Joint press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Barack Obama, President of the United States of America, on Franco-American relations and NATO, in Strasbourg on April 3, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

3 April 2009 · Joint press conference on Franco-American relations and NATO · Strasbourg, France

Context
Sarkozy and Obama held a joint press conference in Strasbourg on April 3, 2009, following the G20 summit and ahead of the NATO 60th anniversary summit.
Main themes
Franco-American relations, NATO membership and European defense, G20 summit outcomes, Afghanistan, multilateral cooperation, France-US friendship, Iran, Russia, Middle East, international peace and security
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,782
72nd percentile
Sentences
143
79th percentile
Readability
57
80th percentile
Grade
10.2
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

143 sentences in 31 paragraphs

MR. PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, we apologize for our delay. My introductory remarks will be very brief. We have reviewed a number of issues: Afghanistan, NATO, Iran, Russia, the Middle East. And I believe I can say, speaking under the authority of the President of the United States, that there is a perfect alignment of views.

But since I am speaking just the day after the G20 summit, I would like to express to Barack OBAMA how pleased I was to work hand in hand with him, how much I appreciated his open-mindedness and his willingness to build a new world. I can say that at this summit, there were no winners or losers; there were 20 leaders, including of course the leader of the world's foremost power, the United States of America, who took their responsibilities. This bodes well for the months and years to come: we have a tremendous amount of work to do because there are a lot of problems, and for us, it is a reason for optimism to be able to address them with an American administration that is willing to listen to its friends and allies and to solve problems. So, Barack, welcome to France, thank you, and I look forward to the coming weeks because we are going to take many initiatives, and the world needs them.

MR. BARACK OBAMA - Well, first of all, thank you for that extraordinary vitality, and I am excited to be part of what is indeed a true celebration. France, which is the oldest ally of the United States, our very first ally, once again, it is France that is demonstrating extraordinary leadership within NATO thanks to the courageous leadership of President SARKOZY. He is courageous on so many fronts that it is difficult to enumerate them all. The energy he brings to foreign policy issues is something we have all benefited from.

I am grateful to him for this partnership because without his leadership, it seems to me, what came out of the summit would not have been as significant as it was. Regarding the issues we discussed, whether it is Afghanistan or Russia, President SARKOZY constantly shows initiative, imagination, and creativity in seeking solutions to problems that have existed for a long time.

America is not only grateful for this friendship with France, but I, personally, am grateful for this friendship we have developed, a friendship that actually began long before my election. This friendship has only strengthened since then. We had a very productive conversation. I look forward to having more very productive discussions tonight, tomorrow morning about NATO's mission, and I am confident. When the United States and France act together, the prospects for peace and prosperity around the world are strengthened. Let's take some questions.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you explained to the French that France's return to the integrated military structure of NATO would somehow have a compensation for European defense. Have you received any guarantees from President OBAMA? For example, regarding the emergence of a strictly autonomous planning and operations cell. And Mr. President, would you accept the idea of an American pillar, a caucus with NATO?

THE PRESIDENT - You know, I have always been convinced that the United States and France are of the same family. We are in Strasbourg. I love history. I tell the French: we must never forget what American democracy has done for us. On June 6, we will be together on the beaches of Normandy to pay our respects at the graves of young Americans who died for us, who were the age of our children today. That matters in the history of two nations.

I do not have, in my relations with President OBAMA, I trust him. I trust his word, and I trust his intelligence. President OBAMA does not need me to understand that a strong Europe, that a Europe of defense that exists, is the best asset for the United States of America. The United States under President OBAMA does not want a weak ally. They want people who stand tall and take their responsibilities.

We agreed on everything a long time ago, but it was not a bargaining process; it is not a question like that. It has been the same vision of the world. There is a family. We do not want to impose our values on anyone, but we want no one, anywhere in the world, to defend us from believing in our convictions.

And finally, a word for the French, it is still extraordinary, it has been years that we have sent soldiers under the NATO banner while refusing to participate in the committee that implements the strategy for deploying these soldiers. I wanted to be transparent and honest with my fellow citizens. I wanted to take responsibility for my choices. NATO has existed for 60 years. If there is peace, it is not by chance; it is because we are together. The United States are allies and friends. They know perfectly well that France will be made up of friends, standing allies, independent because we choose our convictions.

MR. BARACK OBAMA - Allow me to respond very briefly to your question. NATO is the most successful alliance in modern history, the most complete, and the founding principle of NATO states that the security of Europe is equivalent to the security of the United States and vice versa. This is the fundamental principle; it is a pillar of American foreign policy that has remained unchanged over the past 60 years. This is a principle that I affirm here, and thanks to France's reintegration into NATO's highest commands, this principle will continue to be upheld. I want to echo President SARKOZY's words; indeed, we want strong allies. We would like Europe to have much more robust defense capabilities. In fact, no, we will not discourage that. We do not wish to be patrons of Europe. We want to be partners with Europe. The more they have in terms of defensive capability, the more we will be able to act together in the face of the common challenges we face. Therefore, one of the messages I will communicate to our NATO allies: the more we see capabilities here in Europe, the more satisfied the United States will be, the more effective we will be in coordinating our activities.

QUESTION - You said earlier that President SARKOZY spoke of strong allies who take responsibility. President OBAMA wishes to close Guantanamo within a year. Are you ready to accept some of the prisoners? Have you discussed this issue with him?

THE PRESIDENT - You know, I believe that democracy obliges statesmen to tell the truth and to be consistent. I am one of those who love the values of the United States. Guantanamo was not in line with the values of the United States, at least as I see them. I was proud and happy that the United States, which is loved here in France and in Europe, made the decision we were waiting for to close that camp. My deepest conviction is that we do not fight terrorists with the methods of terrorists. We fight them with the methods of democracy.

So, once I have said that, if the President of the United States says: I am closing Guantanamo, but I need my allies to take, in this case, there is one, to imprison here, which allows us to close the camp, then if we are consistent, we say yes, because otherwise we are inconsistent. We cannot condemn the United States for having this camp and then wash our hands of it once they close it. That is not how we are allies. That is not how we are friends. That is not how we are respected in the world. France has only one word, and France asserts a policy that is right, honest, and in line with democracy.

So, yes, we talked about it. Yes, we agreed, and yes, it is logical and consistent. And it is honest, Madam. That is how you should view France.

MR. BARACK OBAMA - President SARKOZY has been honest. He has been consistent. For my part, I made the decision to close Guantanamo because I do not believe it makes America safer. In doing so, I have been very clear that we will do it cautiously. We will do it thoughtfully. And to do it cautiously and thoughtfully, we will consult our allies, and in some cases, we will need help regarding certain detainees who may continue to pose risks. However, these individuals may not be able to be repatriated to their home countries. Indeed, we have discussed this issue. We do not have a detailed statement to make, but I just want to express my gratitude to President SARKOZY for keeping his word, of course, as always.

QUESTION - A question for both Presidents. Would you accept that the Russians participate in the European defense system? Do you think the Russians will indeed exert strong pressure on Iran to end its nuclear program?

MR. BARACK OBAMA - Perhaps I could respond first. Indeed, I had an excellent bilateral meeting during the summit with President MEDVEDEV. I believe there is extraordinary potential for improving U.S.-Russian relations, it seems to me. It seems important that NATO allies engage with Russia. NATO must recognize that Russia has legitimate interests, and sometimes we have common interests. However, we also have points of divergence. I think we need to engage in this dialogue with them to maintain stability while respecting the autonomy and independence of all countries in Europe, whether in the west, east, or center, whichever it may be.

I criticized the Russian invasion of Georgia. I continue to believe that, despite the extraordinary efforts made by President SARKOZY to arrange a ceasefire, we have not yet seen stabilization of that situation, and I think we need to communicate a very strong message to Russia: yes, we are ready to work with them, but we cannot return to the old ways.

I do believe that the United States and Russia, and Europeans, all have an interest in preventing Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon. There must be mechanisms that respect Iran's sovereignty, allowing Iran to develop civilian nuclear power, but it must be made very clear that there cannot be a nuclear arms race in the Middle East. I addressed this issue during my conversation with President MEDVEDEV. It will be a permanent issue during our bilateral negotiations.

We are very happy to be able to work with France and with other countries to reach a position on Iran that invites them to become a responsible member of the international community, but a position that clearly states that it is up to them to behave, to act as a responsible member up to expectations.

THE PRESIDENT - I have always told President MEDVEDEV that the USSR is over, that the Berlin Wall has fallen, and that there are no satellite countries around Russia, and that he must respect that. But at the same time, with the problems that exist in the world today, we are not going to reinvent the Cold War. So, it is very good news, President OBAMA's proposal for a new discussion with President MEDVEDEV, a new agreement with Russia and the United States. We do not need a new Cold War. We need gathering in the world, we need unity in the world, and we need Russia to take its responsibilities because it is a great country, to help us find a solution to the Iranian crisis. Here too, I believe I can say that the United States and France are on the same line. NATO is not made against Russia. The Warsaw Pact is over. We want to work with all those who want to work with us, honestly, to create a security space, and I hope, tomorrow for Europe, a common economic space between Russia and Europe.

QUESTION - As you said, you will take measures with Russia, eliminate warheads, make the world safer, but North Korea seems to be going in the opposite direction. Do you have a message for North Korea regarding the consequences if they indeed proceed with this missile launch? Mr. President SARKOZY, you spoke of honesty and consistency, and you will soon reintegrate NATO as a military partner. What is your response to President OBAMA's message regarding the addition of military troops, for example, in terms of training and assistance in Afghanistan?

MR. BARACK OBAMA - We have made it very clear to the North Koreans that their launch of a missile would be a provocation, that it would place enormous constraints on the six-party talks, and that they should cancel this launch. The response so far from the North Koreans has been not only unproductive but they have used rhetoric that has led to North Korea's isolation within the international community for a long time already.

We are not the only ones saying that North Korea must cancel this launch. Japan, South Korea, Russia, China, and the other members of the Six have all indicated that this launch should be canceled. Therefore, if North Korea indeed proceeds with this launch, we will work with all concerned parties and the international community to take appropriate measures to make North Korea understand that this country cannot threaten the security of other countries with impunity.

One last thing, I think France has already been an unwavering ally regarding Afghanistan; we have talked about the possibility of ensuring that all NATO allies re-engage more effectively in Afghanistan, both militarily and diplomatically, to address the development needs of both Pakistan and India. It is not simply about providing more resources, but we must also use the resources at our disposal more effectively. On this issue, France and the United States are also on the same wavelength. But before Nicolas responds to the question he was asked, I would like to publicly thank France and praise France for its truly extraordinary leadership regarding Afghanistan. I did not encourage France reluctantly to engage in Afghanistan because France recognizes that the fact that Al Qaeda can exploit sanctuaries, which could be used to launch attacks, poses a threat not only to the United States but also to Europe. In fact, it is more likely, probable that Al Qaeda is capable of carrying out serious attacks more in Europe than in the United States due to proximity. This is not an American mission; it is a NATO mission, it is an international mission, and France has always understood that. For this, I am very grateful to you.

THE PRESIDENT - We fully support the new American strategy in Afghanistan, and I want to tell the French that when New York was martyred, it could have happened in any other capital of a democratic state. It is not New York that was targeted; it is democracies.

Either democracies, we stand together against fanatics, against extremists, against terrorists, and in this case, we will win. That is what is at stake over there.

Secondly, we discussed it with President Obama; there will be no French military reinforcements because the decision on reinforcements was already made last year.

Thirdly, we are ready to do more in terms of police, in terms of gendarmerie, in terms of economic aid to train Afghans and for Afghanization. We are not waging a war against Afghanistan; we are helping Afghanistan to rebuild. And we do not support one candidate or another; we support the right of young Afghans to have a future. On this issue and on others, we have sat around the table, we have talked, and I listened to President Obama; he listened to my concerns, and we are trying to find solutions. That is how we have done it, and that is how we will continue to do it.

I would like to say to all the French who are happy and proud that we have the President of the United States of America on our soil that he will return on June 6, and we will give him an extraordinary welcome in this Normandy where so many young people from your country rest beneath the earth, and that really people must regain confidence. We are aware of the difficulties, and we know that we must provide comprehensive responses, responses together. It feels good to be able to work with a President of the United States who wants to change the world and who understands that the world is not limited to the dimensions of his own country. This is really good news for the year 2009.