Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, notably on Franco-German convergences in financial regulation, in London on April 1, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

1 April 2009 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Angela Merkel · London, United Kingdom

Context
Sarkozy and Merkel held a joint press conference in London on April 1, 2009, ahead of the G20 Summit to present unified Franco-German positions on financial regulation.
Main themes
Franco-German cooperation, financial regulation reform, tax havens, securitization and traceability, hedge fund oversight, rating agency transparency, trader compensation reform, G20 London Summit, global financial crisis response, IMF reform
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,432
66th percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
8.6
8th percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

136 sentences in 34 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to express how happy I am to meet with Angela MERKEL, following countless meetings of our collaborators and phone exchanges, even last night, between the two of us.

Germany and France will speak with one voice. I also welcome the presence of Mr. STEINBRÜCK and Ms. LAGARDE; we will speak with one voice. Our objectives are the same regarding both principles and modalities. Our goal is simple, as the Chancellor has very well stated, we demand results. In Washington, principles were established; in London, we want concrete results.

We are in a very significant crisis that is causing a lot of suffering, and the people who are suffering are not responsible for the origins of the crisis. This crisis has become economic, but it was born from the financial crisis. That is why Germany and France want the principle of new regulation to be a major objective in the results of the summit. We understand very well, moreover, that Germany and France have played their part in the recovery; that goes without saying, we need to put fuel in the tank, and we have done that. But we say that without new regulation, there will be no trust, and without trust, there will be no recovery. This is a major non-negotiable objective.

Once the principle is established, we have agreed on the same red lines.

Tax havens. This is a historic opportunity to moralize a system that has become immoral. Now is the time to take responsibility, and the twenty Heads of Government and Heads of State gathered must tell the whole world: are they for the end of tax havens or for their continuation? There are not three positions; there are two. A tax haven is a financial center that refuses to cooperate and provide information on the origin of funds. Is there a Head of State or Government in 2009 who can afford to say to the whole world that a tax haven is normal? Germany and France believe that this is impossible. It is very clear; a list is needed. And the margin for negotiation is whether the list is published immediately or in a few days. There is no need to hold grand summits to obtain the list. Everyone knows that.

The second point is securitization. I completely agree with what the Chancellor has said. We are not against the principle of securitization, without going into details and speaking under the control of the Finance Ministers, but we want traceability. After that, there can be, we are discussing it ourselves, Germany and France will likely take the same position, but we want traceability. The principle that a bank that securitizes retains in its accounts a portion of what it has securitized is simple; it is not technical; it is perfectly clear.

Hedge funds, I will not repeat what the Chancellor has said better than I could; we want hedge funds to be registered and controlled. We can certainly accept the debate: to what level of importance for the hedge fund. We must register and control. We can discuss that. But the principle is: no financial institution without control.

Rating agencies, of course, when we see the scandal represented by the lack of transparency of certain rating agencies. Triple A ratings on a Friday that became triple B on a Monday. Things must change there as well.

Finally, the last point, the issue of trader compensation, and everyone must understand, is a global problem. If Germany and France decided that henceforth these compensations, which have led to reckless risk-taking, would cease, if it were not a global decision, it would mean penalizing our countries. Therefore, it is a global decision to moralize - or call it what you will - the compensation of traders.

All of this represents red lines. We are fully open to discussing the rest with a lot of open-mindedness, if these issues are clearly resolved.

Lastly, I think we must pay tribute to Gordon BROWN; we do so, Ms. MERKEL and I, for all the efforts he is making to bring everyone together. I am sure we will find agreements, but there are other difficulties that are not the time to discuss. But this is what we want to achieve because we owe it to the peoples who are watching us.

QUESTION - Hello, a question, I would like to have a bit of detail on the negotiations because you tell us, we have our red lists, but I have the impression that many are already being respected. Regarding traders, can you confirm that there has been an agreement between your Sherpas that they must be compensated in the long term based on actual profits made and with the approval of the boards of directors? Can you confirm that there is an agreement to sell part of the IMF's gold stock to finance the poorest countries? Can you confirm that the debate only concerns the publication of the list on the condition that a delay is allowed for a new screening in three months to allow those who could be on the list to be removed? And the last question, to Ms. MERKEL in particular, I understood that Germany did not agree with the French views on accounting standards and on the governance change of the IASB; can you confirm that?

MS. MERKEL - You asked me if there was a disagreement between France and Germany on accounting standards? No, no problem. It is not an issue. I will not, of course, prejudge the response of the French President, but the time is not for detailed discussions here tonight. What is at stake is the weighting of objectives. What must be said is that there have been disastrous events in the world; we must get out of the crisis; we must get out of the disaster; but this must not be done at the cost of forgetting the causes of the crisis to prevent the crisis from recurring. So, we have made progress, but there are still, indeed, it is true, points to improve on the issues you have raised. The message we want to convey to the world is the one we have just outlined, the President and I.

THE PRESIDENT - I formally deny any divergence of opinion on accounting standards, unless you are the third secret negotiator on behalf of Germany. In any case, Mr. STEINBRÜCK, Ms. LAGARDE, on the issue of accounting standards, I am astonished.

Secondly, and you must all understand this, since this morning, I may have seen four or five successive texts. So perhaps one or another of you has obtained a copy of one of the texts. It would be good to see that the text has been adopted before the Heads of State and Government meet. So why would we meet? The time - perhaps you have seen many - of summits for nothing is over. Do you know what brought us to the situation we are in? It is the takeover of technicians on eminently political subjects, particularly on accounting standards. We wanted to trust a number of technicians who were mistaken.

This summit, as the Chancellor said, there has been a lot of progress made, fortunately; but we are not there yet. Moreover, if we were there, we could leave tonight. There are also arrangements for statements. We can end up with a little phrase that we like put in an annex; that is out of the question.

There are statements of principle, there are major objectives, and I can tell you that on the major objectives, Ms. MERKEL and I were still in discussion. It is a matter of determining what the objectives of the summit are. I fully understand that some want to talk about recovery; we do too. We do not just talk about it; we are doing it. But regulation is not a dirty word; it is a major objective.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, Mr. President, you have just cited quite definitive objectives. In return, Madam, would you be willing to make compromises on new recoveries? And you, Mr. President, as a compromise, would you be willing to stay until the end of the summit?

MS. MERKEL - This is not about bargaining here, about horse trading. Twenty countries gathered within this G20, and we must have the same understanding of things, namely that such a crisis must not be repeated. This crisis is not a natural disaster; it is not the result of chance; it is the result of long-term deviations that we know. We would not be doing anyone a service by not setting the necessary objectives to prevent this crisis from recurring.

We all know that more regulation is necessary, but we cannot say that because we have obtained satisfaction, we must be nice and wise on another point. Crisis management is essential, and indeed, Europeans can certainly hold their own against the United States of America; we have done the same thing as the Americans.

And I completely agree with what Gordon BROWN advocates, namely that we must support the weaker countries that do not have the resources to implement recovery programs because it is also in our best interest.

But it is not because we will do a lot of recovery that we will settle for doing a little regulation. Those who do not want to understand this are doomed to experience the same crisis again, and that is what must be understood at the G20.

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to remind you that we are in a multipolar world. We do not consider that when Germany, France, and Europe speak, they are doing us a favor by listening. I add that, as Angela said, the idea of the G20 was wanted by Europe. We want the success of the G20.

On development and on the sale of the IMF's gold stock, we are of course fully ready. We must not let the poor countries that were suffering before the crisis drown completely during the crisis; therefore, we must help them.

If the crisis worsens, should we do more? But that is what we have been doing continuously. Simply, we do not blame anyone for the crisis, but we say that this is a historic opportunity to build a new world. The word "historic" is one that Angela MERKEL used, and this opportunity to build a new world, we do not want to let it pass. We are in the 21st century; it is time to lay the foundations for 21st-century regulation. This is not a matter of whim; it is not a matter of ego; it is a matter of results.

We are expected at the rendezvous; will we rise to the occasion or not? Naturally, compromises must be made, always, especially when there are twenty of us. And in Europe, we are used to compromises; that is why we built the European Union. But the compromise must come from all parts of the world. Especially since the crisis did not spontaneously arise in Europe, frankly.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, Mr. President, who are you targeting exactly when you say that someone is not at the rendezvous of history? Are we mistaken in thinking that in recent days, the resistance of the American President has increased regarding regulatory issues?

MS. MERKEL - No, not really; I do not believe so. We just said it; everything is still in motion; there are several texts, and I believe there are still many possibilities to make progress; we will move forward. And even in the United States, there is now a lot of talk about regulation; the American Secretary of the Treasury has made proposals in this direction.

And I believe the time has come to do substantive work because what is not decided today and tomorrow will not be decided in the next five years. The minimum standards that have not been set by tomorrow will not be set the day after tomorrow. We cannot also say we will do what we did not do this time at a third summit.

So, we are really laying the foundations for this new global financial architecture. They must be solid foundations. That is why we are very firm and tough on the details because we cannot afford to remain vague. I believe the chances of obtaining satisfaction are very real.

THE PRESIDENT - The election of Barack OBAMA has generated enormous hope in the world and in Europe. And you know the decision that the French Government made to reintegrate into NATO's command; it was a sign, first of all, of attachment to the Franco-German axis, to Europe, and to the transatlantic link. Mr. OBAMA was elected on the idea of change, "we can." And the platform he published in Germany as well as in France, around the world, is excellent. I have confidence in Mr. OBAMA, but it is undoubtedly necessary, in the United States as in Europe, for the administration to follow what the leader says. It is Mr. OBAMA who speaks in his platform very well about tax havens, about what needs to be done about them. I am sure he will help us, and I am sure he understands it.

We have confidence, but it is today and tomorrow, Angela said, the day after tomorrow is too late. Decisions are made today and tomorrow. It is no longer about making speeches for all of us, us first, it is about taking our responsibilities, that is what we are trying to do.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you have said several times that you would not accept a soft compromise and that if that were the case, you would even prefer to leave. Do you maintain that threat, and what are the points on which you will not compromise?

THE PRESIDENT - I just said it. Listen first, it is bothersome for me to leave when I have just arrived. Second, Angela MERKEL and I are exactly on the same line, but we do not want to win for ourselves, we believe that our positions are the positions of common sense and we see that progress is being made. We simply both wanted to signify that this is historic and that in the face of history, we cannot hedge. And as for the point, that is what Mrs. MERKEL indicated, I merely reiterated what she said, we share the same convictions. You will judge tomorrow what the outcome is, what is not a fight, but a frank discussion.