will consult them regularly, these great researchers, and I want to hear their opinions.

The first major direction is to place the University at the center of our research system. This is a considerable change, Madam President. The University must be at the heart of our research system. We must do this because France will never have a higher education system worthy of its rank if it is not backed by its best researchers. We must do this because it is not enough to produce knowledge; it must be transmitted and disseminated, and the University is the place for transmission and dissemination. We must do this because the most effective research systems in the world are built on the strength of universities and not on their weaknesses.

Valérie Pécresse is working diligently to build this new strength of universities, and I thank her for that. We can debate this. We can debate everything. But frankly, giving French universities the autonomy that was already the rule in all the major scientific countries in the world was obvious! And the only question we should ask is why so late? Given how long we have been considering what needs to be done, autonomy was obvious. The system is ready for this spring. And in 2009 we will finally see the first French universities become autonomous. Autonomy has worked everywhere. I could not stand by and watch the disaster of the decline of our universities in international rankings, even if we can always criticize the criteria. Just as we can always change the thermometer, it is not effective to lower the temperature, after all. So, the University Investment Plan is unprecedented in its amount, as we have mobilized 5 billion euros. And I held a meeting this very afternoon with Valérie to launch the call for projects, so that we can finally have campuses worthy of our universities. There is no fatality that we must study in a grim place only in France. After all, what is the point of having the quality of life that is characteristic of our country if we have dilapidated buildings, a lack of campuses, no housing for students and researchers? No sports facilities, no library open on Sundays, in short... 5 billion euros have already been mobilized. Our campuses must be attractive to students from around the world. An unprecedented effort will be made in the next five years to enable our universities to fully play their role in training young people: since in addition to this investment of 5 billion in buildings, 1 billion euros more each year for universities and research in and around universities, this will total 15 billion euros of additional financial effort over a five-year term and a legislature. This will be easy to verify. Each year, this effort will be renewed. Finally, I will not say 15 billion every year. 15 billion in the budget and 5 billion for investment, that is 20 billion euros in total. This has never been seen before.

So, in return for this, there will be reform. The reform will first involve a very difficult task, which is to redefine the missions of the organizations. This is not the simplest thing. Relieved of the burden of part of the administrative and financial management, soon to be entrusted to the Universities, relieved of the evaluation, entrusted to the Agency for the Evaluation of Research and Higher Education, the organizations, having become agencies of means rather than operators, will implement the scientific policy that, on behalf of the French people, the Government and Parliament will have entrusted to them.

The organizations will thus be able, in close consultation with the National Research Agency (ANR), to fully devote themselves to their true mission, the management of research conducted in universities, whether it involves the selection, animation, or coordination of the best projects. In the long term, the organizations should only retain those activities that benefit from being organized and coordinated at the national level. I am thinking of major computing resources, databases, large equipment, and major technological platforms, but also of programs that require a regrouping of our forces and national coordination, as some institutes within research organizations are already doing, I am thinking in particular of what the CNRS is doing. All other activities are intended to develop in university laboratories, in a spirit of fair and fruitful competition. Competition is not a bad thing; it can even be stimulating.

I want the leaders of our research organizations to quickly inform the Minister of Higher Education and Research how they will support our best universities towards their autonomy and the development of their research missions. I expect from them concrete proposals to eliminate redundancies, a source of waste and inefficiency, to rationalize the system, to simplify the life and work of researchers in mixed units. Finally, I expect above all their proposals to make research careers more attractive.

This question is at the heart of the very worrying crisis of scientific vocations that France is experiencing. So I know the personal and family sacrifices made by our researchers, engineers, and technicians. I know that they give themselves selflessly to their mission; I know that it brings them the greatest professional joys but also the most cruel disappointments of competition, and unfortunately the daily hassles of an administration that is sometimes, if not often, nitpicking. I know how poorly our country rewards its scientific elites; I know that the remuneration of French researchers, you told me, is two to three times lower than that of other comparable countries. I know how great the temptation is for the best to yield to the sirens of abroad. When you are offered to earn three times more in a pleasant environment with the certainty of being able to continue your research, you cannot blame people for making that choice. I want to say this: it is not to the glory of France to treat its researchers this way.

The trust, gratitude, and esteem of our country for its scientists, researchers, and all research personnel must be expressed in ways other than words. I want things to change and for research careers to be dignifiedly compensated. It is a matter of the attractiveness of the research profession. There are avenues that exist, and I wish to explore them with you.

It is naturally not a question of going back on the status of active researchers, but we must remember that 30% of active researchers will retire by 2012. Is this not an opportunity to innovate? To show a bit of creativity, a bit of imagination? Could we not take this opportunity to introduce, pardon the term, a bit of flexibility into a system that has been suffering for so long from its rigidity? Thus, while maintaining a number of statutory positions as we know them today, could we not combine the resources of universities and those of organizations to recruit, within the framework of common procedures, a certain proportion of high-level teacher-researchers who would dedicate the majority of their activity to research for several years? This pooling of university and research resources would create a dual affiliation for teacher-researchers. This would therefore allow for more attractive remuneration for the brightest young doctors and give them the opportunity to fully express their potential. The Law on the Autonomy and Responsibilities of Universities contains all the tools necessary to do this.

This system would give young people the free choice to opt for either the traditional path or a dual affiliation that would allow them to prove their ability to carry out innovative research projects, without burdening them with teaching loads or depriving them of their freedom of initiative. It is at the beginning of their careers that we must unleash their energies and creativity. You reminded us of this yourself, and it is when they are young that we must give them the means to successfully carry out their projects, within the framework of a rigorous evaluation, and ensure that our future scientific leaders emerge.

I want this new generation to be instilled not with the reflex of recurring funding but with the culture of project-based funding, the culture of excellence, the culture of evaluation. We must find the right balance between short-term funding and longer-term funding for riskier projects. But both must be funded solely on the basis of their quality, in universities as well as in organizations, and are not intended to be indefinitely renewed without evaluation. I want to see the funding from the National Research Agency (ANR) develop even further, including the white programs, through which new teams and new research topics can emerge. You see that our conversation has served a purpose.

It is precisely because there is no question of reducing research to its only applications that I am so attached to the spirit as well as the letter of the white projects of the National Research Agency. Freed from all constraints, freed from all ideology, freed from all dogmatism, turning away from single-minded thinking, the most inventive researchers must be able to find at the ANR the means to fully express their creativity. The additional resources that will be allocated to research will allow this. But these resources must be allocated on the basis of scientific excellence.

I also specify that we can perfectly conceive of longer project-based funding, with timeframes of 5 or even 6 years, projects that would not be excessively constrained in their objectives. But it must be clear from the outset that at the end of each project, whether short or long, there will be an evaluation of the results and that the continuation of funding is entirely contingent upon this evaluation.

That is why we have a crucial need for credible and respected ex-post evaluation, as it must underpin the difficult decision to continue or interrupt funding. On this subject, I do not believe in a system where the scientific community elects its evaluators. The only effective evaluation is independent, transparent, and contradictory. The Agency for the Evaluation of Research and Higher Education bears the major responsibility of providing us with a professional and impeccable evaluation. It is intended to play an essential role in the decision-making process. In this respect, it must draw inspiration from the best practices abroad and call upon undisputed experts. We do not have to reinvent everything. Sometimes abroad, they do better than us before us; let us draw inspiration from what works.

But, ladies and gentlemen, the best for tomorrow, I am well aware, goes beyond the borders of the hexagon: it is being built in the European scientific space. I hope that the French presidency of the European Union will be an opportunity to assert our strength of proposal and our determination to work with our partners on the major challenges we share. I am thinking in particular of research on cancer, Alzheimer's disease, and rare diseases, but also on nanosciences and nanotechnologies. Europe, with its new legitimacy, must carry out major research projects. It must establish a true agency of means that will send a signal at the European level regarding the excellence of scientific projects.

Finally, ladies and gentlemen, research must serve society; it must enable society to appropriate its discoveries and results. In the medium and long term, it is essential for fueling the economic growth of France. The wealth of a country like ours relies on its ability to explore the frontiers of knowledge and its capacity to showcase these new areas of human knowledge. This is the only effective response to the challenges posed by emerging economies.

The links that unite research and innovation are based on a competitive logic and a maximization of interfaces between laboratories, society, and the economy. That is why the valorization of research and technology transfers must be organized in a decentralized manner around universities, and I will return to this point. The rapprochement of higher education and research will not occur in siloed national structures but on campuses, in contact with research actors. The valorization process is much more likely to come to fruition in a regional valorization agency or a competitiveness cluster than in the headquarters of organizations or ministries, which do not always have the culture for it, and not so often the skills either. In each region, we must create a unique meeting point between holders of scientific innovations and industrial project leaders.

This decentralization of the valorization system, close to businesses and laboratories, will facilitate the meeting of the most innovative researchers and the most daring entrepreneurs. This fertilization needs territories to express and develop itself. No territory provides a better example than the one we are in today, which I will call the Saclay plateau, even if it slightly overflows, dear Christian BLANC. I came here a year ago when I was the minister in charge of regional planning. I met the main actors of this extraordinary place of French science. And I felt a growing awareness and a movement that contrasted with decades of immobility and mutual indifference.

We must now organize and structure this energy and this mutual will to act in order to establish a grand project that is, I say to the elected officials, scientific, economic, urban, and landscape-oriented, on the Saclay plateau. We can establish here in the 21st century what others have founded in Cambridge in the United Kingdom or in Cambridge in Massachusetts in other centuries, and I believe we can even do better. We now need governance, a project leader, a specifications document, and ideas.

Regarding the specifications document and the scientific strategy, the foundation that brings together the two technological research networks of the plateau, chaired by Philippe LAGAYETTE, is preparing a project that I await with interest. They are doing it; they are quality people, let us wait for what they will propose. As for ideas, I am hopeful that the ten great architects we will commission to reinvent the Île-de-France territory will have the right inspiration, which I will suggest to them to focus on this place. Organization does not kill creativity. And if the State does not get involved, we will still be in the same situation in thirty years. Finally, regarding governance, I believe we need to clarify and invent. Clarification means recognizing that the development operation to be undertaken is not so much about housing policy as it is about the scientific and university policy of France. I admit, this is a change. The goal, I would like to tell you, is not for me to build tens of thousands of housing units between Massy and Versailles; the goal is to welcome the best researchers and students in the world in a pleasant and ecological environment. The invention is to establish a development structure that respects this unique vocation, even if, I announce to you, it may require going through legislation if necessary. We cannot continue to be in a country where the slightest defense association can prevent the realization of strategically important projects solely because there is a corporate interest opposing it. We cannot get out of it. Compensate, yes; always and forever prevent, no. It is not reasonable, or else we will fall thirty or forty years behind, so I say: if the law is necessary, Valérie, then we will go through the law. In any case, by the end of 2008, the Saclay operation will, I commit to it, have a pilot, a project, that will involve all scientific institutions, all grandes écoles, universities, and elected officials, to move forward. It has been too long since we have talked about what we are going to do in Saclay; by the end of 2008, we will no longer talk about it; we will start doing it. It is a matter of honesty towards all those who are mobilizing, regardless of their status and sensitivity. In 2008, we will develop the project, find the pilot, and starting in 2009, we will implement it.

To conclude on the valorization of research work, I want it to fully benefit the scientists who deserve the credit. The benefits of innovation must, of course, be equitably distributed among all actors, but if it is the discovery of a researcher or a team that gives rise to innovation, they should fully benefit from it! Why not consider rewarding them up to half of the expected profits, as is the case in the most advanced foreign countries in this field?

I want all measures that can simplify and accelerate the transition from research results to their applications to be studied. When a researcher waits more than two years for the co-ownership issues of patents to be resolved and for authorizations to finally be granted by a whole series of commissions, their invention is no longer one, and competitors have already exploited the process. We must resolve this patent ownership issue in mixed units as quickly as possible.

Finally, I also propose to completely exempt all valorization activities of universities from taxes, as is the case in all countries that have a real ambition for innovation. Taxing universities, I say this as I think as President of the Republic, makes little sense. This will be a complement to the major advances of 2007: the creation of the young university enterprise massively tax-exempt and the tripling of the research tax credit granted to companies. I want students who want to create a business on campus to have the assurance of being in a free zone and to be tax-exempt.

Campuses will be able to host young university enterprises arising from research, in order to motivate students, professors, and researchers.

You see, ladies and gentlemen, my ambition for research is great. It is commensurate with our immense potential, as reiterated in 2007 by your Nobel Prize.

But nothing will be done without consultation, nothing will be done to the detriment of young researchers, nothing will be done to the detriment of our best teams, nothing will be done to the detriment of our best scientists. Nothing will be done that risks making us lose the gains of our long tradition of excellence.

In essence, I am calling for a true refoundation of the entire French scientific community, around our renovated universities, our teams, and our scientific institutions with redefined missions. This ambition must be the ambition of the entire national community. I know your passion for your professions; I also know your exaggeration about the time that has been lost; I know your sometimes distrust; I know your always concern, but I also know that you are certain that we cannot remain in today’s situation and that immobility will condemn us. So the choice now is simple. We move forward, we change, we advance together, and at each step, we try to involve, we lead, we evaluate perhaps. Will we make mistakes? Perhaps we will need to revisit certain measures, but we collectively acknowledge that immobility is not possible.

Saving research was the slogan, and well, that is what it is about. Let no one make the French believe that we can save research through immobility. And saving research is not simply a matter of more money. The additional money is there. It has already been voted, in any case, for the five billion, it is there, but no immobility. Because this demagoguery will only lead to failure, and it has already been tried. Doing nothing is so easy. But in the end, you will keep your problems. We must unleash energies. The talents are there, the know-how is too. Well, we must restart our entire system, and I am certain that with your enthusiasm and passion, we will quickly regain a French research at the forefront of countries that have invested massively, as we will do in this research. And ultimately, when will we have won? When young foreign talents will compete to come to France and when young French talents—who will continue to go abroad, which is desirable, but I hope they go for good reasons, not bad ones—will return. Abroad, they offer you more than in your own country. If France wants researchers, it must give more. That is exactly our commitment; that is what I wanted to do at the beginning of my term, because I am well aware that it is with you that the future of the economy, growth, and French society will be played out. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.