Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in "Folha de Sao Paulo" on December 21, 2008, particularly on the financial crisis and Franco-Brazilian relations.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

21 December 2008 · Interview in Folha de Sao Paulo

Context
Sarkozy was interviewed by Folha de São Paulo on December 21, 2008, discussing the global financial crisis, capitalism reform, and Franco-Brazilian relations.
Main themes
Restructuring capitalism, global financial crisis, G20 Washington summit, financial regulation, Franco-Brazilian relations, European Union response to crisis, bank bailouts and credit access, economic governance, protectionism rejection, confidence restoration, emerging countries' role in global economy
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,442
81st percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

150 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Q - What do you mean by the expression "restructuring capitalism," which you used during the financial crisis?

R - My conviction is that the financial crisis we are experiencing today is not a crisis of capitalism; it is a crisis of a system that has strayed from the most fundamental values of capitalism. It is a crisis of a system that has gradually prioritized the speculator over the entrepreneur. It is a crisis of a system that has pushed actors to take on more and more risks, and increasingly reckless risks. It is a crisis of a system that has allowed banks to speculate on the markets instead of doing their job, which is to finance investment and development. Capitalism is not the law of the jungle, it is not generalized irresponsibility, it is not the primacy of speculation.

When I talk about restructuring capitalism, I mean that we must return to the true values of the market economy, those that place the entrepreneur and development at the heart of the economy. We must rebuild a regulated capitalism, a capitalism where banks do their job, a capitalism where risk-taking is measured and assumed, where rating agencies behave impeccably and are controlled, a capitalism based on transparency and not on opacity. That is what I proposed, and that is what we began to build together on November 15 during the G20 meeting in Washington.

In Washington, the largest economies in the world agreed on the need for a global stimulus, a new regulation of financial markets, a new global economic governance that is more open to emerging countries, and finally on the rejection of protectionism. The summit also allowed for extremely concrete advances in the oversight of rating agencies, improvements in regulation, particularly in accounting and prudential matters, and concerning remuneration policies in banks. We also decided to open the Financial Stability Forum to emerging countries.

The Washington summit marked a turning point. I add that what we have discovered since about the practices of certain financiers and the gaps in regulation as it is currently practiced reinforces our belief that we must change things quickly to restore confidence to savers, investors, and everyone. I have no doubt that the next G20, in Britain on April 2, will allow us to go even further.

Q - So far, all the major aid programs for banks set up by governments around the world have produced only meager results regarding access to credit. What is happening? What is missing for confidence, an indispensable factor for economic activity, to return?

R - The programs you mention have already helped prevent the global financial system from collapsing completely. That is not what I call a meager result. Do not forget that we came very close to catastrophe when, with the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, we went from a serious financial crisis to what economists call a "systemic" crisis, that is to say, a generalized crisis of confidence within the financial system and a risk of serial bankruptcies of financial institutions. That is what we did in Europe by adopting a rescue plan that included significant guarantees, particularly on interbank loans, which are the lifeblood of the financial system, and by intervening on a case-by-case basis to assist a number of struggling banks.

Has the credit situation returned to normal? Obviously not, things take time. In France, I have met several times with representatives of banks and I have been very clear on this point: those we are helping through the banks are businesses and households, not the shareholders of financial institutions. We have also created a "Mr. Credit," whose mission is to ensure that small and medium-sized enterprises have access to financing. He serves as a mediator. 50,000 contacts have been made by business leaders or households seeking information. 2,500 complete files have been processed, which has allowed for deeper decisions by banks in 500 cases and has prevented bankruptcies. We are not content with principles or injections of billions. We look at each case to see how to resolve difficulties. What is certain, in any case, is that I will remain extremely vigilant on this point. I will not let my guard down.

The priority now is to restore confidence to economic actors through appropriate stimulus measures. Our responsibility, as leaders, is to send strong political signals, and the first of these is to continue to coordinate our efforts closely, as we committed to in the Washington declaration. That is what we did at the European Union level during the last European Council on December 11-12.

Q - Many voices criticize the action of the European Union during the crisis. The European Union would have been unable to act jointly, even if each member country was able to make the right decision. This evokes the famous phrase by Henry Kissinger, "If I want to talk to Europe, what number do I call?" Does Europe lack a common capacity for action, a more substantial single budget, a stronger political orientation?

R - What we have seen in recent weeks is exactly the opposite of what you have just described. We have seen a united Europe, a determined Europe, a Europe that has acted. Not only did Europe respond in a coordinated manner to the crisis, but it was also at the forefront of the initiatives taken at the global level. It was the plan adopted by Europeans on October 12 at the Eurozone summit and then on October 15-16 at the European Council that inspired the American plan known as "Paulson 2." It is also Europe that proposed and secured the G20 meeting in Washington, which led to the adoption of extremely concrete measures, and which will meet again on April 2 in London. And it is still Europe that, during the European Council held last week, was among the first to implement the guidelines decided in Washington.

You see, Europe in this crisis not only had a phone number, but above all, it had an unwavering will and solidarity.

This united and forward-looking Europe is also the one that ended the Russo-Georgian crisis last summer, and it is the one that, with the EU-Brazil summit, is concluding a semester of French Presidency of the Union that has allowed for historic advances, whether in the fight against climate change, where Europe has set the highest ambitions and the most demanding rules in the world, but also in the fields of defense and immigration. More than ever, Europe is aware today that it is never as strong as when it is united.

Q - Why did no government, in Europe, the Americas, or Asia, anticipate the "tsunami" that was coming?

R - It is false to say that we did not see it coming. In August 2007, I wrote to German Chancellor Angela Merkel, whose country was then presiding over the G8, about the need to radically improve the transparency of markets. And the following month, in September 2007 - that is to say, more than a year ago - we launched a joint call for a "code of conduct" for hedge funds.

What is true, however, is that the scale and violence of this crisis took us by surprise. First, because this crisis is precisely linked to insufficient transparency, and I would even say to a certain opacity, of financial systems, linked to the concealment of risks. It is very difficult under these conditions to know how to react. The system had become so complex that those who bought securities did not even know what they were buying, and that no one, not even the sellers, were able to assess the level of risk of the products. That is why it is essential to restore transparency to the international financial system. The second thing is that, as I told you, the crisis changed in nature and dimension when it became systemic after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers.

Today, we must draw all the lessons from this crisis and improve our capacity for anticipation. The early warning mechanisms we are putting in place will be crucial, but we must also radically improve our capacity for collective action, that is to say, reform global economic governance. If we take the example of the IMF, we need to strengthen its mandate so that it can effectively monitor the global financial system and sound the alarm when necessary. But for it to do so, it must be legitimate, that is to say, more representative.

Q - You are in favor of expanding the G8, wanting to transform the G20 into the new economic and financial "manager" of the planet. However, at the Washington summit, the formalization of the G20 as such did not come to fruition. Do you propose that this be done at the London summit in April?

R - I believe that reforming global governance is not an option. It is a necessity, and it is urgent. Who can imagine today being able to solve the world's problems without countries like China, like India, and of course like Brazil? It makes no sense. We are in the 21st century and we are living with institutions from the 20th century. We need to change that. I reiterated this in September at the podium of the United Nations General Assembly: we can no longer wait to expand the United Nations Security Council, particularly to include Brazil, and we can no longer wait to expand the G8 format. In any case, you can count on my determination to make progress on this issue. I am also pleased that Italy, which will preside over the G8 in 2009, has already planned for the second day of the summit to bring together the G8 and the five major emerging economies that participate in the Heiligendamm process. This is proof that things are evolving.

Regarding the G20 in Washington, the situation is a bit different. The goal of the G20 was not to institutionalize a new format to replace the G8, but to find the best framework to respond in a coordinated and effective manner to the most serious financial crisis the world has faced since the 1930s.

To be completely frank, I would have personally liked Africa to also be present at this meeting, and I made that known to our partners. But it is already a very good thing that we managed to convince everyone that a broad gathering was necessary for our response to a crisis of this magnitude to be credible and effective.

Q - How do you assess the action of the Brazilian government, within the G20 but also in view of stabilization in South America or Latin America?

R - Brazil's contribution within the G20 is decisive; it is demanding, as President Lula is a man of conviction who always knows how to assert his arguments with strength and determination, and it is constructive, as President Lula is above all a man of moderation and dialogue.

The role that Brazil plays in the region is essential and extremely positive. Brazil is a factor of moderation, stability, and regional integration.

On the issue of regional integration, I believe a lot in the approach favored by Brazil, based on concrete projects, particularly in infrastructure or energy. I am convinced, indeed, that it is through concrete achievements that we can win the support of the peoples, which is an essential dimension for successful integration. Brazil has also proposed new structures for political dialogue such as UNASUL or the defense council, which will be very useful. This commitment to regional integration is also illustrated by the unilateral concessions that Brazil has made in the economic or trade field, to the benefit of its MERCOSUL partners in order to reduce asymmetries among the members of this group. These decisions were not easy to make; they required a certain courage and a real vision, but it was an essential gesture to better accept integration by the other members of the group.

Finally, I want to commend Brazil's moderation in the face of the demands of its neighbors, often directed against its interests. Brazil has been able to react with lucidity and discernment because it understood that these countries were primarily seeking to gain greater economic sovereignty, to increase the participation of all their citizens in the political debate, and to reduce their inequalities. This is proof of great political and democratic maturity.

Q - President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is an outspoken advocate of ethanol (from sugarcane, to be clear) as being the source of what he calls a "revolution" in global energy but also conducive to the development of the poorest countries that cultivate sugarcane. Do you share this enthusiasm? If so, why does the European Union maintain barriers against the import of Brazilian ethanol?

R - The vision, boldness, and sense of innovation that Brazil has demonstrated by being among the first countries to commit to the path of biofuels deserve to be commended. Your country is now a global leader in the use of biofuels for passenger cars, which is a remarkable achievement.

France is in favor of developing the biofuels sector. Together with our European partners, we have embarked on an ambitious program to develop biofuels that should help us meet our objectives to combat climate change and reduce energy dependence. As part of the "energy-climate" package, a European directive on renewable energies has been adopted to confirm the goal of developing biofuels, while being demanding about their environmental quality. To achieve these objectives, we rely on the production developed by its member states, but we will also need to resort to imports. As you know, Brazil is already by far the largest supplier of ethanol to the European Union.

I would, however, like to add that the recent global food crisis, and the impact of biofuel production on food prices, which is a subject of much debate among experts and leaders around the world, has led me to accelerate support for the development of next-generation biofuels, which will allow us to produce five times more on the same agricultural land. By doing this, we will not penalize countries that have chosen biofuels, like Brazil, but at the same time, we will be able to reserve the maximum number of hectares for agricultural production. Because more than 900 million people suffer from hunger in the world.

Q - An unavoidable question: France is always accused of being the champion of protectionism in Europe, of being the main obstacle to the liberalization of agricultural trade, which could lead to an agreement in the context of the Doha Round negotiations. What do you say in response to these criticisms?

R - This is a very unfair criticism: no other trading area in the world is as open to international trade as the European Union, which brings together - I remind you - nearly 500 million consumers. Europe has always actively supported the conclusion of the Doha Round, provided that it is based on an ambitious and balanced agreement. This is what we reiterated in Washington, and it is still what the European Council confirmed in December.

On the agricultural issue, I would like to remind you that the last reform of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), in 2003, led to a significant reduction in major European supports. Subsidies have decreased sharply; reforms in the dairy and sugar sectors, for example, have led to a reduction in guaranteed prices, and intervention prices have decreased; moreover, the European Union has significantly reduced the use of export refunds. We have continued down this path during the French Presidency with the adoption of the CAP health check. Europe would like all countries to have made as much effort as it has in this area.

I add that the European market is already largely open to agricultural and agri-food products, whether under preferential regimes such as the "Generalized System of Preferences," economic partnership agreements with countries in the Africa-Caribbean-Pacific zone, or free trade agreements.

Q - How do you define the purpose of your visit to Brazil?

R - The objective of my visit to Brazil is twofold: on the one hand, to give substance to the strategic partnership between the European Union and Brazil that we launched in July 2007. For this, I want us to set concrete, ambitious, and realistic goals in several areas where we have a common interest. It is in this spirit that we will sign a joint action plan tomorrow that will focus on a number of priorities: deepening our political dialogue, developing our cooperation on major global challenges such as the environment, energy, or food security, and finally implementing concrete projects in the fields of technological innovation, education, or in third countries.

But I also place great importance on the bilateral aspect of my visit. President Lula and I decided during our meeting in Guyana last February to give a new impetus to our relations. Behind the words, we want the Strategic Partnership that has linked us since 2006 to be based on very ambitious achievements. For both of us, this partnership must be comprehensive, meaning it should cover areas of cooperation in both civil and defense matters; it must be authentic, meaning it should be based on concrete projects, and not just on professions of friendship, however sincere and deep they may be; it must also be balanced, meaning that both our countries will derive significant benefits from it. But our partnership is above all coherent, in the sense that our support for Brazil's accession to the Security Council as a permanent member or to an expanded G8 and our cooperation in very strategic civil and defense sectors form a whole. It is the interface of the same coin. It is not a supplier-client relationship; it is a relationship between partners, based on political dialogue and the transfer of experiences and technologies.

We have worked well over the past few months. My visit will be an opportunity to announce alongside President Lula unprecedented progress. Several very important agreements will be signed in the fields of sustainable development, vocational education, defense, space, etc. But for me, this is just a step, however important it may be. With Brazil, this is a partnership that is meant to last.

Q - The presidential election of 2007 was followed from Brazil through a classic prism: the right, represented by Nicolas Sarkozy, against the left, represented by Ségolène Royal. But your actions have surprised many observers, not only because of the call made to prominent socialists to join the government but also because of positions that are difficult to associate with the right. Has Sarkozy changed? Has the world changed? Has the classic distinction between right and left lost its meaning? If you were a journalist, how would you define President Nicolas Sarkozy in three lines?

R - From the day after my election, I chose to call for an open government, seeking talents and skills well beyond my political family. I did not need this openness arithmetically, but I wanted it because my project for France is ambitious, and when you want to carry out major reforms, you need a large majority. Openness also responds to a deep conviction: that the president must be the president of all French people, that he cannot be the man of a single party, a single clan. The role of the president of the Republic is to bring people together. I must work for all French people: those who chose me, but also those who did not vote for me.

Does this call into question the existence of a right and a left? Absolutely not. I was elected on a very clear government program, and the left-wing personalities who joined me did so knowing my project and to implement it. But I see no reason why I should have to do without their talents simply because they do not belong to my political family.

In terms of ideas, I have always believed that my political family should reject both ideology and caricature. The role of a political party is to be constantly listening to citizens, to adapt to the changes in the world, to know how to question itself and evolve its ideas. For that, one must be pragmatic and seek good ideas wherever they are, even if they come from another country or another political family. To consider that only one's own ideas are valid is to show misplaced pride, and it is especially not to be up to the responsibilities of a public decision-maker. In any case, that is not my conception of politics.