Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the adoption of the Pact for the Euro, in Brussels on March 11, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

11 March 2011 · Summit of heads of state and government of the euro area · Brussels

Context
Sarkozy addressed a Brussels press conference on March 11, 2011, following the eurozone summit that adopted the Pact for the Euro and key financial stability decisions.
Main themes
Pact for the Euro, eurozone economic governance, EFSF lending capacity, Greek loan terms, Irish corporate tax rate, fiscal convergence, economic policy coordination, eurozone financial stability mechanisms, common corporate tax base, Ireland loan conditions
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,746
72nd percentile
Sentences
138
77th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.87
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

138 sentences in 48 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, good evening. We are starting a very long press conference with many questions, I hope. It is only 1:25.

You understand, this summit of heads of state and government of the euro area was very important. We have established the economic governance of Europe, as France has always requested. This economic governance is the meeting of heads of state and government, that is to say, the 17. We have adopted the Pact for the Euro, which is a decisive step. This pact will strengthen the convergence of our economic policies and the competitiveness of our economies.

We have ensured that social partners are involved in the implementation of the pact; they will be consulted annually. Furthermore, France is very pleased that the pact explicitly includes an imperative for coordination in fiscal matters. As of March 16, the Commission will make a proposal on the common corporate tax base. This is an extremely important first step to which we attach great importance.

Moreover, we have agreed on the financial capacity and flexibility of our instruments.

The first political decision is that we have agreed to increase the effective lending capacity of the mechanism known as the EFSF to 440 billion euros. As for the permanent mechanism that will succeed it in 2013, we have decided to endow it with a financial capacity of 500 billion euros. We have therefore significantly strengthened our intervention capacities.

The second decision is that we have expanded the range of usable instruments. Our two facilities - those before 2013 and those after 2013 - will mainly intervene in the form of loans, but we have decided to allow them to subscribe to bond issues in the primary market. I know this may seem technical to those who are less familiar with all this, but this little phrase may not seem like much, but it required a lot of work. This is what flexibility means, that this money can be used. Yes, I know at this hour it is a bit tedious, but still, it is very important.

The third major decision is that we have decided to align the interest rates of loans from the two mechanisms - before 2013 and after 2013 - with those of the IMF. As a result, and considering the commitments made by Greece and the excellent implementation of its program, we have decided to reduce the loans to Greece by 100 basis points and to extend the maturity of these loans to 7 and a half years. This means that Greece will repay over a longer period - it was 4 and a half years, it will now be 7 and a half years - and it will repay at a lower cost since we have decided to reduce the interest rates applied to Greece by 100 basis points.

Regarding Ireland, we have decided to revisit the conditions of its loans on March 24 and 25, because a new government has come to power and naturally, we need to continue discussions with them.

I invite you to appreciate the magnitude of the decisions we have made since May of last year. We have supported Greece and Ireland, we have created a facility of 140 billion euros, we have decided on a treaty change, we have decided to create a permanent facility, we have adopted a pact for the euro, and we have established an economic governance for the euro area.

A year and a half ago, it was not certain that we would achieve all this, but I remain at your disposal if you have questions.

QUESTION - What guarantees, or rather what allows us to believe that the corporate tax rate in Ireland will actually be increased in the coming months or years? And what was the nature of the discussions with Ireland this evening?

THE PRESIDENT - This is a very sensitive issue for our Irish friends, which I understand. It must be perfectly understood, but at the same time, all the member states of the euro area have pointed out that when we have the same currency, it is normal to converge - that convergence could not touch all areas except for fiscal convergence - that convergence first requires reflection on tax bases, if only to be able to compare them - that no one is asking Ireland to have an average rate comparable to that of Europe, but it is also difficult to ask other countries to help Ireland while Ireland responds that it intends to keep the lowest corporate tax rate in Europe. And so there is a discussion that is progressing.

I understand the problems of our Irish friends, but they must also understand the questions this raises for all the other member states of the euro area. If you look at Greece, they have lowered wages, reduced pension levels, and increased taxes. If you look at Portugal and Spain, they have done the same. All of us have had to make efforts, and Ireland, in one way or another, is certainly convinced that it will have to make them. I understand the difficulties faced by its government. There is no certainty, but there is a pact that explicitly provides for convergence, and there is a very clear demand from all the member states of the euro area for at least one gesture.

QUESTION - Mr. President, was there a specific conversation about the situation in Portugal, and if so, what were the conclusions, what message did Portugal's partners convey to it?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, regarding Portugal, as with Greece, all the member states of the euro area wanted to express their support for the very determined, very courageous, and very effective conditions for implementing the plans in Portugal as in Greece. So it was a strong endorsement that was sent to these two governments.

QUESTION - A small clarification regarding the elements of flexibility. Does this concern both mechanisms, including for the primary market, purchases in the primary market, is it also for both mechanisms?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes. Wait, "including," you are asking me if in the primary markets, it is for both mechanisms, that is to say, to be clear: does it apply before 2013 and after 2013? It is exactly for both mechanisms, so it is immediately applicable. In case we need it, it is immediately applicable.

QUESTION - On a number of pieces of information we have heard, it seems that the exchanges with the Irish between you and Angela Merkel on one side, and the Irish on the other, were very frank, shall we say even more than that?

THE PRESIDENT - I do not know what you mean by more than frank. I have the same suit, no stigma, no, no. I greatly appreciated meeting the new Irish Prime Minister. Moreover, it did not concern only Mrs. Merkel and me, who were exactly on the same position, but the President of the Council, Herman Van Rompuy, is exactly on our position, the Spaniards, the Greeks, the Portuguese, the Austrians were exactly on the position we were. No, no, I believe there is a very strong consensus.

It is true that there are a few countries that are concerned about preserving their fiscal specificity - I think of Malta, I think of Cyprus, I think of Slovakia - that is perfectly true. But we also agree that they should keep it, but you will notice that these countries do not ask others to participate in financing their plans and that the problem for Ireland is not at all a matter of principle. It is that it is difficult to ask others to contribute to financing a plan and not to be concerned about the revenue side of that plan. This is what Mrs. Merkel and I have very courteously pointed out to the Irish Prime Minister, who also responded to us very courteously.

We still have the 24th and 25th, and as you have seen, the reduction of interest rates and the extension of the loan duration applies to Greece. To my knowledge, this does not apply to any other country; it is within the framework of a win-win agreement.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT - We made a decision in principle. As you know, we made the decision with 17. It must be validated by the 27, but if you are waiting, does it apply right now - I mean, once the legal decision-making process on this basis has been formalized, it will be decided. The intervention in the primary markets applies before 2013 as well as after 2013, to the current mechanism as well as to the permanent mechanism.

QUESTION - So regarding the question of Irish taxes, what are the things still to be decided? What work is there to do now?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, we should not focus solely on Irish taxes; there is an immense amount of work on fiscal convergence. And then there is something else that is extremely important, which is that all the states of the euro area have decided to work on the development of a financial transaction tax, as it is included in the euro area communiqué. We have decided to develop a project for a financial transaction tax, and I must say that France has had the determined support of Germany and Austria, in particular, regarding the perspective of this financial transaction tax. Things are progressing there as well.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT - It has been voted. The British are not part of the euro area. I remind you that this afternoon, we were at the Eurozone Summit, the 17 of the euro area. So to my knowledge, the British are not part of it. It is the 17 of the euro area, the government of the euro area, that has decided to work on the reflection and development of a project for a financial transaction tax.

QUESTION - Mr. President, how far have you come to an agreement on two very sensitive issues: wages and pensions?

THE PRESIDENT - In the pact, things are specified. You will see the details. There is also a desire to converge, each within the framework of its national negotiations. But regarding pensions, it is: demographic question, demographic response - and regarding wages, we found a compromise with our Belgian friends to move towards an evolution of wage policy that goes in the same direction. France is no longer concerned since, to my recollection, only social benefits are indexed; wages are no longer indexed, but we have found a balance. Just as we changed the name, it is now the "Pact for the Euro in favor of competitiveness and convergence" of our economies. This has allowed us to settle the debate between those who were for convergence and those who were for competitiveness. It is now the Pact for the Euro.

QUESTION - Excuse me for wanting to do a bit of exegesis on your earlier remarks. You put Portugal and Greece on exactly the same level earlier - yet Greece is already under assistance, Portugal was not unless it is changing status?

THE PRESIDENT - Not at all, no, no, you are right to ask me the question; it avoids a misunderstanding. It is because the question that was asked of me was: what judgment do you have on the different plans of the countries in question? I was led to say that the Eurozone Council considered that the Portuguese measures, like the Greek measures, were really going in the right direction, but as you know, Portugal, to my knowledge, is not a candidate for funds from the facility. Only Ireland is. They have repeatedly said, moreover, that this would not change, but it was an assessment of the efforts that have been made, not on the modalities of financing the plan. Thank you for allowing me to clarify that.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT - Even at this hour, I have understood the questions that should not be answered. It is up to Portugal to decide. I do not see, moreover, how - it is always what I have thought - one can force a country that would not be a candidate to emerge for a facility. It is a decision that belongs to the country. I really do not see how one could force it and on what criteria? Especially since the plan implemented by Portugal and the additional measures announced for Greece and the privatization program, for Portugal, it is in terms of budget execution. There is no problem on that side.

QUESTION - I wanted to know if the participation of China in the repurchase of debts of European countries was discussed?

THE PRESIDENT - No. We already had enough topics. The Pact for the Euro, the current facility, the future facility, frankly, we did not talk about it.

QUESTION - Just a few small clarifications on Ireland if you will, to be sure, at least for me: is it clear that Ireland agrees to discuss an evolution of its taxation, of the corporate tax base? Is Ireland specifically mentioned in the conclusions?

THE PRESIDENT - In the Pact on the Euro, it is clear since it is expressly stated. The pact having been adopted, Ireland being part of this pact, it has even been agreed that on March 16, the Commission will make a proposal. So, that is perfectly clear within the framework of the Pact for the Euro. There is no agreement between Ireland and the other countries regarding the application of the conditions of the interest rates that are its own. If there were an additional effort made on our side, we would ask for an additional effort from the other side.

QUESTION - Has it been specifically requested of Ireland to raise its corporate tax rate and has it refused?

THE PRESIDENT - It has been specifically requested of Ireland to make a gesture and, at this moment, satisfaction has not been obtained. The renegotiation of loans has been initiated and concluded for Greece but not for Ireland.

QUESTION - Are you still as firmly committed and determined not to let a Eurozone state default? That is to say, is the restructuring of public debt still firmly excluded, with the markets strongly doubting Greece's ability, in particular, to meet its obligations?

THE PRESIDENT - There is no question of allowing a Eurozone state to default. There is no question of it, we have always said it, we have always emphasized it, that would mean serious problems for the euro, we do not want that at any cost. There is no question of it. Moreover, everything that Greece is courageously and efficiently implementing shows that the problem does not arise. It is perfectly clear.

QUESTION - You mentioned the participation of social partners in the development of the pact, what form can that take?

THE PRESIDENT - It is provided in the pact that there will be a consultation every year. They will be involved in the implementation and definition of this plan and it was very important for France that the reference to European social partners be indicated, it is indicated. And here too, this has been the subject of many discussions but there is a consensus, it was very important.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT - No. Now we have established a rule, each country will have to respect this rule. Convergence is a principle; afterwards, we have not set a timetable and standards, but it is a principle. We have committed to a pact on the euro in service of our competitiveness and the integration of our economic policy. For example, each country commits to inform the others before making an important decision. Can you imagine what problems could have been avoided if, for example, in terms of salary policies in the public service, this principle had been put into effect right from the creation of the euro? It would have avoided many unpleasant surprises for a number of countries we have just talked about. Because if you look at the curves of developments in the different public services, you see extremely divergent developments. That is what we want to avoid. There is really a sharing of information, evaluation meetings, it is really important.

With your permission, I would like to conclude this press conference.

Thank you.

Good evening and have a nice weekend.