Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in the Brazilian weekly "Veja" on March 12, 2011, particularly on the popular revolutions in North Africa, the fight against hunger in the world, nuclear non-proliferation, and Franco-Brazilian relations.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

12 March 2011 · Interview in the Brazilian weekly Veja

Context
Sarkozy was interviewed by Brazilian weekly Veja on March 12, 2011, discussing North African revolutions, Libya, hunger, nuclear issues, and Franco-Brazilian relations.
Main themes
Arab Spring uprisings, Libyan crisis and Gaddafi, Franco-Brazilian relations, democracy and human rights, international community response, Union for the Mediterranean, migration and immigration, humanitarian aid, nuclear non-proliferation, fight against hunger, Tunisia democratic transition, security Council actions
Duration
~39 min
89th percentile
Words
4,621
89th percentile
Sentences
210
90th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
12.1
47th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

210 sentences in 77 paragraphs

QUESTION - To what extent can popular uprisings in North Africa lead to the establishment of anti-Western governments, and what could be the consequences for the region?

THE PRESIDENT - What is happening in the Arab world is historic. These Arab revolutions are admirable because they are authentic. Without the help of anyone, with incredible courage, these peoples have taken their destiny into their own hands and overthrown regimes they rejected. And they did it in the name of the values that are dearest to us: freedom, democracy, justice, human rights. For the first time in history, these values can triumph on both sides of the Mediterranean.

We should not be afraid of these revolutions. Of course, no one can say with certainty what will happen in the future, and no one can rule out deviations. But let us remember that neither in Tunisia, nor in Egypt, nor anywhere else, did the protesters shout "down with the West"; nowhere did we hear extremist or fundamentalist slogans. All these peoples are asking for is respect for their most basic rights. And they are doing so with a courage and dignity that commands admiration.

The hope that these historic movements have generated must not die. Nothing would be worse than seeing this wind of freedom give rise to regimes even worse than those it has overthrown.

Our responsibility is to support these profound changes, to help these peoples and their leaders succeed in their transition to democracy. We have a duty to stand by these peoples who have chosen to be free. It is by supporting them financially, technically, and humanely in this transition that we can best help them avoid these deviations, and that is how we will rise to the occasion of this historic moment.

The time has also come to refound, in light of these historic developments, the Union for the Mediterranean, launched in 2008 at the initiative of France. France will make proposals to its partners in this regard.

QUESTION - What can the international community do in the face of the tragic events unfolding in Libya?

THE PRESIDENT - It is essential that the international community mobilizes to ensure that Mr. Gaddafi and his clan cease the violence against the Libyan people. The unanimous Security Council has already adopted a number of sanctions, referring the matter to the International Criminal Court and deciding on economic measures, which we are implementing with great determination within the European framework.

At France's request, an extraordinary European Council dedicated to the situation in Libya will meet on March 11 to address the Libyan situation as a whole: how to end the violence and allow Libyans to obtain the democratic regime they are demanding? How to address the migration issues resulting from the departure of hundreds of thousands of foreigners who were previously employed in Libya - France has also contributed significantly to this evacuation, particularly for Egyptians, nearly 5,000 of whom have returned home on French planes or boats.

Furthermore, we must prevent Gaddafi from using his air forces against the civilian population. Naturally, this must be done within the framework of a United Nations resolution and international cooperation with our partners. From this perspective, Brazil has an eminent role to play, as it is a respected and listened-to actor in the international community and sits on the United Nations Security Council.

We must also support the Libyan democratic opposition. This is what we have done by being the first country to welcome the creation of the National Libyan Council and by supporting the principles and objectives that drive it.

Finally, our duty is to alleviate the suffering of the Libyan people by providing the humanitarian aid they so desperately need. This is what France, along with others, has begun to do. We have already sent several humanitarian convoys, and we will further strengthen this aid. The world must stand by the Libyan people at this tragic yet hopeful moment in their history.

QUESTION - France supports the revolution in Tunisia but refuses to accept illegal immigrants fleeing the chaos in that country. How do you explain this contradictory position?

THE PRESIDENT - What we have said is that we would apply the visa rules in force with Tunisia, nothing more, nothing less.

Tunisia is experiencing historic moments; our role is to stand by the Tunisian authorities to help them succeed in their democratic transition and to respond to the expectations of the Tunisian people. Europe certainly has an important role to play in supporting this process. I am particularly thinking of issues related to education and training for young people, on which I wish the European Union to engage particularly. This is why France has proposed to its European partners to quickly adopt a common strategy on all these issues.

This is how we can stand by Tunisia, by helping it offer a future to its youth, and certainly not by allowing it to drain away the talents it needs now more than ever. Especially since nothing would be worse than to accept massive numbers of people whom we would not have the means to welcome with dignity.

QUESTION - Last year, you stated that a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians would be possible in 2011. More recently, the publication of documents on negotiations between Palestinians and Israelis indicates that they are, on the contrary, far from reaching an agreement. Do you still believe that a peace agreement is possible in this region? How could it be achieved?

THE PRESIDENT - A revival of the peace process is not only possible, but it is necessary and urgent. The parameters of a peace agreement have been known for a long time; it is now a question of will.

I do not underestimate the difficulties of this negotiation, and I am also aware that the choice of peace is not always the one that requires the least courage. But it is a risk to take. The greatest danger is that of stagnation, as the status quo only strengthens extremism on each side.

Only a resumption of direct negotiations will allow us to break the deadlock, and it is the responsibility of the international community to promote and support it.

But for that, we must be able to learn from previous efforts and address the question of method. A more collective approach is needed, involving all those who play a role in the Middle East, including of course Europe. It is in this spirit that France has proposed to consider a mechanism to support this negotiation, which would involve the countries that are particularly involved in resolving this conflict, both in the region and beyond. This is the only way to restore trust between the parties, which is currently sorely lacking.

I have also said that France is ready to host a second international donors' conference for the future Palestinian state, following the one in December 2007. On one condition: that this donors' conference is framed within a political dimension.

QUESTION - Some economists argue that hunger in the world is not due to a lack of food, but to a poor distribution of wealth. One of the most effective ways to redistribute wealth is to open the markets of rich countries to products from poor countries. Is France planning to go in this direction while it holds the presidency of the G20?

THE PRESIDENT - The fight against hunger in the world is, for France, an absolute priority. Today, one billion human beings are malnourished; agricultural commodity prices are skyrocketing; and there is no guarantee that we will not again experience, as we did three years ago, food riots this year.

France is the country that has fought the hardest in recent years to place the issue of food security at the top of the international agenda: as early as 2008, by proposing the creation of a global partnership for food and agriculture, and then by making this issue a priority of the French presidency of the G20.

To reduce hunger in the world, we must - as you rightly point out - open our markets to the poorest countries. This is what we Europeans did by adopting the "Everything But Arms" initiative in 2001, which allowed for the complete liberalization of access to the European market for all products - with the exception of arms and ammunition - from the least developed countries.

But to meet the gigantic challenge we face, we must go further and tackle the issue of production. The parameters of the equation are simple: we must increase global agricultural production by 70% if we want to be able to feed the 9 billion inhabitants that the planet will have in 2050. This means that there is room for strong agriculture everywhere in the world: here in Brazil and Latin America, but also in Europe, the United States, Africa, and Asia...

Defending food security also means fighting against excessive volatility in agricultural commodity prices. This is an urgent and necessary battle, which I have made one of the priorities of the French presidency of the G20. We must regulate agricultural markets as we have regulated financial markets.

QUESTION - Indeed, what do you say to those in Brazil and elsewhere who believe that the fight against price volatility in commodities is primarily a means of preventing large agricultural countries, as well as poor countries, from benefiting from rising prices?

THE PRESIDENT - I tell them they are mistaken. It is in no way about limiting the development of your agriculture. On the contrary, the priority today, as I have told you, is to develop production. We need strong agriculture, and it is a good thing if Brazil establishes itself as one of the world's leading "farms." We need you to feed the planet.

In no way is it about preventing you from selling your products at a good price. But who can say that the current surge in commodity prices is not a threat to economic recovery and global stability, when, for example, the price of a ton of wheat goes from 120 euros to 300 euros in six weeks?

And who can argue that speculation plays no role when, in a single day, an operator can buy 15% of the world's cocoa production and resell it, pocketing the profit from a price increase that he himself has caused, all without having to invest a single cent?

France does not say: "prices must be fixed." It is the markets that set prices. But we simply say that agricultural markets must be regulated; that excessive fluctuations, which have no connection to reality, must be limited; that transparency must be increased; and that the role of speculation in these markets must be limited, because in the end, it is always the people who pay the price.

And even large emerging agricultures like Brazil have the greatest interest in this, because a sudden and erratic rise in prices is always followed by a drop that is just as sudden and erratic.

What do we propose concretely? First, we need to strengthen transparency in physical agricultural commodity markets, particularly regarding stock levels. Second, we must better regulate financial derivative markets for agricultural commodities, for example by establishing basic rules against market abuse. Third, we need to establish enhanced mechanisms to address food crises; I am thinking, for example, of emergency stock issues in times of crisis. We must also enable the poorest countries to access new hedging instruments to better protect themselves against price increases or events affecting harvests.

You understand, this is a subject that is extremely close to my heart, but it is a question that concerns us all. Because if we were to face food riots again, no one around the table could say that it does not concern them.

QUESTION - France is the state that most fiercely opposes a free trade agreement between Mercosur and the European Union. What is the basis for this blockage of negotiations?

THE PRESIDENT - The agreement you are referring to has been in the works for over 10 years. We have gone to the limit of what we can accept, particularly on agricultural issues. Going further would endanger the livelihoods of many producers and farmers not only in France but also in Europe, because contrary to what you seem to believe, many European countries share France's position. The European Union has already opened up significantly to agricultural imports from Mercosur. We are even the largest buyer from Mercosur by far. While we remain favorable to an agreement, it must be balanced, which also implies that Mercosur, for its part, must be willing to meet European demands regarding services and industry.

I was telling you earlier how much I respect the determination of your leaders to defend your farmers; you must also understand mine. I will not be the president who allows French agriculture to die.

But I remain convinced that we will eventually find a solution acceptable to all because it will respect the interests of each. It is our duty, as it is in the interest of our countries and the interest of our peoples.

QUESTION - The European Union is slow to accept Turkey's integration, and this Islamic country is gradually turning its back on Europe and moving closer to Iran. Is it a mistake not to have tightened the ties between the West and Turkey? Why?

THE PRESIDENT - The idea that a large country like Turkey could define its foreign policy solely based on the question of its accession to the European Union seems to me not only extravagant but particularly disrespectful to our Turkish friends. Turkey has a great diplomacy, particularly active in the region and playing an increasingly important role on the international stage, which I welcome.

I have always defended the idea that Turkey and the European Union should continue their rapprochement and build as close a relationship as possible; but without going as far as integration, which would not actually benefit either Turkey or the European Union. Turkey plays an irreplaceable role, which the world needs more than ever today: that of a bridge between East and West. But to continue to fully play this role, Turkey must maintain this unique position, which is its strength.

It is in this spirit that I proposed that we reflect on building a vast common economic and human space, of which Europe, Turkey, and Russia would be the pillars.

QUESTION - According to the Brazilian government, there is an asymmetry in the world, and imposing limits on countries seeking to develop a nuclear program is hypocritical since nuclear powers like France and the United States do not renounce their arsenals. Is this argument valid? Why?

THE PRESIDENT - One cannot address the nuclear issue without making a very clear distinction between civil nuclear and military nuclear. This distinction is indeed at the heart of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT), which defines the rights and obligations of each country in this area.

What does the NPT say? First, that all states have the right to access civil nuclear energy. This is an idea for which I have always fought: civil nuclear energy should not be reserved for a few wealthy countries; all countries should be able to access it, as it is an essential instrument for development, provided, of course, that they respect international non-proliferation, safety, and security standards. France is today the leading advocate in the world for access to civil nuclear energy. A year ago, we hosted a major international conference dedicated to this issue, which brought together more than sixty countries, including Brazil. On that occasion, I made extremely concrete proposals: for example, I called for international institutions' funding, such as the World Bank, to stop excluding projects related to civil nuclear energy; I also reiterated France's willingness to make its reprocessing and recycling facilities available to countries that do not have them, provided they respect their international commitments; France has played a leading role in favor of creating a fuel bank at the IAEA to address the risk of supply disruption, which the European Union will finance.

Military nuclear is of a different nature: it is all about the security and stability of the world. Who can seriously think that the world would be safer today if there were two, three, or four times as many countries possessing nuclear weapons? The rules defined by the NPT aim to prevent this proliferation: by asking states that already possess nuclear weapons not to transfer them to others and to pursue nuclear disarmament within the framework of general and complete disarmament; and to those who do not possess them not to seek to obtain them.

So it is not a question of symmetry but of respecting the commitments made. Because I remind you that the NPT has 189 states parties, almost all the countries in the world, which have freely adhered to it.

Finally, one last remark: on the question of arsenals, I remind you that France is, of all the nuclear-armed countries, the one that has done the most in terms of nuclear disarmament. And we are also the most transparent country in the world: I announced that our arsenal now has fewer than 300 nuclear warheads, which is half of what it was during the Cold War. I hope that all states with nuclear weapons will take similar measures.

QUESTION - But precisely, why not go further by renouncing your nuclear arsenal?

THE PRESIDENT - I told you, we are, by far, the country that has done the most in terms of nuclear disarmament. Just think: in a few years, we stopped nuclear testing; dismantled our testing sites, but also our military fissile material production sites; dismantled all our ground-to-ground missiles; reduced our air-naval component and our airborne component by a third. These are major and irreversible gestures. France is today the country that most strictly applies the principle of "strict sufficiency," meaning that we maintain our arsenal at the lowest possible level, compatible with the strategic situation and the credibility of our deterrence.

Should we go further? It is the strategic environment, the state of the threat, and the prospects for international security that will allow it or not. Above all, renouncing our deterrent capability at a time when more and more states are seeking to acquire nuclear weapons, when the threats of proliferation have never been so numerous, would simply be irresponsible.

QUESTION - How does France view the Brazilian government's support for Iran's right to develop a nuclear program for peaceful purposes?

THE PRESIDENT - France, like the entire international community, has never contested Iran's right to access, like any other country, civil nuclear energy. With our European partners, we have even made several extremely ambitious offers to the Iranian authorities since 2003, including in the field of civil nuclear energy, provided they renounce their illegal proliferating activities. The Iranians have always refused them.

Instead, they preferred to multiply delaying maneuvers and provocations: by continuing nuclear and ballistic proliferation, ignoring six United Nations Security Council resolutions and ten resolutions from the IAEA Board of Governors, and increasing the enrichment levels of uranium produced at Natanz. And I remind you that in September 2009, our intelligence services discovered the existence of a new clandestine nuclear site.

No one today can seriously argue that Iran's uranium enrichment program is for peaceful purposes. It was designed in secrecy and has no civil and industrial justification. There is only one reactor in Iran, and the Russians provide all the fuel. The IAEA reports do not say otherwise. For us, it is very clear: the prospect of a nuclear-armed Iran is simply unacceptable, as it would pose too great a risk to the security of the region and the world.

QUESTION - But why did you not support the Brazilian and Turkish efforts to find a solution to the crisis?

THE PRESIDENT - I cannot let you say that. France supported the efforts that your country undertook, with Turkey, on the Iranian file. I remind you that the Brazilian-Turkish initiative was in line with an offer we ourselves made, with our American and Russian friends, to the Iranians a few months earlier.

The aim was to take 1,200 kg of low-enriched uranium out of Iran to transform it, outside of Iran, into civil fuel for medical research activities. Why 1,200 kg? Because it ensured that the amount of uranium that Iran would have retained - we estimated its stock at the time to be 1,600 kg - would not allow it to manufacture a bomb. It was therefore an opportunity for the Iranians to show if, as they claim, their objectives were only civil and not military.

What happened next? The Iranians refused our offer after hesitating for several months. Then, when Brazil and Turkey took up the file again with great conviction, the Iranians once again dragged their feet as much as they could. When they finally pretended to resume discussions, almost 10 months later, their stock of uranium had increased so much - because in the meantime, the centrifuges had continued to spin - that even by taking out 1,200 kg of uranium, they would have retained enough material to manufacture a bomb. This is exactly the objective that the Iranians were pursuing by delaying the discussions.

It therefore no longer made sense to continue. That is why, with the other members of the Security Council, we adopted a new sanctions resolution.

I am aware that this situation has created misunderstanding and, let’s say it, a certain resentment here in Brazil. But I want you to understand that at no time did France question the positive intentions of your approach. It is the Iranians who have failed to seize the hands we extended to them to reach a peaceful solution to this crisis. We therefore have no choice but to impose increasing sanctions to convince the Iranian leaders that they have nothing to gain and everything to lose by continuing to violate their international obligations.

QUESTION - Does France support Brazil's candidacy for a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council? For what reason?

THE PRESIDENT - France was even one of the very first countries to support this candidacy. Why? First, because Brazil is already an essential player on the international stage, and it will be even more so tomorrow. It has the weight, the capabilities, and above all the will to contribute to stability and peace in the world. We can already see this in Haiti, where Brazil provides the backbone of the United Nations Mission of which it is the largest contributor, to take just this example.

Then, because if we want - and this is the case for France - the Security Council to remain the main forum for international peace and security, it must be more representative of the balances of our world. This applies to global governance as a whole, and that is why France has fought so hard for emerging countries to be better represented, in line with their political and economic weight.

This reform is already well underway. First with the G20, created at France's initiative, which allows new powers to be at the table of the world's foremost economic and financial cooperation forum; with the reform of the World Bank and that of the IMF, where the weight of emerging economies has been significantly strengthened.

But we must go further. The reform of the Security Council can no longer wait. It is a matter of the legitimacy and therefore the effectiveness of the United Nations. France, along with the United Kingdom, has proposed an interim reform that would allow the Security Council to be expanded now by granting certain states a longer mandate than the current mandate of non-permanent members. This interim reform may not be ideal, but it is probably the only way to break a twenty-year deadlock. It would be a decisive step towards a definitive expansion. We need Brazil's support to make it happen.

QUESTION - President Dilma Rousseff will reassess the offers made in the context of the fighter jet acquisition program. What justification has the Brazilian government presented for reversing a negotiation that seemed concluded in favor of the Rafale, and what offer does France make to confirm the status of its aircraft as the favorite? And how do you think the difference in position between Brazil and France on the Iranian nuclear program influenced Dilma Rousseff's decision?

THE PRESIDENT - I fully understand that Brazil wanted to give itself a little more time to make a decision of such importance. This is a major choice, a strategic choice, that commits your country for years to come. I do not perceive this decision as a "reversal," but as the expression of the Brazilian leaders' desire to choose the best aircraft for Brazil.

From this point of view, we remain convinced that the French offer is the most suited to Brazilian needs. First, because the Rafale is today the most efficient and versatile combat aircraft on the market; secondly, because it has proven itself in operations, unlike one of its competitors which is only virtual; finally, because this offer comes with unrestricted technology transfers guaranteed by the French State, something that neither of the other two competitors can credibly provide. On its part, regarding submarines, and particularly the development of a Brazilian nuclear-powered submarine, our country has shown that it keeps its commitments.

In fact, in this area as in all other areas of our economic and technological cooperation with Brazil, we have understood that simple supplier-client relationships are outdated. It is no longer about selling and buying, but about working together. This cooperation on combat aircraft must also contribute to the development of Brazil's defense industry. This goal of independence and sovereignty is all the more legitimate for France as it is also the one that has guided the development of its own defense industry.

As for the Iranian question, which has nothing to do with this, I do not see how it could influence the choice of the Brazilian authorities. As I told you, beyond the differences we may have had regarding the method, our two countries agree, fundamentally, that nuclear proliferation is one of the gravest threats to international peace and security.

QUESTION - Some say that the strategic partnership between France and Brazil is the result of a privileged relationship you had with former President Lula. Will this privileged relationship continue with the new President, Dilma Rousseff?

THE PRESIDENT - I have no doubt about that. Brazil's choice of France is not a matter of individuals; it is a strategic choice that commits our two countries in the long term.

But it is also, I believe, a natural choice, because our two countries fundamentally share the same vision of the world and are driven by the same values. We are two great democracies, committed to promoting peace and security through dialogue, and we always place people at the heart of all things; we are two important economic powers, equally concerned about social balances; two actors engaged in world affairs who have the ambition to adapt the international institutions inherited from the 20th century to the realities of the 21st century.

France is determined to help Brazil assert itself as a leading player on the international stage; it needs Brazil in return to advance the shared vision of the world that we have. I am therefore very confident that we will be able to deepen and strengthen this partnership with Dilma Rousseff that Lula and I have brought to an authentically strategic level.