Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on a policy in favor of equal opportunities and the promotion of diversity, in Paris on December 17, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

17 December 2008 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed ministers and officials in Paris on December 17, 2008, presenting a policy statement on equal opportunities and promoting diversity in French society.
Main themes
Equal opportunities, diversity and inclusion, republican values, social inequality, integration model failure, discrimination, meritocracy, social mobility, fraternity and solidarity, urban segregation, reform of the Republic
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,102
86th percentile
Sentences
228
92nd percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.73
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 49%49%
  • Institutional 44%44%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

228 sentences in 111 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen,

France would not be France without the passion for the Republic, its values, its principles.

France would not be France without this passion for liberty, equality, and fraternity that is the essence of the Republic.

The Republic has set itself the goal of fulfilling the old dream of kings, that of a nation that is one and indivisible. It has added to that the vision of a community of free citizens united by civic duty and equality of rights and responsibilities.

It is the miracle of the Republic that it has allowed France to combine such a strong identity with such a great aspiration for universalism.

It is the miracle of the Republic that it has allowed France to be a great homeland made up of a multitude of small homelands united by a formidable will to live together, to share a language, a history, a way of being and thinking, where everyone recognizes themselves in a common ideal and a shared destiny without erasing personal stories and individual destinies.

It is the miracle of the Republic that it has forged the unity of France without condemning it to uniformity.

It is the miracle of the Republic to combine such a high idea of the state with such a great passion for freedom.

It is the miracle of the Republic that it has made France feel a shared passion for equality and for merit.

The miracle of the Republic is that it has given France a sense of fraternity, that is to say, understanding, respect, and solidarity.

The Republic is not a fixed model for eternity.

It is not immobility. It is not conservatism.

The Republic is movement, it is progress, it is the call for justice.

It is a dream that is always unfulfilled, it is a project that is always unfinished.

The Republic is our common good, what makes us live together, respect one another, and feel solidarity with one another. It is what the generations that preceded us have bequeathed to us as the most precious legacy.

The Republic is an ideal that we do not have the right to betray. It is a societal project. It is a political project that we have the duty to continue. But it is not enough to glorify the Republic for it to remain alive. It is not enough to proclaim equality for it to be realized.

Let us face our society, let us look at social promotion, the number of children of workers in prestigious schools, urban segregation, discrimination, inequality of opportunity, and let us ask ourselves the question:

What have we made of our Republic?

How can we still speak of the Republic when schools can no longer compensate for social disadvantages?

How can we speak of the Republic when academic success and professional futures depend not on intelligence, not on courage, not on hard work, not on merit, but primarily on the social background from which one comes, the neighborhood in which one lives, the name one bears, the color of one's skin?

How can we make the Republic understandable to a child who feels imprisoned by their environment, their neighborhood, their origins?

How can we make the Republic loved by those it keeps at a distance? By those who are convinced that no matter what they do, no matter how hard they try, the efforts and sacrifices they make, they cannot succeed?

How can we instill hope in a Republic that continues to keep its promises so little, that functions more and more not as a project but as a myth foreign to social reality?

The greatest danger threatening our republican model is that the Republic becomes a disembodied ideology.

We betray the republican ideal by hiding behind grand principles to avoid fighting injustices, inequalities, and discrimination.

The Republic must not be a dogma; it must be a requirement, a political requirement, a social requirement, a moral requirement.

For too long we have betrayed the republican ideal by proclaiming our attachment to a formal Republic without caring to build the real Republic.

There is no real Republic without republican voluntarism.

There is no real Republic without the will to correct inequalities by treating unequal situations unequally.

We can only progress towards real equality by addressing both the causes and the consequences of inequalities, injustices, and discrimination.

We cannot claim to uphold the republican ideal if we are not capable of recognizing that our model of integration, which worked so well for a century, no longer functions. Because that is the truth. Because this model, which for a century contributed so much to reducing inequalities, is now revealed to be powerless to reduce them, if it does not contribute to aggravating them.

We cannot want a real Republic if we are not capable of recognizing that our model of integration, after having long been a model of social promotion, has become a model of social reproduction.

We cannot ignore the ever-widening gap that is glaringly obvious between the diversity of French society and the increasingly greater social and cultural homogeneity of the elites produced by our educational system.

We cannot fail to see, because it is glaringly obvious, that our selection system prevents certain categories of the population from accessing responsibilities.

I say this with gravity: if our society is today threatened with becoming a mosaic of communities withdrawn into themselves, if the risk looms of seeing community solidarity become stronger than national solidarity, if communitarianism threatens the unity and indivisibility of the Republic, it is not because we have too much honored the principle that the detour through inequality could be the best way to achieve equality, it is not because we have given too much to those who have less, it is not because we have transgressed the sacred principles of egalitarianism to implement positive discrimination. It is quite the opposite.

It is because, fundamentally, we have not done much to repair injustices and reduce inequalities.

It is because republican good conscience has for too long replaced republican voluntarism.

It is because we have for too long ceased to consider the republican requirement as an obligation of results.

The best antidote to communitarianism is for the Republic to keep its promises. We must remain firm on principles and pragmatic about means. For two hundred years, the Republic has been the same principles, the same values, the same objectives, but with different priorities, procedures, and means depending on the times and circumstances.

The Republic has been, at different times, Girondin, Jacobin, liberal, anti-clerical, social, radical...

It has developed at different times through conscription, universal suffrage, education, secularism, social security...

It has asserted itself in both war and peace but always in pursuit of the same ideal.

"The Republic is nothing but an instrument of emancipation, an instrument of evolution through the education of all," said Clemenceau.

The principles are sacred. I think particularly of the great principle of equality, which is the keystone of our unity.

But what equality are we talking about?

If we are talking about absolute equality of situations, we immediately fall into egalitarianism, which is the opposite of the Republic because the Republic is also the reward for merit, it is also republican elitism, it is also the reward for effort and work.

Republican equality is equality before the law, equality of rights and duties, it is the equal dignity of persons, it is equality of opportunity.

Equality of opportunity: that is today's priority.

It is by restoring equality of opportunity that the Republic will circulate its elites. It is by restoring equality of opportunity that it will honor diversity. It is by restoring equality of opportunity that it will overcome the temptation of communitarianism. Everything that hinders equality of opportunity must be fought against. Everything that prevents each person from asserting their talents and merits must be corrected. Equality of opportunity must cease to be theoretical and become real. It is not a matter of replacing one discrimination with another. It is a matter of giving more to those who have less. It is a matter of compensating for disadvantages. It is a matter of giving a second chance to those who did not have the means to seize the first.

What is the objective? To meet the challenge of mixing that the 21st century presents to us. The challenge of mixing, France has always known it. It has always risen to it. Throughout the centuries, it has mixed cultures, ideas, histories. Its universalism is the fruit of this constant mixing that has continually enriched itself with new contributions and built upon so many intertwined differences a common sense of belonging and a unique heritage of intellectual and moral values that address all humanity. It has succeeded in this mixing because it has been able to offer everyone the promise of social promotion, the promise that they could deploy all their merits, all their talents.

Responding to the challenge of diversity by resorting to ethnic or religious criteria would risk pitting rival communities against one another and confining each person to their identity and history when the goal is to grant them full and complete citizenship, to strengthen their sense of belonging to something that transcends them and opens them to the universal.

Moreover, how can we define objective ethnic criteria without risking awakening old demons, or religious criteria, without risking undermining the principle of secularism that allows all religious beliefs to coexist peacefully within the Republic?

This is indeed the meaning of the report that was submitted to me this morning by the commission chaired by Simone Veil. I would like to once again sincerely thank each of the individuals who make it up for their remarkable work. It demonstrates that we do not need to change our Constitution to make equality of opportunity a reality. We already have important levers in our hands that allow us to act. What is now needed is will and perseverance.

To successfully carry out these reforms, France must equip itself with statistical tools to measure its diversity, to precisely identify its delays and measure its progress. These instruments must be based on objective and indisputable methods. They must not reflect an ethnic reading of our society. I wish for work to be conducted with the scientific community to advance, in dialogue, on this sensitive subject.

While the question of statistics to measure inequalities and discrimination related to origin is open, the question of a proactive public action based on ethnic or religious criteria must be closed.

It is through the social criterion that we must address the problem because social inequalities encompass all others.

If we look at how inequalities are distributed, it becomes clear that by reducing all social fractures, we will simultaneously reduce all ethnic, religious, and cultural fractures. The territories, neighborhoods, and the most disadvantaged categories must be the subject of a proactive policy that will restore equality of opportunity. This is the solution that the Third Republic chose by creating the scholarship status that allowed so many children of poor immigrants to join, in one or two generations, the social, intellectual, and political elites of a Republic that then accepted to face the reality of its inequalities.

As always, real equality of opportunity begins with education. The reform of primary education, and then tomorrow that of high schools and middle schools, must contribute to this. It is when we raise the level of expectation in schools that social promotion is facilitated, not the other way around. Provided, of course, that students from the most disadvantaged backgrounds are not confined to ghettos where all the difficulties and disadvantages of social life are concentrated. This is why I wanted the school map to be gradually abolished. This is why I wished to experiment on a large scale with the possibility of closing certain schools and redistributing students from the preparatory course to other schools by organizing adapted school transport services, so that social mixing, which for so long has been the success of the Republic's school, is better ensured.

The "hope-suburb" plan has also prioritized the generalization of educational boarding schools aimed at providing support for good students from modest backgrounds who cannot find conducive study conditions at home.

The creation of centers of excellence in high schools located in disadvantaged neighborhoods, the monitoring of young people who drop out, academic support for children who are left to fend for themselves too early at the end of classes, the requirement for all high schools to present at least 5% of Terminale students in preparatory classes for grandes écoles, the development of "second chance schools," the autonomy contract being tested in 35 departments, and the opening up of neighborhoods will also contribute to increasing equality of opportunity for children who do not start life with the same chances as others.

But all these initiatives are not progressing fast enough. Some have fallen significantly behind. Others, after numerous negotiations between administrations, have seen their ambitions greatly reduced. I want to say today that I will not tolerate that what has been decided is not implemented quickly. I will not tolerate that what should be a priority is relegated to the background.

Social diversity in schools, excellence boarding schools, second chance schools, and the opening up of neighborhoods must be driven by the same ambition that propelled the development of the republican school during the time of Jules Ferry and the Republic of teachers.

From now on, equality of opportunity will no longer just be a priority in words, but it will also be a priority in actions. I will personally ensure this. Because we cannot continue like this. Because we cannot continue to make decisions that are not followed by effects.

I want a mobilization of the entire apparatus of the State, of all administrations and all ministries. I want the State to be exemplary. Exemplary in the implementation of policies in favor of equality of opportunity, exemplary in the fight against discrimination, exemplary in the promotion of diversity, exemplary in terms of transparency regarding results. But it is not only the State that must be exemplary. Local authorities must also be exemplary. Political parties must also be exemplary. Businesses must also be exemplary.

In recent years, many initiatives have been taken to change the situation.

I think of Sciences-Po, which has established a reserved access pathway for deserving high school students from priority education.

I think of the Montaigne Institute, which has mobilized more than 2,000 companies around the commitments of its diversity charter.

I think of certain business schools, certain Institutes of Political Studies, or Polytechnique, which have set up tutoring mechanisms to provide support to young people from the suburbs from those who have succeeded.

I think of high schools that, in different regions, have established training programs to help students from modest backgrounds enter preparatory classes.

I think of the "success pathways" that have just been launched by the Government to establish more bridges between schools, grandes écoles, and universities.

I think of the magnificent work accomplished over the past year and a half by the interministerial delegate for equality of opportunity for French citizens from overseas.

I think of the remarkable initiative of Lycée Henri IV with its preparatory classes for leveling up for good students from schools located in disadvantaged areas.

Many other actions deserve to be mentioned. Those who initiated them had the courage to break taboos that have long prevented our country from progressing. I want to pay tribute to all those who, with courage and imagination, have made social promotion and diversity their fight in associations, businesses, grandes écoles, and the media. But these initiatives remain too few. The count is not there. It is the whole of society that must be mobilized. We now need to go faster, further.

We need a France that makes room for everyone.

Where social promotion becomes a promise for all.

Where work and perseverance allow all those who deserve it to access the elite, to access responsibilities.

Where the principles of the Republic are respected in reality and not just formally.

Where duties are the counterparts of rights.

Real equality of opportunity must be implemented at all levels of society, breaking down all barriers.

First, in education.

To do this, we will open wide the places where the elite of tomorrow is formed. I want all high schools that prepare for the entrance exams to the grandes écoles - I say all - to create preparatory classes for leveling up based on the model of what has been done at Lycée Henri IV, and that, starting in September 2009, 25% of the places in each preparatory class for grandes écoles be reserved for the best scholarship students. By the start of the 2010 school year, this rate will reach 30%. I want the national education system to mobilize to encourage these young people, convince their families, and stimulate their applications. Every teacher, every head of establishment must feel invested with the responsibility to identify and guide students from modest backgrounds who show potential towards centers of excellence.

To support scholarship students towards these demanding pathways, I ask that "excellence boarding schools" be developed in high schools with preparatory classes for grandes écoles. Having quality accommodation is essential for working under good conditions. But it is not enough in a world where social and cultural codes are so important. That is why these institutions will offer their boarders tutoring provided by students from grandes écoles, personalized follow-up by teachers, as well as additional disciplinary support. In advance, I reiterate, we must also develop more ambitiously the establishment of boarding schools in secondary education and even in primary education for children from modest families who show good dispositions for studies. This policy must be conducted with more determination, more resources, even if it means relying on partnerships with private companies.

Excellence is not only about preparatory classes and grandes écoles; it is also about universities. But everyone knows that not all young people are equally equipped to succeed there, particularly in the first year where the failure rate is high. To introduce more equality of opportunity at this pivotal moment in higher education, I ask that the establishment contracts with universities include the creation of student jobs to ensure enhanced tutoring for scholarship students entering their first year. The reforms implemented to make universities more autonomous and an unprecedented investment effort will allow them to gradually assert themselves as full-fledged centers of excellence.

After education, the world of work.

I want anonymous CVs to become a reflex for employers. We have long known that the French are not equal in recruitment. Everyone should have the chance to benefit from an interview, to express their motivation, to showcase their skills. On this subject, we will not advance through constraint but through conviction and pragmatism. Such was the direction taken in 2006 by social partners in the agreement they reached on diversity, as it provided for experimentation. This experimentation must now be carried out.

In 2009, the Government will propose to 100 large companies to implement anonymous CVs. The results will determine if we need to go further. I also want to experiment with a system of pooling internships by training institutions, so that the best proposals from companies benefit all young people and not just the most privileged. Finally, I want to reduce discrimination within companies themselves. To this end, we will give HALDE the power to conduct unannounced inspections in workplaces.

We must go further, encouraging companies to introduce diversity at the heart of their human resources management. From a certain size, they will be required to report in their social balance sheet on the actions they are taking on this subject. A "diversity label" will be created to highlight best practices. It will be awarded to companies, but also to administrations or local authorities engaged in an active approach to promoting diversity. The first labels will be awarded as early as January. I also ask that we examine how the execution of major public contracts from the State could be conditioned on the implementation by companies of actions favorable to diversity. We must use all means to encourage stakeholders to make this issue a priority.

But if we demand such an effort from companies, the public service must set an example.

First, by helping young people from modest backgrounds prepare for competitive exams. Today, there are 170 schools for civil servants, and few of them provide a foothold for the least privileged candidates. The principle I want to apply is simple. It is the same as for preparatory classes: the same exam for all but not the same preparation. In 2009, each ministry will create integrated preparatory classes in its schools with success objectives. These preparatory classes must accommodate a student body representing at least 30% of the positions open to competition. Those selected will benefit from scholarships and housing assistance. I want this principle to apply to all public services. But it is also upstream of the exams that the public service must open up. I want the administration to offer internships to young people from neighborhoods, similar to the system implemented by the Bank of France for middle school students.

Furthermore, I expect ministers to be exemplary in the appointments of senior civil servants. I want appointment procedures that allow everyone to showcase their skills. I want the usual pool of candidates to be broadened and opened to the diversity of France, if necessary by using recruitment agencies.

The political world must also open up to social diversity.

All political parties have a considerable delay to catch up. Few candidates from minorities are presented for election, and even fewer are elected. This situation is unjust. It generates understandable frustrations. And what legitimacy can a political class have in which a significant part of the population does not recognize itself?

To introduce more diversity, we must renew the political class profoundly. I therefore want parties to commit to a diversity charter. Their public funding could be conditioned on their compliance with their commitments.

An evaluation commission for the promotion of diversity in political life will be established. It will publish an annual public report on the efforts made by the various political formations benefiting from public funding to ensure better representation of diversity in local and national political bodies. Each of these political formations will have to submit an annual report on the initiatives implemented and the results achieved in this area.

Diversity must also find its place on television.

Each channel will determine objectives for improving diversity on screen, but also in management and decision-making structures. These commitments will be formalized in agreements with the CSA. The CSA will verify that the channels fulfill their commitments and will publish its findings. I will naturally ask France Télévisions to be particularly exemplary.

To implement all these measures, I ask the Government to present me with an action plan by March. I have asked Yazid Sabeg to take charge of this work of mobilizing all the resources of the State and society as Commissioner for diversity and equality of opportunity. I thank him for accepting this mission in the name of his vision of the public interest and his attachment to the values of the Republic. I know he will put all his energy, conviction, and heart into accomplishing this great task. He will work in close coordination with the interministerial delegate for equality of opportunity for French citizens from overseas, whose experience will be invaluable. He will conduct thorough consultations with all stakeholders, as we will not advance without dialogue, particularly with associations and individuals from diverse backgrounds who have too often been excluded from the development, implementation, and evaluation of diversity promotion policies.

Dear friends,

We must change.

We must change our behaviors, we must change our habits.

We must change to remain true to our values.

We must change so that the Republic remains alive.

We must change so that no French citizen feels like a stranger in their own country.

We must change so that our children are proud of the France we will leave them.

We must change because it is a moral duty and because it is a political necessity.

We must change and we will change.

This change, many French people are waiting for it, many French people hope for it, many French people want it.

I will personally get involved. I will dedicate all my energy to it.

Long live the Republic!

Long live France!