Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in "Le Généraliste" on January 13, 2012, on health policy.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

13 January 2012

Context
Sarkozy gave an interview to medical journal Le Généraliste on January 13, 2012, reviewing his presidency's health policy reforms.
Main themes
Health system reform, remuneration of private practitioners, multidisciplinary health houses, medical desertification, drug safety and health scandals, access to care, fee overruns, performance-based payment, regional health agencies, Alzheimer plan, bioethical laws
Duration
~14 min
50th percentile
Words
1,735
50th percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
62nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

101 sentences in 23 paragraphs

THE GENERALIST - Reform of the drug system, creation of regional health agencies, revision of bioethical laws, Alzheimer plan, new medical convention. In your opinion, which of these projects, initiated under your presidency, will have the most impact on the world of health?

Nicolas Sarkozy - Your question reflects the extent of the changes we have initiated. I personally got involved in health issues right after my election. My first trip as President of the Republic was to the hospital in Dunkirk. Choosing one reform over another is always difficult, especially since we have transformed the entire health system since 2007: hospital governance as well as the organization of outpatient care, the drug safety system as well as the remuneration of private practitioners. However, I believe that I would primarily highlight the dynamic of change driven with private practitioners and paramedical professionals. The new medical convention initiates a revolution in the remuneration of private practitioners. At the same time, the massive deployment of multidisciplinary health houses and centers will profoundly transform the organization of care. Furthermore, Health Insurance has established ambitious agreements with private nurses and physiotherapists that will help rebalance the distribution of these professionals across the territory. We are building the future, and no one will turn back.

- You had to face the Mediator affair. Health authorities are now confronted with the scandal of PIP prostheses. Health agencies have been under significant pressure lately... Will the reforms that have been initiated be sufficient?

N. S. Allow me to emphasize the responsiveness and effectiveness of the minister in charge of these issues, Xavier Bertrand, who has made the right decisions regarding the Mediator case by initiating a profound reform of our health product safety policy after a consultation that was as exemplary as it was thorough. Today, we have a more transparent and effective system of expertise and control. It was imperative to guarantee our fellow citizens total trust regarding the drug chain.

Regarding the PIP case, we are also fully determined to identify all responsibilities. This is the purpose of the investigations requested by Xavier Bertrand, and we will ensure complete transparency on them. It seems, at this stage, that we are facing a blatant deception that transcends the borders of our country. Justice has been seized.

- Concerning access to care issues (financial or geographical), are the recently adopted conventional or legislative solutions the right ones? Should we consider more stringent measures to combat medical desertification and excessive fees? Should we multiply the number of multidisciplinary health houses across the territory to reach a thousand by 2017, as suggested by the UMP?

N. S. I have chosen a principle and a method on these subjects. The principle is one of trust. The method is that of dialogue and partnership with health professionals. Because I do not believe in coercion. Because I do not want our fellow citizens to consult general practitioners who have been forced to settle "by constraint." That is not what the French want. However, I do not overlook the concerns of many local elected officials, who themselves are the spokespersons for the fears of their constituents. That is why we have, with private practitioners and other professionals, an obligation to deliver results.

And when I see the results we are achieving regarding multidisciplinary health houses, I tell myself that we have made the right choices. In 2007, multidisciplinary health houses were supported by a handful of "activists." Bringing their project to fruition was a Herculean task. Today, we have 250 operational health houses and more than 500 solid projects that will come to fruition in the coming months. We are therefore well ahead of our roadmap. For a simple reason: because we have developed and deployed legal tools, funding, and operational support to truly accompany the projects of private professionals. We have worked in conjunction with local elected officials. We can now capitalize on these efforts; the ramp-up will continue strongly in the coming years.

Regarding fee overruns, Parliament has defined the parameters for a first step for the optional sector. This must be implemented quickly. I remain convinced that a common regulation between Health Insurance and complementary organizations, shared with private practitioners, is the right solution.

- A new performance-based payment system will be implemented in 2012 for general practitioners. Does this correspond to your desire to diversify the remuneration of general practitioners? Should we go further in this dynamic, even if it means further reducing the place of fee-for-service payment?

N. S. In December 2010, during my visit to Orbec in Calvados, I set the course for the diversification of the remuneration of private practitioners. It is not about replacing fee-for-service payment but about building complementary forms of remuneration based on fee-for-service payment. To recognize the new missions of private practitioners. To better guide towards best practices. Medical unions and Health Insurance have together reached the performance-based payment system. I note that this new medical convention has been signed by a very large majority of medical unions, which is unprecedented and proves the strength of this commitment. The challenge now is to make it work on the ground, but I am pleased that this convention can be deployed on the basis of a near-consensus among the medical community. Who could have said, just five years ago, that we would have this consensus around such an ambitious evolution of the remuneration of private practitioners, after so many sterile confrontations? We must go further, particularly in terms of reducing paperwork and procedures that take up too much of health professionals' time. We must also continue to progress in the digitization of practices.

- Should the respective roles of hospitals and outpatient care in the French healthcare system be redefined? And what role should general medicine have in your view within our healthcare system?

N. S. With the hospital law passed in 2009, we initiated a reform of hospital governance and its place in the healthcare system. It needs to be refocused on its priority missions: the management of acute pathologies. It must be allowed to better cooperate in its territory, with private medicine as well as with other health establishments, both public and private. These changes are now fully underway, but all of this takes time.

Regarding general medicine, its place is absolutely central. We must continue to consolidate, in coherence with what we have done since 2007: the full recognition of general medicine as a specialty in its own right, the structuring of a dedicated teaching pathway, and on the ground, the structuring of a proximity medicine of which the general practitioner is the pivot. Let us look at the situation in our European neighbors and measure the chance we have to rely on numerous, well-trained, and easily accessible general practitioners for the population.

- Doctors are feeling an increasing sense of insecurity; some have even been assaulted in their own offices. What measures do you plan to implement to address this discouraging situation for new installations?

N. S. Claude Guéant and Xavier Bertrand have already initiated an action plan to enhance the security of private practices, including the development of surveillance cameras around practices and the facilitation of filing complaints for private practitioners. The assault of a private practitioner in a difficult neighborhood is all the more unacceptable as it provides a service that benefits the entire population. Seeing a doctor remove their nameplate for this reason is an unbearable waste. Furthermore, do not forget that the various installation aids concern both rural areas and sensitive urban zones. We must create a set of favorable conditions to maintain practices in these areas, even attract new doctors.

- The High Council for the Financing of Social Protection will soon begin its work. What do you expect from its reflections, especially as the government seems to be moving towards a rapid implementation of social VAT?

N. S. I announced in my wishes for 2012 my determination to act quickly to reduce the cost of labor in our country. This is essential for the competitiveness of our companies, for growth, and for employment. This involves a reform of the financing of social protection. We will debate this with social partners during the social summit on January 18. However, this will be a first step, and the High Council for the Financing of Social Protection will need to evaluate its implementation and conduct complementary analytical work.

- During your visit to Bordeaux, you declared war on social fraud. Will this issue be at the heart of the debates in the upcoming presidential campaign?

N. S. It is especially at the heart of our action today. By cross-referencing the files of different administrations, by increasing and better targeting controls. By systematizing sanctions. In the face of social fraud, as in the face of tax fraud, we must have a principle of zero tolerance. In a period where we are asking all French people to make efforts, nothing is more unbearable for our fellow citizens than to see profiteers taking advantage of the generosity of the system. This is therefore a priority today, and it will remain so. We have already achieved results. In 2010, 3.4 billion euros were detected in terms of social, tax, and customs fraud, which is 20% more than in 2009. This shows the effectiveness of the repression of this unacceptable phenomenon.

- Whether it concerns access to medically assisted procreation, research on embryonic cells, or the demand for medical assistance to die, France takes a more restrictive position than its neighbors. On the left and the right, some advocate a more liberal attitude on these issues. And you?

N. S. On issues that touch the core of the human condition, we must above all preserve the values that underpin our society and our conception of the human person. Just because something is technically possible does not mean it is humanly desirable. Obviously not. This is the debate we had during the revision of bioethical laws, a debate that showed the French people's adherence to the principles that underpin these laws: respect for human dignity, the refusal of any form of commodification and exploitation of the human body.

Some tell us that our neighbors go further than we do on certain issues. I do not resign myself to the idea that our ethical rules should be copied from those existing abroad. Let us remain true to our values!