Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reforms undertaken by the government and the role of the assemblies, in Paris on January 11, 2012.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

11 January 2012 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French parliamentarians and officials in Paris on January 11, 2012, presenting New Year's wishes and outlining reforms undertaken during the legislature amid economic crisis.
Main themes
Government reforms, economic crisis, pension reform, parliamentary responsibility, social model preservation, fiscal responsibility, courage in policymaking, truth in political discourse, French national resilience, European solidarity
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,073
86th percentile
Sentences
210
90th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%56%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

210 sentences in 89 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the Senate,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Deputies and Senators,

Ladies and Gentlemen representatives in the European Parliament,

Mr. Mayor of Paris,

Ladies and Gentlemen Councilors of Paris,

I am happy to be able to extend my best wishes to you for this new year. These are wishes for yourselves, for your families, and for all those who are close to you. The political struggle is tough, political life is difficult, and each of us, regardless of our commitment, knows the price of a solid family and personal support system, which often suffers from a political battle that it did not choose and that we impose on them. I also think that, regardless of your commitments, everyone can share this feeling and that everyone understands what I mean and what I am alluding to.

Of course, I do not forget the institutions that you embody. You are the representatives of national sovereignty. In this capacity, through you, it is to the French people that I wish to extend my wishes.

On December 31, I wanted to speak to the French people with gravity, because the crisis that our country has been going through for three years is serious. I wanted to speak to them with sincerity, without denial and without false pretenses.

How, moreover, could the French people have confidence if they felt that the truth was being hidden from them? How could we ask them for efforts if we do not tell them the truth?

Since this crisis began, our compatriots have shown exemplary courage. They have also demonstrated their ability to accept the reforms that were, in our eyes, inevitable to preserve our social model.

For thirty years that I have been engaged in political life, I have heard it said that France is not a reformable country, that France is doomed to decline due to its alleged inability to profoundly transform its structures. All the actions we have taken together since the beginning of the legislature demonstrate the opposite. When it comes to the survival of our social model, as was the case with the pension reform, the French people have shown that they are a responsible people. No violence. No blockages. Of course, the expression of differences - that is normal in a democracy - demonstrations to mark discontent, but France has given the whole world the example of a country that accepted the discourse of truth and the making of difficult decisions.

Last year, I told you while presenting my wishes that I thought this 13th legislature would be marked in contemporary history as one of courage.

I believe we can agree together that this past year has confirmed that conviction. You voted on three budgetary collectives, two Social Security Financing Bills, in addition to the traditional budgetary exercises. What have you demonstrated, National Assembly and Senate? Your responsiveness and your sense of responsibility.

Far from the clichéd images of supposed parliamentary indifference, you have proven that you were up to the mission that the French people entrusted to you. You have allowed France to face new challenges, to assume European solidarity, while protecting our economy.

Be proud of the way you have exercised your mandate. Courage is never a vain virtue. The French people know how to recognize those who protect them and, above all, the French people can guess what situation the country would have been in if you had not voted for the reforms that we submitted to you to save our social model.

The Minister of State, returning from Portugal, informed me that the Portuguese government is working on a 25% reduction in the salaries of senior civil servants. This is what happens in countries close to us, courageous countries, strong countries where reform decisions were not made in time.

I cannot emphasize enough the magnitude of the threat that hung over our distribution system. One in ten pensions was no longer guaranteed, and the State had to resort to borrowing every year to pay them.

Of course, no one is enthusiastic about the idea of contributing for two more years. But what was the fair solution? To lower the pensions of the French? To increase contributions? Any other solution would have been unjust. The French know this. Just as our compatriots know perfectly well that no one will go back on this reform that you decided together.

For the French to accept to follow the path that is proposed to them, it requires, I am well aware, a balance between the efforts requested and the expected benefits.

The path is narrow. The role of the politician is to lead the French people along this ridge line. During this legislature, we have tried to maintain this concern for balance and justice.

Our compatriots are ready to make an effort, provided they do not feel that they are being asked for more than they can provide or, more precisely, that they are not being asked for more than the situation exactly requires. The problem is that there is no great book where this line is precisely defined. How convenient it would be for political leaders like us, regardless of our commitments and sensitivities, to be able to refer to this great book where it is perfectly explained where the limit and the ridge line are.

That is why -- in addition to safeguarding pensions -- with the Prime Minister, it seemed just to us to protect the most vulnerable by increasing the minimum pension by 25% over the course of the five-year term, and the Disabled Adult Allowance by 25% over the course of the five-year term.

In the same way, we have maintained the core of our project on work.

I did not want to revisit the exemption from charges and the tax exemption for overtime, for a simple reason, which is that 9 million employees benefit from it. 9 million! For those who received overtime, and we would have liked there to be more, it is additional purchasing power. To go back on that would have deprived them of this purchasing power earned through extra work.

For France to navigate the crisis under the best conditions, it has been necessary to constantly seek this balance. I am not saying that we have found it, I am saying that it is probably the most difficult thing to achieve for political leaders. Ultimately, the dialogue between the Executive and the Parliament allows us to find this balance, text by text, the right dosage to achieve a just reform.

I therefore want to pay tribute, on this day of wishes, to the fruitful collaboration between the government, which I salute, and your assemblies.

Among the members of the government, you will allow me to particularly salute Patrick OLLIER for the remarkable work he is doing.

In my wishes to the French people, I recalled that it is thanks to their composure that France has resisted. But I believe it is fair to say that it is also thanks to the solidity of our institutions.

We can collectively take pride in this. The institutions of the Fifth Republic are no longer in fundamental debate today. The political landscape, as the older among us know well, was built in 1958 between supporters and opponents of the Constitution of the Fifth Republic. It took two decades and alternation for those who contested the legitimacy of the regime to rally to it. Today, there is no longer a governing party that contests its foundations. Our regime is a precious asset. Whether we draw our roots from Gaullism or not, it seems to me that we can all agree on this.

In this regard, the change of majority in the Senate last September, Mr. President, is just the latest illustration of the long series of examples that demonstrate that our institutions rely on a subtle balance that it would be absolutely foolish to want to disrupt.

I have no doubt that those who argued, not long ago, for the abolition of the Senate will see in the alternation in the Senate a reason to preserve an institution that is very useful to the balance of our Republic.

So often, heirs of Montesquieu, we like to oppose the majority and the opposition, the Executive and the Legislative, considering that the institutions, as they have been conceived, should have as their main objective to allow each power to temper the other or to prevent its excesses.

That was not the mark I wanted to imprint on our relations. I believe in complementarity. I believe in mutual stimulation.

In proposing the constitutional revision of 2008, I told you that a "strong" executive power does not imply a "weak" legislative power. We need a strong Parliament. Not to protect us against some drift. But rather so that the dynamic of a strong executive power and a strong Parliament nourish each other. That is the meaning of the constitutional revision that you adopted.

Not one of you has regretted it since this reform has been implemented, including those who did not vote for it. It passed by a single vote.

But this is a constant of our modern political system. Once a text is adopted, and regardless of the parliamentary battles that took place, it is rarely discussed afterward. This reform gave rise to a psychodrama, as our political system loves. But who, today, two years later, contests the reform or talks about modifying it? No one.

Do not be mistaken: this constitutional revision will be a major achievement of your parliamentary action. Because we often talk about the two main roles of Parliament: the legislative power and the power of oversight. But we forget another fundamental power, that of the Constituent.

For the fiftieth anniversary of our Constitution, you adopted its most profound revision since 1958. You created no less than 9 new articles and modified 39 others.

Contrary to the fantasies circulated, not a single one of these articles has strengthened presidential power. All the provisions you adopted -- as well as the 9 related organic laws -- strengthen the rights of our citizens, the rights of Parliament, and the rights of the opposition.

The rights of our citizens.

The priority question of constitutionality (QPC) is a tremendous advance for individual freedoms. Every litigant now has the right to challenge the conformity of a law with the Constitution.

This reform had been considered several times over the past twenty years and each time it had bogged down in endless debates. The President of the Constitutional Council had called for it since 1989, Robert BADINTER. Two constitutional bills, in 1990 carried, if I remember correctly, by Mr. François MITTERRAND, and in 1993, did not succeed.

It is the honor of this legislature, yours, to have given our compatriots the right to raise a question of unconstitutionality. And this right is being used by our citizens since, for the past year, the Constitutional Council has issued 110 decisions in response to these questions. We are thus discovering, each month, the scope of this device that profoundly rearranges our legal environment and better protects the fundamental rights of our citizens.

It was a difficult choice to make. But today, who would come to tell the French: the priority question of constitutionality, it must be canceled?

For five years, public freedoms have progressed in our country, but so has democracy.

Your role, the role of Parliament, has been revalued.

We have thus established public session discussions based on the text adopted in committee. Since I have been engaged in political life, I have heard this request. No one ignores that, in practice, this right is probably the most powerful since it rigorously inverts the balance of power when there is disagreement between the committee and the minister.

We have imposed the respect of mandatory deadlines between the deposit of a text and its examination, which guarantees that committees do not bypass their work.

We have established the sharing of the agenda. In two years, practice has evolved: instead of having two distinct and parallel agendas, the Government and the chambers dialogue to establish what we call a concerted agenda. This allows for better prioritization of legislative work in the interest of the French people.

We have strictly limited, in law, the use of Article 49-3. In practice, Ladies and Gentlemen parliamentarians, with the Prime Minister, François FILLON, we are the only ones who have not resorted to Article 49-3 since the mandate of Georges POMPIDOU, never, not once.

The constitutional revision has also ensured that Parliament is now systematically informed of external military operations, which is normal, and authorizes their extension.

This revision has given the opposition and minority groups a true constitutional status.

In practice, this allows them to have numerous time slots on the agenda and to propose, as a right, investigative commissions. I remind you that we have also entrusted the opposition with the presidency of the Finance Committee of the National Assembly. And that should not have been such a bad idea, since the new senatorial majority has decided to follow this happy democratic path by entrusting the presidency of the Finance Committee to the opposition.

Who, today, can contest that these are democratic practices that honor France and do not weaken Parliament?

Furthermore, I made sure that it was a member of the opposition, from the majority opposition group, who was appointed to the presidency of the Court of Auditors. And I believe that, here too, the usual practice of appointing a political friend, however prominent, however strong-willed, to head the oversight body does not strengthen this great institution that is the Court of Auditors.

I know that this has raised many questions within the majority, but frankly, France deserves this effort of openness.

I would also like to remind you that we have chosen to better frame the prerogatives of the head of state.

At my initiative, you adopted the limitation to two of the number of consecutive presidential terms. I believe that this is wise and that it will prevent France from having these endless careers. It will compel France to have alternations that are not simply alternations between the left and the right, between the left, the right, the center, but also within each political camp, each political family.

Who, when sincerely questioning their conscience, can say that it was normal for us to be the only major democratic country with the political longevity that we have known, regardless of the quality of the individuals who have held these responsibilities?

Who knew in 2006 who would become President OBAMA? And who can doubt the rhythm, chanted by the streets, of "10 years is enough," which could also be echoed on the other side of the Channel and in so many other democratic systems?

This aims to make our country an exemplary Republic. I was also talking about the presidency of the Court of Auditors, a position held by a member of the opposition. Frankly, was it normal that we had to wait 50 years for the magistrates of the Court of Auditors to be able to cross the door of the Élysée? That we had to wait 50 years for the President of the Republic to accept that the accounts of the house he embodies or directs be audited? Never had a magistrate of the Court of Auditors been allowed to enter the Élysée Palace. From now on, the Élysée will be audited by the Court of Auditors every year. Here too, it is a step forward in our democratic functioning.

I would like to clarify, finally, regarding the appointments for which I wanted you to have a say on the most important ones, that I have decided, in agreement with the Prime Minister, that the vacant positions until the next presidential election will not be filled if they concern heads of public institutions that play an essential role in implementing the economic and social policy of the Nation.

I wish, in a democratic spirit, that the same applies to positions in public enterprises that play a comparable role in the life of the Nation. I am well aware that I am setting a precedent, but it is a precedent that will honor our democratic life. Naturally, according to the letter of our institutions, the prerogatives of the head of state last in their entirety until the last second, regardless of the choice of the French people. But it seems to me that France must learn to progress in democratic life and that the last three months are not conducive to appointments, regardless of what the judgment of the French people will be. You see, I believed in the exemplary Republic in 2007, and at the beginning of 2012, I believe in it just as much.

Of course, not everything is finished. We must make our institutions live.

Bernard ACCOYER often speaks to me about the example of the Bundestag. I would like to commend the initiative he took with President Norbert LAMMERT to create a joint working group. The much-needed convergence between France and Germany must teach us to work together, and it cannot be solely the responsibility of the two governments; it must also involve their Parliament.

But since I am talking about the economic responsibility of Parliament, I cannot fail to mention, once again and with gravity, the necessity for France to adopt the golden budget rule.

Ladies and gentlemen, all governments in the eurozone, from both the right and the left, agree to adopt this rule in their Constitution.

It was Chancellor SCHROEDER, a great statesman, a socialist, who had it adopted by the German Parliament. It was socialist Prime Minister ZAPATERO who had it adopted by the Spanish Parliament.

What political leader could make anyone believe that this golden rule is not necessary?

France cannot, on its own, free itself from the minimum rules of budgetary discipline. The golden rule is neither right nor left. It is the subject of a transpartisan consensus.

Our fellow citizens understand the necessity of adopting these rules because no one can be exempted from the essential effort to restore public finances.

We have therefore mutually committed ourselves at the European level. I would like to remind you that it is the word, it is the signature, it is the authority of France that is at stake. And when President MITTERRAND or President CHIRAC signed a treaty, it was the word of France. And the word of France imposes itself on all. It cannot be called into question like that. In all countries, it is the same, and in ours particularly, given our responsibilities.

So of course, it is France as a whole that is making this effort. The First President of the Court of Auditors, Didier MIGAUD, just emphasized, during the solemn opening session, that: "the structural effort to reduce the public deficit in 2011 represents a significant improvement compared to the past."

I want to tell you all that it is all public authorities that must participate in this national effort. I know that the crisis is hitting your local authorities too and that all this is not easy, but in 10 years, from 1998 to 2009, all local authorities created just over half a million public jobs. During the same period, the number of state civil servants decreased by 59,000. Since I have been President of the Republic, the decrease in the number of state civil servants has accelerated, as in the last five years, 160,000 state civil servant positions have been eliminated. I know that every day, in the municipalities of France, 500,000 local elected officials are serving our fellow citizens. I respect their work, I know their dedication, I understand their sense of responsibility. But I call on all local elected officials to heed the message just delivered to them by the First President of the Court of Auditors:

"A real control of local spending requires a more rigorous management of the staff of the territorial civil service."

I quoted him so that everyone understands that in my mind there is nothing partisan. Social security is making efforts with respect to the ONDAM. The State is implementing considerable efforts. Our local authorities, especially regions and departments, cannot be exempted from this reform.

These recommendations from the Court of Auditors seem to me to need to be taken into account. It is obviously not about stigmatizing anyone—what would be the point?—but about facing, together, a reality: it is the same taxpayers at the national level, as at the local level, who are called upon to finance public spending, exactly the same ones.

I am therefore convinced that, in the current situation, a republican, responsible, and reasonable dialogue is possible to better respond to the challenge of controlling our public finances.

That is why, together with the Prime Minister, starting next month, we will bring together the presidents of local elected officials' associations, the president of the local finance committee, the presidents of the finance commissions of the Senate and the National Assembly to examine, together, the ways and means to better involve local authorities in the essential effort to reduce the public deficit. How do you expect our fellow citizens to understand something if the rule of 1 out of 2 applies to the State and if there is no control rule for local authorities? I will be told, it is not easy because the crisis is hitting, that is true. But if the crisis is hitting, it is also hitting the accounts of the State and the management of the State.

Ladies and gentlemen, in closing, I would like to tell you that among all the concerns of political leaders, there is one that is shared by all our families: to ensure that politics matters and that "it is not the markets, nor the rating agencies that make politics for us."

This question is legitimate, and this question occupies all our political formations. This question deserves an answer. In the face of the situation we find ourselves in, to preserve, today and tomorrow, our budgetary maneuvering room, our autonomy, our sovereignty, the control of our destiny, we must remember that we cannot spend more than we have.

Of course, these agencies and these markets exasperate many of our fellow citizens, but let us not be mistaken: it is not the thermometer that gives the fever. The best way to regain our autonomy and control of our destiny is to implement urgent, structural decisions to regain growth and competitiveness, and to continue the effort to restore our public finances.

If these agencies, if these markets have gained too much influence, it is because since 1974 our country has not voted a single balanced budget. This question, I believe, must be posed in this way. Undoubtedly, it holds us all accountable, it questions us all about our responsibilities. But it seems to me that we cannot avoid posing this question in this way.

So, ladies and gentlemen, members of Parliament, to my political friends, I want to express my friendship. To my political competitors, I want to say that I am sensitive to their republican presence. Let them be reassured, I have enough experience not to draw any conclusions from their approval. But for our fellow citizens, ladies and gentlemen of the opposition, it is extremely reassuring to see a great country like ours capable of gathering in the house that symbolizes political power men and women of different ideas and capable, for a moment, of coming together to present republican wishes without insulting each other, without disrespecting each other, and without drawing conclusions that we do not have to draw.

And may I be allowed, in closing on a more personal note, to express the wishes I have for you and your families, wishes that, of course, are directed at those who share my convictions as well as those who do not. Because the right to happiness for the political class is neither left nor right. It is for all those who have chosen this difficult commitment, with much pressure, much complexity, and just for that, I want to express my respect and the hope that you find in your family lives the compensation, because you may not find it necessarily in your professional lives during this year 2012.

Thank you all.